« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

269 to 269: Not just a hypothetical outcome anymore

RealClearPolitics is now projecting Obama with 269 electoral college votes based upon recent polls (See here ).  By their count, Romney has 181 electoral college votes.  RCP only has 7 tossup states:  Florida (29), North Carolina (15), Virginia (13), Missouri (10), Colorado (9), Iowa (6) and Nevada (6) for a total of 88 ECV up for grabs.  But what happens if Romney does run the table in those undecided states, which is certainly a possibility?  The election would be a 269 to 269 tie.  Forget the popular vote, that doesn’t count.  Instead, dust off your Constitution and look at the 12th Amendment.

In the event of an electoral college tie, the Presidency would be decided by the House of Representatives with each state having one vote.  Because the Republicans control an overwhelming majority of state delegations, which is almost certain not to change regardless of the outcome of House elections, Romney would be elected President.

But there is an interesting twist in the 12th Amendment.  The Senate would choose the Vice President, with each Senator having one vote.  That makes it even more urgent for Republicans to win control of the Senate (and hold their collective noses and support Aiken in Missouri).  If Democrats maintain control of the Senate, they would control the election of the Vice President.  And in the event of a 50 – 50 split in the Senate, the incumbent Vice President would, according to the Constitution, cast the tie-breaking vote.  Does anyone believe that Senate Democrats or Joe Biden would do the right thing and vote for Paul Ryan?  I don’t think so.

Friends, it is not outside the realm of possibility that we could end up with Romney – Biden.

COMMENTS

  • http://deadite.wordpress.com deadite

    If Romney had Reagan’s sense of humor, this would open up SOOOO many possibilities!

  • http://travismonitor.blogspot.com Freedoms Truth

    Chance of this happening is smaller than the chance of the liberal media up and declaring support for Republicans.

    I continue to believe talking about ECs, polls, horserace, etc. is missing the point. What is the point? The point is what is at stake in this election and making that clear to voters:

    “Let me make this very clear — unlike President Obama, I will not raise
    taxes on the middle class. As president, I will protect the sanctity of
    life. I will honor the institution of marriage. And I will guarantee
    America’s first liberty: the freedom of religion. President Obama
    promised to begin to slow the rise of the oceans and heal the planet. My
    promise is to help you and your family.” – Mitt Romney

    America is being strangled economically by Big Government policies that limit our freedom and by limiting our freedom, damage our path to prosperity. Obama has the wrong policies and those policies are holding the economy back. The result has been the worst economic recovery in 75 years.

    If the election doesn’t touch on these facts, and the fact that our current economic misery is due to Obama’s economic mismanagement, it wont be Romney who loses, but America. Obama wins, America loses.

    • mittromney

      idiot ^

      • RedstateBillS

        Toodles

  • naraht

    And then there is the entire question of Maine. It isn’t completely out of the question that we could be looking at 49 Democrats (incl Socialist Bernie Sanders), 50 Republicans and Angus King of Maine. If King votes for Ryan, he’s VP, if King votes for Biden, then Biden breaks the tie to put himself back as VP…

    • keepcoolwithcoolidge

      Wouldn’t the vote take place before King is seated? Although, I have begun wondering how feasible it is for King to be pulled over. No one saw the Obamacare decision falling the way it did, hypothetically King could caucus with the R’s.

  • barleycorn

    There is the further question of whether it is the “old” congress or the “new” congress who would take this action. If this winds up 269-269 be prepared for all manner of shenanigans.

    • http://www.tooncesthecat.wordpress.com tooncesthecat

      The electoral votes are opened and counted by the “new” Congress, which will be sworn in on Jan. 3. Electoral College ballots from the states will be opened and counted in joint session on Jan. 6. Here’s link with the National Archives, which is charged with receiving the ballots: http://www.archives.gov/federal-register/electoral-college/key-dates.html .