« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

A Final Look At The Minnesota Races

With four days to go, let’s run down the outlook in Minnesota one more time.  I’ll do them in an order that can only make sense to a mind as disorganized as mine.  :-)

– Obviously Safe Democrat seats:  MN -04 (Betty McCollum) and MN-05 (Keith Ellison).  One would like to think that the ethically-challenged Ellison could be beaten, but it’s just too Democratic a district.  Ellison’s opponent, Joel Demos, has forced a little bit of Democrat money to be spent there, though, so we can thank him for that, as well as this good ad.

– Not-So-Obviously Safe Democrat seat:  MN-07 (Collin Peterson).  One would think that a Democrat in an R+5 district would be in at least some position to worry in this cycle, but Peterson seems to be immune to it.  A lot of this comes from the fact that he seems to subscribe to the rather odd notion that a member of the House Of Representatives should, you know, represent his district.  Peterson voted against both cap-and-tax and Obamacare, and that’s why Barney Frank is in more danger than Peterson is.

– Obviously Safe Republican Seat:  MN-02 (John Kline).  This is my home district.  If I wasn’t someone who actually paid attention to this sort of thing, I wouldn’t even have any idea who Kline’s opponent is.  I have seen precisely two signs for Kline’s opponent:  one was at the MN State Fair at the Democrats’ booth, and the other was in the window of the local Democrat election headquarters.  Kline’s opponent (in case you haven’t heard, and based on the publicity, she might not have heard, either) is former state representative Shelley Madore, who won the election for my state district’s seat in 2006, then lost it in 2008.  If you’re a Democrat who lost in 2008 — yeah.  Madore’s there because someone has to be.

– Safe-In-This-Cycle Republican seat:  MN-03 (Erik Paulsen).  Paulsen represents an R+0 district, so in a more heavily Democratic year, this might a race to worry about.  Not this year, though.

– Seats That I Am Lumping Together To Make An Offbeat Prediction:  MN-06 (Michele Bachmann) and MN-08 (Jim Oberstar).  So what in the world could these two seats possibly have in common?  Not much, really.  One is a powerful committee chairman, the other is a two-term incumbent who narrowly won against a political neophyte twice.  One is a darling of the conservative movement who was heavily targeted by the opposing party back when they still thought they could play offense, the other was about as safe as they come, having been in that seat since before your humble author was even born.  (Oberstar won the seat in 1974, while the man currently behind the keyboard was born in 1975.)  One is in a tight race right now, and the other isn’t — and it’s exactly the opposite of what you would have thought even as recently as three months ago.  Oberstar is getting a scare from Republican Chip Cravaack; at least one poll had Cravaack within the margin of error.  Bachmann, meanwhile, has been trouncing State Senator Tarryl Clark, a well-known proud tax-and-spend liberal who chose precisely the wrong cycle to try to run as a proud tax-and-spend liberal.  One of the Democrats’ biggest laments from this cycle will be all the money they wasted on this race.  While I’d love to see Oberstar lose, I believe he will still hang on, but here’s the offbeat prediction I alluded to:  Bachmann will win by more than Oberstar does.

– The Seat That’s Flipping:  MN-01 (Tim Walz).  I originally grew up in Mankato, which is right in the center of this district, and I have cousins who had Tim Walz as a teacher at Mankato West High School.  He seems to be a decent fellow by all accounts.  But as a representative of this R+1 district, he’s pretty much the exact opposite of Collin Peterson — a Pelosi lapdog.  As fellow southern Minnesotan eburke has pointed out here, Walz is one of those guys who talks a good conservative game at home before doing the opposite in Washington.  He takes his veteran status and NRA endorsement and tries to fool people into thinking he’s a conservative.  He was able to get by with it in 2006, when incumbent Gil Gutknecht got caught up in the Abramoff scandal, as well as in 2008, when he had no serious challenger in a Democrat wave year.  But now that he has the dual millstones of Obamacare and cap-and-trade around his neck, he’s ripe for the picking, and Randy Demmer is just the man to do it.  When the upcoming Crimson Tide became apparent, Demmer finally started getting some well-deserved attention, and his fundraising has been very good going against Walz’s big union war chest.  The only poll I’ve seen on this race had Walz up 46-41, but the poll used a 2006 turnout model.  Not likely this time around.  Demmer will restore this seat where it belongs.

