« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

The Elite Become Fringe. We Will Remember Come November

“The same people who have dedicated the entire year to proclaiming the tea party movement ‘fringe’ suddenly find themselves fringe.”

I’ve written about this before. Let me pretty much repeat myself because it is vitally relevant here.

I cannot tell you the number of reporters at major networks and newspapers who will, in private moments, admit there is a real bias in the media. That bias largely comes up from the elite power brokers, trend setters, news reporters, and politicos who live in the New York to Washington corridor.

In most cases it is not an intentional bias. It is a product of being highly educated, liberally inclined (“centrist” if you ask them, which is typically code for standing for nothing and everything at the same time), white urbanites who live on the Upper West Side, have drivers whisk them off to their studio or out of Adams-Morgan into downtown DC where they hang out with other fashionable liberals who, unlike me, think Jimmy Choo is a shoe manufacturer and not, as I thought, a Chinese restaurant.

They talk about what’s in the New York Times Magazine and on its front page. They gossip about who isn’t fooling around with Maureen Dowd anymore. They go to wine country in France, tie the latest J. Crew sweater around their neck because Michelle does, and otherwise live in an insular world of group think.

The preconceived notions they develop in this insular world of their likeminded friends colors what becomes the conventional wisdom, what gets reported and what doesn’t.

The latest bout of conventional wisdom is serenaded more sincerely than the gospel, which can be politely and publicly disdained in favor of Islam, because quoting the Koran indicates tolerance. Quoting the Bible indicates you’re a rube. Republicans willing to speak truth to power are adored. The women from The View are considered intellectuals, except for that Republican one who is just on there for the affirmative action quota for wingers.

Sarah Palin is disdained because she had a Down Syndrome child and all the forty something first time moms dropping their kids off (assuming it’s not the nanny doing it) at Birch Wathen Lenox, Trinity, and Dwight before going to work at their six-figure jobs know that smart women abort Down Syndrome babies — there’s a great clinic in SoHo where you can shop fashionably before the “procedure”.

The mainstream media arises from this culture. Most every network is interested only in what happens within 50 miles of a major metropolis situated along the Atlantic or Pacific. Very few media outlets care about the views of people within 50 miles, let alone 300 miles, of the Mississippi River unless it is environmental because that sells among the coastal elite. Remember, they care more than you.

In this insular world of popular politicos who get serenaded in the “saw him at the Palms” section of the Washington Post and reporters who quest to work for a major New York media outfit, the rubes down in Georgia or Missouri or Idaho are probably bigots or racists or homophobes or Christians or, at the very least, not very culturally aware.

So we are all forced, those of us not in the New York – DC corridor, to listen to preaching from “centrist” politicos, pundits, and purveyors of conventional wisdom about how the Ground Zero mosque is a sign of our tolerance and opposition to it is racist.

If we disagree, Grover Norquist — a man who has never been right on matters of Islam and Jihad — will be trotted out to prove not all Republicans are close minded bigots. This may be the one occasion David Frum can plan a vacation around because he’s usually the guy the media calls on for those statements. But on this issue, Frum may be just a little too…what’s the word they use? Neoconish?

As trust in the media goes down, ratings sink, subscriptions are cancelled, and the preaching of the left/media intensifies on this, we need to understand something clearly. The reason the left/media is so preachy on this issue and so unwilling to talk about whether the mosque should be built since, after all, it can be built, is because the people who set the news narrative are realizing they are fringe.

They can’t actually admit it. They cannot say it out loud. They are too self-aware and in touch with their inner-do-gooder to say it. But they have become fringe and subconsciously their ratings, poll numbers, and subscription cancellations are telling them this. And they know that, like a tree falling in a forest with no one around, soon they too will be the punchline of a joke.

The same people who have dedicated the entire year to proclaiming the tea party movement “fringe” suddenly find themselves fringe. Consider: the same percentages of people believe 9/11 was an inside job and believe Barack Obama is a foreign born Manchurian candidate and believe the Ground Zero mosque should be built.

