So, what sort of hue and cry do you think would have been raised if President Bush had proposed that he develop an “art czar” like Obama is proposing? Do you think that the left would have eagerly agreed with the idea that a President Bush should be in control of art in America — at any level whatever?
No, high dudgeon would have been the likely outcome if Bush had proposed to invent the pseudo cabinet position of “art czar” answerable only to the executive branch. Once again Bush would have been excoriated by the left as stamping on people’s Constitutional rights of free expression. They would have lost their tiny little minds over the fact that government with a Republican at its head would be controlling art in any way at all. They would have been outraged anew over the audacity of the Bushhitler and apoplectic over his various evils.
And, at some level they’d have been right.
Not that Bush is a freedom quashing Hitler wannabe, but that the federal government has no business whatever having anything at all to do with the art world. Not funding it, not directing it, not planning it, not even promoting it.
Yet, here is how Artnet News greets the announcement that the Obammessiah is considering inventing an “art czar” out of whole cloth:
WHITE HOUSE OFFICE OF THE ARTS?
The transition team of President-elect Barack Obama is keeping a firm hand on any appointment news, but the buzz in art-and-politics precincts has the new administration seriously considering the idea of an official White House Office of the Arts, overseeing all things having to do with the arts and arts education. The new arts czar wouldn’t be a cabinet-level position — too complicated and too limiting, say insiders — but rather a liaison with the president with real access to funds and power. Who might fill the post, which would be a CEO kind of job? One possible candidate could be Agnes Gund, former president of the Museum of Modern Art and founder of Studio in a School.The idea of such a position has been floating around for some time. In its 2008 “10-Point Plan,” for instance, the U.S. Conference of Mayors suggested the establishment of a cabinet level secretary of culture and tourism. And though the Obama campaign didn’t specifically mention such a post, it was the first to have an in-depth arts platform (developed in consultation with Americans for the Arts), which actively painted the candidates as “champions of arts and culture,” urging the creation of an “artist corps” trained to work in low-income schools, among other projects. Stay tuned.
Stay tuned? Stay tuned is all they can say?
Where is the outrage that a president dares imagine that HE should be telling artists what to do with his little “art czar”? Where is the “artistic integrity” of these purported artists who so often wish to claim they are free of coercion or control by government and should remain so? Why is it that they don’t seem to mind The One taking control of their world of art?
Ah, but that is just it, isn’t it? These so-called artists really HAVE no principles. They love them some Obama and that is all they need to turn around and paradoxically cast their general disdain of government out the proverbial window. Of course, wait until the next Republican gets in office and see them suddenly remember that they want their freedom from oppressive government, eh?
But, for now, the silence from the “art” community is deafening.
And while we are at it, how about eliminating the unconstitutional funding that is PBS and the National Endowment for the Arts?

The WPA had the Artists Project.
Achance Wednesday, January 14th at 8:23AM EST (link)The government paid “artists” to do all kinds of stuff from the statuary around the Hoover Dam to government notices and, especially, WWII propaganda posters. There’s some outfit on the net that reproduces a lot of them and I had my office decorated with Artists Project posters dealing with labor and safety issues. Some of them are pretty cool if you’re into that School of Soviet Realism style.
Yep, we have seen the future and it works!
In Vino Veritas
I need $20,000,000
izoneguy Wednesday, January 14th at 8:49AM EST (link)for the BHO docu-drama:
“A man, a dream, a trainwreck”
“When the government fears the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny.”
Thomas Jefferson
I think
Warner Todd Huston Wednesday, January 14th at 9:14AM EST (link)I think Chris Matthews already got that grant. But he is calling his film “A Man, Some Cream, And a New Pair of Pants.”
———-
Be sure and Visit my Home blog Publius’ Forum. It’s what’s happening NOW!
My to Fathers
itdiehard Wednesday, January 14th at 9:19AM EST (link)Is Chris Matthews new movie title…
LOL, was that a tingle up my leg?
izoneguy Wednesday, January 14th at 10:58AM EST (link)n/t
“When the government fears the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny.”
Thomas Jefferson
Huh?
PD Wednesday, January 14th at 9:18AM EST (link)I’m not sure what the problem is. The point of this new position, assuming it’s more than a rumor, would not be to increase the federal role in the arts or to tell artists “what to do,” but to coordinate the involvement that the federal government already has in arts funding and sponsorship, and to give the federal role in the arts some increased visibility and official backing.
My Mother would have beat me if I'd put stuff on her walls
Achance Wednesday, January 14th at 9:29AM EST (link)like what passes for “art” in the federally funded arts programs. My state emulated the federal stupidity with a 1% for Art program for public facilities. We have warehouses full of that crap because nobody can stand to look at it and won’t have it on their walls.
In Vino Veritas
I want
Warner Todd Huston Wednesday, January 14th at 9:34AM EST (link)I want the federal government OUT of the arts in EVERY way.
———-
Be sure and Visit my Home blog Publius’ Forum. It’s what’s happening NOW!
Me too - especially
Praying Wednesday, January 14th at 2:58PM EST (link)the liberal propaganda outlets of NPR and PBS. I actually used to listen to that rot - thank goodness I grew up! How can they try to enact the “unfairness doctrine” when the government is PAYING for NPR and PBS? When will the American public finally wake up? Or are they all to busy watching “dancing with the stars” or some such rot?
Join the RedState Strike Force
I want
kat Wednesday, January 14th at 9:46AM EST (link)The government (BHO) to stop adding people to the federal payroll. Art Czar, Global Warming Czar, etc. All that says to me is spending more that we don’t have. I don’t even need to get into the next level about whether they should be involved in the arts or not.
“Democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not.” Thomas Jefferson
Join the RedState Strike Force
The world has already seen...
I use four letter words to describe women. Wednesday, January 14th at 10:41AM EST (link)what happens when a meglomaniac begins fiddling with “state-controlled” arts programs. Witness the art and architecture of Hitler’s Nazi Germany. Anything that deviated from the proscribed norm was deemed “decedant” and their creators were often jailed–or worse. How so many are now willing to step-aside and accept anything that “…comes from above” is beyond me. This country is rolling over and playing dead!
Government Art
Dan McLaughlin Wednesday, January 14th at 10:55AM EST (link)If that’s not an oxymoron, what is?
“No compromise with the main purpose, no peace till victory, no pact with unrepentant wrong.” - Winston Churchill
This sounds
Matthew Wednesday, January 14th at 6:30PM EST (link)This sounds like an Orwellian way of saying Ministry of Propaganda.