« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Barack Obama – the American Idol President

Another day, another poll.  On Wednesday, the latest CNN/Opinion Research poll was released, and to no one’s surprise, President Barack Obama’s approval numbers have declined.  His post-Osama bounce has become a dead terrorist bounce…and the POTUS is back where he was back in April.

But the thing that struck me in this poll, and in CNN’s summary story, was the coverage of Obama’s so-called “personal appeal”

According to the survey Obama’s strength remains his personal appeal: Three-quarters of all Americans say they approve of him personally, including a plurality of Republicans. But positive views of the president’s personality may be trumped by economic jitters.

Yeah.  Americans will probably, at some point, hopefully, become more interested in Obama’s actual accomplishments, rather than his personality and “cool.”  But I find it a bit odd that Obama is still considered appealing and likable, considering his recent descent into surliness. The WSJ’s Daniel Henninger noted this back in April:

In 2007-08, Obama’s high-toned, consistent persona was everything. What else was there? Barack Obama took a blank slate and wrote a masterpiece of a presidential campaign across it. From nothing, this fresh Obama persona defeated the familiar, experienced Hillary Clinton in the primaries. In the general election, he ran famously on “hope and change,” gave a stirring speech on race in America, and persuaded enough moderate and independent voters to turn 2008 into a “historic” American election.

Barack Obama had levitated himself above the usual, dispiriting muck of politics. This new person seemed to be precisely what a disgusted electorate wanted. Candidate Obama embedded that image in the American psyche. He built it. He fed it.

Now he’s deconstructing himself into another Obama. The latest Obama, which seems genuine, routinely ridicules and mocks his opposition. He mocks pretty much anyone who disagrees with him about anything.

As the CNN poll illustrates, Barack Obama, American Idol, has yet to completely lose his appeal.  His mocking and ridicule are generally aimed at Republicans, so Democrats continue to “like” him.

So how does this apply to American Idol?  There are two angles to this illustration.  From a world stage perspective, Obama is still idolized by Europe, despite fumbles such as his botched toast to the Queen of England.  Cal Thomas touched on his “idol” status last week.

Observing the start of Lord and Lady Obama’s (aka president and Michelle) grand European tour and the fawning press coverage, one might conclude they were imbued with royal blood.The normally reserved and thoughtful columnist for the London Times, William Rees-Mogg, gushed about the president’s speech before members of Parliament, comparing him to Winston Churchill. Obama is to Winston Churchill as Lady Gaga is to Ella Fitzgerald. Both are singers, but that’s where the comparison ends.

Daily Telegraph columnist Bryony Gordon claimed to have had a conversation with an unnamed Secret Service agent. She quoted the agent as saying about Michelle Obama, “She has this glamour that I haven’t seen before. She isn’t just a first lady. She is Hollywood.” Gush.

The second, more amusing “Idol” parallel is one noted over at “Bookworm Room” by diarist Don Quixote, who observantly pointed out the similarity between Presidential likeability and how American Idol contestant Pia Toscano was rejected by a popular vote, even though she was widely considered to be one of the top performers in the contest.  American Idol founding father Simon Cowell stated several years ago that the show was more of a popularity contest than a talent contest.  Sound familiar?

Thus has become the White House:  Obama is a fairly popular guy, even though his presidential talent is sorely lacking.  People keep punching the Like button for him, but they don’t seem to think he knows what he’s doing.  But hey, he’d probably be a cool dude to have a beer and shoot pool with.  I find it very odd that he can continue to elicit this kind of emotion, considering this item from the CNN poll story:

Forty-eight percent say that another Great Depression is likely to occur in the next year – the highest that figure has ever reached. The survey also indicates that just under half live in a household where someone has lost a job or are worried that unemployment may hit them in the near future. The poll was conducted starting Friday, when the Labor Department reported that the nation’s jobless rate edged up to 9.1 percent.

Almost half of Americans believe we’re about to enter another Great Depression, yet they think their President is a dandy guy.  Marvelous.

Too bad we can’t vote Obama out with a phone poll, like on TV’s American Idol.  Thankfully in November, 2012 we’ll have the ability to do it via a real poll…the only poll that actually counts.

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • charliesalmanack

    ….it would be wise for Republicans to concede the likability part when they describe Obama.

    Describing the President as a “likable liberal”, repeatedly, is a promising strategy.

    An example of how this line might be delivered:

    “I agree, the President is a very likable person. And he seems like a wonderful father and family man. That’s not the issue at all: he’s likeable. The issue is that he’s a likable liberal. And because he is liberal and he governs as a liberal, President Obama has put the intrusiveness of government into areas of the economy where it’s never been before and on a scale that we’ve never seen before. He’s done real damage to our economy and our country, at least some of which may be permament.”

