« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

Barack Obama Takes Our Soldiers Hostage to a Shutdown

Over at Big Government, Mike Flynn has a fascinating post on what Barack Obama is doing to our soldiers.

In the past, American soldiers were classified as essential personnel. Therefore, should the government shut down our soldiers would keep getting paid.

But Barack Obama has decided to hold our American soldiers hostage to a government shutdown. The Commander-in-Chief has, via the Secretary of the Department of Defense, proposed classifying our men and women in harm’s way as “non-essential.” That means, should the government shut down, they will not be paid.

As Mike Flynn notes, during the previous two government shutdowns during the Reagan and Clinton Administrations, soldiers were treated as essential. Barack Obama is not following suit.

It is important to note that the “non-essential” classification is a draft recommendation, but it is a huge departure from prior shutdowns and comes directly from the Office of the Secretary of Defense.

Why would Barack Obama and the Democrats do this? The answer is simple.

They need to change the message because right now they are losing. And they are willing to use our soldiers as hostages to get that message changed. Let me tell you why.

Democrats are getting pasted in the budget debate generally. They can’t beat the GOP on the argument that cuts are needed. The Democrats have no plan for cutting the deficit, and even liberals are calling Paul Ryan ‘courageous.’ They can’t win, because they simply can’t engage on cutting entitlements. So the GOP was winning on budget cutting, winning on the FY 2012 budget, and likely to win on the debt ceiling vote. The Democrats need a way to change the debate.

Remember, the only reason we are on the verge of a government shutdown is because for the first time since the budget act was passed in the mid-seventies, a Congress — controlled by Democrats last year — failed to pass a budget. That’s right. We are where we are because the Democrats last year failed to pass a budget and now are refusing to go along with cuts as the GOP sorts out the mess the Democrats made.

The only way the White House can do that is to get a shutdown. They want to put the blame on the GOP, but even more than that, they want a shutdown. So the argument will be that spending bills start in the House, and the House still hasn’t passed anything that can get 60 votes in the Senate. And until they do, the fault for the shutdown lies with the GOP. And, in the meantime, our soldiers are fighting in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Libya and cannot get paid.

With a media all too willing to push the anti-GOP position, we can bet the first photo in the newspapers the day after the shutdown will be of a boy scout locked out of the Smithsonian and the second picture will be of a flag draped coffin of a soldier with the headline “Because of the GOP, He Died Without Pay”.

The Democrats will get their shutdown, and the debate will change to how to get the government open again. And when there is an agreement, Obama will take the credit for bringing the sides together. And he will be the hero.

Meanwhile, our troops fighting a non-essential non-war in Libya are reclassified just like the non-war.

COMMENTS

  • Donald Ayotte

    So he will take his marbles and go home. Like a spoiled brat in a school yard.

  • radicalrighty

    understand the looney left’s hatred of Bush. But now I do.

    I hate, yes, hate this man and his Democrat party.

  • gon4beer

    I hope and believe and anticiapte that the shutting off the military pay, which is an obvious and devious move by the President intended to stick it to the Right, will backfire big time as he will (hopefully) have to defend his actions before the American people, who will see this gambit for what it is-a treasonous political move made by a man who could truly care less about our military. Here in Charlottesville, Lars Larson is in town to do his radio show with Lars’s long time buddy, JoeThomas. Afterwards there will be dinner at a local bistro, the Boathouse Grill, to rasie money for the wounded Warrior Foundation-go USA and our troops!!

  • bay0wulf

    Is it any surprise that this President and His Administration and the Democrats-In-General would pull this sleaze? It should come as no surprise that he will willingly sell anyone “down the river” to push His agenda forward.

    He is a piss poor excuse for a President. He is an even lousier excuse for a Commander -In-Chief.

    He is looking for any way possible to throw dirt on “His Opposition” be they the GOP or the Tea Party or … just common folks like you and I. This action in particular should speak loudly as to just how much he cares about “We The People”.

    His action in this does not just impact the soldiers (which is reprehensible enough) BUT it also will impact the families, their wives, their children. If he doesn’t manage to throw all the blame on the GOP, I see a very good possibility that we may experience our very first military coup here in the USA … or is he deliberately trying to provoke this type of thing so he can put us under martial law?

    He and His Administration are being criminally stupid and wrong-headed OR they are playing out a very dangerous strategy that may very well burn not only Him and Them but may change the very fabric of Our Nation beyond recognition.

    This may be the biggest REAL Change he unleashes.

