Official Red State predictions thread
By trevino Posted in Elections — Comments (40) / Email this page » / Leave a comment »
What do Red State Editors think will happen tomorrow? Herein is the official RS election predictions thread. Read on -- and put your own predictions in comments. Winner gets a no-prize.
Ben Domenech -- BUSH VICTORY
Bush wins, 281 to 257. I think he loses Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania and NJ - but wins Iowa, Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Florida.
Senate: 53 Rep, 45 Dem, 1 Ind (GOP gains 2)
House: 232 Rep, 202 Dem, 1 Ind (GOP gains 3)
Governor: 27 Rep, 21 Dem (Dems gain 1)
Erick-Woods Erickson -- BUSH VICTORY
I'm going 296 to 242 for Bush.
I think he's got OH, WI, and IA. I don't think Bush has MI, MN, or PN.
Kevin Holtsberry -- BUSH VICTORY
Bush 271
Kerry 267Bush takes FL, WI, and IA but loses PA, OH, MI, and MN.
Jay Reding -- BUSH VICTORY
I give Bush Iowa, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Florida, New Mexico and Ohio leading to a Bush blowout:
Bush 306
Kerry 232I'd also be willing to believe that Bush has a strong shot at Michigan and Hawaii which would be a major rout for Bush 327 to Kerry's 211.
This won't be nearly as close as we think.
Pejman Yousefzadeh -- BUSH VICTORY
Bush: 296, Kerry: 242
OR
Bush: 276, Kerry: 262
Craig Linton -- KERRY VICTORY
Bush: 253 / 47%
Kerry: 285 / 50%
Turnout: 55%
Me -- KERRY VICTORY
277-261
Bush loses all the hot swing states -- Ohio, Iowa, Pennsylvania, Minnesota
and Wisconsin -- except for Florida.
Thomas Crown -- BUSH VICTORY + DESTRUCTION OF AMERICA
Bush wins, 300-something to the rest. Bush holds all his states from 2000, picks up WI, PA, and NM. He barely loses The People's Republic of New Jersey and MI. After a brief outbreak of room-to-room fighting in Portland, OR, quickly won by Bush supporters (who are disproportionately armed with more than butter knives), OR goes for Bush too.
Nonetheless, the Donks file suit in every state in the union, contesting the results. Whole batallions of Dem lawyers are executed on the steps of the Texas Supreme Court on general principle. The Supreme Court of Wisconsin declares a popular election to violate the Republican form of government clause, and promptly orders the electors to vote for Gore, no, wait, they mean Kerry. After the bodies of dead lawyers from Texas and AK are dropped by a cackling Tom DeLay over Green Bay with the words "Lambert Field" etched in their flesh, an internal civil war erupts in that state, quickly spreading to MN and Illinois.
The Florida Supreme Court, speaking through the Fifth District Court of Appeals, issues an opinion from its secret underground bunker, invalidating the election results. However, the Florida Legislature impeaches the whole Court and post-facto voids the ruling. Angry denizens of Boca and Broward County launch a furious assault on the Panhandle, only to find out that the Panhandle is largely populated by angry men with guns. The death toll is in the tens of thousands.
In Texas, some more lawyers are shot on general principle. Some guys from Houston drive to Austin and shoot some of the locals for voting for Kerry.
In NY, being a Republican is made illegal, thus sending thousands of legislators from the 1870s spinning in their graves.
In MA, someone does something and no one cares, because the frigging Sox finally (1) beat the Yankees and (2) won the frigging World Series. The Big Dig, sadly, continues.
California secedes from the Union. No one cares until the people of Texas, finally running out of lawyers to shoot, turn their sites on CA.
The hippies of New Mexico stage a rally, and are shot by Texans on their way through, and by some Arizonans who are hacked by the snowbirds in the area.
Pete Coors sacrifices Salazar on an altar of blood, just to give The Nation something to write about.
Tom Daschle is deeply saddened.
Krempasky - BUSH VICTORY
Bush gets 290 electoral votes.
Republicans pick up two net seats in the Senate
Republicans pick up five seats in the House.
« Question and answer time: the Wes Clark thing. — Comments (50) | Floridians -- Get Out There and Vote! — Comments (14) »
Official Red State predictions thread 40 Comments (0 topical, 40 editorial, 0 hidden) Post a comment »
You know the thoughts of millions -- nay, billions -- of individuals, and can sense their motivations?
Stop posting on this thread and save humanity! The Earth needs you now!!
but I am impressed you didn't feel that you all had to be glass-half-full for Bush.
