« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Mad as Hell: Why Carl Paladino Matters

And why the national GOP had better pay attention

On June 2nd, Republican leaders in New York chose a candidate for Governor.  The man they chose, a favorite among GOP elites, was Rick Lazio.  Of course, in New York, as in other states, it is ultimately the voter, and not the elites, who make that final determination.  Last night, the voters chose Buffalo businessman Carl Paladino.  In a similar — though much more publicized — Senatorial race in Delaware, TEA Party favorite O’Donnell upset NRSC favorite Mike Castle.  And like Castle, Gubernatorial hopeful Lazio was left at the end of the polling wondering what, exactly, happened.  Both men had been coronated, after all, by the GOP Leaders.  Why, their supporters wondered, weren’t the voters willing to just follow the marching orders?

And it is exactly this attitude that handed wins to the likes of Paladino and O’Donnell.  Moderate Republicans have ignored or denegrated TEA Party Conservatives as extremists — echoing familiar liberal talking points — while failing to realize the fundamental fact that most TEA partiers are just people who want to be left alone.  Voting Republicans have always had an independent streak.  It is, indeed, this streak that has made them identify with the GOP for so long.  They have never liked being told what to do, be it by Government mandate or intra-party dictum.

Incumbent Republican legislators were warned time and again about the consequences of bowing to liberal causes.  When Mike Castle voted for Cap and Trade as a Congressman, the outcry of his constituents was in no uncertain terms, that his days were numbered.  They weren’t bluffing.  They were warned before that, when they voted for the so-called stimulus package.  They were warned when they voted for the unconstitutional penalty tax on large corporate bonuses.

They failed to listen.

They failed to act.

They stuck their fingers in their ears, denying the majority voices, and plugged their ears to the shouts of those sign-carrying “extremists.”

And they lost.  Big.

Rick Lazio, a shoo-in for GOP Governor candidate made it clear early and often that the spot was his.  That calls for a primary — a chance for the people to speak — were pointless.  He refused to even acknowledge his primary opponant, let alone debate him and give the voters a chance to learn what he was about.  He had bigger fish to fry.  The Republican voters would fall in line and do as they were told, and he had a general campaign to plan.  He, too, learned the hard way.  You have to listen to the voters.

The shoo-in — the sure thing — was defeated with 62% of the vote.  Lazio and the State GOP believed, right up to the end, that this election was in the bag.  THAT is monumental failure to listen.

You can call it a mandate from the TEA party, if you wish.  You can chalk it up to anger over the economy.  But what the Paladino win — and O’Donnell’s — suggests to me is that voters are tired of being ignored.  We’re tired of being ignored by the Obama administration and his rubber stamps in Congress.  We’re tired of being ignored by an agenda-driven press.  We’re tired of being ignored by our own party.

Republican voters will not heed marching orders from On High.  But the National GOP had damned well better learn to heed ours.

COMMENTS

  • fedsocdan

    This is great Randy, I couldn’t agree more.

    Carl will give “Andrew,” as he referred to him in his victory speech, a great challenge.

    Fingers crossed…

  • VanishingNYRep

    I am sorry but some of your facts are wrong. The State Chairman, Ed Cox, wanted Steve Levy a democrat to be the GOP nominee not Lazio. Lazio went to the convention and took the nomination away from Cox and Levy.

    Carl Paladino was a Democrat until 2005. He gave lots of money to Schumer, clinton and the rest of the dem-libs so he could keep his business free from gov’t interference.

    This year, he sensed and opportunity and ran for Gov. The State GOP was moribund due to years of neglect and abuse by Gov. Pataki and his cronies. So Paladino spent his money knocking down a scarecrow.

    I have spoken to a few people that voted for Paladino and yes they were angry at what was left of the GOP establishment but they also voted for Paladino based upon a belief that he would keep his promise to spend whatever it took to win. Well the last time that happened was Bernadette Castro and when she figured out she couldn’t win, she didn’t spend a dime of her own money. She went down in flames.

    I believe that Paladino, a lifelong democrat, would be happy to have Cuomo as Gov. (as he probably donated to Mario Cuomo). Unless and until Paladino publicly states that he is committing $10 Million of hiis own money to the race, I don’t beleive he will do it. Paladino’s only chance is to run a saturation negative TV ad campaign making Cuomo the issue. In that way, he sets himself up as the “no vote.”

