RS
FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR
To grab or not to grab … guns? That is the question.
This morning a friend sent me an article about the Sikh Temple murders in Oak Creek, Wisconsin. The article describes how the president of the temple attempted to fight back against the murderer – with a butter knife.
On Sunday, he died standing up to the horror of a gunman’s attack on his house of worship in the Milwaukee suburb of Oak Creek. Kaleka, 65, managed to find a simple butter knife in the temple and tried to stab the shooter before being shot twice near the hip or upper leg, his son said Monday.
Of course a butter knife is probably not going to do much against a 9mm semi-automatic. But Kaleka did fight back heroically in the only way he knew of at the time. My friend’s comment indicated that this incident demonstrated the fallacy of gun control, implying that gun control means that victims only have rudimentary weapons (like butter knives) at their disposal in a situation where a concealed handgun could well have stopped the murderer. This, of course is the argument that “Gun Nuts” – Second Amendment & concealed carry supporters – often make in these situations…more guns in the pockets of law-abiding citizens will be a deterrent and would give the ability to cut such episodes short.
The opposite argument comes from the “Gun Grabbers” – “If guns were outlawed, this kind of incident would never happen”. When posed with the sticky problem of the Second Amendment, their response is “The Founders never imagined that such deadly weapons would be available to commit these heinous crimes”. Really?
In the 1776 timeframe, the musket was a far deadlier weapon than the bow & arrow, spear or the other weapons that were common with the Native American population. Surely they had this in mind when they wrote the amendment, say the Grabbers. But what of the revolver or the repeating rifle? They were the 1800s’ equivalents of the musket – much more lethal than the single-shot smooth-bore, muzzle-loaded musket. Many bad guys AND good guys fell dead at the hands of a Navy Colt. What about the Thompson submachine gun that was popular during Prohibition? The Tommy Gun was illegal, yet the mobsters of the early 20th century had little difficulty obtaining them and using them in crimes around the nation. Yet the Second Amendment and private citizen gun ownership has survived these times.
But, “militia!”, says the Gun Grabbers. The Second Amendment speaks of a militia – an army. We don’t have militias, therefore we don’t need to own firearms, they say. But the Founders understood this.
“I ask, Sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them.”
George Mason
Co-author of the Second Amendment
during Virginia’s Convention to Ratify the Constitution, 1788“And that the said Constitution be never construed to authorize Congress to infringe the just liberty of the Press, or the rights of Conscience; or to prevent the people of the United States, who are peaceable citizens, from keeping their own arms; …”
Samuel Adams
quoted in the Philadelphia Independent Gazetteer, August 20, 1789, “Propositions submitted to the Convention of this State”“Firearms stand next in importance to the constitution itself. They are the American people’s liberty teeth and keystone under independence … from the hour the Pilgrims landed to the present day, events, occurences and tendencies prove that to ensure peace security and happiness, the rifle and pistol are equally indispensable … the very atmosphere of firearms anywhere restrains evil interference — they deserve a place of honor with all that’s good.”
George Washington
First President of the United States“To preserve liberty, it is essential that the whole body of the people always possess arms and be taught alike, especially when young, how to use them.”
Richard Henry Lee
American Statesman, 1788
Et cetera.
My intent here, however, is not to defend either position…which is why I used somewhat crude names for both sides of the argument. I bring up this point because every single time an incident such as the Aurora, CO or Oak Creek shootings occur, these debates rear their ugly heads again…usually within seconds of the shootings (search Twitter for #templeshooting if you doubt this…).
Support for gun control has waned since a peak in the 1998 timeframe. In fact, last year Pew reported that the % of Americans who support gun control is virtually the same as the % who support gun ownership rights. And polls run shortly after the Aurora, CO movie theater massacre show no change in attitude on gun control. And the debate rages.
Does it matter?
John Wayne Gacy did not shoot his victims. Timothy McVey killed his victims with fertilizer. The 9/11 terrorists used knives and airplanes filled with jet fuel. Cain murdered Abel without a gun.
Christian theology teaches that original sin was introduced to the world by the Fall in the Garden of Eden. Death was introduced at that point, and it will be with us until Jesus returns (and let’s not get into eschatology, please…) As long as there are fallen people, there will be sin, violence, death… and murder. People will find ways – some that are unimaginable – to kill other people.
Do automatic weapons make murder easier? Sometimes, yes…but there are much more efficient ways to commit mass murder than using a machine gun. Do concealed carry laws save lives and avoid murders? In some situations, yes…in some, no. Would Satwant Singh Kaleka still be alive if he had had a Glock? Maybe. If *I* had a handgun, I’m not sure *I* could bring myself to pull the trigger. Who can know unless they’re in that situation?
The argument about gun control will never be won. Ever. It’s been going on ever since there were guns and a Second Amendment, and it’s not likely to change any time soon. Both sides will speculate about the impact of reduced numbers of guns on the street and the impact of concealed weapons in more citizens’ pockets.
And there will still be murders, with guns or without. AK-47s or muskets or switchblades or perhaps even butter knives.
Until the End.

