What Is The Sound Of Corporate Shoulders Shrugging?


Think that class warfare and mindless anti-business hatred don’t have real-life consequences?

Think again:

Much political hay has been made in Congress about “unpatriotic” corporations that move operations abroad. Weatherford International is the latest, taking its headquarters from Houston to Switzerland. The oil services company said that it wants to be closer to its markets. But what it really meant was that it no longer saw the future in the U.S.

In a political atmosphere of blaming corporations, it’s no wonder. Halliburton fled to Dubai in 2007. Tyco International, Foster Wheeler and Transocean International all went to Switzerland. As a pattern emerges, America’s global standing diminishes, in part because it’s based on the willingness of companies to invest. It’s an especially bad sign when domestic companies flee.

“The U.S. is an important market,” Weatherford CEO Bernard J. Duroc-Danner told the Houston Chronicle Thursday. But, “it’s just a market. It’s not the primary market.”

How does that sound for a loss of global leadership? If that’s not clear enough, try this: “In the hierarchical pecking order, (Houston’s) not going to be Rome anymore.”

This is what happens when oil companies are unremittingly portrayed as villains, when various businesses have their patriotism questioned as a consequence of rational and entirely defensible decisions that they make–decisions that are based on the current climate in the United States and when politicians threaten to remove all restraints on the power of unions through antidemocratic measures like card check. It’s imperative, of course, to reverse this trend of business flight–especially given the current economic downturn and the need to rebound from it–and yet, the same old class warfare and Pavlovian demonization of business continues unabated.

Business is not blameless, to be sure. Large enterprises staffed by human beings make mistakes. But there is a difference between honest criticism and demagoguery. The former makes the target of criticism better. The latter only serves to drive away any prospect whatsoever of reasoned discourse. And in the present case, it is serving to drive away moneymaking, job-creating, service-providing enterprises, which have decided that they can do better outside the United States than they can in it.

If you think this won’t have deleterious consequences for the American economy, then you will probably also believe that Rod Blagojevich is both intellectually brilliant and morally incorruptible.

Category: , ,

RSS feed | Trackback URI

30 Comments Leave a comment

The first time I read Atlas Shrugged...

Vinnster Sunday, December 14th at 6:10AM EST (link)

I was in college (1978) and was being fed a constant intellectual meal of Socialism. Of coarse I never thought in a million years much of what was in the book would actually take place in reality…boy was I wrong.

I noticed so many things looking more and more like the world in the book I went back and reread it two years ago. Now it almost seems like a book of prophecies. The financial market bailout was the first major event to see capitalism undermined by the government that rewarded failed business practices “for the sake of the people”. The now endless stream of bailouts to prop up failed business models is expanding.

The auto bailout is just the beginning. If they are not forced into reorganization that is competitive then we can expect the government to expand its subsidizing of failed businesses just as was the case in Atlas Shrugged. Much of the language and positions of our politicians are identical to the players in the book.

Keep businesses open, even if they are running in the red and will continue to run in the red “for the people”. Businesses that have leaders that actually know how to make a profit are, and will continue to leave America.

Among my personal friends, they are all in a “protect their assets mode”. They last thing they are doing is investing (most started divesting over a year ago in anticipation of a Democrat assault on income and capital gains) or thinking of starting a small business.

Understand, just 4 years ago most of my fiends were retiring (all have been very successful in big business) with plans to open a small business to keep them busy. They each had a retirement dream of opening a small business that would employee a few folks with the goal of paying expenses and having some fun running a business in area they always liked…florist, pizza shop, dog grooming…

All that is thinking is over. America’s politicians are now in full Atlas Shrugged mode of save all the businesses with taxpayer money even if they are failing, At the same time they are planning to raise taxes, implement business killing strategies of making it easy for unions to expand to kill more businesses and carbon taxes.

I expect a steady stream of business out of America and laws being passed to prevent it. Individualism consider the ultimate sin and praise of the Socialist mentality.

