Okay, I get that Oprah is a media icon, with a large slice of every venue ‘media’ has to offer. I really do understand that. And, like many of you, I rolled my eyes in disgust when she stated she was declining to allow Sarah Palin on her show before the election, because she didn’t want her show to be a political outlet.
But, this morning I got an email inviting me to sign a petition “telling” Oprah to have Palin on the show. I’m not going to sign this petition. I’m not even going to link this petition. I’m sure many of you have gotten a similar email anyway.
The reality is, Oprah not allowing Palin onto the show (especially after numerous public appearances with Barack Obama) already speaks volumes, in a way that a sit-down chat between the Barracuda and the “Big O” could not.
I’m quite certain many people view Oprah as exceedingly relevant, culturally. I’m equally sure that Oprah fancies herself something of a kingmaker. Neither, actually, is true. Media would be basically what it is today, whether Oprah was a part of it or not. In general, our culture would be largely unchanged. This is not to diminish Oprah’s achievements: she is one hell of a self-promoter, is indeed very popular (popular enough that I fully expect some vehement disagreements with the bulk of this paragraph, even from RS regulars) and has had a brilliant and inspiring career. To be clear, I’m not suggesting that Oprah is culturally irrelevant — simply that she’s not as important to what happens, to whom, and how, as she and her followers might believe.
I see Oprah’s show much as I view a good zombie movie (except that I enjoy a good zombie movie): basically meaningless, mindless (in some cases, brainless) fun. It serves those who enjoy that sort of thing, but nobody with a brain sees it as a serious source of information.
This brings us back to the Palin situation. It’s Oprah’s show. She can have on her show whomever she likes. Palin’s appearance on Oprah’s show, or lack thereof, is simply not going to impact this election.
The petition is as reactionary as it is unintelligent. It forces relevance onto an irrelevant non-event and gives an illusion of importance to something that isn’t. Palin not being on Oprah, I think, will prove far more useful. Or, at least, less useless.

Yup, it's HER show.
Mord Saturday, September 13th at 9:08AM EDT (link)I agree. Outrage seems to be a growing fad. I would bet that the origional author of the pettition hardly watches the show, but just couldn’t resist trying to make the world “fair”. If you are really that upset at Oprah, don’t watch her show, it’s that easy.
————————————–
“Republicans never win polls, they win elections,” - Rudy Giuliani
————————————–
Sara Palin don't jump on couches
SteveLA Saturday, September 13th at 9:14AM EDT (link)Looking back to Tom Cruises appearance on “The O’s” show, do you think she really needs to go there and jump up and down on couches? How about Sarah exclaiming her respect for her new running mate?
I think not, this whole petition is a dumb thing in my book.
______________________________________
Competency over ideological purity
Yeah, rstreu, I got the email too and deleted
janis Saturday, September 13th at 9:31AM EDT (link)it every time. Like you, I don’t even want to see Sarah Palin on Oprah’s show and I have no idea why McCain would lower himself to be on “The View” the other day either.
Both shows are daytime junk food. On the other hand, after the past two days of Gibson arrogance, I don’t know why I would want either of our candidates to appear on MSM news shows either.
ALl of these events are quite instructive to the public at large. They may have been on the fence before, or asleep, but they are no more.
Not being on Oprah's show
Steph C Saturday, September 13th at 12:11PM EDT (link)hurts Oprah more than Sarah Palin. Don’t worry about her and her show. She has billions with which to console herself and jumpstart a new career.
“[I]f the public are bound to yield obedience to laws to which they cannot give their approbation, they are slaves to those who make such laws and enforce them.” –Candidus in the Boston Gazette, 1772
Hillbilly Politics
A bigger mark
eagle24 Saturday, September 13th at 1:16PM EDT (link)I hope Palin doesn’t go on. It might make a bigger mark if she doesn’t. If O gave in and lets her on then it immediatly becomes a non-issue. There are plenty of other outlets for the public, including the O crowd, to see Palin and what she stands for.