While this Ground Zero mosque controversy may be the first time any of these elitists have ever embraced property rights, it has also done a brilliant job of outing them as out of touch with the America they supposedly represent in office, cover in the news, and talk down to on an hourly basis. The elite has become just as fringe as birthers and truthers.

But they will never, ever, ever admit it. They’d rather call you and me racists. But you and me? We will remember come November.

COMMENTS

  • marstep

    I believe those who base their understanding of constitutional governance require that RedState refrain from identifying this group, ‘fringe birthers’.

    Is it Mr. Erickson’s position that Lt. Col. Larken or his legal advisers and and public supporters are ‘fringe’?

    Seriously deficient opinion!

  • ocleverone

    but I think this one ranks as one as my all time favorites.

    Bravo.

  • america1st

    but true Americans can affect them only indirectly, by ignoring them, which we already do and the more docile are doing as they become more engaged – as witnessed by your phrase “ratings sink, subscriptions are cancelled (sic) . . . . ”

    I dream of the day the old gray lady crumbles into the dust or becomes a shopping weekly circulated on the Upper West Side.

  • smagar
  • pamdale

    “While this Ground Zero mosque controversy may be the first time any of these elitists have ever embraced property rights….”

    Thanks for the chuckle.

  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    Birthers aren’t welcome here.

  • romeg

    regarding this fringe to which you now refer: “There is only one political value that they have stood by through three generations, and that is the political value of disturbing your neighbor.”

    Taranto goes on to write “The pro-mosque left’s pieties about “American ideals” have about as much to do with the reality of the controversy as the fringe right’s ravings about “Shariah.” In truth, the left favors a mosque near Ground Zero simply because most Americans find the idea obnoxious.”

    http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704554104575435484116485898.html#printMode

  • writeblock

    When JPII visited and became the focus of millions of Poles who, for the first time, realized their collective strength. Conservatives are realizing more than ever that they are the real national majority–and both parties had better recognize this. Before this the leadership of both parties responded to the magnetic pull of elitist opinion. That day is coming to a close. That’s what the tea parties have been all about.

  • writeblock

    …The real enemy of the left is us, not Islamic terrorism, not Iran, not tinpot dictators like Castro or Chavez. It’s us they hate most–which means most of the American people.

  • novacon

    This post stands in very sharp contrast to yesterday’s excellent post from the Heritage Foundation. This Mosque “controversy” is just another culture war grease fire in an endless string, and will have little effect on 2010 or 2012 elections. In fact, I doubt voters are even going to remember it in a couple months (Henry Louis Gates, anyone?)

    Conversely, yesterday’s Heritage Foundation post set out a wide swath of discrete conservative policy proposals that address the real, substantial challenges that this country is facing right now, most notably our balooning national debt. Americans will almost certainly put a significantly greater number of conservatives (perhaps even a majority) in office when they go to the polls this fall, and its incipient on us to articulate a comprehensive, specific governing platform, a la the Contract With America. Culture War distractions like this aren’t a governing philosophy, and regardless of how riled up people are, it won’t help conservatives get this country back on track.

    Also, DC’s car service set wouldn’t be caught dead actually living in DC with the plebes, let alone Adams-Morgan. Despite their global warming rhetoric, most are driven in a great distance from Northern Virginia and the Chevy Chase/Bethesda area of Maryland.

  • writeblock

    Culture war disagreements like this reveal far more about the left’s true radicalism than the left would ever want revealed. It’s why most progress on the left must be by subterfuge. That Obama so openly opposed most Americans on this issue poses major difficulties for the left. In effect the issue is emblematic of the huge disparity between the thinking of average Americans and the thinking of the elitist fringe on the left.

  • Superheater

    “In most cases it is not an intentional bias. It is a product of being highly educated, ”

    Highly educated? Really?

    No, its highly indoctrinated. The stealth sole purpose of the modern “elite” university education is, to paraphrase the late Professor Bloom to CLOSE the mind, not to OPEN it. Many “universities” are little more than left-wing madrassas.

    Lets not confuse a pedigree with actual learning.

  • JadedByPolitics

    laugh because those two candidates are about as ALL- American as a Conservative candidate could be. It is these so called “elites” which btw I don’t consider them to be elite at all. I consider them to be boorish intellectually dishonest socialists who want you and I to pay for their kingdom but that they would NEVER pay one cent more then their accountants can hide to the government.

