« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Tax Pig: Loudoun County should reject the Metro Tax

Here in northern Virginia, there’s a huge local political issue right now. WMATA and MWAA, the DC-area transit and airport authorities want to extend the DC Metro train system out to Dulles Airport. That’s fine. It’s their prerogative.

The problem is that the Beltway people want to make the people of Loudoun County pay for it. That’s the problem, and that’s why a pig was parked next to the Loudoun County government center in Leesburg on Monday.

The people of Loudoun County don’t actually need the Metro Silver Line, as they’re calling the new line that will run on the planned extension from Falls Church to Loudoun via Tyson’s Corner, Reston, and Herndon. The people who live and work there already have two great options to get there. The first is to take one of the highways there, driving either on the toll road or the freeway. The second is to take the comfortable Loudoun County Transit busses that run one way from as far out as Purcellville all the way into downtown DC, and the other way going from Falls Church as far as Leesburg.

I know it’s perfectly practical, right now, to commute from the DC area to the middle of Loudoun without a car. I do it regularly. I live in the Crystal City neighborhood in Arlington. My employer is based in Purcellville. I’m fine. Loudoun County Transit gets me from Falls Church, near the Arlington/Fairfax border, through Fairfax, and all the way to Leesburg with no problem. From there it’s a hop on the local VRT* bus into Purcellville. The same kind of commute would be possible to and from a variety of locations in Loudoun County.

So you see, the people of Loudoun don’t actually need this. Who wants this are uppity Beltway folk who just want to get on a train in downtown DC or Rosslyn, and ride it all the way to Dulles airport. They don’t want to have to get off at Rosslyn or Falls Church and hop a Washington Flyer bus.

And again, I say that’s their right. What’s not fair is that they want the people of Loudoun to pay for it. That’s where the Tax Pig comes in. The plans are starting to come out for how Loudoun County is expected to pay for their part of the Silver line, and it’s not pretty. Higher tolls. Business taxes. These things punish the people and businesses of Loudoun that made it prosperous to begin with, and worse, are self limiting.

Yes, this would only be the beginning of Metro taxes. Once the tolls go up, more people stop taking it and start taking the freeway, which results in less toll revenue than projected and slower commutes for many Loudoun County residents. Additionally, businesses would simply leave the affected tax areas, reducing projected revenue and necessitating higher taxes.

And that’s not even counting the inevitable cost overruns, which are bound to happen as the project tries to defy Virginia’s right to work law.

I make the long commute from Arlington to Loudoun. I’m just the kind of person that the Silver Line is supposed to help. But I oppose it. Busses work better for a low population density area like Loudoun. Metro, with its institutional racism and forced unionization, is less reliable than LCT. Metro can’t even keep escalators running, let alone the Red Line. And the Silver Line isn’t going to get treated any better than the Red Line, because in WMATA’s eyes, Virginia is second class to DC.

How do I know this? Rush+, the new scheduling coming out this month, is a grand plan to favor DC-centered traffic over intra-Virginia traffic (people like me). The plan guts the Blue Line proper, cutting service from Rosslyn to Pentagon, to make room in the Foggy Bottom-Rosslyn tunnel for future Silver Line trains. Service to Franconia is replaced with new Yellow Line-badged trains coming from L’Enfant. Service to Largo is replaced with Orange Line-badged trains coming from Vienna. What do those lines have in common? They go through DC. Those with no need to leave Virginia lose out.

So yes, even when WMATA is pretending to service people like me, they can’t even do that right, and plans like Rush+ telegraph the truth. This is all about DC folk trying to go to and from the airport in a Metro cocoon, with Loudoun paying for it.

Just say no to the Metro Tax.

* Yes, VRT has the worst site in the world. All flash, making it impossible to check a bus schedule from the bus stop itself.

COMMENTS

  • Scope

    It sounds like you have settled into your new state of VA. You are an asset here for sure.

  • Ron Ferraro

    …not sure I am completely on board.

    I live in Loudoun, for the past 12 years. Moved from south Arlington, probably only a few blocks from where you now live (we were on south 22nd street). I worked in Sterling, VA at the time, and made the reverse commute, much like you are doing today. While I’ll admit it’s been a long time since I made that drive, making the reverse commute, either by bus, or by your own vehicle, is far better, less aggravating and takes less time.

    Not long after I moved out here, I took a new job with my present company, who at the time were based in DC on Vermont Ave. I tried all options…I tried the commuter bus, I tried the Herndon Park and Ride (with bus service to Falls Church metro), and the problem was the same. My family was back in Loudoun, and once I committed to the bus, I was trapped in DC without a return option that would take less than 2 hours. The buses, for all of their value, are stuck in the same traffic you would be in if you drove your own vehicle.

    This is why even with the mass transit options you mention, most folks who live out our way drive their cars. And even that has its limitations, because I-66, which is the main thoroughfare into DC, is HOV west bound from 3:30-6:30PM. So you either have to leave your office in the middle of the afternoon, or stay there until 6:15 or so, which doesn’t get you home until 7:30PM or later.

    Now, I am in no way suggesting that the metro is perfect, and would solve all of these issues. But it would be nice to have an option that required you to park your car, get on the train and get downtown, rather than having to perform a mini-version of planes, trains and automobiles every day.

    Is that worth the proposed tax increase? Perhaps not. But I will say this…Loudoun has passed so many other tax increases over the years, for things that benefit the few rather than the many. Those sorts of things passed with flying colors. Now we are faced with something that may actually benefit the greater population, and the caterwauling is deafening.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    The speculators who bought up land around the planned Metro stops past Dulles.

  • barleycorn

    Don’t live in the godforsaken hellhole that is Northern Virginia. I get the hives if I have to go up there once every 5 years or so.

    And I’ll NEVER EVER again book a plane that leaves out of Dulles between 7 and 10 am.

    I’m getting nauseous just thinking about it.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    What’s wrong with it?

  • barleycorn

    My mother was born in Hamilton.

    For most Vuhjinyens “Northern Virginia” refers to the area roughly north of Rt. 234 and west of Rt. 15.

    Back in the 40′s my grandfather ran a dairy farm a mile outside of Oakton. Its changed since then.

  • barleycorn

    arg

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    I’ve only been here 2 months on Friday, you see. :)

  • acat

    grabs money from Illinois and uses it to the benefit of Chicago …

    And I *like* light rail as a solution. (over 8-lane freeways, anyway)

    MEw