It depends on what you think of "trends" really... it's obviously too close to call... which is of course when it's fun to call.
I'm afraid if I did predict I'd just be playing the expectations game... you know... don't forget to go vote on Wednesday kind of stuff.
Oil traders are betting on Kerry? You base that on what exactly? I think the realization that the election is almost over (no matter who wins) and the realization that problems in Nigeria will not have an impact on oil exports is the more likely reason for the drop in oil prices.
By the way you may want to try spell check next time.
I went to RCP, looked at the polls, went with my gut, and filled in the Electoral College Calculator. That spit out the EC vote I predicted.
Then I guessed at the popular vote. I figured that it would be a cold day in Florida before another president would win the popular vote but lose the EC vote. So I put Kerry up by 3 percent, leaving 3 percent for Nader, Badnarik, and the other potential spoilers.
Turnout was just random, probably too high.
Senate: Thune, DeMint, Martinez.
Oil trades on supply and demand or speculation about either. Oil traders don't have political preferences, they like to make money.
Oil reserves jumped dramatically last week which means the markets perceive sufficient supply, thus the decline in crude of a little over 10%.
I would suggest you go to Tradesport.com or the marketbased indicators at Real Clear Politics to see how market based indicators where participants actually risk their capital on the election results are trading.
Lastly, if you really belive what you wrote and actually posses any investment capital I pray you have hired a professional to advise you as your comments about oil suggest you are at best an investment novice and at worst an investment idiot.
When the Revolution comes, you will be spared.
Kerry 279
Bush 259
Kerry 49.7%
Bush 48%
Futures prices, like stock prices, depend on certainty. Certainty of the future, to include world stability. If anyone can explain how a Kerry presidency will increase certainty in the world, I'll buy you a donut.
The world won't know what Kerry stands for until he takes a poll. Bush, love 'em or hate 'em, he's pretty darn certain.
I hope it's the Socks with Sandals Revolution. I'll pass that one up!
I talked to a staunch Democrat today and she was resigned to a Bush victory. Ho-hum.
305-233 in EC.
A southern sweep as the GOP wins NC, SC, GA, and FL Senate seats.
Pete Coors and Coburn pull it out in Colorado and Oklahoma.
And best of all, Tom "Puff" Daschele will be unemployed tomorrow night.
State flips:
OH and NH turn Democrat, IA, NM and HI turn Republican.
I think, for reasons I've given before, it's a Bush blowout.
344 to whatever that leaves.
Bush wins OH, FL, MI, MN, WI, IA, NM, and PA.
Loses NJ, HI, NH.
PV: who cares, but I'd say 52-47, like Cheney predicted. Point is, I believe many states will be close, but I believe they will break for Bush. If many states are close, the national PV is close, but Bush wins the states.
No, I've not drunk any Kool-Aid lately.
The only prediction I can make is: there will be an election tomorrow.
Since part of my prediction is close results in most states that will break for Bush, my prediction comes with the caveat that the imminent massive voter fraud will only result in making it closer than it would otherwise be (vis a vis Florida 2000) or be completely tossed in the courts.
If Kerry's Lawyer Brigade succeeds in getting the frauds upheld, Kerry could easily take OH, FL, MI, PA, or whichever states he picks.
HOWEVER... I think Bush wins enough states that Kerry's Lawyer Brigade will not be able to thwart the will of the people in enough of them to swing it into a Kerry victory.
So BUSH STILL WINS (even if it results in a 269-269 EC tie and it is sent to the House of Reps where Bush wins 35-40 state delegations. God Bless the Framers)
Bush 327/50.2%
Kerry 211/47.8%
Bush picks up Pennsylvannia and the upper Midwest except Michigan. He also takes New Mexico in addition to holding all the states from 2000 (including FL) except for NH. New Hampshire is Kerry's sole pickup from the 2000 red states.
The U.S. electoral map will be a sea of Republican red, interrupted only by Democrat blue on the West Coast, New England, in some of the Rust Belt and the Upper Midwest. I don't think Maine or Nebraska will split their votes and I don't think the vote-splitting referendum in Colorado will pass. Kerry states will be:
Washington, Oregon, California, Hawaii, Minnesota, Illinois, Michigan, Pennsylvania, New York, Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Maine, the District of Columbia (yeah, I know it's not a state, but despite that it has three electoral votes), Maryland, Delaware, and New Jersey. This means Bush will win 296 electoral votes compared to Kerry's 242.
