« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

Responding to Stern Emails From Speaker Boehner’s Office

I’m getting stern emails from Speaker Boehner’s Office about my prior post. The Speaker is not happy with me.

The feeling is mutual the more I learn of this budget deal.

Here’s the first email:

Subject: This is False

“Turns out it does not cut $38.5 billion. According to the Congressional Budget Office, it only cuts $353 million.”

From story: “The CBO study confirms that the measure trims $38 billion in new spending authority.”

I understand you’re opposed, but at least be accurate.

Okay, I should have said “cuts the deficit $353 million.”

But we’re playing with semantics here. Note what I said: “cuts $353 million.”

Now note what the Speaker’s Office points out from the CBO analysis: “the measure trims $38 billion in new spending authority.”

I think I’ll stand by what it being cut, because a cut implies something is going down — in the case of what we always have been talking about, the deficit.

The Speaker’s Office also sent this email:

Subject: This also not true

“It’s just the *deficit* only gets cut $353 million.”

353 million in the next 6 months, but 315 billion over a decade. For example from the story: “CBO does credit a move to eliminate year-round Pell Grants with generating more than $40 billion in deficit reduction over the coming decade from both mandatory and appropriated accounts, though just slightly less than $1 billion this year.”

So . . . we are only cutting the deficit $353 million this year? I haven’t been talking about the next decade. No one has. And $315 billion over the next ten years is one grain of sand on deficit beach. This year’s deficit is $1.5 TRILLION.

I’d just point out that John Boehner said on February 11, 2011, “We are going to cut $100 billion in discretionary spending next week. Write it down. $100 billion in discretionary spending. And we aren’t going to stop there.”

Oh, lastly we also know the spending baseline went up $3.3 billion.

The net, bottom line IMPACT is that the CR will only reduce discretionary spending by $352 million this fiscal year (once all the smoke and mirrors are cleared).

COMMENTS

  • jmimac351

    It means they know this stink bomb smells as bad as everyone knows it does. What disappoints me most is that we have the Speaker of the House, the Leader the GOP selling us a BS story just like Obama would. I was at a Tea Party rally last year in downtown Orlando, FL and stood 15 feet from Boehner as he railed on and on about what he would do. “HELL NO!!” Boehner screamed again and again. Now I know it was all typical BS. They are gutless, lack principle, and I am fed the hell up. Liberals infuriate us all, sure – but we know what to expect. But for us to elect these GOP chumps in a landslide last November and now get the same old gutless nonsense from Boehner… it’s just too much. Sandy Adams in FL-24 is hearing about this and will be primaried if she votes for it.

    Up to this point, I’ve prayed that God would save the country from the likes of Obama. Now I realize the real threat are the gutless elected officials who won’t defend us, after all the pomp and circumstance.

    You keep doing what you’re doing. No one is buying it and they know it.

  • Dave_in_Fla

    Or his sock puppets anyway…

    If he is right that we are not understanding the deal, because we don’t understand the budget and authorization process (which I’m willing to bet I understand better than he thinks) then write up an explanation and educate us.

    Because the big problem he has got is explaining this to the voters, there are *millions* of voters feeling betrayed right now and we are the ones the need to understand why this is a good deal and helps avert this slow motion train wreck.

    He and others in leadership have been allowed to make front page post in the past, I’m pretty sure they would be allowed to in this case.

    I would venture that he has about 12 hours before this blows up in his face, one way or another.

  • Dave_in_Fla

    The CBO did him no favors on this. In the future he should condition all “deals” on CBO scoring agreeing with the negotiated intent.

  • http://908StraightSt.wordpress.com/ mbecker908

    testosterone challenged bunch of brain dead wimps would be if you actually called them out on their absolutely gutless deal that’s selling us down the river for another at least two years.

    They should be happy you’ve become Mr.Kind&Gentle.

    They are pathetic and I hope you come the realization that without new leadership – top to bottom – in both the House and Senate we are the Titanic. These idiots aren’t even bothering to rearrange the deck chairs.

    “We have met the enemy and he is us.”

  • Puddle_Pirate

    Boehner just sent the GOP down the road bravely blazed by the Whig Party. Nice work, John.

  • http://908StraightSt.wordpress.com/ mbecker908
  • ohiohistorian

    Boehner is trying to blow smoke. He got rolled, and he agreed to it to keep from a government shutdown. Doesn’t the fool know that with Billy Boy Clinton being re-elected (remember Bob Dole was pitiful and Ross Perot pulled a lot of conservative vote) they still retained the majority in the house and INCREASED in the Senate? http://www.facebook.com/pages/US-Senate-election-1996/138758862818062 For pretending to be a conservative, and having a pretty good (but not stellar) ACU voting record of 94%, he is fast becoming the lieberal mouthpiece of the house. So he needs some home district competition to strengthen his spine.
    You’re doing great, Eric. Keep the heat on him. Make him spin and dissemble. That will NOT get him re-elected. Only honest dealings with the voters who are tired of the Trillion plus deficits as far as the eye can see will get him re-elected.

  • http://908StraightSt.wordpress.com/ mbecker908

    I’d say it’s been nice, but that would be a lie.