    Carl Paldino did not run a primary on principle, he did it for ego. I hope i am wrong but I have seen these people before. Look at Fla nominee Scott. After spending $50 million of his own money to win a primary, he doesn’t want to spend it for the general election. Scott only has $250,000 in the bank, has raised only $45,000 since the primary and is 7 points behind in the polls. Scott isn’t serious and unless Palaidino does something positive like pledging to spend $10 million of his own money, he isn’t serious either.

    I will still vote for him because the Dem-libs are running NYS into the ground but I cannot beleive he really wants to win.

    • http://slcliberty.blogivists.com randy streu

      Carl Paladino was a Democrat until 2005. It is now 2010. A lot can happen in five years.

      Also, Levy was a non-starter. Cox is one guy who wanted to do a favor for a buddy and was shot down. THE REST of the GOP elites wanted — and chose — Lazio. It’s a fact. It’s what happened. Try hitting the links provided.

      Also, exactly what the hell does Scott have to do with Paladino?

      • VanishingNYRep

        I use Scott as an example. A millionaire that wants to run for office, spends his time beating up on the real Republicans and then decides he can’t win.

        BTW, what is a “concern troll?” and what is a Half-kostard?”

        When and until Paladino commtis to spending his millions running negative ads against status-cuomo, I won’t beleive he is serious.

        If i am wrong, I will post an apology.

        • http://slcliberty.blogivists.com randy streu

          Does it help? Nope. Not even a little.

          A Concern troll is somebody who pretends to be just another fellow Conservative who has this deep concern for something that nobody could change, even if it WERE true, in order to do nothing but stir up trouble.

          What you have are half-assed assessments based on somebody else, and this idea that Paladino has to prove himself innocent by whatever your standard happens to be, of whatever crimes you happen to think he’s guilty of.

          It doesn’t help, it’s not instructive, and it does NOTHING but stir dissent when we are now post-primary and in need of UNITY.

          In short, I don’t give two sh_ts for your apology. You had time to voice your concerns during the primary. Time’s up. Time to jump in or go home.

      • http://slcliberty.blogivists.com randy streu

        that it’s not ABOUT Paladino. The election wasn’t about Lazio, or even beating Cuomo. It was about reminding the State and national GOP who’s in charge.

        Lazio probably wasn’t going to beat Cuomo. Paladino might not. The guy who, in my opinion, had the best chance… ain’t running. This election, as my post, which you didn’t read, suggests, was all about smacking down this GOP/party idea that the voters are here for THEM, as opposed to the other way around.

      • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

        on TV debates. Saw Lazio on MTP or some Sunday show a few weeks ago and he was great. Hope he stays active and wins a race soon. He is a great GOP asset. Reminds me of Fiorina in his on TV debate ability to smack down dems with relevant facts in sound bites.

  • eburke
  • SKully

    NY GOP, and local county GOP were responsible for the Dede Scuzzy fiasco. They didn’t learn anything with that loss, except how to point the blame to us Tea Partiers. As a Paladino volunteer, I can tell you being ignored by the NY GOP at the convention just fired us up even more. That’s how 2x the number of signatures were collected to force the primary. That’s how enough signatures were gathered to insure a separate Taxpayer line.

    Not only the GOP is in the frying pan here though. Keep your eye on the so-called NY Conservative Party. With their endorsement of Lazio over Paladino, they insulted the party base. Many of us registered Republicans would vote for the Republican candidate via the Conservative line in November, to keep the minor line viable. It’s possible the new Taxpayer line can take over the Conservative line after Nov 2. Serves them right.

    • http://slcliberty.blogivists.com randy streu

      I truly hope the era of mutual support between CPNY and NYGOP isn’t over. But so far, it ain’t promising.

  • peg_c

    I did phone banking all day long on Election Day for Paladino, and our Tea Party group did endorse him after Lazio NO SHOWED on us with 35 minutes to go at an August candidate vetting night he requested of US. He dissed most Tea Party groups repeatedly as well as the Ulster Country Republican Chairman, who wanted to host fundraisers for him. Most establishment Republicans (committee members and local politicians) supported Lazio, but there was zero energy in the voter base for him. He consistently came across as entitled, arrogant and contemptuous. He looked to Cuomo and completely overlooked the immediate threat.