Not literally, but in his predictions for tomorrow. I think Bush takes Iowa, Wisconsin, and New Mexico, while losing only New Hampshire. I live in PA and as much as I'd like to tell you I think he can win here.... he can't.
Won't matter. Once Ohio goes up on the board for the good guys we won't need PA anyway
Kerry wins Michigan, Minnesosta, Pennyslvania, New Hampshire, Hawaii.
Bush wins Florida, Wisconsin, Ohio.
Plus perhaps a single elector from Maine's Second District, which would make it 297-241.
As for the Senate, David Hogberg already filed my opinion at spectator.org. He must have been channeling me.
Seriously, agree on every one. Think we hold Murkowski and win Thune, Martinez, DeMint, Burr, Vitter, Coburn. Lose Coors and whoever that fellow is in Illinois. (What a horror that is.)
I think a key defining feature in this race is the success of Ken Jennings on Jeopardy. Ken, from reddest-state Utah, represents the best of the opportunity society, combining smarts, experience, and family values to push through a conservative agenda on an important gameshow. He's no Eminem.
Amusingly enough, it appears Ken will pass the all-time winnings record for a gameshow contestant on tomorrow's Jeopardy. Which will be pre-empted by election coverage.
Hey, it's as logical as the Redskins homegame theory.
I say Bush, 296-242. All states the same as in 2000, except for the following:
Kerry wins New Hampshire.
Bush wins Wisconsin, Iowa, and New Mexico.
My prediction is if every legal voter is counted once Bush will win. If voters voted based on shared values he'd win in a landslide.
I hope fraudulent voters go to jail, pay fines, and they are not allowed to vote in another election.
I hope a system is devised that will allow a voter to be registered at only one address.
I hope there is a clear winner and voters give lawyers and foreign observers the bird.
Stigma will be placed on Americans who think Bush is a greater enemy than Bin Laden. Moore will finally feel shame.
McCauliffe is fired and replaced by someone like Lieberman or Bayh....actually almost anyone else.
and as to the margin of victory in the EC, take your pick of any of the other pessimistic predictions above. One reason will be the massive fraud efforts of the dems in FL, PA and OH, which will go largely unremarked and unopposed by republicans, as always. If put on the spot, republican officials will mouth pious folderol about seeking the good of the nation, passing over in silence the fact that the USA will have become a banana republic like Venezuela, differing not in nature, but merely in the lower level of corruption and intimidation employed.
Islamists and other evildoers the world over will rejoice. Limp-wristed Eurofools and Europhiles will celebrate. Secularist ideologues will wring their hands in delight and anticipation.
And the damage wrought, over the subsequent four years - in terms of foreign policy ineptitude, bogus treaties signed, leftist ideologues appointed to the federal bench and Supreme Court, the acquiescence of the system in its subversion by fraud, and more - will be so massive, so extensive, that.... well, let me just say that a future generation of historians will reflect upon the election of 2004 and wonder how the American public could have gone so wrong. Will the last patriot left please turn out the lights?
If Vitter (R) doesn't win outright tomorrow (La. has an OPEN primary system) against the three dems, he'll lose in the runoff. Vitter had reached 51% in the polls. before running some really abrasive ads that, along with Breaux, have knocked him back to about 48%.
The sixth circuit court of appeals just overturned previous federal court rulings and will allow GOP poll watchers to be at polling places to challenge voters' registrations in real time.
So Mary Poppins and Mickey Mouse and Donald Duck will have to have that name on their Driver's License and all signatures must match.
A win for the good guys.
276-262 EC vote total. Same as 2000, except Bush picks up IA, NM, and WI, and loses OH.
1) US Senate-OK:
Coburn 53
Carson 44
Bilyeu 3
2) US Senate-other:
IL-Obama (D)
GA-Isakson (R)
SC-DeMint (R)
LA-Vitter (R)
OK-Coburn (R)
NC-Burr (R)
FL-Martinez (R)
CO-Salazar (D)
AK-Knowles (D)
SD-Thune (R)
These predictions are in the order of my certainty (i.e. I am most certain about IL and least about SD). These results put the senate at 54-45-1 and constitutes a +3 for Republicans.
3) US House:
Republicans +3
4) Presidential Election:
Due to the lack of clear information, I do not have enough chutzpah to predict a winner. I believe these states will switch from 2000:
From R to D:
NH 4
From D to R:
NM 5
WI 10
And these are too close to predict:
OH 20
FL 27
PA 21
MN 10
IA 7
HI 4
That gives me an electoral base of 242-207-89 for Bush-Kerry-Tossup. That means the President needs 27 EVs to win (tie goes to the President in the House) which can be done many ways but winning FL, OH, or PA is key. Any two will definitely put him in the White House for 4 more years.
