Do you want your government to know that you have bowel troubles? Do you mind if the president can discover if you have erectile disfunction? Would you be out of sorts if your local Congressman could discover if you’d had an abortion? How about if your state comptroller’s office or your governor could discover if you’d had breast implants? Well, a vote for Obamacare is a vote to give away your personal, private, maybe embarrassing medical information.
Do you think this is a silly claim? Well, don’t. In the newly released Obamacare plan, section 3102 titled “Financial Integrity” makes provision for state and federal governments to be able to investigate any medical care provider at any time. This provision gives government the right to look at any record that a doctor has in his files and that means your private medical information. Worse, they may do so without court approval, without a warrant, with no cause stated.
Patient’s United has created a searchable data base of what is in Obama’s “Health Care For All Americans” plan, if you’d like to take a look for yourself. But here is the section I described above: (Note: the term “gateway” as in the bill is defined as a state-created insurance plan, which in turn will control the doctors.)
Sec. 3102 Financial Integrity
“(1) In general - A State shall keep an accurate accounting of all activities, receipts, and expenditures of any Gateway operating in such State and shall annually submit to the Secretary a report concerning such accountings.
“(2) Investigations - The Secretary may investigate the affairs of a Gateway, may examine the properties and records of a Gateway, and may require periodical reports in relation to activities undertaken by a Gateway. A Gateway shall fully cooperate in any investigation conducted under this paragraph.
This is a downright authoritarian clause. Doctors will no longer be free of what is now defined as “illegal search and seizure” because with the passage of this bill **PRESTO-CHANGO** all requirements that government faces to get a warrant and go through the courts to stormtroop through a doctor’s office to seize records is magically eliminated.
Remember, with government involvement comes government interference and control.
So, next time you are with your doctor talking over some delicate medical condition that you would just rather not have everyone else know about, remember that you are telling every last member of the government the same embarrassing information whether you want to or not.
Now, when Ed Morrissey first wrote about the above facts, someone took Ed to task for having once agreed with the warrantless wiretapping of foreign terror suspects and posited that the Bush era program and this matter of government snooping into everyone’s medical information at will is pretty much the same thing.
But this lefty that chided Morrissey couldn’t be more wrong. In the first place a foreign terror suspect is not covered by the Constitution of the United States. In the second place, those wire taps didn’t target specific people, but only lighted on buzzwords that raised a red flag for investigation later. On the other hand, these medical records that the government has suddenly decided are its property is specific information about specific people. And specific people that are American citizens on top of it.
So, no, the situations are nothing at all similar.
In any case, a vote for Obamacare is a vote to give away our privacy to the federal and state government. To me that does not sound like a very good deal.

ACLU Silent?
maddog Monday, June 8th at 7:19AM EDT (link)It’ll be interesting to see what (if anything) the ACLU says about this. Maybe they’ll join our side on this for their once a decade quota.
My thought exactly
red4ever Monday, June 8th at 9:13AM EDT (link)I can see the “report” allowed under this to be then used by law enforcement. Which definitely would cause the ACLU to squawk about the Fourth Amendment.
Strange bedfellows. We’ll take all the help we can get to stop this travesty.
The hottest places in hell are reserved for those who, in times of great moral crisis, maintain their neutrality.
Dante
As I recall...
DamnCat Monday, June 8th at 7:40AM EDT (link)…unlike most other presidential candidates in recent history, Barack Obama refused to release his own medical records. Instead he put out a short statement from a doctor saying he was in good health. If it’s good enough for the president it’s good enough for me.
Kennedy - Dodd
tedpomeroy Monday, June 8th at 7:45AM EDT (link)Keith Hennessey at Keithhennessey.com
has a draft of the Senate Bill
Check it out, it is bad!
Those two together is never good
molybdanthan Monday, June 8th at 9:16AM EDT (link)They’ve got a sordid history of working side by side. Rumor has it there’s a restaurant in Georgetown where they had their way with an unfortunate young woman. People still refer to it as the ‘Kennedy room.’
And they used to freak out about Bush spying on people.
NeoKong Monday, June 8th at 8:27AM EDT (link)This will be ten times worse. Keep in mind also that the govt. controls some large banks and insurance companies too. That is a lot of financial and other data that they now have access to.
Does anyone remember how when Joe the plumber was becoming a nuisance to Barack Obama how all of his govt. records were laid bare to the press….?
Now that Obama is running two car companies as well just think of all the financial data bases that can be accessed. Credit scores, checking accounts, annual income and insurance data are all available to his auto task force.
The opinion of a wise whitino male.
here's a good link
molybdanthan Monday, June 8th at 8:28AM EDT (link)http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejECvUjIx1U
Watch from 7:25-9:30. It shows the near future of this Orwellian program.
FOIA
ElectGoldwater Monday, June 8th at 9:01AM EDT (link)Coupling this with the FOIA, would this mean anyone’s health information is open to the public?
This seems to be contradictory to Roe v Wade
suzieQ Monday, June 8th at 11:25AM EDT (link)Wasn’t that case based on a right to privacy law? Now that the government will know who is committing murder of the unborn, they have no excuse to let it continue.
“It’s finally happened: Abortion stopped a bleeding heart.”
- Ann Coulter, January 25, 2006
“My concern about the role of the federal government is that an intrusive government, a government that says, ‘Don’t worry, we will solve your problems’ is a government that tends to crowd compassion out of the marketplace, that too often in the past people said: ‘Somebody else will take care of the problem in my area. Don’t worry. The government is here.’”
- George W. Bush October 31, 2000
“Had the decision belonged to Senator Kerry, Saddam Hussein would still be in power today in Iraq. In fact, Saddam Hussein would almost certainly still be in control of Kuwait.”
- Dick Cheney
Left out of the embarrassment angle...
bart Monday, June 8th at 11:40AM EDT (link)is the blackmail angle. As in political opponent, married, being treated for STD’s they did’nt have before, etc.
So what are you saying?
Hi, I'm a fake. Ignore me. Monday, June 8th at 3:15PM EDT (link)Should be a simple fix to put some restrictions in the law without trashing the whole concept of health care reform altogether.
The original post is another example of how Republicans are falling behind by emphasizing negatives without coming up with positive solutions.
So many Americans right now know people who can’t get health insurance at all. Telling them to vote against health insurance by warning that the government might know if you’ve had breast implants isn’t a winning combination for November ‘10 or ‘12.
Check me out on HuffPo!
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/users/profile/JonBen
"think of women and children", boo-hoo...
DONTREADONME Monday, June 8th at 3:28PM EDT (link)I am sorry so many people are without health care, but I have rather good health care because I paid attention in that little thing we call school. There is no reason for me to give up my personal details for the benefit of giving someone else health care. Capitalism and life is a real bear and cry me a river, because there is one thing I know for sure and that is when the chips fall you’re on your won kid. It is called living not just surviving.
Man, it is bleeding hearts like yours that ruin the very things you claim to want to fix. Your stupid bleeding heart gives the enormous payouts when doctors and OBGYNs are sued, now you want me to pay for those without health insurance. Make up your mind, lawsuit payouts for malpractice with high cost of health care or low cost of health care and lower life expectancy and quality. Pick one, that is what you will get either way we try your ideas.
“The UN is right? you can’t be any more “un”; Than you are right now, the UN is undone, Another mushroom cloud, another smoking gun, The threat is real, the Locust King has come, Don’t tell me the truth; I don’t like what they’ve done, Just give me ammo for the United Abominations”-Megadeth