    It is they who are indeed the FRINGE and it is they who will have their smirking pathetic hateful smiles SMACKED OFF their faces on November 2nd. I look forward to November 3rd to watch the horror as they come to realize that indeed a MAJORITY of Americans are taking their Country BACK from their destruction!

  • flajim

    There’s overwhelming evidence that the boy in the White House is foreign born and more evidence that he’s not an American since his parents, under the law at the time of his birth, couldn’t confer that on him.

    Thought you were smarter.

  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    much appreciated.

  • acat
  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    n/t

  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    Well said.

  • http://www.ArchitecturalShots.com mdyou

    …but I made this same point yesterday in response to Neil Steven’s piece and I think it’s important. And it’s the short way of encapsulating everything you said, Erick.

    This is nothing more or less than intellectual in-breeding, producing all manner of unpredictable abnormalities. The DNA is confused and will eventually result in the isolation of it’s host and leave it twisting in the wind.

    One would feel sorry for their condition and assured destruction, if only they weren’t doing so much damage.

  • spainishirish

    it is more fringe the Truthers or Birthers or Pelosi. No small feat there.

    Sharp piece, by the way.

  • spainishirish

    it is more fringe the Truthers or Birthers or Pelosi. No small feat there.

    Sharp piece, by the way.

  • janis

    Your piece, Erick, is all the more reason why we need to make sure that these radicals don’t manage to fund “journalism”. This stuff needs to die and be buried with all the other failed policies and ideas of the Left.

  • izoneguy

    Photographed in Dallas the same day Obama was here.

  • Common_Cents

    “Let?s show the Tea Party crowd that they?re no match for our grassroots strength. Stand with us against the Right?s despicable attacks and their fat cat fundraising by joining Team Pelosi ? an elite group of grassroots Democrats who are leading the fight against radical Republican candidates in races nationwide.”

    The fringe elite dems are openly declaring war on Americans. How do you even have an “elite group of grass roots”? Our elected dem elites are out of control and dangerous.

  • gekster
  • Common_Cents

    Is the stuff you smoke because they are so incoherent they must be high.

  • tomkinney

    That it is the elite fringe itself calling the mainstream the fringe is an excellent point!

    As a post-9/11 convert (my vote for W in ’04 was my first ever for an R) and a new member of redstate, I’m delighted that you are banning birthers and umpiring a clean game here.

    I do think there’s some stereotyping in your piece above, but those elites do exist. It’s just that not all liberals can be painted with the same brush any more than conservatives. As someone who has lived in the Madison, WI area for the past 41 years, I know many liberals intimately and am involved in an email group of friends with several, though they are outnumbered. What I see in my non-stereotypical liberal friends–note we are mostly former writers and editors for Madison’s underground-ish weekly–is confusion and extreme dislocation. They are bewildered by events that have transpired since Obama’s election and can’t find dry ground from this tsunami of a backlash.

    In short, they are ripe for the picking by conservatives who are either moderate or at the very least tolerant of other POVs. You don’t have to be moderate to be tolerant, but it is a fine line and needs to be tread most carefully. I would accuse very few of my liberal friends–after all, most off campus are humble Wisconsinites–of being elite.

    A well-tempered presentation is always a winner in the long run.

    But, as for these cries of racism and intolerance from the liberal left, that alas, I cannot and will not tolerate. And as you say so well, the intolerant who preach tolerance are not only hypocrites, they are headed right into the teeth of the tsunami.

  • ss396

    If we disagree, Grover Norquist ? a man who has never been right on matters of Islam and Jihad ? will be trotted out to prove not all Republicans are close minded bigots.

    Chicago Tribune article in the Houston Chronicle this morning; headline “Mosque issue creating dissent within the GOP” featuring – ta da-a-a! – Grover Norquist.

  • http://moelane.com/ Moe Lane

    Bye, novacon/fairbanks!

  • http://barbershopvalues.com daconia

    Great article, Erick.
    Sadly, these elites are now ruling over us, at least until November.
    My prediction is that they and their party will become “fringe” for a long time after this.

