« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

I Have An Idea, Invite Haiti To Join The United States – Open Thread

Here are some thoughts I want to present, along with an opportunity for others to chime in.

We’ve all seen the pictures of the tragedy going on in Haiti. We also know that Haiti is perhaps the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere (although my money on that is actually Cuba; but I digress). All attempts by the U.S. to provide Haitians with the ability to elect a responsible government have failed miserably. Haiti as a nation looks like Detroit. On steroids.

There is a way to fix this problem, at least in the long term. Invite Haiti to be a part of the United States. Maybe as a semi-autonomous territory at first, like Puerto Rico, then maybe later as a state if they want to be one. Yes, I understand there would be issues with this as leftists would do what they could to maintain the victimhood status of Haitians, as they do with Detroit. But Haitians don’t have the kind of axe to grind that the politicians of Detroit try to perpetuate there. We know that legal Haitian immigrants have contributed mightily to the United States.

What this also does is get Haiti out from under the failed thumb of the UN. UN peacekeeping missions do absolutely nothing to get a failed state like Haiti out of the misery its in. I would argue that they help perpetuate the misery by encouraging “victimhood”. Where in the world have these kinds of actions actually helped any nation?

Sure, there would still be corruption, especially in the short term. But Haiti would then be under the purview of United States law. Much as we complain about it, our federal laws are much stronger than those of Haiti’s national laws. It would also give Haitians the real security to set their own direction as a territory and perhaps as a state.

One of the criticisms from others in the Western Hemisphere will be the notion of expanding U.S. imperialism. That will come from the Castros, Chavez, Ortega, Morales, and the usual leftist jerks running their countries into the dirt. There might even be some push back from trading partners like Mexico, Brazil, Chile, and perhaps even Colombia. The Dominican Republic, Haiti’s neighbor on the island of Hispaniola, may feel threatened; they must be assured U.S. interest in offering Haiti to be a part of the U.S. will not expand to there. It must be explained that this is an invitation, not a usurpation. If Haiti says no, then the no must stand and the U.S. butts out. But if they say yes, there would be all kinds of benefits to Haiti, as well as the U.S.

An invitation like this shouldn’t be made lightly. Geography has to be taken into account, so we can’t just make these invitations willy-nilly. But I think it would work for Haiti.

Let me know what you think.

Tags:

COMMENTS

  • Trelaina

    We have enough problems here in the US as it is.

  • izoneguy

    Wow, another set of corrupt politicians could be born & bred – right on Haiti!!!

    As it is – the libs are trying to bring as many Haitians into the US as they can.

    Haiti needs to find it’s own set of George Washington’s & Sarah Palin’s to save it.

    • Richard Mullins

      and infect the place with conservative ideas. Personally, I don’t see a George Washington type coming out in Haiti. That place is very repressed when it comes to conservatism. I don’t think making them part of the US is silly.

      • Politics1001

        among the elite class. However, it’s going to be a tough sell to the 95% of poor people.

  • http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i240/jkcummi/Kung%20Fu/DawnKyleOpenHand2.jpg Shiheng Zeke

    The first problem would be related to the costs associated with a take over of Haiti by the U.S. The country of Haiti has no resources and almost no farming. This would mean the population would be dependent on social welfare programs from day one. It would be very hard for the country to develop into a place which could contribute to the U.S. economy.

    The second problem would be political. The Democratic party would love having 9 million new members but the Republicans would not. The shared border with Dominican Republic would also present problems with immigration and smuggling.

    I thought about the possibility of evacuating Haiti completely due to the level of destruction but this would be harder than cleaning up the mess and putting them back to where they were.

    In the end, the action plan will be to provide disaster relief, clean up the mess, and hope the Haitians can rebuild. There is some doubt to the last since there are so few resources left. We will more than likely see the political system collapse and a period of anarchy before they can progress again.

    • mom2oneson

      with the aid and human resources that will be given to them from governments and private charities.

      Couldn’t we assist them with developing rice farms again?

      PR has very high rates of public assistance usage and working age men on disability and they remain part of us.

  • acat

    Move the U.N. headquarters down to Haiti.

    Better weather for the “diplomats”, fewer problems for NYC to contend with, makes spying on the U.S. harder.

    The best reason, though – if the U.N. can’t fix Haiti, with their headquarters there, then perhaps it’s time to admit the U.N. is a failed institution. After that, we can experiment with sending different group headquarters to Haiti. I’d suggest the 700 club to follow the U.N….

    Mew

    • http://www.itsmyblog.com uttles

      This is the best idea I’ve seen.

  • Achance

    and a couple of communist representatives. The Dems would love it though.

    • acat

      Nothing else to say here.

      Mew

      • aesthete

        I say that as a proud Puerto Rican.

  • Third Street

    We’ll just bring them all up here. The Democrats are already looking to move as many tens (hundreds?) of thousands of refugees as possible into Florida, put them on the welfare rolls, and register them to vote.

  • Politics1001

    just to see the reaction at redstate. The only thing Haiti has to offer the US would be rice, coffee, rhum, sugar cane, lots of cheap labor, and maybe a place to house Guantanamo detainees. With US assistance, Haiti would probably end up a very nice place like Hawaii or Puerto Rico; but the US taxpayer isn’t ready for this burden.

    THe UN based in Haiti would be a better idea.