« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Palin-RedState Hypocrisy

How soon some forget their criticisms...

First let me say I think Governor Palin’s selection by John McCain is brilliant and masterful. I join thousands of other three-legged stool conservatives in being re-energized when I thought my presidential election energy was entirely spent. Based on McCain’s VP choice alone, I’ve donated to a presidential campaign for only the second time in my life.

The energetic and postive response to Palin from conservatives and RedState is outstanding and appropriate.

In my enthusiastic reflection, however, I can’t help but notice a number of similarities between Palin and another GOP presidential hopeful who was regularly — and often hatefully — disparaged by many here at RedState.

I’m talking about Governor Mike Huckabee.

Huckabee was blasted for raising taxes as Governor of Arkansas in order to improve a deteriorating state infrastructure. Palin did the same.

Huckabee was lambasted for alienating the state GOP leadership. Palin did the same.

Huckabee was criticized for reaching out to Democrats to pass important state legislation. Palin did the same.

Huckabee was denigrated for accepting an invitation to speak to a small state chapter of a labor union organization. Palin and her husband have both been active members of a labor union.

Huckabee was chided for having the audacity to attempt to reach out to non-traditional Republicans, Reagan Democrats and independents. Palin has done and will do the same.

Huckabee’s tenure as governor of a small state was described as lacking the foreign policy and defense credentials needed for high office. Palin’s credentials are quite similar.

Huckabee was derided as a “populist” wolf in sheep’s clothing. Palin rides a similar wave of populism.

Huckabee’s stance on creationism was ridiculed by the GOP elite. Palin’s creationism views are similar.


Now I’m not stupid enough to claim that Palin is nothing more than a Huckabee cross-dresser with better teeth. However I do find it curious that so many who crucified Huck here at RedState are swooning over Governor Palin. What’s good for the Moose is good for the Gander.

COMMENTS

  • Adam_C

    I missed where Huckabee went full bore against the pork barrelers in his own party? Or where he took on a corrupt member of his own party and beat him in a primary?

    And despite the adulation, Palin could never have won the primary for President this year. VPs have different roles. That’s why the lack of foreign policy background matters much less.

    Finally, some of your descriptions are quite odd: for example, “Huckabee was lambasted for alienating the state GOP leadership. Palin did the same.”

    I don’t recall that being a knock on Huck. But I can tell you it is a positive for Palin because the state GOP is rather corrupt and has no fiscal responsibility.

  • Jaded

    evangelist will be fine…..I say evangelist with a little derision because I personally don’t believe in the religious becoming quasi rock stars….He by the way would immediately turn off Independent women….so ergo Palin is the better pick.

    • gclaghorn
  • simpson316

    AK owns the oil. They increased the price that they were willing to sell it for. That is not a tax.

  • mbecker908

    Get over it Ed. Huckabee is, thankfully, a has-been. Actually, a never-was. He got a slice of one constituency of the Party and got zip from everybody else. The guy had his fifteen minutes of fame. He’s done now. If he tries to run again, he’ll get buried. And, in his case, he’ll stay buried. No resurrections for Mikie.

  • Rod_Patrick

    And now that I think about it, she has more to offer.

    1. Refuting Democrats’ accusation of republicans as old boys party.
    2. Emphasis that indigenous America never really forgotten, Palin’s family comes from Eskimo clan.
    3. Emphasis for Efficiency and Reform at state, county, municipal and city levels… not just White House.
    4. Palin refreshes. Being young, she represents the future of this Party: that includes Cantor, Jindall, and many more.

    Lastly, it’s McCain’s preference. She won the primary by votes of the republicans and conservatives. We must respect that.

    Prior to the announcement, my preference was either Jindall or Cantor. But I chose to stay in the course. Our differences will cause us our fight against Obama. Hope you can also continue with the course.

  • Rod_Patrick

    And now that I think about it, she has more to offer.

    1. Refuting Democrats’ accusation of republicans as old boys party.
    2. Emphasis that indigenous America never really forgotten, Palin’s family comes from Eskimo clan.
    3. Emphasis for Efficiency and Reform at state, county, municipal and city levels… not just White House.
    4. Palin refreshes. Being young, she represents the future of this Party: that includes Cantor, Jindal, and many more.

    Lastly, it’s McCain’s preference. She won the primary by votes of the republicans and conservatives. We must respect that.

    Prior to the announcement, my preference was either Jindal or Cantor. But I chose to stay in the course. Our differences will cause us our fight against Obama. Hope you can also continue with the course.

    • Mr_Ed

      I’m not expected a Huck resurrection. I’m merely pointing out that some of the major criticisms of Huck here at RedState are on points which Palin also shares…but without the criticism.

      • mbecker908

        I apologize for not welcoming you back. You’ve been missed. Looking forward to our chats!

        Welcome!

  • BigGator5

    Huckabee is a populist, what more can I say?

  • JillEE

    started with his “populist” rhetoric but solidified with him using my religion (not shared by him) as a political tool.

    Other then that he’s a funny guy.

  • TomOConnor

    Palin or Huckabee was not the choice.

    McCain beat out Huckabee.

    It’s the same argument the Liberals are trying to make comparing Palin and Obama.