« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Engaging The Arena of Ideas

Taking Responsability for Ones Own Ideas

This is going to be short. I need to get ready for work.

Yesterday I made a post critical of the Republican Main Street Partnership and the moderates there whose own goals on their web site is to counter Conservatism. I also pointed out that some very prominent members of the Republican Party belong to this group. John McCain is one of them.

Now that the election is over, I want to engage in the conversation about who has better ideas. Should a Republican group whose stated goal is to attack and undermine other Republicans be driving the bus now?

This group is a group of avowed “moderate” Republicans. This is the group that runs moderate Republican candidates against safe seat Republicans in primaries, solely because they are conservative.

This group was launched in response to Newt Gingrich’s successful take over of the House of Representatives in 1994. How suicidal to their own party are they? They would rather fight other Republicans they don’t agree with, and reach across the isle in bipartisanship with Democrats.

Should the members of this group be challenged and told that the last two elections where they drove the bus off a cliff is enough?

I had one moderate Republican in this site take offense to this suggestion. I challenged him to explain why the moderates, who keep losing elections, be given additional chances to to repeat those results?

Big clarification: In no way am I advocating the removal of moderates from the party! However, as the election cycle spun up, and McCain won the nomination, we more conservative members of this site were told to get in line for the good of the party. A few people here even stated that rather harshly.

Now that the fruits of unity behind a moderate has produced its results. I ask the question, “shouldn’t those same moderates who told us to unite be just as noble to “unite” behind more conservative candidates for the sake of not losing elections anymore”?

Lastly, those moderates told us the key to winning is to “take the political center” in politics, just as John McCain did in this election. Is it time to shift the “center” to the right and let a candidate from that perspective lead.

Or, will moderates, as typified by this Republican Main Street Partnership be allowed to keep us in the wilderness?

Okay, convince me the center is the place to be in politics. Right now the center just happens to be in the center of the wilderness. Prove me wrong!

COMMENTS

  • kyle8

    IF YOU RUN A SOLID ARTICULATE CONSERVATIVE IN NATIONAL AND CONGRESSIONAL ELECTIONS IN THIS COUNTRY YOU USUALY WIN!

    And if you are a moderate republican you can only win in a few states.

    That is a certainty. All we have is our conservative ideas. IF we say we believe in all the same things the Democrats believe in, a managed economy, higher marginal taxes, no protection for the unborn, Then what exactly is the reason anyone would prefer us over the Democrats?

  • youthgrunt

    Certainly regarding party leadership. But is it really good that there are now literally no Republican House members from New England? Understanding that we probably cannot get a true “conservative” elected there, there is certainly room for “moderate” Republicans.

  • Wubbies_World

    I never once use such a term as “true conservative”. I did use the term “more conservative”. Please do not ascribe words to me that I did not use.

    You also totally ignored my “Big Clarification” where I expressly stated that the objective is not to drive out moderates.

    Please go back and actually read my post.