  • peasoup

    as high treason! This is a betrayal of our military and our country! I wonder if he knows that one day he will have to stand before G-d and give an account for his life? Or does he even care? This is a despicable act by a petulant, narcissistic, spoiled man-child who, unfortunately, is the “leader” of the free world! Well, at least for today we’re still free … unbelievable.

  • http://theminorityreportblog.com Repair_Man_Jack

    This shouls be Rand Paul’s time to shine. Get the GOP together as a caucus. Inform Harry Reid that no quarum will be present to raise the debt ceiling on 8 May 2011 a clean, straight bill paying all uniform military personnel has been passed by COB today.

  • http://theminorityreportblog.com Repair_Man_Jack

    should read “unless a clean straight bill paying…”

  • renny

    the Koran gives absolution to lies and deceit that opposes the infidel.

    Cannot the Pentagon itself authorize pay as it does purchases? You cannot tell me there is no money left in any of the thousands upon thousands of military agencies and departments that does not have an excess from prior allocations.

    Even school districts keep “balances” from public tax monies in their budgets for emergency outlays or capital expenses demands.

    I cannot believe o and the Dems. really think stiffing the military while in harms way is good pr. Even the Dems. have been forced to pretend they support “the soldiers” even as they oppose “the war.” Perhaps even the MSM will not be in o’s pocket over this “overreach.”

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    The point is that THERE IS NO BUDGET.

  • eddiethegeek

    There was no internet back then, and Clinton was able to successfully spin the shutdown. People have other sources of news these days and are more aware of exactly why there’s a shutdown. Reid and Pelosi punted on passing a budget, Obama has shown ZERO leadership, and Reid still can’t get the votes to pass a budget on his side of the Capitol. Boehner isn’t doing enough to stanch the hemorrhaging, but at least he’s doing SOMETHING. And the people, if they’re willing to educate themselves, will see that Obama has thrown the military under the budget bus. The compliant media cannot control what people know and think like they used to be able to do.

    You are correct to say that the Dems are losing. The focus is not on WHETHER to cut the budget, but on HOW MUCH to cut the budget. There is real hope that a stake can be driven through the heart of the entitlement mentality, at long last.

  • gumbeaux

    This delusional moron has gone too far. He needs to go ASAP, not in 2012. Until his ‘re-election’ he will have ample time to destroy everything that is America. He has violated the Constitution, no count on how many laws, and HE HAS VIOLATED US. WE THE PEOPLE need to stand up to this Socialist and Congress and tell them NO!

  • texan4america

    Yes, a shutdown is going to hurt — and hurt a lot of people — but at this point it is a “must do.” Boehner cannot give in again — or he is as bad as they are.

  • http://www.scragged.com petrarch

    …every time he looks in a mirror.

  • ksgrl444

    I literally told an acquaintance recently that I could never understand the the left’s horror at a second Bush Administration, but now I contemplate a second Obama Administration with that same absolute fear.

  • Old_Crow

    The first shutdown in ’95 didn’t span a pay period, so there was no disruption in pay. The second shutdown in late December came after the military appropriations bill had been passed, so active duty automatically received their pay.

    Congress has not passed a military appropriations bill (or a budget), so in order for active duty to be paid (assuming the shutdown spans the next payday), specific legislation must be passed.

    The ‘essential’ and ‘non essential’ tag has no bearing on military pay.

    FYI, retirees do get paid since their pay is not part of the budget or appropriations bill.

  • cjca

    the very few that actually believe in him, that would be. How uncaring can anyone be to cut the funds from our soldiers and dependents who have mortgages, credit cards and vehicles payments. Non-essential? Let us then make the Obama Administration, czars non-essential status – not that they aren’t anyway. Add Air Force One and every means of transportation and security to this list. Take away Michelle’s staff, hairdresser, make-up artist all unpaid at the same time. They don’t make her look or behave better anyway. Send their household staff and chefs, cooks home for the duration. Cut all spending to support the White House. No money to NATO or the UN, truly non-essential.

    Lock and Load, it’s about to get ugly. Join the revolution all of you in the military and lets clean up and out the mess in DC.

  • givemefreedom

    A new and more horrible spectre has just hit our military . . . . .
    The Military is now NO MORE important than an average liberal political boondoggle.
    Just like a bridge to no where:
    A bank too big to fail:
    Spending our grand children’s inheritance:
    “We have to pass the bill before we know what’s in it” :
    Obamacare!