  • http://908StraightSt.wordpress.com/ mbecker908
  • drivlikejehu

    This is really bad on a number of levels. I think at this point it’s basically too late for FY 2011. The GOP surrendered without a fight.

    Two things absolutely need to happen:

    1) Boehner must apologize for this debacle and heads have to roll, e.g., Hal Rogers’ chairmanship.

    2) Boehner must stand strong for very significant concessions in exchange for raising the debt ceiling. In fact he should demand a cap on the 2012 budget roughly in line with the Ryan plan. No negotiations with Obama. Take it or leave it.

  • luvnthebigsites

    Boehner:

    “These are real cuts!”

    “I got 78 billion out of a 100 billion cut”

    and my favorite… “shutting down the government will drive up costs”

    Mr. speaker, Get your free “I cut spending” T shirt and go sit down. Stop acting like Obama or get out of the way.

  • phoenix0401

    Thank God we have people like you standing up against a complete and total cave by people whose only concern is keeping the nice offices with the pretty secretaries. We need more tea party folks winning next November — and to welcome in a new Speaker.

  • ohiohistorian

    through his Speaker box, and got a “page cannot be found” error. He either is getting a ton of email, or has taken the hero’s way out and taken it down. Either way, I hope he likes my comments to him whenever he may get it.

  • Raven

    Raising other spending.
    According to the CBO, Total Federal Spending will INCREASE by $3.3 Billion with this budget “deal.”

  • Praying

    I really didn’t think anyone in Washington cared a rat’s a$$ what the people thought. If they are reading Redstate – and caring what is said on this site, at least there is a chance we can win them over from the dark side! I have to agree with you, though, the whole budget cut charade was nothing but smoke and mirrors, and gives me ZERO hope that they will do anything differently on the debt ceiling or the 2012 budget. They are so afraid of their own shadow, how are they ever going to stare down the dirty dems? Sigh…

  • runner12

    Although all it does is really make the deal stink a little less.

    They can make up for it though if they stand strong on the FY 2012 budget and the debt ceiling.

  • pauly1620

    What was the point of last year’s election if all we’re going to do is the same-old “compromise” with the other side of the aisle? We’ve been “compromising” with the Democrats for as long as I can remember. And for as long as I can remember, the United States has continued to slide from the pinnacle of power to a nation that is on the edge of the abyss. I am really questioning why I’ve been a member of the GOP since 1989 (the year I turned 18) if all that we’ve fought for means nothing in the end.

  • donnybrooke

    Just wanted to check on something. Is it true that a lot of the “cuts” are actually deciding not to spend “unspent” funds from things like the census, federal construction money and highway funds?

    This isn’t cutting. It’s not spending.

  • Puddle_Pirate

    Rep.Boehner@mail.house.gov

  • broncboy

    I am guessing never?

    Just once I would like to hear it straight, no gimmicks, no smoke.

    Don’t hold your breath.

  • d_lamar

    my understanding is that the 38.5 billion budget deal was merely a reduction in Obama’s proposed budget plan. To my way of thinking, what Obama planned to spend is irrelevant, and was not even a starting position to negotiate.

    Boehner should have started with the 2008 budget, and negotiated cutting from that. Then we would have been talking about real cuts in government spending.

  • marshmom

    If you don’t like the criticism, then do your JOB! Do what you were elected to do! Stop kissing Obama’s rear end and be a MAN!

    I can’t tell you how sick and tired I am of all this pandering to the stinking MARXISTS in our government! You can’t give these people an inch……..they’ll take 10 miles!

    You think you’ll lose a PR war with the democrats?? Then do better PR!! We are all very frustrated right now because we elected you to office to stop the insanity, but you’re just helping them limp it along. What the heck goes on in Washington that seems to disintegrate your spines so? The person with the biggest….*ahem*……spine…. in Washington is Michelle Bachman. Aren’t you ashamed??

    Get it together or you will be GONE!

  • Kyle-MI

    It was suppose to get us back to 2008 spending levels. I would not be picky about the exact number if only we were headed in the right direction. We are not even back to 2010 levels! Someone give these guys a compass.

  • nancylee

    But I don’t like being taken for a fool. You lied to us, and you are continuing to lie to us.

    This spin of yours is losing you more PR than telling the truth would. Grow a spine. Tell the truth. And try actually doing what you promised us you would do.

    We put Republicans in power to stop the Marxist insanity, not help them along. Do your job, or we’ll put in someone who will.

  • lmiller25

    There are members and staffers who read RedState (and post here) because they are are conservatives who want to advance conservative ideas. I used to be one of those staffers who worked for one of those members. Then there are staffers that keep up with RedState to monitor criticism of their bosses. Don’t bother trying to win them over. If a huge win in November couldn’t provide them with enough courage to stand up to the president, nothing will.

  • MikeInOhio

    This deal is like having your $5000 credit limit reduced by $50, even though you never planned to use all that credit anyway.

    It’s not cutting spending.

  • avgjo

    or the dims when they were demagoguing the whole shutdown thing last week.

    Doubt it.