  • BA Cyclone

    I was just going to quote the very same line.

    Priceless!

    *5* Erick, thank you!

  • BA Cyclone

    I was just going to quote the very same line.

    Priceless!

    *5* Erick, thank you!

  • IJB

    :)

  • BA Cyclone

    I hope you are right daconia, but the battle for the staying power of dyed-in-the-wool conservatism is bound to be long and arduous.

    We in flyover country have let them play in their closed swamp in the East for so long, they thing they have a right to rule over us. We have shirked our own duties of public service.

    It will take many years of detoxification to restore Liberty to its rightful place in our culture and this great nation.

  • BA Cyclone

    I hope you are right daconia, but the battle for the staying power of dyed-in-the-wool conservatism is bound to be long and arduous.

    We in flyover country have let them play in their closed swamp in the East for so long, they thing they have a right to rule over us. We have shirked our own duties of public service.

    It will take many years of detoxification to restore Liberty to its rightful place in our culture and this great nation.

  • msctex

    “Education” CANNOT be a bad thing. The “higher” versions thereof, thus only the more so. The word simply implies being taught things that are demonstrably true. We take for granted that an educated man believes and acts upon things which are clearly the case, in reality.

    But equally as clearly, we are confronted by a highly pedigreed, utterly indoctrinated group of quasi-elitists who all believe the same things, things which cannot pass the litmus test of function. So to save the value of the word “educated,” as it would be genuinely dangerous for the word to become at all a negative, let’s call these people what they are:

    Mal-educated.

  • novacon

    [Sorry: I thought that we had made the banning of the retread stick. My bad. - ML]

    No room for principled dissent? I really did like that Heritage foundation post, too. Perhaps Hot Air will have me, then.

  • acat

    …. making this a win/win for me (but another loss for Captain Ed and Allahpundit)

    Mew

  • jackhammer

    I have a lot of contact to exactly this sort of elite, be it in the States or abroad. You’re description is apt. they are generally nice people, people you liek to spend time with, and they are very polite and very well meaning. They are also incredibly taken aback that someone could differ from their highly evolved opinions. I am an unapologetic conservative, who will gladly look for a discussion on any of their “self evident” beliefs.

    What does amaze me is how seldomly they question their own beliefs,a dn how unable they are to coherently defend them. I am not overly animated in these discussion, nor do I harras them, but it is just for them, they cannot comprehend that another opinion could exist, and are nto realyl sure why they hold theirs.

    these are educated erudite people, but as regards their assumptions on what “proper” is, it follows the Krugmanesque….we all know socialism woudl be utopia, it is just no one has tried it “properly” yet.

    I have a lot of access to this priviliged class, but I choose to associate myself with more normal people. I choose a parochial school in a mixed income neighbourhood for my daughter, I like living in a mixed income neighbourhood and having my daughters friends be more normal and truly diverse. I enjoy splashes of luxury, but prefer the honestly held values of the normal man…people who work an honest day for an honest pay….grudgingly pay their taxes, rather than avoid them through the use of high priced accountants and lawyers…..The elite sometimes accuse me of spending too much times in the latrines, but it is who I am, where i am comfortable,a dn filled with the values I want my daughter to live by.

    My education, my background and my income allow me a level fo security that most of the “normal people” don’t have, and that is somehtign I thankfully cannot fully empathize with, but otherwise….

  • ralatredstate

    “It will take many years of detoxification to restore Liberty to its rightful place in our culture and this great nation.”

    I agree. More than 60, maybe 80 % of our institutions and centers of power are not just infected but septicised*.

    Most infections yield quickly to the proper antibiotic if the environment is otherwise healthy . We are still otherwise (apart from the socialist/progressive infection) healthy, and the popular uprisings typified by the Tea Parties are the proper antibiotic – so at least I pray.

    * (a semi-neologism meaning “dominated by the infectious disease process” [yes, I realize it has a contrary meaning in some construction industry sources]),

  • BA Cyclone

    The “conventional wisdom” discourse has so far removed from any honest historical roots of life, liberty, and property that it will take a considerable amount of reasoned discourse to reset the field.