  • Douglas Erley

    “But I still state unhesitatingly, that for pure, vacillating stupidity, for superb incompetence to command, for ignorance combined with bad judgement – in short for the true talent for catastrophe, Elphy Bey stood alone. Others abide our question, but Elphy outshines them all as the greatest military idiot of our own or any other day…”.

  • http://theminorityreportblog.com Repair_Man_Jack

    So is OMA. They can’tpay their people or buy any spares until this fustercluck gets straightened out.

  • msctex

    . . .this sort of thing would be unthinkable from the Dem perspective, because they would know exposure and backlash were inevitable But since Obama still operates from the safety of a pink gauzy bubble of invulnerability, as far as the mainstream media daring to question him, this sort of thing can pass relatively unnoticed.

    On the other hand, it should cement the military vote our way once and for all.

  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

    democrat and independent support. He lost the military vote before he started when he voted to cut off funds for them twice as senator.

  • Douglas Erley

    “Only he could have permitted the First Afghan War and let it develop to such a ruinous defeat. It was not easy: he started with a good army, a secure position, some excellent officers, a disorganised enemy, and repeated opportunities to save the situation. But Elphy, with a touch of true genius, swept aside these obstacles with unerring precision, and out of order wrought complete chaos. We shall not, with luck, look upon his like again.”

  • thecommander

    Treason is defined as giving aid and comfort to our enemies. How better to demoralize the military who stand for the defense of the nation and the rights of freedom for individuals to express their opinions than to declare them nonessential for budgetary concerns. Once again Obama and the leftist Democrats have shown their contempt for our nation. In the election of 2012 the Democrats must go or they will destroy us and being a Bible believing Conservative who holds fast to the Constitution will be seen as a crime against humanity.

    If the Democrats continue in their evil ways the seeds of rebellion and Civil War will be sown and in the end the nation will be damaged and it may take years to climb back to the position of eminance we now hold.

  • kywrite

    The Pentagon has been running near empty for well over a year. Remember, when Obama got into office the first thing he did was tell the Pentagon to cut 10% from the military budget immediately. There have been other cuts since. I can tell you, having done a PCS move last year, the military is already squeezed; troop transfers, except to combat zones and ship deployments, are very, very slow because they haven’t had full funding in that department for years.

    Well, since last year’s budget was not passed, the military has also been funding cost of living increases, housing cost increases, and an across-the-board salary increase WITH THE SAME BUDGET AS LAST YEAR. This stretches anyone. They’ve been raiding the PCS budget, the only really flexible one, to the point that my husband’s new backup, selected in February and needed right now, will not have his transfer funded until at least October. This severely affects military readiness. They simply can’t raid the funds any longer. If they don’t have the funding provided for military salaries by the federal government, they truly and sincerely cannot afford to pay them. It’s not in any way the military’s fault – instead, they have been put in a position of unreadiness by a Congress that has been criminally unwilling to do its job.

    Trust me here: if there is a shutdown, the military knows EXACTLY who to blame.

  • kywrite

    I will be directly affected; my husband is full-time military, I’m a freelance writer, and we have four kids and no savings to speak of. So — I’ll just work more, find corners to cut, and be ready to go to appropriate agencies for assistance until this gets sorted out. It’s not a tragedy; we will survive.

  • kywrite

    Can’t lose what you didn’t have to begin with.

  • rightwingmom52

    taking up for the Tea Party and slamming Reid. He laid out the case that the Dems want the shut down for a cheap political victory. He’s introduced a bill that keeps the gov’t. open but at a much lower level. It would pay workers 75%, congressional staffers 50% and congressman 0% until they work something out. No back pay for anyone. He puts the blame squarely on the Dems. He said he would vote for the CR if they could get a BBA first & a 5 year plan to balance the budget. He points out that his tea partiers point out that the proposed cuts do little to fix things.

  • rightwingmom52

    especially what happened to the walls of Jericho. Lots of trumpets in play there, but I think the GOP needs some lessons. I just don’t understand why they can’t, don’t or won’t get the message out there. I realize the press will try to spin, but I doubt they would ignore us if the GOP would call a few press conferences and just keep making statements.

  • http://www.plumbbobblog.com Plumb_Bob

    Do not make the mistake of believing that because your feelings are similar to theirs, that your position is the mirror image of theirs. It is not.

    Their horror was delusional. Not one of the claims made about President Bush by the Democrats was factually sound.

    Your disgust with President Obama is based on facts.