    They find more ways to show contempt for their own side than i can count.

    If you listened to Boehner today on Hannity, you heard condescension, you heard disdain for people that didn’t like his precious compromise and you heard dodgy answers to softball questions.

    He’s ruling class, pure and simple.

    Someone above posted how these people and their staffers read sites like RS. I wonder if they aren’t aware of the whole ‘conservative in the primary, republican in the general’ and our stringent efforts to observe Reagan’s 11th commandment and if they aren’t inclined to use that against us.

    One must wonder.

  • phenry

    Boehner, the people have spoken. Ignore at your own peril. That goes for everyone else in house leadership too. If I were you and I wanted to get re-elected, right now I would trying real hard to figure out how I could possibly get out of voting for the deal.

  • dontell

    is getting re-elected more important than our country’s future?

  • jmimac351

    our sights were aimed at Democrats jamming Obamacare down our throats. Now, they are aimed at our own “Leadership”.

    It is true, most of these people in Washington are corrupted by the power. I think most of them on our side really did not start out that way, but they just could not resist. The Capitol is an impressive place, one that must make these people feel pretty good about themselves.

    It’s a weakness of the human condition. Those who have been there a long time and have not been corrupted are truly special Patriots.

  • popdaddy

    Let your rep know the yes votes Thursday will serve as the record for GOP primary targets. I did.

  • avgjo

    I wonder how to explain what has happened….?

  • Tbone

    while she was lying to us. Plus, I expected her to lie to us. And, she kept her people in line.

    Boehner, is a loser.

  • annas

    Fox News poll says almost 60% of the country want to just raise taxes on the “rich!” How does it happen this socialist regime has fooled 60% of the people??? Hannity said today that at some point some politician has to stop looking at re-election and do what’s right! I don’t see it happening as long as polls show the folks want more taxes (tax increases on the “rich” are taxes on all of us).

  • Jim
  • Jim
  • roscopico

    I’d love to rail on the guy, but he’s a lost cause. If these are the standard bearers for our party, we are lost.

    It is a g-d damn f***** shame. I could not be more displeased. Boehner: Resign.

  • roscopico

    QE1, QE2, whatever iteration of monopoly money infusion is floating the economy right about now,,, sure looks pretty “endy” to me.

    And doesn’t is stink even worse that those who should be helping our cause are on their knees facing the Statist? It’s bad enough they sell out my generation, but my child? And lying to my face is bad, but to steal from my daughter?

    We didn’t elect a Tea Party House for you to f*** my child, Boehner.

    Coward.

  • http://908StraightSt.wordpress.com/ mbecker908

    I see no one on the current horizon who can herd the cats that are currently members of Congress.

  • http://www.AmericanThinker.com Hammer2008

    (h/t Pirate. Thanks for the email address. Here’s what I sent the Speaker)

    Hon. Speaker Boehner,

    I heard a freshman congressman on Bill Bennet’s Morning in America radio show 13 April and I concur with his premise. ?Here’s a way out for our country, the “pledge”, and your own integrity:

    Bi-monthly debt ceiling votes coupled with $10 billion in real cuts. Let Obama veto each if he dares.?

    You’ be asking him and Sen. Reid to accept the equivalent of one days worth of interest on the national debt for servicing the other six days not accounted for. 14.3% by GOP with 85.7% for the remainder of their progressive agenda.

    May thru September 2011 would thus yield $100 billion in actual cuts.

  • Marcus_Traianus

    There is either a dishonest attempt to hoodwink party members as to the success of this “deal” or grotesque negotiating incompetence by Mr. Boehner and his sidekick Mr. Cantor.

    Is this what we can expect on the debt ceiling and next budget debates; a bunch of rah-rah, rally the troops and requests for support follow by the Speaker folding like a cheap lawn-chair and covering his behind by having minions call every media outlet (including Democrat leaning MSM) to tout the “success” of the “deal”?

    This isn’t even a paradigm upon which we can build future deals. It’s an embarrassing display of political behavior meant to mimic the bygone days of smoke-filled, backroom deals where everybody “wins”.

    That’s not leadership; it’s grotesque, dishonest ineptitude.

  • adair

    It is frequently pointed out that the American public … well, that nobody … can comprehend billions and trillions of dollars.

    G. Gordon Liddy, back 15 or 20 years ago when Million was a lot,, clearly defined billion as “a thousand million.”

    The mistake has been, I think, that our brains multiply by tens so easily. Instead of clearly realizing that when you have a billion and it goes to a trillion, that’s A THOUSAND BILLION. It’s a million times a million.

    When the pols keep saying the deficit will be so-much, or so-much-more in ten years, it’s eye-glazing instead of heart-stopping, breath-gasping outrage that it should be.

    We understood it better at the Tea Party meetings last year. The horror of debts multiplied by thousands instead of tens was part of our impetus. . Obama’s deficit for February was a THOUSAND TIMES more than $billions in appropriations for a “program” that benefits some Americans.

    Make it clearer and thus more dramatic, Mssrs. Boehner, Cantor, Ryan, McCotter, Pence, and any of the 12 or 15 possible Presidential candidates.