« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

Short Memories And Republican Successes

Back on March 15th, I wrote a post pointing out what happens when Republicans get milquetoast — their polling goes down.

If you will go back to March 15th, there was a poll out that said the GOP hadn’t been compromising enough. In fact, the poll said that “71% say the GOP is not willing enough to compromise with Obama on the deficit.”

I noted at the time that the GOP had been muddying the waters with Barack Obama and the Democrats. I said that “House Republicans have been muddying the water so much since November and painting their policy positions in pale pastels. The public voted in November with bright colors — mostly in red.”

I also said, perhaps counterintuitively, that the GOP needed to stop being so compromising, even though the poll suggested otherwise, and start leading. “As long as the Republicans are being milquetoast on spending and the budget, the Democrats will see the polling benefits,” I wrote.

In the debt ceiling fight, it appears I was right. As the GOP has held a firm and consistent line insisting on massive spending cuts and entitlement reform, their poll numbers have gone up — exactly opposite what the chattering class of compromising good government types insisted would happen.

In a new Washington Post/ABC poll of adult Americans, the headline drawing the big buzz is that Mitt Romney is head of Obama among registered voters. That’s huge and good news for Romney. It’s even better than the poll suggests because that data comes from the registered voters. Obama and Romney are tied among all adults. But registered voters, unlike likely voters, also skews to the Democrats by a few points, though not as badly as among all adults.

So if Romney is ahead of Obama by 3 points among registered voters, he’s probably ahead 5 or more points among likely voters. That headline, however, overshadows a more important finding.

In another indicator of rapidly shifting views on economic issues, 45 percent trust congressional Republicans over the president when it comes to dealing with the economy, an 11-point improvement for the GOP since March. Still, nearly as many, 42 percent, side with Obama on this issue.

This is among all adults surveyed. So in a pool of respondents that favors the Democrats, the GOP is ahead 3 points. With registered voters, I’d suspect the GOP is ahead more and even more with likely voters.

For the GOP to be ahead on this issue is significant. And what has the GOP message been for the past month and half? Significant cuts in spending and reforming entitlement programs.

The GOP has had a consistent message and drawn a firm line in the sand. It has been portrayed as terrible, heartless, nasty, and impractical. But the public is responding to it. The public recognizes the need for it.

I am plugged in enough to the goings on in Washington and talk to enough congressmen and senators to sense a disturbance in the force. I suspect Republican leaders feel like they have dialed up the rhetoric and positioning too much and are going to find a way to weasel out of their statements and scale back.

That is what they do.

But they shouldn’t. They have the public with them. The polling reflects that. The public wants the GOP to win on this issue. We cannot rely on polls and a clearly fickle public on this issue. The polling will go up and down.

But the lesson we can take away is the one I pointed out in March — the public wants leadership. Leadership always wins in the face of milquetoast statements and compromise. As I said then and repeat now, saying the sky is falling, but then not doing anything about it really is not what any reasonable person could call a winning strategy.

The GOP has the winning strategy right now. They better not blow it or it will blow up the GOP. I hope the Presidential candidates are paying attention to this.

COMMENTS

  • wennejunk

    candidates to make their positions forcefully clear and provide some backing to the Congressional leadership.

  • averagevoterdotcom

    2010 was the end of the 1st qtr of this football game, not the end. 2012 is the halftime mark. Conservatives, independents and tea partiers know this. Their DC temp hires better know this too.

  • bbfmail

    Why are Republicans not holding Obama accountable????

    [Copyright infringement redacted - NS]

  • nickel

    If the Republicans nominate a strong fighting candidate who will take the fight directly to the Progressives and their Obama puppet the Republican candidates at all levels of Government will ride a wave to victory. If instead the Republican primaries allow a milquetoast weeny to be our candidate then we are all toast.

    Sarah Palin for Republican candidate for President of the US to restore our competitive free economy and unleash the power of millions of hard working entrepeneurial Americans. If you want a job done right get a women to do it.

  • nickel

    If the Republicans nominate a strong fighting candidate who will take the fight directly to the Progressives and their Obama puppet the Republican candidates at all levels of Government will ride a wave to victory. If instead the Republican primaries allow a milquetoast weeny to be our candidate then we are all toast.