(Cross Posted at Okie's Corner.)
Or, as they say in France, bon chance. Not a bod prediction. We'll see how close you came on the flipside.
Cheers -
Going on my gut feeling, it will be :
BUSH 301
jfk 237
My prediction is
Bush 272
Kerry 266
71% turnout overall
Carville's head explodes at 10:30 EST
In incumbent elections, either the incumbent or the challenger wins big (note: 3rd party candidates have been left out, and keep in mind as you go back in history, the electoral college gets smaller because there are fewer states):
1996
Clinton 379
Dole 159
1992
Clinton 370
Bush 168
1984
Reagan 525
Mondale 13
1980
Reagan 489
Carter 49
1976
Carter 297
Ford 240
(an exception)
1972
Nixon 520
McGovern 17
1956
Eisenhower 457
Stevenson 73
1948
Truman 303
Dewey 189
1944
Roosevelt 432
Dewey 99
1940
Roosevelt 449
Willkie 82
1936
Roosevelt 523
Landon 8
1932
Roosevelt 472
Hoover 59
1924
Coolidge 382
Davis 136
1916
Wilson 277
Hughes 254
(another exception)
1912
Wilson 435
Taft 8
1904
Roosevelt 336
Parker 140
1900
McKinley 292
Bryan 155
1892
Cleveland 277
Harrison 145
1888
Harrison 233
Cleveland 168
1872
Grant 286
Hendricks 42
1864
Lincoln 212
McClellan 21
(11 Southern states didn't participate)
1840
Harrison 234
Van Buren 60
1832
Jackson 219
Clay 49
1828
Jackson 178
Adams 84
1820
Monroe 231
Adams 1
1812
Madison 128
Clinton 89
1804
Jefferson 162
Pinckney 14
1800
Jefferson 73
Adams 65
(another exception, one where Aaron Burr tied Jefferson in the electoral college at 73)
1792
Washington 132
Adams 77
It looks to be a landslide, so I'm calling Kerry at 311 or more.
I pray for a Bush landslide, but I'm preparing myself for what could be a bad night. At any rate, if worse comes to worse, we'll still have a good number in Congress to get some obstruction going on. Oh gosh...the '90s all over again.
*My 2 Scenarios*
1) Same as 2000 except:
Bush picks up New Mexico, Iowa, and Wisconsin
Kerry picks up New Hampshire and Ohio
Bush WINS 275-262-1 (West Virginia RINO Deduction)
2) Same as 2000 except:
Bush picks up New Mexico and Iowa
Kerry picks up New Hampshire and Ohio, holds Wisconsin
Kerry WINS 272-265-1
If the President holds Ohio I'm popping out the champagne.
Also, does anyone have polling data from the same time during the Reagan landslides? I know Carter probably knew he was going down the tube. What about Mondale?
sorry, forgot to post where to get fun link on past elections: http://www.presidentelect.org/
(also wanted to add that in 1800 where adams was incumbent, maybe this should be considered a landslide, too, since jefferson's and burr's sum of electoral votes would have been 146 to adams' 65)
Today I just say: take your little lecture on market-based indicators and go Cheney yourself.
Dixville Notch 2004:
Bush 19
Kerry 7 (gain of 2 from year 2000)
Hart's Location 2004:
Bush 15
Kerry 15 (gain of 2 from year 2000)
Smell of victory getting sweeter and stronger, dude.
I hope you kept didn't bet all your stash at Tradesports, you'll need to buy yourself a bottle tonight.
EV: 300-238
PV: 51-47
Senate -
R: NC, SC, GA, FL, LA, SD
D: IL, OK, WA*, AK
*I previously thought Nethercutt had a high chance of picking up the WA Senate seat, but he never seemed to pick up momentum this fall. Unless there's a last-minute pro-Bush surge in WA, I don't think he'll pull it out.
And for the record: Jim Moran, "safe" incumbent most likely to lose :).
...for being late with my prediction. Here it is, for what it's worth:
Bush (286): Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Florida, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Mexico, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia, Wyoming.
Kerry (252): California, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, Wisconsin.
can you spell landslide?
Electorally speaking, that is.
Hope you saved some of the betting money you lost at Tradesports for a bottle of the strong stuff, dude, you're gonna need it tonight.

Kerry 298
Bush 231
Oil is below $50 a barrell, traders are betting on Kerry