« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Farm/Food Stamp Bill Vote Tally

Yesterday, Erick mentioned a revolutionary one-stop website designed to hold Republican House members accountable for their voting records.  The Madison Project unveiled ConservativeVotingRecords. Com, which houses a simple yet novel index that compares the voting records to the ideological bent of the member’s district.  The results are not pretty.  52 members who hail from solid Republican districts scored 20 points below where they should be given the ideological makeup of their district.  They are displayed prominently in the Hall of Shame.

I’ve been privileged to help work on this project and expand the scope of the site to include additional features.  In addition to the index, we will also provide background information and commentary for each Republican House member to offer a full picture of their performance in Congress. We will post continuous updates of voting tallies on individual pieces of legislation in both the House and the Senate.  That way you can easily track how your member voted on every consequential bill or amendment.

Our first release is the Farm Bill.  Nothing embodies the “red state statist” problem more than farm and energy subsidies.  Many of these members work together with local special interests to ensure that red states remain dependent on government in anticipation of a constant flow of government subsidies.  This bill represents the motherload of dependency for both urban and rural interest.  The $970 billion leviathan permanently enshrines the Obama-levels of spending for Food Stamps, perpetuates market-distorting favors for special interests and rich farmers, and creates a new farm program that guarantees farmers 90% of average annual income for many farmers.  If the blue state members protect their special interests and if red state members follow suit with regard to their parochial interests, we will never shrink government, restore the free market, or balance the budget.

The bill passed 64-35.  Republicans opposed it 30-16; Democrats supported it 48-5.  I would note that a number of the southern Republicans opposed the bill because it didn’t provide enough subsidies for southern crops, not because it proposed too much spending.  Thankfully, the House has agreed to scuttle the bill until July out of concern for conservative objections to the bill.  We need to continue fighting this thing.  It’s legislation like the farm bill that will ensure the budget never balances.

Many of these massive bills provide numerous opportunities to vote on amendments that are of concern to conservatives.  It’s extremely tedious to keep track of voting records when there is a series of 70-80 amendments within a few days.  This is especially true with the 12 annual appropriations bills, in which the open amendment process in the House (thank you Speaker Boehner for keeping this process) can provide for as many as 100 amendments on a given bill.

To that end, we’ll begin uploading easy to read color-coded spreadsheets where you can view how each Republican senator or congressman voted on some of the major amendments.  They will be stored on the “legislation” page of the new Madison site.  I’ll try to post each one for the Red State community.

Today, we begin with a number of important amendments to the Farm Bill that can be viewed here.

This is a work in progress, so any and all feedback would be appreciated.  Knowledge is empowerment.

COMMENTS

  • spoasteph97

    And a special shout out to the four with PERFECT records:

    Senator Jim DeMint
    Senator Mike Lee
    Senator John McCain (I’m impressed)
    Senator Rand Paul

    • http://madisonproject.com/ Daniel Horowitz

      has always been good on this stuff. But once again, it always boils down to the big 3 with Toomey and Johnson close behind.

      • spoasteph97

        Kelly Ayotte has also been doing an okay job—considering that she was seen as the more establishment type in 2010.

        Marco Rubio has kind of sunk a little on my list…although he is still better than anything I could expect from Crist (who is now a Democrat). But I hope Senator Rubio returns to core Conservative values soon…and STOP defending those silly sugar subsidies on national radio and TV!

  • billstanley

    She voted “yea”. She should retire now, instead of in January. We need Ted Cruz. www.newsandopinions.net

  • wlcjr

    continues to impress.

    • mikeymike143

      he is one of only 4 senators to have been given a perfect record,

  • bobguzzardi

    this is a sophisticated analysis that is very helpful. Lots of information. The Club for Growth lists Key Votes and this goes a step further in detail.

    What would be helpful is either a link to the amendment or some description of what the amendment does or does not do.

    Pennsylvania’s Republican delegation is not surprisingly disappointing.

    If I am reading the Madison Project correctly, this tells me is the Member is voting his district ( Penna has no women Republican House members).

  • bobguzzardi

    The Environmental Working Group has a detailed searchable database of Farm Subsidies http://farm.ewg.org/

    On top left, click “Farming” and then under “2012 Farm Bill Resources”, click “EWG’s Farm Subsidy Database”

    EWG is not a fan of Ethanol subsidies nor Crop Subsidies.

    alert: this appears to be a left leaning good government website as will be evident. Nevertheless, data is data.

  • Melody Warbington (rwm52)

    I have a suggestion. It would be very helpful to have a short explanation on the legislation votes page (good bills and bad bills) as to why each billl is good or bad.

  • devany

    I have never understood why farmers can’t buy private insurance to insure revenue in the bad years. I do understand why farm state politicians stick together.

  • rightlane1111

    We do need natural gas and oil…we still drive cars…no more subsidies to the oil companies. Farmers…Are there not enough people that need food in the USA. With Michele’s new veggie diets…you should be in heaven.

    Ethanol…I want that gone…gone…gone. It ruins the engine of the automobile. Besides that…the mpg is less and therefore…for the Greenies out there…we leave a larger footprint…forget the crop dust that the EPA is now trying to regulate.

    Sometimes I wonder when looking at our government whether this is an intelligent group of people or they are just plain greedy with no concern for much of anything.

    No more subsidies…Can we say Greece.

  • wlcjr

    Anyone know why conservatives voted against amdt 2363?

    ” To ensure that extras in film and television who bring personal, common domesticated household pets do not face unnecessary regulations and to prohibit attendance at an animal fighting venture.”

  • Seedyrom

    I understand the Speaker doesn;t vote except in the case of a tie usually but what was his record before 2010 ? If you don’t know that’s okay, just curious since the Conservative Union has details but the 2 organizations use different methods which is good for comparison of the bad ones. Thank you.

    http://www.conservativevotingrecords.com/member/oh-boehner-john/