  • jeffreywturner

    “Man that Obama sure is a swell guy. He gives me the warm and fuzzies, just like Jimmy Carter in his cardigan sweaters. As a matter of fact, this isn’t the only way in which he reminds me of Jimmy Carter. FILLINTHEBLANK…..”

  • chbroussard

    I would bet that the percentage is probably truly closer to somewhere in the mid-40% range for two reasons. One, that’s the percentage of Americans who don’t pay income tax or are on the govt. teat in some shape or fashion. Of course they like him. He’s doing everything in his power to keep the milk flowing. Second, there are still some that fear being called a racist because they don’t like him. So it’s in their comfort zone to say I don’t really like his policies, but he seems like a nice person.

    I wish they would have called me for that poll. I would have quickly told them I don’t like him badmouthing this country at every turn, I don’t like what he’s doing to the economy, I don’t like what he’s doing to our health care, and I don’t like that he wants to open our borders to every Tom, Dick, and Harry that comes across our borders illegally. How do you still like someone who is destroying your country? So do I like him personally? NO.

  • throwback59

    One, they tend to oversample democrat respondents.
    Two, people still worry that if they criticize Obama they can be labeled “racist.” After all, Obama’s supporters still use the race card to explain away his problems. Better to give him high marks on job approval, or at least say they like him personally then risk a knowing “tisk, tisk” from the pollster.
    I believe his real numbers, both job approval and personal, are far lower.

  • Bill S

    but I believe your point “two” is probably a big part of it.

  • spinoneone

    We don’t know the answer to that, but Real Clear Politics says, this morning, that 0′s approval rating is +2.3 percent. That is, 48.1 approve; 45.8 disapprove.

    So, is that enough to get him reelected? Maybe, and that is a bother!

  • Wubbies World

    I can’t help but wonder if Obama’s personal approval number isn’t a lingering “fear of being called a racist” if they say they do not like him personally. I can’t help but think it is still an element of “white guilt” being played out in the poll. It is the only logical thing that explains it in my opinion.

  • dianecee

    It is rather odd that more than half of the nation feels that obama is not an American, yet the polls say that a communist usurper is likeable. I find the man totally dislikeable and an enemy to the nation.

  • sundaycombo

    The poll illustrates something that is not talked about enough in politics. Most folks would assume voters choose their candidates on the basis of issues or ideology. Studies have shown that is often not true. In many cases the “I would like to hang out and have a beer with the guy (or gal)” is the voters deciding factor.

    Likability can be a real asset when things are not going well politically. Look at Anthony Weiner for example. Not particularly liked by many of his fellow Dems due to his abrasive personality they have been unhelpful this week as he became a page one story. The voters in his district (if you believe the polls) are lukewarm to his continuing in office. I believe if he had been more likable it would have given him more political breathing room.

    Unlike Hillary Clinton (who was “likable enough” according to Obama in 2008), the man we must beat in 2012 has a likability factor that you can mock or, be indignant about, Just don’t ignore it.

  • chriser

    It’s the “Bradley” effect. I think that these poll numbers are highly skewed because of people being hesitant to tell a pollster that they disapprove of the “historic” first black president. In 2008 a lot of people voted for him because he didn’t have a record and they could also assuage their racial guilt. In 2012 they may still have the guilt, but Obama also has a record (a very bad record). I still believe that most people vote in a rational manner and that will make it very hard for him to be re-elected despite what they the pollsters are hearing now. Perhaps I’m wrong – if so, then our country really is finished, but at least for the next year and a half I refuse to be a defeatist about it.

  • edintexas

    Of course I could be wrong, and the citizens are actually that stupid, but I doubt it. Add to that the reliability of a CNN poll. Well, the CNN polling will reliably trend Democrat.

  • Bill S

    I should have delved farther into that thought, as it has been dancing around in my brain for a while. As some of my RS colleagues noted, this measurement of “likeability” seems to have emerged during the Clinton years, where there was a notable disconnect between Bill’s personality and the nation’s economic situation (Clinton was a nationally-recognized scumbum, but the economy was zooming along, so no one really cared).

    The net of it is: voters vote for people, not policies.

  • eddiethegeek

    He’s dishonest and arrogant, and it’s hard for me to like anyone who displays those two qualities so unashamedly.

    A well-run GOP campaign will leave the electorate liking him less. A well-run campaign will focus on what he has done, what he has not, and on the content of his character.

  • avgjo

    The man is cold, he is arrogant, he is incompetent, his articulation comes out of a teleprompter; he is a hypocrite, his smile is creepily disingenuous and his tactics are thuggish. And yet 3/4 of the country finds such a man personally likeable?