  • johnlincoln

    Obama’s threat is dripping with extortionate Chicago-style politics: first and foremost, members of the military are not one of his voting blocs, in fact, far from it. So his advisors see no downstream negative consequences at the polling places in 2012. (here’s where “unintended consequences” are going to bite him). Furthermore, the Beltway Boys close down the Gov. every time that it snows in D.C., anyway, don’t they?

  • myron_j_poltroonian

    Maybe Janet was on to something regarding returning veterans, only she called them, potential domestic terrorist’s. Considering the rampant shift to the left of this government, I would call them Patriots. There should be a call to set aright the many injustices done our constitution, including the injustice of the democrats habit of misplacing military votes, or even sending them ballots in time to be properly cast, returned and counted. I’ve reluctantly said for years now: “It’s Coming”. And now? it’s about Damn Time.

  • myron_j_poltroonian

    should read: ” … or not even … “.

  • YnotNOW

    At least among the enlisted ranks. Remember, the enlisted force is disproportionately minority, and most minorities lean strongly Dem. While the military ethos mitigates this somewhat, it is still there.

    Officer corps tends to be more reliably conservative. Enlisted is less reliably conservative.

  • YnotNOW

    At least among the enlisted ranks. Remember, the enlisted force is disproportionately minority, and most minorities lean strongly Dem. While the military ethos mitigates this somewhat, it is still there.

    Officer corps tends to be more reliably conservative. Enlisted is less reliably conservative.

  • http://www.plumbbobblog.com Plumb_Bob

    “Trust me here: if there is a shutdown, the military knows EXACTLY who to blame.”

    But does the public know? The press will be pounding the Dem party line, blaming the Republicans. We need all hands blasting out the truth on this, placing the responsibility where it truly deserves to be. The public needs to know that the Democrats think it is fair play to starve our military in harms way for their political gain.

  • acat

    Yes, makin’ mock o’ uniforms that guard you while you sleep
    Is cheaper than them uniforms, an’ they’re starvation cheap;
    An’ hustlin’ drunken soldiers when they’re goin’ large a bit
    Is five times better business than paradin’ in full kit.
    Then it’s Tommy this, an’ Tommy that, an’ “Tommy, ‘ow’s yer soul?”
    But it’s “Thin red line of ‘eroes” when the drums begin to roll,
    The drums begin to roll, my boys, the drums begin to roll,
    O it’s “Thin red line of ‘eroes” when the drums begin to roll.

    Mew

  • longwalker

    Your service must have been Viet-nam Era. Check the latest figures – the percent of minorities in military service is roughly proportional to their percentage in the national census.

  • Danielle Davis (ocleverone)

    http://www.navytimes.com/news/2010/04/military_poll_advance_041110w/

  • finnmccuill

    Keep reminding yourself what o?cockroach and his tribe of cockroach cronies, including the Hillary Twins and their Chicago buddies are doing. As o?cockroach announced on Oct. 30, 2008: he/they would immediately begin ?fundamentally transforming the United States of America.? The whole festering nest of them have certainly been following that aim. They are all, including whatever label they give themselves, all pathological liars, all congenital parasites, and all full-time, self-congratulating thieves. They seem to infect anyone unlucky enough to come into any kind of contact with them with their galloping corruption. The best part is o?cockroach boy?s abject humiliation of this great country with his butt-fondling golf outings (at taxpayers? very great expense!) to an assortment of dictatorships throughout the world. His intention is power and control, with attendant thievery, by completely and totally ignoring our Constitution, our traditions, the wishes of concerned Americans. He?s having much fun pretending that he?s taking over a tiny, struggling African country of forty years ago, but with lots more money to steal. It?s what his father (whoever he is?) taught him, supposedly what his grandfather (whoever he is?) taught him, but since Americans don?t typically run screaming into the streets, waving knives and spears and assorted stolen firearms (the ones gun control laws don?t seem to control, including the dread ?assault rifle?, (whatever that is?) I’m concerned; I may have an undeclared “assault paring knife” in my kitchen! ), and otherwise behaving like indifferently raised 15 year olds indulging themselves in a well-rehearsed tantrum, he?s been able to pursue that aim. I?d load up the whole lot of them and ship them to Guantanamo, where they can compare notes with their radical muslim buddies. Since we’re short of money they’ll have to get by without rat control, or hot meals, or hot water, or TV, or laundry, or mail, or telephones, or beds, or, etc. You know, just the way o’cockroach lives! Bet they can all have some fun together in the game room! !

