« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

So This is It?

This is what we get from a new House Republican majority?

Call me naive, but from the onset of this legislative session I really expected we would witness some transformational change in the way Washington does business.  That was obviously a foolish expectation.

GOP leaders agreed last night to pass the omnibus bill with largely the same provisions as the one they introduced yesterday.  After all of the bravado and grandstanding throughout the year; after cutting a mere $352 million in non-baseline spending in FY 2011, they are prepared to cut nothing off the 2012 budget.  In fact, with the $8.6 billion in extra disaster spending, the total discretionary budget authority will surpass last year’s levels by roughly $3 billion.  Yes, we know that there are spending offsets, but they were cleverly packaged in a separate bill from the rest of the omnibus, allowing Democrats to vote them down.

What about the riders?  Democrats are bragging about the fact that they jettisoned all the major policy riders except for the block on light bulb bans.  We now have a 1200-page bill that encompasses funding for most of the federal government, yet it cannot be amended.  That leaves one option for conservatives: vote no on the entire package.

Hey, I guess we can take solace in the fact that we slowed baseline spending from what it would have been had Democrats retained control of Congress.  Then again, all these numbers only account for discretionary spending, or about one-third of the federal budget.  The other two-thirds, mandatory and entitlement spending, continues to grow out of control.

And speaking of mandatory spending, what are we getting in return for agreeing to defacto permanent super-long-term unemployment benefits?

At this point, we are looking at another short-term extension of UI benefits, along with Medicare doc fix and the payroll tax cut.  They are looking at a deal to extend it for another two months….and then have the same discussion again.  Republicans will never block the permanent extension, and will only achieve notional cuts over 10 years to fill in the gaping hole in the budget.  If we don’t push for the Keystone pipeline, UI reforms, and cuts in the federal workforce now, we will never get them in two months.

I could just hear the echo chamber now; “yes, but we only control one-half of…..”  Actually, in recent months, Republicans have eschewed that excuse in favor of a more political argument.  They are simply too scared to stand for unfettered free-market policies.  They are scared to death of electoral reprisal.  Period.

Well, I have news for you.  The road will not get any easier from here.  If Republicans are scared of being blamed for political fallout when they only control one branch of government, will they be less tepid if and when they control all branches of government?

And one more thing.  If Republicans can’t preempt the creation of a fourth permanent entitlement, is there any way they will have the moxie to push even for Paul Ryan’s watered-down Medicare reform plan (which was watered down from the original free-market voucher plan in the Roadmap)?

Then again, this is all a game to these people.  It’s the red team versus the blue team.  Forget about the purpose of the team.

Call your Republican members of Congress and implore them not to cave on the omnibus, Keystone pipeline, and reforms of Unemployment Insurance.

COMMENTS

  • bjames

    The one school of thought of forcing shutdowns and risking even your minority leverage in the political fallout vs. the other school of thought of getting what you can, build your majorities and pushing further at that time. The problem is, both never really work and spending always increases until we eventually go belly-up.

  • http://www.planettron.com NickDeringer

    We have a crisis managment team. They will keep kicking the can down the road until we run out of road.

    • http://edgeinducedcohesion.wordpress.com nathanalbright

      No one wants to face the inevitable so they’re rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic knowing the icebergs ahead.

  • swi2522

    the politicians in washington know it so why make any changed keep spiending until the line of credit is revoked

    throw them all out.
    problem is with the military funding bill they may make speech like this grounds to identify a person as a terrorist and lock them up

    i am thinking all the rinos and dems in washington like socialism as our new form of government

  • jimmyneutron

    Here we sit – our country and hence our future facing economic ruin and stagnation and this is what we get?!? I am so unhappy with the Republican leadership. I understand that politics are involved with decisions that have to be made, but I also understand that you have to stand by your principles and, especially in situations like this, you have to fight for what is right. You have to have a plan to get from here to a better future and that plan is not to simply go along and get along in the fear that you won’t get reelected!
    What good will it do for the current crop of R’s to get reelected if they get reelected by continuing to promise the voters the same old same old unsustainable and unrealistic promises of lots and lots of goodies – all free? Better to go down fighting and speaking the truth than to be culpable along with progressives and statists for the stagnation and economic ruin that is coming.
    I work with many smart people and very few of them have any clue as to what is to come – they all think that the economy is going to turn around any day and that things aren’t really that bad. Lets increase funding for education and lets give free medical care to all because anything else would be mean or cruel – they say this with no idea that there is no money left! The conservatives have to speak to this mindset – they simply have to be the adults telling people that the money is gone and that we have to do some drastic cutting soon or the drastic cutting will be done in the most painful manner possible.