    If, as some here say, people who claim this are doing so out of fear of being called racist, we have a large contingent of abject cowards in this country. (No matter how well or how bad the next 20 years turn out, I will always look at the period of Obama as a great period of cowardice and greed on the part of our ‘leaders’ both in and out of politics; consider how literally almost nobody stood up for the Chrysler bondholders, how gentle Republican criticism of Obama has been, how many companies folded to support Obamacare, GOP failure on King Amendment and Budget issues, etc. I fear that the same may be said of much of the rank-and-file in this country, as well.)

    And if people are just expressing a genuine sentiment, that is even worse. Then, Obama just reflects the people of this country. Of course, I know more than one great mind has asserted that the government of a place is a reflection of its people.

    Not good, any way you look at it.

  • harlan

    …was considered a swell guy by his “friends” also, until it finally became clear that he was a pathological liar and swindler.

  • msctex

    We live in a time where to find Obama personally — as a human entity — anything less than ideal is to admit a de facto racism.

    There are reasons an utterly unaccomplished, completely inappropriate individual was capable of being elected, and this is high if not chief among them.

  • jackhammer

    you could say all the same things about FDR. I never understood his appeal, and he did about evewrything that could be done wrong wron,g, and presided over the single longest decline in the american economy…..but apparently people loved him.

  • Tbone

    In that I don’t live at 1610 Pennsylvania Ave, having him as a neighbor would be doing a the Country and World a favor.

  • Next93

    You’re probably right. The right’s personalization of thier dislike for Obama has sometimes reached silly levels, almost reminiscent of BDS. It would probably be good strategy to try to paint him has a likeable but incompetent president.

    That being said, it’s 18 months to the election, and I don’t think I could control my gag reflex that long.

    First, there’s the fact that I find him personally repugnant. I look at him and see an arroagant, self-righteous jerk who’s never really accomplished anything other than his own self-promotion, but is nonetheless certain that the sun shines out of his butt. I haven’t been in a fist fight since junior high, but I’m farily certain that if I were to “sit down for beers” with him, the experience would end in a bar brawl of epic proportions (well, as epic as my lack of fighting skills and his well-publicized pectoral perfection would allow).

    But even putting my personal distaste aside, it’s just hard for me to reconcile “likeable guy” with “Guy who surrounds himself with thugs and terrorists, has systematically weakened my country in matters military, diplomatic, and economic, and views consitutional limits on his power as minor technicalities”. I’m not into conspiracy theories, but it’s getting harder and harder to look at the long-term damage he’s done and continues to do, and hang on to the beleif that he’s just misguided. To be honest, I’m starting to beleive that he’s intentionally and systematically destroying everything that I see as America.

    In light of that, I find it really, REALLY hard to refer to him as “likeable”.

  • johnt

    Why not, he’s so nice, he slanders people with such a kind touch, he invites them to speeches and insults them to their faces, how nice, he restricts energy production,raises prices, what a guy, he lies AM & PM, isn’t he sweet. It must be all the kindness and charity he experienced in the Rev Wrights church, wonderful.
    Well I guess CNN has to say something.
    Let’s all vote for him because he’s nice.

  • avgjo

    (A description I always took issue with; I always thought the Founding generation was the greatest, but I’m weird and none too bright, so I’m probably wrong.)

  • littlehouse18

    Painting him as the devil is a mistake, but if we kowtow to his supposed likeability, we only hurt ourselves. Why mention it at all, the facts of his actions speak for themselves.

    The more this ‘he’s a likeable guy’ theme gets passed around, the more people believe it and will cut him slack. As many here have said, there’s nothing likeable about either his demeanor or actions.

  • etpietro

    ….this President is abrasive, arrogant, thin-skinned, petulant and whiny.

    What’s not to love?

    OK, I will grant that he is a good-looking dude (if a bit scrawny) and he’s got a good sense of humor, but those things are far outweighed by his unpleasant personality characteristics.

    I think those who have noted “fear of being called a racist” have it pretty much on the money.

  • jackhammer

    but I do take my hat off to the Generation that fought in WW2. They ended a long period of American Isolationism to fight in a war that could really only effect them at the periphery, fought on two fronts bravely and adeptly, and came back and just worked hard as hell, without moaning and whining a lot. They started and built companies that have become world beaters, they took America from a good country to the greatest country, and the envy of the world. Not sure if they were the “greatest”, but what the individuals did (not the government) was pretty damned impressive.

  • obxster

    Saying Obama is an American Idol is like saying Hilter was a Hero of the Jews. If anyone watches American Idol it is not always the best singer that wins but it is always one of the more likable contestants who displays humility, morals and overall just a nice person. In other words the American Idol winner appears more conservative than liberal. Pia Toscano may have been the best singer but didn’t appear to be the best person. She seemed self centered and also seemed that see felt she was “entitled” to be a winner. Reports of her dating some star while in Hollywood and not telling her boyfriend who stood by her for many years was appalling.