– Oh Yeah, Don’t Want To Forget This Race:  Governor (open, current Governor is Tim Pawlenty).  This is a three-way race between Democrat and former U.S. Senator Mark Dayton, Republican Tom Emmer, and Independence Party candidate Tom Horner, a former RINO.  Horner is obviously not going to win, and any dropoff in his numbers will likely benefit both Emmer and Dayton equally, so we’ll ignore him.  As much as I like what I’ve seen from Emmer, this race is ultimately about Mark Dayton, heir to the Dayton-Hudson fortune.  Aside from the money, Dayton’s biggest advantage is his name recognition, and his biggest disadvantage is, well, name recognition.  He was a Senator from 2001-2006, and was about as useless as my nipples.  (Still a slight improvement over “Acting Senator” Al Fraudken in that at least he wasn’t a complete embarrassment to the state.)  He even gave himself an ‘F’ for his time there, not running for re-election.  But now we’re supposed to believe that he would somehow be more competent as a Governor?  We’ll just have to wait and see what the voters say.  Oddly enough, even though Minnesota hasn’t voted Republican in a Presidential election since 1972, we also haven’t had a Democrat in the Governor’s mansion since 1990.  Will Minnesota continue to be contrarian, or will the Crimson Tide be enough to carry Emmer to victory?  I’m predicting the latter, and by just enough to avoid getting Frankened.

See you at the polls!

COMMENTS

  • distantvoter

    MN-1 Survey USA has a recent poll showing Walz up 50-41. However, long-time Democratic congressman Penny just blasted Walz for his ads on his radio program, which could have a big impact. I currently see this as Lean Democratic, but definitely in with a chance. Poll link: http://www.surveyusa.com/client/PollReport.aspx?g=e05d2f18-f025-4f0a-8aa8-66fc44c53b14

    MN-8 A poll announced yesterday has Oberstar with a 47-46 lead. http://www.surveyusa.com/client/PollReport.aspx?g=e05d2f18-f025-4f0a-8aa8-66fc44c53b14

    It’s only one poll, and SUSA may be a little Republican in their results this cycle, but it isn’t very far off. Oberstar is probably being hurt by some votes he made, but hurt even worse by the perception that he has “gone Washington” (only one in-district donor in his last report, almost all PACs). Add to that his arrogance in debates and calling some of his constituents flat-earthers. I also have this as Lean Democratic, but I think Oberstar is in greater danger than Walz, amazing as that may seem.

  • lukematthews

    Is using the old numbers from 2006 and 2008 when collecting their data. They are taking more Dems and fewer indies, who are breaking two to one for Repubs. The First is a probable win, the eighth is a win unless the felon/cemetery/vacant lot vote is too great. Seventh is in play. I really think with the indies breaking our way and the Dems depressed as all get out, we have a shot for all three. Widespread lethargy has broken out in the state among leftists. In south Minneapolis, which is a voter rich source for Dayton, I have yet to see a canvasser. I don’t think Dayton will pull it out. There are just too many angry and vocal indies that want to see the wayward Dems trounced. We will see come Tuesday.

  • qsclues

    MN-08 is the hardest for me to judge, because it’s completely outside the Twin Cities, and I know no one from there. Sounds like Cravaack has the momentum right now.

    I remember Tim Penny pretty well…he was the only Democrat that I ever remember my dad voting for. Even with your recent update, I’ll stick with my prediction that Walz goes down.

    Thanks for the update, though.

  • distantvoter

    until Penny’s intervention. I’m hoping that will bump a few votes the other way, and it won’t be a surprise if we get this one.

  • distantvoter
  • http://conservativestateproject.blogspot.com/ SE-779

    Are going down, Ellison wins with at least 71%, and McCollum wins by less than usual. Kline(68-32), Bachmann(61-39), and Paulsen(57-43) will all win big, as the margins in parentheses indicate. I think Emmer wins 47-44, with Horner at 9%.

  • qsclues

    I am changing my prediction that Oberstar would hold on after seeing his campaign ad tonight, which is probably the first one he’s had to run since the Carter administration. He claims Chip Cravaack wants to turn us into Malaysia. Seriously.

    If that’s the best Oberstar can manage, he’s done for. I’m a bit more pessimistic about Walz than I was previously, but I’ll stick with my original call.