« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

The Government Take Over of Faith-based Schools

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/teachers-union-calls-for-an-end-to-faith-schools-1662932.html

That’s what the teacher’s union of Britain wants to see.

“Religious groups, of whatever faith, have no place in the control and management of schools,” said one union leader.

As the new U.S. administration continues to lead our own country down the many paths already trod by our socialist European friends, how long will it be before we face the same outcry in our own country?

I find it strange that those seeking to shut down faith-based schools due to fears of intolerance indoctrination or so intolerant of those with a faith-commitment.

COMMENTS

  • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

    Britain has a system of state-funded religious schools, and it is these schools that the teachers union are asking to change. What the article seems to suggest is that 1) this is a political rebuke to Tony Blair, who promoted these schools, by his political opponents, the unions; and 2) an maneuver to extract concessions from these schools in terms of more inclusive admissions – and probably more control over curriculum.

    In other words, this in an effort to neuter religious distinctives that might challenge the PC and secular orthodoxies in Britain, an effort to indoctrinate the children into the post modern values infesting Europe and seeping into Britain.

    Curious are these numbers:

    There are about 6,400 primary and 600 secondary faith state schools in England. Of these, about 4,700 are Church of England, 2,100 Roman Catholic, and 150 Methodist, with 36 Jewish, six Muslim, two Sikh, one Greek Orthodox, one Hindu and one Seventh-Day Adventist.

    The low number of Islamic schools (6) surprised me until I saw this sentence that followed:

    There are a further 140 Muslim schools in the UK which are not part of the state system.

    Thus this could turn out to be a blessing for people of faith if they see the red flag here on the consequences to their integrity of accepting state money and instead opt-out of the state funding system, like these Muslim schools have done.

    This is where the churches in England should be looking to spend their money – on educating their youth in the faith rather than the many ways they piss away their donations. The Muslims are doing a good job of looking after their youth (aided perhaps by Saudi money?)

    And for us in the U.S., this is another warning of the perils of accepting government funding for faith-based activities – with government funding inevitably will come calls for state control – or state manipulation.

    • mom2oneson

      It’s going to be the same thing here if we get vouchers. If bet if we get vouchers for everyone private schools will be forced to accept them or close.

      • IJB

        Early on, I supported vouchers. But I now oppose them, for the reasons you indicated.

        It’s an education tax credit (like Reagan advocated), or BUST, on this issue.

        And as I’m ultimately a flat-tax advocate, BUST is probably the only good outcome.

        • mom2oneson
  • Achance

    a sentiment I can appreciate. Problem is, under our laws, restricting one “faith” requires restricting them all. Though I suspect carefully tailored legal requirements for curricula would control the worst of the madrassas.

  • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

    As the article points out (if you analyze the statistics), this effort would only affect 6 out of 146 functioning Islamic school – it only affects state funded schools, whereas the vast majority of Islamic school are private – and I suspect by the numbers that almost all the madrassas are the 140 outside of state-funding – I suspect because they are amply funded by Saudi Wahabbists.

    Rather, this is just another manifestation of the general hostility towards religion that animates the European collectivsts who believe that children are the property of the State and the the State needs to have access to inculcate them in collectivist/post-modern ideals. Religion is a challenge to the monoplogy. Germany has been quite egregious in the belief, which is why they have persecuted home-schoolers so vigorously, imprisoning parents and taking custody of the children.