  • streiff

    It hasn’t been heavily minority for 30 years.

  • YnotNOW

    “These career-oriented officers and mid-grade and senior enlisted members are still far more conservative than liberal, but they are less likely today to identify with the GOP, the survey shows.”

    Note that this sample does not include lower enlisted, and still the trend is from VERY politically conservative to less skewed.

    My experience was well after Vietnam (late 80s to early 90s) but my understanding is that enlistees are still higher percentage minority than the general population, although not nearly so much as used to be. I was Army too, which probably varies from Navy statistics.

    The more telling statistic, though, is how many military voted for Obama in 2008.
    “using general election data provided by the New York Times, I was able to determine that the military communities most affected by the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan shifted significantly toward Barack Obama and the Democratic Party in 2008 when compared to the numbers from 2004.”
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/brandon-friedman/election-data-military-co_b_143621.html

    or this:
    “?This indicates that the increased support for the Democratic presidential candidate among members of the Army is due to both a shift of the Army?s traditional voting block away from the Republican Party as well as an infusion of new, predominantly minority voters into the Democratic column,? said Jeremy Dempsey, author and Army infantryman,”
    http://www.amconmag.com/blog/2008/11/04/the-shifting-military-vote/

    Also found this breakdown of poll prior to election in Military Times:
    http://militarytimes.com/static/projects/pages/081003_ep_2pp.pdf

    But my point still holds, that the military vote that was pretty monolithic conservative/republican is now less so.

  • YnotNOW

    a higher percentage minority than the general population.

    https://www.dmdc.osd.mil/Rank_Gender_Race.xls
    shows:
    Officer: 78.7% White, 8.8% Black, 5/3% Hispanic,
    but
    Enlisted: 68.6% White, 18.5% Black, 11.5% Hispanic.

    I am very surprised this lists such low numbers as “Hispanic”, when my experience suggests otherwise, so there may be a self-classification bias here. But the data does suggest a significantly higher Black percentage than the general population, particularly in Enlisted, and particularly in Army.

    But the difference is not huge. And certainly the self-selection into the all-volunteer Army skews the ideology much more than the demographics.

  • davidleigh

    There’s so much to write concerning the subject, where does one begin! How about the NY Times exposing the wiretapping and Swift bank program? Attack, attack, attack your own country!

    Not even Clinton would do something so ugly as to deny our troops their pay and he was the top narcissicist until Obama came along. It’s true, the Left was grinding their teeth like little demons over Bush and smeared every conservative at every turn, even to the point of staging protests in their front yards.

    These people are stark raving mad. Conservatives are overwhelmingly more grown-up. Please name one conservative Senator to slander a Supreme Court nominee like Kennedy did Bork. Across the board, they’re insane.

    They have no character, no integrity, no decency, no God.

  • runner12

    callous moves by a President. This is all about politics for him and the Dem. Party. These people have no shame.

  • streiff

    you made a statement. Either defend it or admit you’re wrong. Those are your options.

  • http://www.mullinslawoffices.com/ Jim Mullins

    It is an enormous credit to our Constitution and the rule of law that our President can make the military a pawn in his personal political battles to the point of openly threatening to withhold their pay and benefits without fear that his actions will result in an unexpoected shortening of his tenure in office. In most counties, such antics would quickly make the president a man without a country. Fortunately for us and our country, President Obama will be able to sleep soundly tonight and the hundreds of nights remaining until, on January 20, 2013, he flies off into the sunset and retires to the land of his birth–Hawaii (no, he will not go back to cold, dreary Chicago, except for occasional visits).

  • Danielle Davis (ocleverone)

    I guess he hasn’t figured that out yet.

  • YnotNOW

    That Obama in particular, and Democrats in general, have a significant voting support in the US Military. It is still a minority of the overall military vote, but higher than in the past. And certainly nothing to ignore totally as a constituency.

    I stand behind that statement.

  • YnotNOW

    That Obama in particular, and Democrats in general, have a significant voting support in the US Military. It is still a minority of the overall military vote, but higher than in the past. And certainly nothing to ignore totally as a constituency.

    I stand behind that statement.

  • Danielle Davis (ocleverone)

    Your polls broken down by race were conducted before the 2008 election. If you go to page 2 of the polls, the issue with the highest concern for African Americans was the economy.

    You are arguing with old data. Data which still reflects less than a 25% approval for Obama. How do you think that holds up now? That is NOT significant support.

  • YnotNOW

    So I will stand.

  • YnotNOW

    So I will stand.