« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Senate Democrats to Bypass Appropriations Process

It is funny how those who believe Congress has unlimited power to regulate the private sector are abdicating their primary constitutional responsibility.  Senate Democrats have not passed a budget in 1,169 days.  Last year, despite their failure to comply with the Budget Act of 1974 and to pass a budget resolution, they made an effort to pass a couple of individual appropriations bills.  Now Roll Call is reporting that they are planning to ignore the entire appropriations process, opting for a continuing resolution showdown from the get-go. This, despite Reid’s promise earlier this year to complete work on the spending bills for Fiscal Year 2013.

And they’re not embarrassed to say so.

In fact, Harry Reid is actually claiming that the reason they will not pass a budget or a single appropriations bill is because the House did pass a budget:

Amid lingering differences with the House over government spending, Senate Democrats may not pass any appropriations bills before the end of the fiscal year on Sept. 30.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) today said the major hurdle to completing the appropriations process is the House GOP, which has been pushing for spending cuts greater than what was agreed to under last year’s Budget Control Act. The House is moving its spending bills in accordance with the House Republican budget resolution, which sets spending at $19 billion less than the $1.047 trillion spending level agreed to in that measure.

“We passed last August legislation that is now law that set forth the spending for this country during the next fiscal year,” said Reid. “They refuse to adhere to that. So that makes it hard to do these appropriation bills.”

Harry Reid is contending that Republicans are not allowed to pass a budget and follow the Budget Act of 1974 because they already established spending caps in the debt ceiling bill (Budget Control Act) last August.  This would be hilarious if it weren’t so sad.  All the Budget Control Act (BCA) does is set a topline discretionary spending cap.  It doesn’t specify the funding levels for the thousands of line items within that topline number.  Imagine if you would sit down to formulate a personal budget and rely solely on the topline spending figure, instead of working out the individual costs for specific expenditures.  Following Reid’s logic, the Senate would be exempt from passing a budget for another 10 years.

Moreover, the BCA doesn’t mandate a spending floor; it only prescribes a cap.  The debt has increased another $1.6 trillion since passage of the BCA.  It is not a cardinal sin to cut more.  Furthermore, the Senate Parliamentarian already ruled that the BCA does not constitute a budget.

The real motivation for not passing a budget is to avoid the embarrassment of putting out 12 bloated spending bills, which will be full of undesirable expenditures such as implementation of Obamacare.  Why make all his red state Democrats suffer the humiliation 12 times when he can roll them all into one omnibus bill at the end of the year?

In order to accomplish his goal, Reid needs House Republicans to abandon their budget and give him bipartisan coverage.  They mustn’t fall into the trap the same way they did last year.  As imperfect as it is, Republicans have a budget that cuts some spending and defunds Obamacare.  They must refuse to negotiate with Democrats until they pass a budget and all 12 spending bills in regular order.  The imperative of formulating a budget is something that even the average voter understands.  There’s no reason why Republicans can’t take that message – 1,169 days without a Democrat budget – to the American people.

Let’s grow beyond the cycle of capitulation that marred the legacy of the House majority in 2011.

Cross-posted from The Madison Project

COMMENTS

  • michaelbowler

    to actually fight this issue out, Reid knows it and the budget process will continue to be dysfunctional until adults get power…if THAT ever happens.

    • z06gal

      Agree totally. John Boehner will compromise us right off the cliff. I would love to see Michele Bachmann as Speaker.

      • garfieldjl

        Republicans only control the House of Representatives, what Boehner can actually do is fairly limited.

        1. The House can pass 5 budgets a day every day and it amounts to zilch when Senator Harry Reid (D), whom is the Majority leader in the Senate simply decides to sit on them and refuses to allow them to even be discussed. There is very little that Speaker Boehner can do because he doesn’t have any say in the Senate. I think McConnell has the ability to force some things up on the Senate floor as the Minority Leader, but Boehner doesn’t.

        2. Harry Reid and Obama are perfectly willing to have a government shutdown and inflict all kinds of misery on the American people. In fact, they know that most media outlets will start spewing DNC talking points about how it is all the Republican’s fault. If the media had a shred of integrity, I think we’d be seeing a lot more backbone from Boehner on the issue of a shutdown, because the American people would know what was actually going on.

        3. There have been things that Boehner has stood firm on, including the contempt vote concerning Fast & Furious. So it’s not exactly the situation where Boehner is flopping all over the place… Speaker Boehner has to pick and choose fights that he knows he can win, especially with how unethical the Democrats have been and the media’s willingness to cover up what the Democrats have been doing.

        Look folks, Speaker Boehner doesn’t have the title Senator by his name for a reason, he’s not in the US Senate, instead of screaming that Boehner grow a backbone to push things through that he Constitutionally doesn’t have the power to do in the first place.

        You guys would be screaming at Newt Gingrich if he was in the position John Boehner is currently in to grow a backbone. In case people have forgotten, Republicans controlled the US Senate when Gingrich became Speaker.

        Michelle Bachman couldn’t do any better than Boehner given the current situation, in fact she might do worse because she would be more easily outmaneuvered than Boehner, not that she isn’t right in principle because she is, but because she would be too easy for the media to turn her into a scapegoat instead of calling out the Democrats on their destructive policies.

        THERE IS A REASON WHY SEVERAL OF OUR PRIMARY CANDIDATES WERE SAYING WE NEED TO TAKE THE SENATE IN NOVEMBER!!!! We could have every house seat in Congress held by Conservative Republicans, and IT WOULD NOT MATTER ONE BIT IF THE DEMS CONTROL THE SENATE!

        Stop blaming Boehner for McConnell’s lack of a backbone! If we had control of the Senate and we were seeing total inactivity from the House, then you would be right to blame Boehner. Fact, of the matter is we have seen a lot of activity in the House, but the Democrats in the senate won’t even let it up on the floor or in a committee to get a hearing in the first place.

        Speaker Boehner and the Republicans in the House have been trying to do their jobs, however they can’t do anything when Harry Reid sits on it.

  • http://inkredulousbasterds.com/ Gethan Curtis

    …is in this passage:

    They must refuse to negotiate with Democrats

    Every time these…people… “refuse to negotiate” they do it anyway, and we invariably suffer even more for it.

  • Tbone

    and why should they when there are no repercussions?

  • athanasiusrc

    we can’t trust the House Republican leaders. 19 billion is where they drew the line in the sand? Really?

    Anyone remember this:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K9DuYlcVwbo

    Go to 2:45.

    It fits the House Republican leadership to a “t”.

  • chriser

    Why? Because the words “govenment shutdown” sends them running with fear and trembling with their tail between their legs begging the Democrats to make a deal so they won’t get blamed when the sleigh rides at Jellystone park stop.

  • http://travismonitor.blogspot.com Freedoms Truth

    “We passed last August legislation that is now law that set forth the spending for this country during the next fiscal year,? said Reid. ?They refuse to adhere to that. So that makes it hard to do these appropriation bills.? …”

    Reid is an incompetent idiot or takes the rest of us to be that. Why cant he simply pass appropriations bills that match the spending level HE wants? And then negotiate from there as has always been done?

    This great article exposes the cowardly approach the Senate Democrats and DC Democrats are taking generally. It’s only the Republicans who can give them ‘cover’ for this phony act of fiscal irresponsibility.

    Republicans should be publicly mocking Reid daily and demanding he come to the table with a real budget and appropriations …

    “The imperative of formulating a budget is something that even the average voter understands. There?s no reason why Republicans can?t take that message ? 1,169 days without a Democrat budget ? to the American people.”

    Indeed!