    My philosophy is that we fight for principles that will save this nation and do our best to educate the public in sound economic and political ideas while accepting the fact that they may vote us out of office. I can live with that because I do not want to be at the helm of the Titanic, sailing into iceberg after iceberg, just happy to be in charge no matter what.

    This idea that we can’t possibly fight now because we don’t have the power (ie 1/2 of 1/3 of blah, blah, blah) is not new – it has been around forever. Patrick Henry spoke to it best around 250 years ago:

    ‘… They tell us, sir, that we are weak; unable to cope with so
    formidable an adversary. But when shall we be stronger? Will it be
    the next week, or the next year? Will it be when we are totally disarmed, and when a British guard shall be stationed in every
    house? Shall we gather strength by irresolution and inaction? Shall we acquire the means of effectual resistance, by lying supinely on our backs, and hugging the delusive phantom of hope, until our enemies shall have bound us hand and foot? Sir, we are not weak if we make a proper use of those means which the God of nature hath placed in our power. Three millions of people, armed in the holy cause of liberty, and in such a country as that which we possess, are
    invincible by any force which our enemy can send against us. Besides, sir, we shall not fight our battles alone. There is a just God who presides over the destinies of nations; and who will raise up friends to fight our battles for us. The battle, sir, is not to the strong alone; it is to the vigilant, the active, the brave. Besides, sir, we have no election. If we were base enough to desire it, it is now too late to retire from the contest. There is no retreat but in submission and
    slavery! Our chains are forged! Their clanking may be heard on the plains of Boston! The war is inevitable and let it come! I repeat it, sir, let it come.

    It is in vain, sir, to extenuate the matter. Gentlemen may cry, Peace,
    Peace but there is no peace. The war is actually begun! The next gale that sweeps from the north will bring to our ears the clash of resounding arms! Our brethren are already in the field! Why stand we here idle? What is it that gentlemen wish? What would they have? Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course
    others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death!’

    • YnotNOW

      Patrick Henry really knew how to arouse the populace. Would that we had the leadership to boldly state what we need to hear, and awaken the citizens from our slumber!

  • eddiethegeek

    I have informed my Congresswoman that unless she repudiates the GOP leadership, Speaker Boehner in particular, I will not and can not help her in 2012.

    If there is no difference between a GOP House and a Pelosi Democrat House, then why bother expending my time and treasure???

    I am thoroughly dismayed and have come to believe that our nation is doomed. I cannot envision a leader rising up to courageously deal with this nation’s problems – not in the Senate (McConnell?? HAH!), not in the House (Boehner?? completely neutered), and not in the White House (none of the current crop is worth a damn).

    We are so, how shall I say it, F… oh shoot No Profanity

    • inovrmihd

      eom

  • eddiethegeek

    I have informed my Congresswoman that unless she repudiates the GOP leadership, Speaker Boehner in particular, I will not and can not help her in 2012.

    If there is no difference between a GOP House and a Pelosi Democrat House, then why bother expending my time and treasure???

    I am thoroughly dismayed and have come to believe that our nation is doomed. I cannot envision a leader rising up to courageously deal with this nation’s problems – not in the Senate (McConnell?? HAH!), not in the House (Boehner?? completely neutered), and not in the White House (none of the current crop is worth a damn).

    We are so, how shall I say it, F… oh shoot No Profanity

  • Emissary74

    If it’s one thing that gets me about Michele, it’s her constant preening about “being in the fight.” Does anyone know if she even bothered to show up for this debate in Congress? Methinks the country would have been much better served with her these last few months in Congress rather than running around campaigning.

    • Lucas Black

      Michelle Bachmann is about as effective as a moth slamming up against a light bulb. Honestly, the more I am exposed to her, the less I like her.

    • virginiahiker

      Having watched Michele Bachman in action as a hill staffer, I can guarantee the only time she leads anything is when there are cameras present. She will always choose to rouse the crowd on the West Lawn of the Capital rather than do the hard work in committee or legislative drafting sessions. She can be counted on to appear for every press conference and miss every strategy meeting. She will conduct countless telephone interviews while never returning calls during whip checks. Her idea of leadership is to look for the parade, run to the front, grab the baton from the real drum major and preen in the spotlight. The fact that anyone takes her seriously as a presidential candidate is proof positive of the intellectual depths to which far right conservatism has fallen.

    • writescribe

      The only thing she uses her public office for is to promote her self-interests, whether they be financial or publicity-related. She probably reads just enough lines to parrot what conservatives want to hear, and the rest of the time is devoted to thinking of ways to get attention. Truly useless.

  • eddiethegeek

    “We are going to DEFUND Obamacare!” so they proudly proclaimed before the 2010 elections.

    Speaker Boehner absolutely needed to grow a pair. It is quite clear that if the GOP should somehow retain its House majority, then Boehner needs to go. He is the problem, not the solution.