I never believed anything like Atlas Shrugged could happen in America, but now I see I was wrong.

Reagan said it well:

JDidSaint Tuesday, December 16th at 4:22PM EST (link)

“Government’s view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it.”

I just finished Atlas Shrugged this year and I couldn’t agree with you more. It’s nearly time for us to trade our jobs as CEOs, CFOs, business owners, inventors, PhDs, lawyers, etc. for a job digging holes and filling them back in.

Play by their rules - causality will show the errors inherent in their theories.

“I’d rather go through the pain of the re-emergence of free markets than endure the long suffering of a socialist state. One is natural and comes from that spark of human desire; the other is imposed and smothers the flame of ingenuity.”-Crowe (from RedState!)

 
 

Coming Next: Talent Flight?

Skanderbeg Sunday, December 14th at 10:20AM EST (link)

Good summary, Pej,

Since this was discussed behind the curtain earlier, this is a good place to drop in some even more frightening thoughts - dropped from a front-line participant.

Even before the last election, I was banging on regularly about the nearly complete lack of realization of how increasingly uncompetitive the U.S. is as a place to do business.

Between the corporate income tax, the personal income tax, the absurd rules that double-tax repatriated outside-the-country profits, the absurd rules that make it nearly impossible to avoid double-taxation of personal income earned outside the country (those last two are almost unique to U.S. rules), Sarbanes-Oxley’s crushing of the IPO window, and of course the abuse of the old Williams Act…. what part of “Why do business in the U.S.?” is anyone missing?

Other jurisdictions have been moving aggressively to improve their overall competitiveness as places to do business. The clueless standing-still that’s gone on here has been bad enough - now we seem to be poised to make things even worse.

The key thing to understand here is that this could be poised to go beyond what has to date mostly been enterprise-flight. The way this has worked is that, e.g., Ford closes a plant in Michigan, builds a new plant in Mexico, and produces cars there; local people get Ford jobs in Mexico, and the displaced Ford workers in Michigan collect unemployment, get jobs at WalMart, etc.

But we’ve never really had a talent-flight situation. There are Americans who expat, but there’s tended to be an over-representation of disaffected artists and writers (who go to say Paris) and of course the gays and the potheads (who go to say Amsterdam). These aren’t exactly the sorts of people who build your economic base and keep the real economy going.

But I fear that the new regime in Washington may manage to cause something that we’ve never had before - a forced flight of enterprising people with real skills and real energy that matter to a real economy. This would be on a scale of Paul’s metaphors of the sky being green or the sun rising in the west - it’s been unthinkable for so many centuries that it’s off in the realm of supposed impossibility.

I’m not a political pundit, so as I’ve said before, this isn’t a spectator sport for me of writing things up. I deal with about two dozen non-US jurisdictions on an almost-daily basis - and the ugly truth is that a lot of them are starting to look pretty darned good.

I may have to deal with making decisions of that sort in the not-too-distant future. This is pretty hard to digest, because the talent flow has always been INTO here. For the first time EVER, the “system” could encourage talent outflow. And, trust me, this looks very different when you have to make life decisions of that sort, not just comment about them.

BTW, one thing I *can* say. I’ll be d*mned if I’m going to be expected to spend my most productive years working my tail off, innovating new innovation, and producing…. so that I can pay exorbitant taxes to prop up the UAW, the NEA, and that whole lot of screw-ups who think they’re entitled.

And if these thoughts are crossing my mind, I can’t be the only member of the “innovative class” who is having them….

So, Skander, if you could choose which country had the best prospects,

janis Sunday, December 14th at 11:49AM EST (link)

which would you predict the talent would go to? I know that you are very optimistic about Estonia, for instance, but do the actions of Russia over the past several months change the equation any?

Competitive Prospects

Skanderbeg Sunday, December 14th at 8:36PM EST (link)

That’s difficult to say, Janis. These things are dynamic, and there will be questions about competitive jurisdictions crafting responses.