    Carl Paladino COMES from the Buffalo Tea Party group and was recruited by them to run for governor. I heard the whole story at the Paladino press conference hastily called for this past Sunday after the Siena poll very misleadingly stated that Tea Party support was split between the two and that Paladino did not enjoy much TP support. Incidentally, in the whole state no one in the TP movement knows a single legitimate Tea Partier who was polled by Siena. How did they arrive at their numbers?

    I have met Paladino several times and got a big hug and kiss from him Sunday. We worked our butts off for him. NO ONE cares whether he was a Democrat, as we have Dems, Independents and unaffiliateds in our group. I was a Dem for 26 years. Right now, “Republican” doesn’t mean much! He has a TP sensibility, he despises Albany and the corruption and mess there, and he’s going to give Sheldon Silver and a whole raft of arrogant pols up there fits!

    Interesting – I just heard he will be on Hannity’s radio show this afternoon. Hannity has assiduously ignored Paladino and rebuffed the campaign’s attempts to come on the radio and TV show. Suddenly Carl is hot. Ha!

    The Tea Party movement is mowing down Democrats and old-style Republicans alike. Good!

  • aurelv

    I saw the Paladino interview on CNN with Rick Sanchez. Wow. Let me put it like this, it takes considerable skill to make Sanchez look like a man of reason. In any event, my favorite part was Paladino’s insistence – without any sense of irony – that as Governor he would enthusiastically employ Eminent Domain to prevent the Park51 Mosque from being built.
    I know he’s a new convert and all to the Tea Party, but it’s almost criminally negligent for his staff not to have properly briefed him on the necessity of showing righteous indignation toward ED. One more slip-up like this and people may start to get the impression that he’s just an opportunistic malcontent.

    • aesthete

      However, this post doesn’t really have to do with the merits or demerits of Paladino as a candidate, but moreso with general Tea Party sentiment and the contradistinction between the Tea Party and establishment Republicans.

    • SKully

      and at times has tailored his responses to be ‘do anything legally possible’ to prevent the mosque. For the overall picture, he is far more conservative than any of the opponents. This is the message he (and voters!) are trying to give to the elite. They need to ‘get’ it.

      • peg_c

        is, to MANY Tea Partiers and conservatives, at least a defensible use of a repugnant and unconstitutional power-grab.

        I’m no fan of Eminent Domain and know no one who is in our movement. But the Mosque is more repugnant.

        In the same way, I defend torture of terrorists.

        We are never going to beat our enemies if we always play nice and always follow the rules. The Dems have broken every rule and law imaginable. I can excuse Paladino’s power-grab to kill the Mosque. We need to drop the rose-colored glasses. This is war.

        As for Paladino, he is very conservative, wants to lay waste to Albany, and has called out Sheldon Silver, Pataki (to an extent), Koch, D’Amato and McCall BY NAME this past Friday on Hannity’s radio show. Hannity was left basically speechless. Hannity not only is friends with Lazio and a NY Conservative Party member (a party that is hopelessly compromised and corrupt), but I have decided he lacks a true Tea Party spirit (unlike, by comparison, Rush and Mark Levin). Paladino made him sound like a stuttering idiot ;-) I think Carl is fantastic, I admit it.

        • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

          besides if this mosque does get built, it will be a primary spot to keep under watch for terror activity. And once such activity occurs, it can then be shut down and kept shut. (under a different administration of course)

          • peg_c

            about the Mosque being shut down in the future, but I would not bet on it. I’d rather do everything we can to prevent it from being built.

            A victory Mosque at Ground Zero allowed by America is a HUGE win for the Islamonazis and a terrible step towards Sharia and oppression of America by them. BTW, there is a victory mosque planned for Shanksville where United 93 came down, are you aware of that?

            The repugnance of these extremists is limitless. We are starting to give in to the Religion of Beheading.

  • aurelv

    but it’s ok to use this one time to prevent the construction of a building that even Saint Sarah acknowledges has a constitutional right to be built. So, if I understand you correctly, you want to use what you consider to be an unconstitutional measure (Eminent Domain) to prevent a constitutional right (building of a Mosque), solely based on the grounds that you consider the action to be an affront to the 9/11 victims?

    Unbelievable.

    And to think that Arab Muslims in the U.S. used to vote Republican.