I apologize for the multiple diaries, but some things are time-sensitive. Iran is, and so is this case of the Christmas “knicker-bomber” which is quickly spiraling out of control; from a departmental security slip-up, to a full blown scandal, with criminal, or at least serious legal overtones.
It’s no longer that Obama should fire Eric Holder. The Republican Party should insist on his impeachment, and his case be turned over to either a special prosecutor or his own DOJ. This is no longer a case of incompetence disguised by brash arrogance. There were serious legal and security breaches every step of the way, which, as serious as the bombing attempt was, overshadow it…
…for the fact that one man, outside the normal chain of command in a terrorist event can circumvent that chain, then, later, cover up the level and nature of his involvement, is not just frightening. It is criminal.
This is my belief.
Going back to the January 20 hearing before the Senate committee headed by Lugar, the most stunning admission by adminsitration officials…the “other” Janet, Homeland Security chief, Napolitano, National Security chief Blair, FBI Director Mueller, is that none of them knew that Abdulmuttab had been mirandized, and hushed up. Eric Holder stated the decision was his.
That really isn’t enough, at least for the intrepid investigative reporter. As any of you lawyers know, there is a chain of evidence and a chain of custody, both of which detail every movement of the bomber from the time he was wrestled down on the aircraft over Detroit, to the time he was marched in front of judge and arraigned….and every shred of evidence taken in that process.
To say “the FBI” did all this misses the point entirely. The FBI has a boss that stands between them and the Attorney General. The FBI didn’t get involved until the plane landed, which means the pilot had radio’d ahead and agents had been dispatched. Those agents had names. Jones, Smith. And those agents had marching orders, from a superior…who wasn’t skiing at Aspen. There is a chain there, too…who told who what, and when? And how?
For if Eric Holder is being truthful in saying that this was his call, alone, and Napolitano, Blair and Mueller all say they weren’t consulted, then how did a mid-level FBI field agent in Detroit manage to totally circumvent his own chain of command and pass the ball off to some one in DOJ, or perhaps Holder directly? I am fairly certain that agent-in-charge in Detroit does not have Holder’s personal number in his Rolodex.
I don’t know about you, but if I were Napolitano or Blair, both of who are co-equals in government with Holder (or nearly so) I’d have kicked Holder’s door in within 24 hours. And Mueller should have done it even quicker, firing on the spot the agent(s) who circumvented the chain of command and his authority. Or, is FBI working under some internal marching orders no one knows about?
The idea that agents on the ground either winged it, or immediate supervisors winged it, is not an option here. This is not, and was not ever a case of mistaken “crimes”, i.e., a simple felony versus a terrorist act.
There are already lies aplenty here, and those lies began spewing only hours after the bomber’s arrest. Only who’s telling them and why?
I didn’t follow the senate hearings closely, but from the sound bytes, while revealing, they were as investigatively deep as the proverbial pool of warm horse urine. I wasn’t whispering in M’Cain’s ear (I’d have bitten it) or Sessions, but the devil is in the details here, and the people with the details hadn’t even been asked to testify. Nor is the Senate asking the right questions, in my view.
Of course, since those original 20 January hearings it has been revealed that the bomber is singing like a bird, (I doubt it) along with the usual deflections that this is the way Bush handled the shoe bomber too (nyah, nyah)…so everything is working out anyway, almost as if we’d treated him like a terrorist from the git-go. See where the White House and MSM want to redirect public angst and anger…hey, no harm, no real foul? Just as soon as we give KSM a fair trial before hanging him, we’ll convict this guy, too, depending on the deal he cut, then send off to Spandau where no one can ever talk to him again.
But without fully understanding the chain of custody…who cuffed him, who transported him and on whose orders, and where did those orders come from? By phone? Email? Fax?…this is all deflection. For the criminal analyst recreating this chain of events, then filling in the blanks, it can be a thing of beauty.
The Congress should have asked these questions from the outset, and no, there should have been no reason to wait a month for an internal review (It was close to month when the Senate opened hearings anyway.) Considering how he was screwed over by DOJ and his own subordinates, Mueller should have (probably did) instigated one the next day, and could have had a full report on his desk the day after that.
Seriously, all this can be known inside a day, just by sitting the people down, taking theit statements, and begin connecting the dots on the chain of custody and time line. Those original after-action reports have all probably disappeared, or been edited, but It wonn’t do to allow the agencies with the culpability, the most to hide, to do their own internal review as to why a man with so much to tell, and so wanting to tell it, is talking to his lawyer and not trained interrogators. That’s why Congressional oversight is there in the first place.
Either Eric Holder called this, or he is ‘covering”, at a great price, for someone else.