Historically, we’ve had three notable advantages on the innovation/economic-building front:

o Good “costs” of doing business (I’m lumping together EVERYTHING there - various monetary costs of all sorts, plus other “costs” related to time and annoyance);

o A good talent pool in place, plus great ease in pulling in talent from anywhere virtually at will.

o A culture that encourages innovation, new ideas, new industries, “creative destruction,” etc.

How that will sugar off is a good question. I tend to worry about the last one more than the first; I know it’s beloved of “public policy” folks that all you have to do is set things like tax policy to desirable status and exact results will follow. However, my expectation is that if tomorrow you imposed the Estonian tax system on France, the results (for the foreseeable future) would look very close to what France is now. It’s really difficult to get across to anyone who hasn’t dealt with it what a “slug culture” has grown up in western Europe. The stuff I’ve been involved in has just drifted to the east because people there have more get-up-and-go about trying to DO things and make things happen. In western Europe, everyone just wants to sit around in cafes telling each other how wonderful everything is.

That’s what will ultimately be the crux of how this shakes out. Are we now going to make a big change, to put all of our resources and sweat into propping up entrenched incompetence and disreputable featherbedding? That would kill off the innovation culture in short order.

The problem for some time has been that many places have been improving their competitive position while we stood pat - and we got comparatively worse by doing nothing. If we’re going to “go French,” a large question is - will other jurisdictions really see a chance to pick all the fruit off the tree?

There’s an old show-business piece-of-advice: “Don’t f*** with the talent.” That’s the ultimate question to be answered. But referring back to the three points above, if you muck up the first and the third, the second will readjust itself in response.

With that tax system and long-running pro-commerce culture, Estonia could become the luckiest country on earth. But will our veal-calves re-empower Peter the Great? Sigh…. many sleepless nights ahead for some of us over the next couple of years….

Thanks for the response, Skander. The notion that

janis Sunday, December 14th at 8:55PM EST (link)

America will “go French” as you put it is horrifying indeed. It is time to shake up and wake up the powers that be, but it may well take losing a lot of our advantages as a “talent draw” and the natural results thereof before anything is done about it.

As to the sleepless nights thing, I think that will apply to a whole lot of folks for a whole lot of reasons in the next few years. We are facing unprecedented times on a number of fronts. The sky, in other words, is green on many days now.

 
 
 

In a way, we HAVE had a talent flight situation skanderberg

Jack_Savage Sunday, December 14th at 10:31PM EST (link)

I live in the RTP area of North Carolina. Because of the idiot leftist policies of state and local governments in northern states, there has been a mass exodus to the South. This area is a prime example. Most of my friends here are ex-pats from OH, PA, MI and NJ. They would sooner die than go back home.

The only problem is that the leftist mentality is so ingrained they cannot see the connection between the states they have fled and the policies they embrace. This, plus significant black populations, was enough to turn NC and VA blue for example. They are living in the golden land where they can vote for and support leftists like Obama without it having any real effect on their lives - yet.

I would imagine that when the people and companies that have produced the boom that the South has enjoyed for so long get the picture, the exodus of talent from the US to other countries will be real, and it will be final.

 
 

Back on January 2,......

wolfgang Sunday, December 14th at 6:00PM EST (link)

…..2005, shortly after the Fed made its first upward move in interest rates, the Toll Brothers insiders began dumping their company’s stock in large blocs, large enough for the commentators on CNBC to notice and remark about it.
It was a very prescient move on their part since the stock was trading well north of where it is today, quite close to one hundred dollars a share.
Two and a half years from now will we be saying the same thing about these companies? Probably.
How’s a seventy per cent personal income tax rate sound?
The financial crisis has provided the perfect segue for the Obama Administration to introduce its wealth redistribution programs. Their argument will be that (1) your house would not be worth what it currently is without government intervention (2) your 401K or other retirement savings would not be worth nearly what it still is without the government’s intervention (3) your job probably would not be there without the government’s intervention (4) your cash savings would probably be gone without the government’s intervention.
Therefore, what you think you have is not, and would not be yours if not for the government with its infinite wisdom, therefore it is not really yours. Hand it over!
With a little slight of hand in the back rooms from Jess Jackson, Al Sharpton, and Jeremiah Wright, and their disciples, all of the downtown ladies and gentlemen will be driving Cadillacs, Mercedes, and BMW’s on the way to their digs, complete with swimming pools, saunas and 50 inch flat screen televisions.
I don’t think I’ll ever count either a swimming pool or flat screen TV among my possessions.

