« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

How Obamacare Sunk Student Loans

Buried beneath the thousand or so page monster known as “Obamacare” was a measure in place having nothing to do with actual health care, health care costs, or ways in which to provide affordable, high quality care for lower income Americans. IN this bill there was a provision put in place by Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi that would give the federal government via the Dept. of Education sole control of student loan access.

Now I’ve been asking this question for a good three years and I have yet to come across an answer: “What do student loans have to do with health care?”

I can recall the lessons in my English class from the 4th grade at Robinwood Elementary in Florissant, MO. We learned about “Cause and Effect”. We read sentences and stories rife with examples of cause and effect, and would point them out to the teacher, thus learning how to read and identify instances of cause and effect. However this process is not relegated to the world of literature and grammar, there are many examples of cause and effect throughout history, some with devastating consequence and some used as guidelines for a more stable and peaceful existence.

With such measures in place, stuffed behind measures and provisions, granted powers and commands, the Department of Education took control of the student loan program thereby eliminating their partnership with banks. Before this happened banks such as Citi and Bank of America provided federal loans, private loans, what have you. Now the government provides loans and banks are no longer able to offer any type of loan to students as a result.

Fast forward to this year and we’ve run into a little problem with rising interest rates and overall increases in student loan debt. One might assume full federal dominion over loan access might have solved the problem, not caused the problem. Well, sadly there are a lot of naive people out there who saw this as a good thing. But think about it, the more access students have to loans the more money is spent, resulting in more debt because students for the most part have trouble paying off the loans.

When private banks had the power of issuing loans at their discretion, there was a balance. If you wanted a private loan you needed private loan credit, most young people didn’t have the established credit to take out a loan for 15k. For that you needed a cosigner which is the extra added safety net for people started their life independent from their parents.

A cosigner would be on the hook for a majority of the repayment obligations, which in turn puts enough pressure on the primary loan beneficiary to be reasonable in how much they needed.

Now with the federal government handing out loans like Mr. Good Bar hands out ice cream treats, you’re going to have any and everybody taking out loans they can’t afford.

Yes we should have learned from the housing market debacle but know we didn’t and know we won’t. There are those in this country who believe things should be free, that we have a right to things that don’t belong to us. I’m currently in between jobs and about to resume the final two years of college starting in August. I know that i can’t go crazy on someone else’s tab because there are people, including my mom who pay taxes that goes toward my student loans.

If you’re a student it all comes down to how much you borrow and what you pay for in college. Far too many of our young people waste thousands of tax payer dollars going to “party schools” wasting their time and learning nothing, majoring in Women’s Studies or African American Studies, taking with them a degree that gets them nowhere but back to the basement of their parent’s house.

There’s a reason why going to school to learn how to fix cars, build Harley Davidson motorcycles, or becoming certified as a HVAC technician is worth far more than a Gender Studies major with a minor in Human Rights and at half the cost.

So hopefully the Supreme Court strikes down the entire Obamacare bill and that could actually benefit many students because that provision will no longer be in effect. When conservatives said Obamacare would have expansive consequences beyond health care I guess they were right.

You can make a solid argument that Obamacare has in effect been the single most burdensome yoke around the neck of the economy, student loans, health care, and social policy in America. Wow, all in one bill so much was negatively impacted.

COMMENTS

  • lastgopinillinois

    The Doc Fix, year after year

    And now there will be the student loan interest rate fix, year after year.

  • Pingback: Maria Cole

  • dragan

    I agree that bringing in student loans item into the ACA was wrong. However, the government take over of student loans is not wrong. You mentioned as if the banksters were providing loans that maintained balance. That is pure BS.

    Banksters provided student loans purely based on government guarantee and for a fee. Banksters never took any risks. They simply made money without providing anything of value. The government here eliminated the fraudulent middlemen banksters and is going directly to the students.

    You may be against O and all of that is fine. But dont support the banksters. Support the entrepreners but not the banksters. Banksters are scum. Entrepreuners are not.

  • acat

    What business is it of the government to hand out student loans? For that matter, what business was it, previously, for the government to effectively co-sign for student loans?

    In neither case does the federal government have constitutional authority to undertake student loans or student loan guarantees.

    You assert, though, that “the government take over of student loans is not wrong” .. and yet you provide only #OWS-grade hand-waving to back it up.

    A student loan should be a business decision – but the hand of government has been pretty heavy on the scales.

    Consider the earning potential of various college majors, as represented by this handy chart then tell me why anyone would invest the money to create a psychologist or social worker or a WalMart cashier (erm.. arts major).

    From a purely business standpoint, these careers make no *sense* as an investment … and yet, the buckets of “follow your dreams” b.s. that the current college students and their older siblings have been marinading in their whole lives have led to an explosion of kids going into those fields instead of into fields that are solid investments like healthcare (nursing has quite the shortage) or the physical sciences or any of the engineering disciplines.

    At this point, dragan, I question not only your conservatism, but your common sense.

    Mew

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    .

  • Repair_Man_Jack

    Support the entrepreneurs by making credit completely unavailabe? Novel concept.

  • gekster

    1. Asides from a war or two, what has the Federal government run
    that didn’t get totally screwed up.
    Example: Fanny Mae/Freddie Mac.

    2. You sound like an OWS’er.
    Part of the 99%’ers, are we.

    The banks are not evil.
    They are the ones who loan the money TO the entrepreuners.

    It is up to the students to find a collage and take classes they can afford, and find a loan that will fit thier money situation.

    I don’t see any bankers forcing students into taking loans that they can’t afford.
    If you have knowledge of that happening, please feel free to post this info.

  • Repair_Man_Jack

    let the university admitting the student co-sign it.

  • audax

    nt

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    They should be willing since they’re the ones receiving the money, and well, they’re the ones claiming their degrees have such value.

  • acat

    if only because I’m sure the Libs will hate it. No threat should befall the cloistered academic in his or her ivory tower, certainly nothing as .. pedestrian .. as having to produce results!

    Mew

  • http://stevemaley.com Steve Maley

    … during the BP spill. They didn’t have enough money to entrust to their local banksters.

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    We see the current problem with entrepreneurs without access to capital with the tepid small business startup numbers.

  • Repair_Man_Jack

    nt.

  • checkmate2012

    is also due to O’care. The Dems wrote it into the bill that the interest rate would rise at the end of July 2012. Why the Reps aren’t out there shouting this I don’t know!

    You diary is correct that O’care has many bad effects on the mounting debt. I think you pointed to “unlimited gov’t money” but the real cause and effect on the mega gov’t money supply is tuition increases. Colleges know that they can raise rates because the gov’t will loan or subsidize student loans.

    This effect is the same anytime gov’t interferes in the free market. It’s predicatable as the sun rising in the east.