In either case, “the people” have no standing to intervene in this case, and investigate it more thoroughly, except through the auspices of their elected representatives. Both Boehner and Jeff Sessions should know, that if we do win back one of the Houses in November this case is coming back on-line, in all its former glory.
Just one more reason we should win. Putting Holder in jail is just one more bumper sticker I’d like to see this fall.
(Oh, if I’ve misstated any facts here, please correct me.)
Steve Maley
Neil Stevens
Daniel Horowitz
Thanks for your analysis,
Viet71 (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 8:50AM EST (link)which makes clear that Obama (not Holder) decided for purely political purposes to treat the would-be-bomber as a criminal, so as not to have to deal with a “terrorist” on American soil in the full glare of the corrupt press, while the Left chanted loudly in the foreground.
There are plenty of ******bags to go around here.
Thanks for that clarity.
H (Diary) Saturday, February 13th at 11:35AM EST (link)I have enough of a conspiratorial mindset that I was wondering to myself whether this was solely the undisciplined tampering of a hyper-ideologue CinC or a desperate attempt to silence a low level patsy in some hideously evil pre-SOTU “man made disaster.”
My younger brother the pole climber for the utility always has to remind me, never assume evil plotting when just plain stupid can explain the situation. They are just not that smart.
How come our side is not making more noise about this?
penguin2 (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 9:59AM EST (link)FBI agents are attached to a field office, which is run by a Special Agent in charge, and possibly an Assistant Director in Charge, for the larger offices like DC, NY and LA, don’t know about Detroit. Everyone of those agents, police and maybe even Michigan had its own State investigators there when that plane landed, all of them had to know and be aware of the seriousness and the implications of the terrorist incident.
So Holder learns of it, and makes a decision “on his own?” I don’t believe it. And I think it is even more than just covering for someone, maybe covering for many….but in the end, as you say this must be a circumventing of the laws that are designed to protect the American people. Thus far, we are seeing a President and his Leftist administration acting as if they are “above the law.” It is worrisome that we have to wait until we win back at least one of the Houses in November to stop this deceit and harm to the American people.
Vassar, if you and I am sure others on our side recognize this, do our GOP leaders know it as well and are just biding their time, because they cannot do anything about it now? Lousy way to run a country…..
Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God. – Benjamin Franklin
When Good stands up to Evil, Evil blinks. – Vassar Bushmills
Conservative Education: Suggested Reading List
Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots
I wish I could answer that, Lady P
Vassar Bushmills (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 11:04AM EST (link)In Wsahington, if you can turn a criminal event into a political event, all bets are off as to how people will behave and what protocols they will follow. The deflection on this began very early, probably before the other key players even knew. It could only be that Holder knew he’d screwed up and then moved quickly to hide it. I can’t say, but if you’ll recall, the nature of this guy getting past Dutch and airline officials (having nothing to do with our TSA, which was turned upside down because of it)…and seemed to be the same idiot-savant as the shoe-bomber…almost as if the bomb was designed not to go off.
I can’t imagine an end game, it just doesn’t make sense.
But I am surprised Boehner’s side of the house isn’t kicking up a fuss (I expect the Senate side to be comliant.)
Actually, why I posted this was to kick up some dust, but my resaerch skills are not as good as others, and interestingly, a lot of the original film of the senate testimony is hard to find anymore.
vassar, here's a chronology I find more likely:
Achance (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 10:09AM EST (link)The flight crew notified their dispatcher who probably has a fixed procedure to notify someone in airline management. Somebody in airline management, probably a security head of some sort, has a protocol which would include notification of the FBI, FAA, maybe TSA and others. That notification to the FBI would be made higher than the SAIC/Detroit, probably to some airline threat clearinghouse number with immediate access to USDOJ in DC. That contact would be structured so that major players at the AG level would be pretty much immediately notified. So, I suspect Holder himself was notified within minutes of the event. I don’t know what access Comrade Obama’s secretaries or Holder personally have, but the way most governments work, Holder would either know how to get to the President directly or to the COS, Emmanuel. It is inconceivable that such a decision would be made without at least notifying the President. It could be that this kind of situation had been discussed and they had an agreed upon plan to treat any act of air piracy or attempted bombing as a criminal matter in all cases. Even if there was already an SOP, no competent, I chose that word carefully, government would tolerate a cabinet officer stepping into such a portentous situation without at minimum notifying the President before taking action, even if there was an SOP already in place.
There are a couple of other scenarios as to how the aircrew might have given notice but in this day and age no matter how that notice was given, it would have been sent to the top of the chain almost immediately. Because the plane was on approach at the time, the flight crew might have made contact directly with the Detroit tower, but that doesn’t seem likely because nobody has mentioned the FAA having a part in this. The flight crew might also have contacted their Detroit station agent, but any company the size of Delta would have an SOP requiring a station agent to contact airline management, but the station agent might have contacted Detroit local law enforcement. If that were the case, the Detroit SAIC might have been the first federal contact but the FBI is a supremely rule-bound organization so notice of the event would have gone screaming up the chain to Holder.