 

If I may counter balance...

buffalo_hierophant Sunday, December 14th at 8:06PM EST (link)

This is a piecemeal response; I apologize I don’t have the time to craft a narrative linking all my points together. I thought I’d bring some debate and dialogue to this post, amid the self-congratulating and—to be vulgar—intellectual masturbation.

[Bored now. - Moe Lane]

[It has been demanded that I revisit this comment in order to put in an appropriate video. Fine. Here's the intro to the anime Robin Hood. In German. - ML]

We need some way to edit comment titles, too.

Moe Lane Sunday, December 14th at 8:12PM EST (link)

Gee Moe. Is the baby asleep?

mbecker908 Sunday, December 14th at 8:16PM EST (link)

I was going to go get some dinner and rip the guy to pieces. You’re so quick RS is just getting to be no fun anymore.

CongressCritter™: Never have so few felt like they were owed so much by so many for so little.

Just put him down for the night.

Moe Lane Sunday, December 14th at 8:18PM EST (link)

Sorry, but I had to try out the new banning tools for this iteration of RS anyway. Next time I’ll load the dishwasher first.

 

Buffalo Wild Wings

Skanderbeg Sunday, December 14th at 8:45PM EST (link)

Yeah, Mike, I was pondering something short and killer for this drone. I would love to have seen YOUR response.

It’s just amazing how many clowns can sit in their rooms reading a few books and think that gives them infinite knowledge of the world. I talk about competitive tax policy problems, and this clown calls ME names? I’m out there in the mix, he clearly isn’t.

I was wondering if some goofball would show up and refloat that whole “creative class” b.s. Somehow I don’t think the people who have fled to Paris and/or Amsterdam are ones we miss at all.

If you missed it, some Canadian professor wrote a book back in 2000 called “The Rise of the Creative Class.” The basic thesis was that the prime underlying driver for creating economic growth was to make your jurisdiction friendly for “artistic” types - and somehow this would create magic fog in the air that promoted commercial growth.

I don’t know where the guy was getting this (or maybe his book was a spoof), since from my travels all over everywhere I long ago concluded that a good commercial situation is what generates the cash flow that lets you have high-grade performing arts. Atlanta is a good example of this.

Florida’s book created two awful problems. First, it provided an excuse for all sorts of self-serving fools to focus on building up an “arts community” - which usually meant bringing in all their junk art buddies with their hands outstretched. The second was that it gave an excuse for all of these people to be incredibly pompous - that somehow only “artists” were “creative” - and everyone else was just a braindead cog in a big machine. None of these people of course would deign to have any business or innovation experience - which is where you find the genuinely most-creative people.

Your comment reminds me of a lot of folks I've known

janis Sunday, December 14th at 9:07PM EST (link)

around the communities near to me over the past 20 years. This is a place that draws a lot of creative people, mostly, I think, because it’s cheaper to live here than in the cities, but also because there’s a lot of personal freedom due to more space and privacy.

What many of them don’t seem to understand though, is that it’s not enough to be creative if you don’t have a marketing plan, a targeted customer base, and the ability to deliver your product consistently. Too many of them think that they are so wonderful that people will flock to their doorstep and beg for their work.

And too many end up getting jobs at McDonald’s to pay the rent. Reality can be a b**ch.