    That the statists have molded themselves as the supreme arbiters of “higher education” will not make the battle for awakening easier – however thankfully we still have truth on our side. We simply must not be afraid to speak it plainly, with authority and conviction.

  • BA Cyclone

    The “conventional wisdom” discourse has so far removed from any honest historical roots of life, liberty, and property that it will take a considerable amount of reasoned discourse to reset the field.

    That the statists have molded themselves as the supreme arbiters of “higher education” will not make the battle for awakening easier – however thankfully we still have truth on our side. We simply must not be afraid to speak it plainly, with authority and conviction.

  • drwallst

    Fact One-Most politicians are out to get votes
    Fact Two-They will only get votes if they say what a majority of people want to here

    If you accept facts as they stand, then there is no reason for Democrats to support such warped policy as the Stimulus, the healthcare bill and cap-and-trade.

    So why do they support things that won’t get them elected?

    Only one explanation-Democrats don’t care about getting votes when they have blind extremists who will always vote the blue ticket.

    But it can’t be just the great unwashed, since the Dem agenda affects them the worst.

    So of course it’s the elite. The millionaires and billionaires, the limousine liberals and the champagne socialists, the Bollinger Bolshys and the Liberal Elite.

    They bankroll Democrats, they give Democrats votes on a platter.

    And the reason the elite flock to Dems? The idiots like the birthers and the other fools who are detracting attention from the real issues that Republicans should be focusing on.
    ………………………………………………………………………………………………
    www.musingsofablogger.wordpress.com

  • havasu

    …so, what’s so wrong with a sweater over one’s shoulders?

    I live in mortal fear of these people exiting their limos and actually seeing the light of day with us regular folk. Then, they might actually marginally change the tone of their writing and attitude, which might make them look just not-out-of-touch enough to attract support from casual or gullible observers. And voters.

    No; let them stay aloof in their modern-day salons, huffing about us guns-n-religion obsessed plebes with our outdated notions of right and wrong, patriotism and keeping what we earn. All the more fun to watch them flail after Nov ’10 and Nov ’12.

    In your collective free time, pencil ‘Cancer Ward’ in for a read or reread. Fascinating to read the attitudes of Soviet apparatchiks, and compare them with modern-day government employees and elected officials. Indistinguishable beyond the funny accent (the east coast government people, I mean).

  • havasu

    Well done.
    Well said.

  • callawyn

    The blanket accusations of racism thrown around by lefties, both media and politicians, against anyone that opposes the economic policies of the current regime are going to come back to bite them.

    People who find themselves suddenly vilified as ‘racist’ for merely holding to the principles of limited government and free market capitalism that made America the great nation it is tend to become a bit enraged at this, and this will lead them to the polling places come November with a newfound determination.

  • drljr

    Actually Mr Barrack H. Obama Jr’s birth place is irrelevant to the eligibility issue. Because his father is/was a foreign national (British) at the time of his birth Mr Obama Jr is not a natural born citizen. The definition of natural born citizen is “a child born in the country of parents who are citizens”. This definition is rooted in Vattel’s Law of Nations (published in 1758) and has been referenced in at least 5 Supreme Court rulings from 1814 to 1939 as well as other histories and legal documents from the time of the US Constitution’s writing.

    And from reading the relevant law Mr Obama, as far as I can tell, is a native born citizen because of his mother – regardless of his birth place. He just is not a natural born citizen. She was not living in Kenya but at best visited Kenya and may have given birth there. Mr Obama at birth was both a British and US citizen.

    So Mr Obama, and Senator McCain as well, is not and never can be President. As such Mr Obama is not President and nothing he does under Presidential authority is valid. In fact, as far as I can tell under the Amendment 12 and 20 the acting President is Richard Chaney. Hilliary Clinton’s campaign was correct.

    P.S. The US Code can be found at http://uscode.house.gov/ for any one interested in reading the actual legal code.

  • Flagstaff

    what percent of the population fully trusts the traditional media?

    That number must be south of 30%.

  • olds88er

    Erick,If someone STANDS on your right hand and someone else STANDS on your left hand, just how are you going to defend any bridge?