  • johnt

    A new bridge here, a road construction with the congressman’s name all over it, photo ops, bragging about education spending, always a sure winner with the morons. Yes, they do learn fast don’t they? And they always have the gentle hand of Boehner and other old hands to guie them, to help them see the light.
    You see, the idea is to take over both Houses and then they get tp play with the uncounted $billions$, so why cut?

    • writescribe

      representatives betrayed their followers…so what else is new? They are politicians. Politicians care about two things – currying favor and consolidating influence. The fact that Tea Party followers are shocked and dismayed by this is mind-boggling. I don’t know why they thought they were immune to corruption.

  • rickdeckard

    as another group of enthusiastic Republican base voters sat down?
    Sounds like Boehner was much happier as Minority Leader and is working tirelessly to get the title back.

    What a difference 12 months makes.

  • Kyle-MI

    It is not clear from your post and I would think that caving on Keystone would be creating a lot more noise.

    • http://redmeatconservative.blogspot.com/ Daniel Horowitz

      The omnibus cave is sealed and final.

      The keystone pipeline is part of the “extenders package”. As it stands now, they are looking at a two month temporary extension of the tax cut, UI, and doc fix. If that temporary deal would go through it would more or less be a clean extension, and would therefore, jettison all the reforms, including the pipeline, They would be kicked down the road until February or March. It is doubtful there would be any more progress then.

      • Kyle-MI

        NT

  • craigbardo

    Ya. been had, ya been took, ya been bamboozled, led astray, run amok, ya been hoodwinked!

    Not much of a Beck fan, in fact I hate when he does his both parties spiel – but boy does it apply here!

    The fix is in, we just didn’t know.

  • dave2131

    This is my problem with the GOP, they have no spine, no guts, no balls…All they are good for is slowing down the failure of the USA.

    The GOP is full of “electable” Moderates. There are only but a few of the true, limited Government conservatives around. We are foolish to think they will actually change the game at all. The GOP is pathetic garbage which is not much better than their Democratic foes.

    And we think Newt or Mitt will do anything different? They are both cut from the same cloth.

    They rode the Tea Party wave, but in the end, it is business as usual. Boehner must go.

  • tailfins1959

    While Hannity says “Let not your heart be troubled” and Limbaugh says “be of good cheer” most of the rest of the politically engaged are just like Alan Grayson, even on the right. We don’t have good elected officials and we have a weak GOP field because we have a shallow pool of decent people to draw from. After seeing the venom in the blogosphere, including here, I sometimes think our nation is beyond repair. The Amish may be on to something in their belief that modernity corrupts. Venom is not progress.

    I ask the posters here, especially the “moderators”, are you presenting yourself like Sean Hannity or like Alan Grayson? The public is watching. Your actions affect the level of interest in the conservative movement.

  • jasondallastx

    to get the money out of Washington. They’ll never defund Obamacare. The insurance lobby will make a killing off of that bill. think about it – suddenly millions of americans who don’t have insurance are suddenly forced to get it (and it will be subsidized I’m sure by the govt), so insurance companies will make bank.

    Look up who gets political contributions from the insurance industry – it’s everybody. So, they may bluster about repealing it, but secretly they love it. Just means more money in all of their pockets.

  • http://undo4me.com WmCraig

    Open season is coming. We sent a Republican majority to congress because we wanted to stop the out of control spending. We wanted to undo the power the Obama administration usurped.

    What we got was legacy Republicans stealing from our future under the guise of cooperation. Legacy Republicans are no different than Democrats. They are nothing more then the “Washington Generals” to the Democrat’s “Globe Trotter’s” team.

    Instead of reduced spending, removing funding from over zealous government agencies and changing direction of the growth of Washington powers we got a bunch of kids yelling “I want MY turn to drive”.

    Time to take the keys from everyone in Washington, or we will never get thing out of this ditch!

  • dmartin

    “I could just hear the echo chamber now; ?yes, but we only control one-half of?..? Actually, in recent months, Republicans have eschewed that excuse in favor of a more political argument. They are simply too scared to stand for unfettered free-market policies. They are scared to death of electoral reprisal. Period.”

    I understand that the 2010 freshmen dont have the numbers to run the show, but I did expect to at least see some opposition from them.

    As far as electoral reprisals go, I expect 2012 to resemble 2008 more closely than 2010.

  • Flagstaff

    It’s fine to demand perfection, but you still have to define perfection.

    Your purity does you well, but the people we put in Washington have to not only get bills through an obstructive Senate and president, they also have to deal with a press that paints everything “bad” that happens as the fault of Republicans. “Mr. Republican, why won’t you compromise on ____?” “Mr. Republican, why did you shut down the government?” “Mr. Republican, why are the sleigh rides in Yellowstone Park closed?” BTW, “shutting down the government” doesn’t save any money–it just gives the workers who are sent home a paid vacation, because they are never docked for the time not worked.