I’ve never been a federal cabinet officer trying to contact a President, but I’ve had to try to track down a cabinet officer and a governor on more than a few ocassions and an hour or so to work the chain would comport with my experience and it was about an hour or so before the determination was made.
In Vino Veritas
You may very well be right, Art...
Vassar Bushmills (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 11:08AM EST (link)…in which case I’m all wet.
No matter, but it would have been nice had those details been made public. The “viewing citizenry” as proven her at RedState, is no longer a dullwitted mob content with 20 seconds of sound bytes.
If someone had the interest, it should be easy
Achance (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 11:23AM EST (link)enough to find out. Once you get out of the airline’s people, everyone involved would be subject to a FOIA request or a request under MI or Detroit law.
I don’t think you’re all wet; the fundamental conclusion has to be that either somebody really screwed up, unlikely but possible, or the decisions were made at the very top. In my experience, saying “no” and bucking it up is the default position on EVERYTHING that might be controversial or involve more work. I think you said you’d worked in government so you know that by the time you reach mid-management, upward delegation is your worst enemy. Government is the one place where crap flows upstream. If that call came first to the local FBI, that SAIC’s career indicator light started flashing very brightly and he’d be looking real hard for somebody to take responsibility for the near take-down of a widebody over an American city.
In Vino Veritas
Interesting take, Art
Vassar Bushmills (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 12:11PM EST (link)I was last in government in 1971, and in the private sector, only at the top echelons,
I thought about FOIA but doubt you’d get what you suggested. The problem, still, is the chain of command was circumvented…which had to come from the top…but when my boss’s boss calls me and tell to me “jump”, i still gotta run it thru the boss. Remember, this was Christmas, no one was in the office.
All I want from this is that someone up on the hill ask some questions that weren’t asked the first go round.
These days, nobody in government can resist sending an email,
Achance (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 12:18PM EST (link)so it went flying up and down the chain by email probably. If somebody with a brain got hit with the email, they might have had the sense to start calling rather than emailing to reduce the record, but there’d still be a record of the call. So, an org chart and some phone and email records would tell a good story.
Even at Christmas the upper level people are reachable and the chain of command will function, if somewhat more slowly. I don’t think I ever got called on Christmas, but I once got called by the COS on New Years’ Day and told to catch the next plane to Anchorage. I mumbled a lot and then didn’t do it because I knew I wouldn’t be able to find anybody. I just caught the first plane the next morning and nobody knew the difference. Government rarely does anything that can’t be put off for awhile.
In Vino Veritas
But Vassar, however the decision was made, and I think...
penguin2 (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 12:28PM EST (link)they all knew (whoever was supposed to anyway) it was not in the best interests of the American people, IMHO. Of course, Holder, et al can claim decision made under the guise of his/their professional capacity, the one presumably Obama hired him, and we are paying him for. In the end, many more decisions like this, involving the weakening of America, where eventually a direct strike can hit the U.S. because of Obama’s policies, wishes and directions; will bring some kind of attention and grievance against these folks. At least I hope so; it will be a matter of which side remains standing when all is said and done.
Though they are standing now, we must continue to expose everything we can.
Yesterday I read and cannot find it just now, an article talking about the difference in how these characters are being defined, ie terrorist vs extremist – that is how the Obama administration is getting around full prosecution of these folks as true terrorists with intent to harm the United States.
Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God. – Benjamin Franklin
When Good stands up to Evil, Evil blinks. – Vassar Bushmills
Conservative Education: Suggested Reading List
Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots
Walking it back: only 21 Republicans voted against Holder
ColdWarrior (Diary) Friday, February 12th at 5:47PM EST (link)http://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/roll_call_vote_cfm.cfm?congress=111&session=1&vote=00032
Thank you.
ColdWarrior
No More Scozzafavas!
In 2012, will YOU become a “voting member” of the Republican Party in your precinct?
Where it all started. Twitter @kaltkrieger
Unified Patriots.
Learn how to GOTV at The Concord Project and at Procinct and
The first impulse at the lower levels of the FBI
Vegas_Rick (Diary) Friday, February 12th at 6:11PM EST (link)and most other law enforcement organization, when there is ANY potential for controversy, is CYA. I refuse to believe that these decisions were made at the field level. But, like VB, I would like some answers.
“God is great, beer is good and people are crazy.”- Billy Currington
“Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful people with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan ‘press on’ has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race.” Calvin Coolidge.