« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Kevin Drum Insult Christians, Ignores Definitions of Words

Over at Mother Jones, lefty extremist Kevin Drum wrote an insulting piece of tripe called “Helping the Poor is Now Apparently Anti-Bible“. Apparently, Drum took umbrage at a statement pastor Rick Warren made on ABC’s This Week:

Well certainly the Bible says we are to care about the poor….But there’s a fundamental question on the meaning of “fairness.” Does fairness mean everybody makes the same amount of money? Or does fairness mean everybody gets the opportunity to make the same amount of money? I do not believe in wealth redistribution, I believe in wealth creation.

The only way to get people out of poverty is J-O-B-S. Create jobs. To create wealth, not to subsidize wealth. When you subsidize people, you create the dependency. You — you rob them of dignity.

After admitting that he agrees with Warren’s sentiment, Drum gets nasty:

But I’m a blogger, not a minister. And while I might not be an expert on the Bible, I’ve read enough to know that Jesus sure didn’t seem to think that helping the poor robbed them of dignity. Can someone help me out here? What part of the gospels do you think Warren is referring to?

It’s extremely difficult to have a discussion with someone like this, someone who is deliberately misleading about Warren’s point and ignores the definition of English words. But I think I can help Drum.

I’m no big Rick Warren fan, but I can see no reason to insult him as Drum does. Warren never said helping the poor robbed someone of their dignity. In fact, Warren explicitly lays out what robs poor people of their dignity, government subsidies; and, Warren is right. Having the poor stay on the dole for scraps, a policy supported by Democrats for the last 45 years, since the days of LBJ’s Great Society, is not help. The statistics bear this out:

But according to Drum, “helping the poor” means having the government give out scraps of taxpayer dollars forever. Maybe Drum should take a look at the data that proves him wrong before he bears false witness against and insults a Christian minister, a minister who, by Drum’s admission, is more of an expert on the Bible.

The answer, then, to Drum’s question:

What part of the gospels do you think Warren is referring to?

is a question to Drum. Drum says he’s read enough of the gospels “to know that Jesus sure didn’t seem to think that helping the poor robbed them of dignity.” The question to Drum is, since he’s read enough of them, what part of the gospels says Jesus supports the government endlessly giving scraps of taxpayer dollars to the poor, subsidies the poor can collect only if they don’t work?

Cross-posted at Scipio the Metalcon.

COMMENTS

  • Viet71

    Drum is clueless about the difference between creating government dependency and thoughtful charitable giving.

    Giving to an organization such as the Salvation Army or a local food bank, for example, is a way for individuals to help the downtrodden without government’s doing what LBJ tried to do with his Great Society program.

  • kipling

    The answer to Drum’s question can be found throughout the Bible but I will highlight just a few places.

    First, from Genesis on the creation of man: “Be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth and subdue it and have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the heavens and over every living thing that moves on the earth.” (1:28) and “The Lord God took the man and put him in the garden of Eden to work it and keep it.”

    Man and woman were created in the image of God and thus bear the creative traits of their creator. God created man for a purpose and instilled him with God given talents to complete that purpose. Work brings dignity because in our work we honor and reflect the dignity and glory of God.

    Second, sloth is condemned throughout the Bible. So is theft [i.e. redistribution of wealth] and envy [as in the 99% rhetoric]. Paul said that those who do not word should not eat and warned against providing charity to those who could work on their own. He also warned against idleness that leads to sin.

  • wvfii

    that what we need to do is to return to the common sense tax rates of the 1990s

    • aesthete

      of the 1990s.

      • wvfii

        probably shouldn’t have started that silly trillion dollar war… or maybe should’ve planned a little better on the front end when staring down the prospect of the largest generation in history reaching SS/ Medicare eligibility. it’s too bad you can’t just run out on the tab now, eh?

        • aesthete

          Maybe we could have better defined foreign policy which tends towards less action abroad, while also moving towards pension and healthcare systems which have been proven to save money and harness the power of markets to provide quality and effective rationing. Additionally, maybe state governments can negotiate 401k defined benefit plans for their workers, instead of engineering deals that benefit only state politicians and those working in the civil bureaucracy. Finally, maybe we can remove some of the regulations both on the supply and demand side (particularly in labor markets) that get in the way of productive enterprise and the purchasing of same.

          Screw it, that sounds tough; let’s just hand . Obama 2012!