 

After a quick scan of said exercise in

mbecker908 Sunday, December 14th at 9:15PM EST (link)

mental masturbation, the things that really hit me were:

1. The guy had no concept of economic reality.
2. The guy seemed to think the most important cog in the creation of wealth was the role of government.

I think you’re way too generous in assuming he’s “read a few books”, other than maybe the kind with lots of color pictures. Personally, I think he’s been watching too much TV and paying way too much attention to stuff like Democracy Now!

CongressCritter™: Never have so few felt like they were owed so much by so many for so little.

 
 
 

Can you tell comment titles are third party addon for us? :-)

Neil Stevens Sunday, December 14th at 8:21PM EST (link)

Noted.

Want to run for conservatives? Give.
There Is No Crisis

 
 

Fine, Skanderbeg, fine. I've added a video.

Moe Lane Sunday, December 14th at 8:55PM EST (link)

I've been hoping for the Obama Anti-Gun blam

JLenardDetroit Sunday, December 14th at 9:04PM EST (link)

been waiting for you to blam someone in a discussion that has any reference to guns so you can remind peeps of Obama’s anti-gun rhetoric before he became Presidential candidate (and so many people think he’s gun-safe… oh please)!

Could you just throw it in here for good measure? ;-) Those links have long fallen off my list I so don’t have the Video embed around

(RS:Help) (JLD) (Hollyweird) (Brain-deads) (SPIN-cycle) (Obamaocare) (Party of kNOw) (Conservatism) (TEApeats) (respectful) (Reco) (Quotes) (removeRINOs.com) (RSmas)
+ 0bama Lies & your Bank acct will Die! (4/15 Truthers)
+ Heil “O” Hell No Obamao is NOT MY PRESIDENT! “No U won’t”
+ I want “O” to FAIL (here, here, & whole Diary (Ofail) here, is why)
The first Liberal was Satan” - a Rush caller (other Quotes)

 

Happy

Skanderbeg Sunday, December 14th at 9:10PM EST (link)

Yes, Moe, happy now. :-) It was called-for. :-)

Have some Albanian folk dancing again.

Vital, earth shaking question that demands an answer!

mbecker908 Sunday, December 14th at 9:16PM EST (link)

How do you get those smileys in your comments?

CongressCritter™: Never have so few felt like they were owed so much by so many for so little.

Just do the colon for the eyes, the dash for the nose and the half parenthesis for the mouth.

janis Sunday, December 14th at 9:20PM EST (link)

It comes out with the smiley face on Wordpress.

How do you get a little face that looks menacing and foul?

Jack_Savage Sunday, December 14th at 10:35PM EST (link)

Anyone? And I don’t mean read one of Obama’s memoirs then look in the mirror…

oh I don't know pull up McCain's Senate website :-)

JadedByPolitics Sunday, December 14th at 10:45PM EST (link)

nt

Whoever has his enemy at his mercy &
does not destroy him is his own enemy

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Let me see if this works, Jack.

janis Sunday, December 14th at 10:41PM EST (link)

n/t :<(

Nope, that didn't do it. Beats me! Anyone else?

janis Sunday, December 14th at 10:42PM EST (link)

Let's try this

Skanderbeg Sunday, December 14th at 11:16PM EST (link)

That worked?

Skanderbeg Sunday, December 14th at 11:17PM EST (link)

Is that what you wanted? Same as the smile, but make the last paren a righty (shift-zero) rather than a lefty (shift-nine).

:-)

:-(

;-)

:-O

Okay, I'll see if it works for me, Skander.

janis Sunday, December 14th at 11:20PM EST (link)

Nope, the first one didn't, but I got the winking one.

janis Sunday, December 14th at 11:21PM EST (link)

I’ll try it again ;-(

Chicken with Marbles

Skanderbeg Sunday, December 14th at 11:30PM EST (link)

Frown-wink doesn’t work.

Frown uses colon-dash-rightparen

:

-

(

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Leave a Comment

 

Be respectful, or be banned. No Profanity.