    The liberals always have a cow because their favorite on American Idol is not chosen.

  • gunslingr45

    ?She has this glamour that I haven?t seen before. She isn?t just a first lady. She is Hollywood.? Gush

    You would have to put the SS guy in front of me and get him to repeat it. Sorry, can’t buy this one.

    Overheard on the internet:
    Obama?s popularity is falling so fast that Kenyans are now claiming Obama was born in the United States.

  • ag8tor

    arrogant, obnoxious, egotistical, disregard for the Constitution and apologizing for America become “Cool”? Proves my long time point that Americans will buy anything from anybody. They bought this “Hope & Change” nonsense in 2008. That turned out to be “Marxism & Socialism” instead. So now since the majority of Americans supposedly think this “Community Organizer” from the land of “Chicago politics” is still “Cool” after the hole he has driven us into, they will vote for him again? Hope they enjoy their Change since that’s all the money they’ll have left after this loser gets through raiding the treasury. We need to continue the wake up call to the sleeping masses or this depression we expect will bring us down and we will become just what Barry wants, another Venzuela!

  • treasuregem

    I’ve never liked him from the first. He just seemed….so smooth, too friendly…I recognize a smoozer when I hear/see one (my term for anyone who uses charm to lie, cheat, steal…like a lot of old car salesmen used to be. Too good to believe, so beware!) He just smiled too much, but his eyes always held that glint of content. It still shows if you know how to read people. He genuinely HATES America and Americans, and all his actions thus far have shown it. Likability? I believe scripture says Satan was a beautiful angel…..

  • joanb36

    One could change names with Madoff and describe the president and way too many in congress or the president’s staff.

    On excuses for Weiner? Try ” politician arrogance” and just plain evil & no morals. Not sick or mistreated as a child. He’s a politician who he thinks is above all. If his wife backs him, what’s wrong with her? He was ALWAYS arrogant and disrespectful when interviewed by conservatives.
    It’s a great day when these losers implode & fall in their own hole.

  • joanb36

    incompetent as president. Community organizer, President of the greatest country ever? NOT! If people look passed his” Hollywooditis” and actually see what has been stolen or lost or wrecked in the last two years, not to mention the path that he is leading us to, what’s to vote for? As we speak, Hillary is giving our 2nd amendment rights to the UN!!!!! Another 4 years of this mess, we’ll not recognize this country and your children will have no future as free Americans. There will be no incentive to create, work hard or dream! Pathetic, no hope.

  • groverc

    First of all, on a personal level, I can’t stand the guy. His look and attitude are an amalgamation of stupidity and haughtiness — which puts him just about a notch above the level of the grotesque. “He seems” like a wonderful husband and father — well, yes, I’ve seen that written over the last 50 years about a few hundred Hollywood stars and DC politicians who turned out to be crumbs (you can find John Edwards in there somewhere, I’m sure).

    But the semi-popularity of the guy as President is definitely real, “seemingly” unbudgable, and, so, extremely discouraging. This is such a disastrous Presidency at this point, to see Obama at 50 percent overall approval and under 10% “strongly disapprove” over “strongly approve” in the Rasmussen Poll, as he was yesterday, suggests that nothing is going to absolutely ruin this guy’s chances for reelection.

    Okay, today he had a bit of a plunge, 47 overall and -15, but he’s recovered from blips quickly before. He has never had an extended period below 45 percent overall approval in Rasmussen in his entire presidency.

    45 percent! The man has an incoherent and deadly foreign policy, a disastrous string of economic “initiatives,” and trampled anew on the Constitution on a near weekly basis.

    If this isn’t a 25% approval President — i.e. suitable only to ultra leftists (who deplore prosperity and will swing any politically partisan way the wind blows regarding foreign war interventions) — than I can’t imagine what could be. There must be some surface less stickable than Teflon to categorize this guy’s mesmerizing of the electorate.

  • treasuregem

    now THAT IS funny!

  • westcoastpatriette

    seem to be in a stupor and that is the most frightening part of all of this. I truly believe many people know something is really amiss in America but are just too uninformed and ignorant of how our republic is designed to function to fully grasp what an abomination Obama is.

    The rise of the Tea Party is our main hope as these are the Americans who are rapidly educating themselves as they do see Obama as the threat he represents. We must educate America so they understand why we must return to the Constitutional principles of federalism that make this country great. It must be done –in a matter-of-fact way–as the election approaches to peel back the veneer and expose Obama for the phony that he is. If done in an inspiring and factual manner I think enough people still love America enough to listen.

  • avgjo

    that they weren’t great. They were awesome. But without the founding generation you and I would be fellow subjects. Of course, by the end of all this, we may be anyway.

  • http://www.tinfoilhelicopter.com lunaticrex

    That is a great comment. May I employ it with the (very few) liberals I know?