    Not that some of those things shouldn’t happen, and not that we shouldn’t stand up to the blackmail at times, but until we have the majority and a leader who will act responsibly on DOMESTIC policy, it’s silly to pull your hair out over this bill.

    I know that you didn’t use the “shut down” phrase, but it’s the fact of life Republicans in Congress face, because it’s the threat that Democrats always make these days. We are forced to use our only real weapon–promote policies that are obviously “right,” even to non-political-junkies. There aren’t that many, but the pipeline is one of them and we should use it to its utmost, for sure. Nuanced positions are impossible during a Christmas budget fight.

    There hasn’t yet been a budget passed during the Obama administration. Obama has dropped to a 43% approval rating in one poll. “Shut down the government” and those numbers pop back up, perhaps enough to reelect him.

    The immediate, primary objective should be to get the majority in the Senate and the House, and win the Presidency. For conservatives to say “a pox on your Republican Party” because it isn’t perfect is counterproductive.

    We don’t like our Congressional leadership? Let’s push to have Ron Paul
    made Speaker. Maybe they’d behave better.

    And the Tea Party movement is not dead. None of us are any less motivated than we were two years ago. It just isn’t as obvious.

    Then again, this is all a game to these people. It?s the red team versus the blue team. Forget about the purpose of the team.

    If you really believe that, why are you wasting your time writing here? Just go back to bed and pull the covers over your head.

    • rickdeckard

      We just don’t see any reason to cover for a party that can’t even produce a 2% cut in the wake of the most unprecedented spending explosion in history. They took the House on the promise of enforcing fiscal restraint, and they have done nothing but whiff since they were sworn in.

      Let Reid bury everything that comes out of the House. The record will speak for itself. This isn’t ’95, and the old guard media are losing control of the narrative.

      A quick look at Nielson’s ratings shows that on cable Fox News Channel, not exactly a hostile environment for republicans, beats all other news channels combined, in all time slots. And that’s only part of the story.

      By now it is redundant to point out how the information landscape has changed since the invention of the internet. Stories that never would have seen the light of day as recently as ten years ago are published hourly. The uninformed aren’t simply absorbing the liberal message by osmosis anymore. Other ideas are getting through.

      Republicans know the majority wants less spending, less regulation and the full repeal of Obamacare. It’s time they stopped being coy and publicly embrace a clear change of course from the current administration’s policies.

      Admittedly, this still leaves the problem of party autocrats and the obstacles to budget cutting they produce. That’s what primaries are for, and that is another topic for another thread.

      • Flagstaff

        I was too abstract.

        What do you want them to do? No, really, what?

        I agree that passing great bills in the House to use as examples of the obstructionist Senate is the right idea. Pass them, let them fail in the Senate, show what we could have done with a Republican/conservative Senate.

        I like what they just did, although it will NOT get the pipeline approved. That it was the right thing to do is proven by Obama’s silence on the pipeline. He really doesn’t know what to say, can’t really say anything, because when he speaks he has to put down Republicans, and he can’t do that on the subject of the pipeline. Whatever he would say would make him look bad.

        But it simply can’t force him to do anything; that isn’t in the Congress’s power. What it will do is force him to either sign it an later do what it says or explain why not to the people at a time that is actually better for us than now. Or he will not sign it, and throw the talking heads into a tizzy. I believe he will sign it, because he can’t really spin it that Republicans refused to do anything–his own party helped pass the bill. It would be hard for even Sgt. Shultz to ignore that (but he would, of course).

        In the end, it isn’t good or bad behavior on the part of Republicans and Democrats that’s the problem, it’s the American public who buy bad behavior and bad economics from Democrats and think they’re getting something good.

      • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

        The GOP is the least worse reflection of how we have evolved as an affluent society. We the Conservative People are a minority that faces what the minority that threw off the Brits faced.

  • colonelflagg

    …enjoy life at the back of the bus with the rest of the conservative base.

    And enjoy casting your vote for Mr. Big Government, Noot Gingrich or Mr. Big Government, Myth Romney. Because they aren’t Obama, and our betters said we have to.

  • calhoun211

    If I get to keep my Edison bulbs nothing else matters.

  • tomatin

    Boehner will just claim that he got 98% of what he wanted and then raise government spending.

    The Keystone XL Pipeline deal is just a joke. Now Obama has a reason to kill what he never wanted. When are people going to realize they are just playing games with us conservatives.

    • Flagstaff

      If NOTHING is ever enough for you, why should you be attended to at all? If you refuse to recognize the world around you, you are beyond help.

      As an exercise, please tell me what you really wanted them to do, and explain how they would get it through the Congress.