Bloggers Get Press Creds From NY Police Dept.


In a turn of events that should and will be used by bloggers all across the country, three news bloggers have prevailed over the New York City Police Dept. and received their press credentials despite being denied previously without explanation.

The New York Times City Room Blog reports that that Rafael Martínez Alequin, Ralph E. Smith and David Wallis filed a federal lawsuit when each of them were denied credentials, even though all of them had such credentials in the past.

In the face of the lawsuit, the NYPD changed their minds and issued the three their press cards, anyway. This move gives other bloggers across the country hope for legitimacy in the eyes of government officials.

“This step recognizes that bloggers are 21st-century journalists,” Mr. Siegel, a noted civil liberties lawyer who has announced plans to run for public advocate next year, said in a phone interview. “It’s an important first step, but only a first step, because we still need to address the constitutional problem of who gets press credentials in New York City. The Police Department should not be in the business of determining who’s a journalist.”

Bloggers should carefully cite this precedent and store it away for future reference.

Category: ,

RSS feed | Trackback URI

3 Comments Leave a comment

I can see a specific problem with this.

phxg Tuesday, January 13th at 3:00AM EST (link)

At what point does a blogger meet the level to be issued a press pass? 25,000 hits a day? 1MM?

Sure, someone representing RedState would, and should qualify, but what about Joe’s Hometown News? And is Joe’s News less relevant only because of its’ lack of traffic?

I know this is a can of worms, but if I open a blogger account tomorrow, I should not be immediately approved for press credentials.

It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. –Aristotle

I see no

Warner Todd Huston Tuesday, January 13th at 3:09AM EST (link)

I see no “problem,” but only a simple matter of specification. I agree that just anyone with a blog shouldn’t get a press cred, but the opposite extreme of NO ONE getting one is just as stupid.

Don’t you think that officials can come up with a sensible way to assign creds to on-line writers? I think they can.

The problem with the NYPD is that they tried to stop ALL Internet writers from getting creds. Clearly the wrong decision.

———-
Be sure and Visit my Home blog Publius’ Forum. It’s what’s happening NOW!

Clearly qualification is needed.

phxg Tuesday, January 13th at 12:24PM EST (link)

And to me, therein lies the problem. Who is going to make the determination of who is or isn;t qualified to receive the pass.

In 2006 a redstate blogger would have been laughed at for press credentials. 2009, the site is one if not the most influential single blog on the right. It would be unconscionable to deny that pass now. But really what’s the difference between then and now? Hits? Daily page views or contributors. Because in my history here it’s only about traffic, the content has been A+ from day 1.

Therefore, the qualification can only be based on traffic because if it were on content that would be a subjective approach.

And knowing city government IT types, they will not be “fair” (because RS is blocked here and DKos isn’t) if requested to provide information.

But I do agree, internet only writers should be allowed, heck it’s 2009 time to get out of the 19th Century NYPD.

It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. –Aristotle

 
 
 

Leave a Comment

 

Be respectful, or be banned. No Profanity.