![[RS]](/t/img/logo-footer.jpg)
Pingback: gsdfghsdkflhgksdfl
Pingback: look
Pingback: wholesale nike air jordans
Pingback: homepage
Pingback: Watch Prometheus
Pingback: Magnetic Tags Remover
Pingback: http://www.immaginario.tv/lamorealtempodellacrisi/storie/manuela-massari/
Pingback: sexy lady
Pingback: Better sex
Pingback: Extreme weight loss diet
Pingback: jak szybko schudnac
Pingback: best appetite suppressant
Pingback: Make money online
Pingback: diablo 3 gold
Pingback: How to fight
Pingback: about yoga
Pingback: Tax
Pingback: Primerica Scam
Pingback: jewelry
Pingback: Marketing Digital
Pingback: moncler veste cheapest
Pingback: tile denver
Pingback: cheap viagra
Pingback: spar 60% p� m�rke solbriller
Pingback: make money fast online
Pingback: spinning text
Pingback: Mini Guitar
Pingback: Download Microsoft Office 2010
Pingback: Nikon 1 V2
Pingback: Chilli Seeds
Pingback: Fusevision.com.sg seo google
Pingback: How To Make Youtube Videos
Pingback: lake erie
Pingback: videocamere
Pingback: a fantastic read
Pingback: Extreme weight loss diet
Pingback: learn more
Pingback: learn more
Pingback: uslugi remontowo budowlane
Pingback: replica handbags purses
Pingback: lint trap
Pingback: Click This Link
Pingback: KSL Squaw
Pingback: Get More Info
Pingback: free online classifieds list
Pingback: circuit training
Pingback: software toko program kasir terbaik
Pingback: nikon d7000
Pingback: leappad 2
Pingback: rank site SEO
Pingback: Lainaa
Pingback: xenical
Pingback: swissdent
Pingback: Make money Youtube video
Pingback: This Site
Pingback: Alexis Fyler
Pingback: Find Out More
Pingback: pond5 promo codes discounts
Pingback: sushi delivery Somerville ma
Pingback: acheter louboutin
Pingback: seofabrik
Pingback: stables
Pingback: online personalization
Pingback: property in dubai
Pingback: website designer
Pingback: alternatives to steroids
Pingback: buy synthol
Pingback: Website
Pingback: spybubble free
Pingback: click this
Pingback: he has a good point
Pingback: best supplements for muscle gain
Pingback: best legal steroids
Pingback: web design barrow
Pingback: services transportation
Pingback: Classified Cars
Pingback: hp adapter
Pingback: Lower Abdominal Pain
Pingback: out of body lucid experience
Pingback: free chat
Pingback: rv warranty
Pingback: astral projection scientific evidence
Pingback: check my website
Pingback: gutters tampa fl
Pingback: dr oz green coffee bean extracts
Pingback: Indianapolis Indiana homes for sale
Pingback: spanner
Pingback: rv warranty
Pingback: escorts leeds.
Pingback: escorts leeds.
Pingback: Suggested Site
Pingback: Look At This
Pingback: steam showers
Pingback: los angeles publicists
Pingback: los angeles publicists
Pingback: people search,
Pingback: people search
Pingback: people search
Pingback: Tycoon World war Warcraft Gold Addon Review
Pingback: Tycoon World war Warcraft Gold Addon Review
Pingback: Best Credit Repair
Pingback: swissdent
Pingback: hp battery
Pingback: como aumentar masa muscular
Pingback: jeux,
Pingback: jeuxjeux
Pingback: junk car milwaukee
Pingback: PPI Claims
Pingback: PPI Claims
Pingback: PPI Claims
Pingback: click this
Pingback: redtube
Pingback: american mortgage help
Pingback: tartamudez tratamiento psicologico
Pingback: American Music Awards
Pingback: PPI Claim
Pingback: PPI Claims
Pingback: Fuck you
Pingback: velkoborsky
Pingback: velkoborsky.
Pingback: velkoborsky
Pingback: Nikon v2
Pingback: sushi delivery Somerville ma
Pingback: Make Money Youtube
Pingback: garage doors melbourne
Pingback: garage doors perth
Pingback: garage doors perth.
Pingback: gryphon garage doors
Pingback: gryphon garage doors.
Pingback: NHL schedule
Pingback: gryphon garage doors
Pingback: gryphon garage doors.
Pingback: the stables towneley park
Pingback: the stables towneley park,
Pingback: the stables towneley park,
Pingback: casino
Pingback: haccp zachodniopomorskie
Pingback: lecteur datamatrix
Pingback: amarillo tree
Pingback: verificagru
Pingback: amarillo tree
Pingback: amarillo tree.
Pingback: amarillo tree
Pingback: amarillo tree.
Pingback: breaking events
Pingback: viagra
Pingback: ipage affiliate
Pingback: porn
Pingback: Rottweiler
Pingback: air quality testing
Pingback: abc blinds
Pingback: ipage customer reviews
Pingback: Dumpster Rentals
Pingback: mls inmobiliarias
Pingback: "?????"
Pingback: Dumpster
Pingback: this youtube channel
Pingback: banque Bordier
Pingback: logo quiz
Pingback: samsung galaxy s3
Pingback: land of nod
Pingback: target baby registry list
Pingback: junk car towing milwaukee
Pingback: Ramona Kuhry
Pingback: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wVXfRT84C9g
Pingback: network marketing
Pingback: pirater facebook
Pingback: pirater facebook
Pingback: Cecil Weisheit
Pingback: pc dial.
Pingback: pc dial
Pingback: chaise eames
Pingback: hair loss products
Pingback: texas driver education
Pingback: Marketing a Medical Practice
Pingback: #Party Animal
Pingback: Bügelperlen Vorlagen
Pingback: zynga poker chips
Pingback: http://ldlhdlcholesterollevels.org
Pingback: natural depersonalization treatment
Pingback: natural depersonalization treatment
Pingback: travel
Pingback: Marketing a Medical Practice
Pingback: website logo design
Pingback: snel afvallen
Pingback: my latest blog post
Pingback: salsa
Pingback: annacredits.wordpress.com