    Sarah Palin for Republican candidate for President of the US to restore our competitive free economy and unleash the power of millions of hard working entrepeneurial Americans. If you want a job done right get a women to do it.

  • acat

    In several decades of people-watching, I’ve confirmed that this is true – people lie to themselves, so naturally lie to pollsters.

    They say they want bipartisanship – but what they really want is a combination of non-rancorous government and for their pet issues to be addressed.

    They say they want to take care of the environment – but what they really want is to feel like they’ve done something without giving up anything.

    They say they think the U.S. is the great satan – but immigration and emigration rates show this to be a lie – if it were true, who would come here and why wouldn’t more be fleeing?

    Republicans believe polls at their peril, Erick – if anything your piece here did not go far enough!

    Mew

  • ag8tor

    This administration still is trying to make chicken salad out of chicken crap. It is painfully obvious that they have NO workable plan for reviving the country’s economy. The Reps need to hold their ground for once and not cave to the RINOs and POTUS who will tempt them to compromise and make deals with our future. Whether they are front-runners or also-rans the Reps that are throwing their hats in the ring to run for POTUS need to LOUDLY get the Rep message out especially in regards to the ECONOMY. We have a better plan ( of course any plan is better than NO plan) and the candidates can go a long way in assuring a 2012 victory by getting the word out NOW at every opportunity. ANY compromise on the budget at this point will doom any and all Reps in the election. The MAJORITY in the House should use this opportunity to make sure that NO deals are made through 2012 that aren’t to our liking.

  • sundaycombo

    From the same Post/ABC poll–

    “Romney, though, is the only Republican to run that well; Obama leads all other potential opponents tested in this poll — Palin, Newt Gingrich, Tim Pawlenty, Michele Bachmann and Jon Huntsman. Palin fares worst, trailing Obama by 17 points among all adults, 15 points among registered voters.

    Indeed, despite advancing in GOP primary preference, Palin faces daunting challenges. Sixty-four percent of Americans say they definitely will not vote for her for president, a new high. Sixty-three percent describe her as unqualified for the job, below its peak but still a substantial majority. Even in her own party, among Republicans and Republican-leaning independents, 41 percent rule out voting for her and 39 percent see her as unqualified. ”

    This tells me it’s going to take more than a message to beat Obama in 2012. It’s going to take the right messenger.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    We respect copyright around here.

  • acat

    President Bob Dole proved you can win on an anti-incumbent message alone…

    Mew

  • clarkm

    I read a good viewpoint about this on w ww.whitehousevoice.com

  • YnotNOW

    People especially lie when they say they want to cut government spending, but just don’t cut anything that affects them.

    The bottom line is “they want.”

  • YnotNOW

    People especially lie when they say they want to cut government spending, but just don’t cut anything that affects them.

    The bottom line is “they want.”

  • YnotNOW

    when they agree with the principles and the leader adheres to them strongly and consistently.

    Milquetoast turns off the most partisan as well as the independent moderates.

    That means, don’t be afraid to take a stand, and defend it decisively.

  • YnotNOW

    when they agree with the principles and the leader adheres to them strongly and consistently.

    Milquetoast turns off the most partisan as well as the independent moderates.

    That means, don’t be afraid to take a stand, and defend it decisively.

  • melbedewy

    “In the debt ceiling fight, it appears I was right. As the GOP has held a firm and consistent line insisting on massive spending cuts and entitlement reform,”

    Let’s see how much you will be crowing AFTER the final vote…

  • Kyle-MI

    This is the most difficult fact for politicians and especially Republicans to understand. The majority of voters don’t think issues through, they support positions based more on gut feelings.

    We are seeing this play out in CA with the election of Jerry Brown and keeping Dems in control of the legislature despite running that state into the ground.

    We will probably see it played out in WI where it wouldn’t surprise me if they return control of the state back to the Dems who will promptly follow CA lead down the drain.

  • johnt

    If the Repubs are commencing to cave, remember, they are beneficiaries in D.C. of the largess as well. Chinless Mitch & Big John in the House have careers to protect, rareified air to breath , status, and a public to take for granted. At least for themselves. On the other hand, where are all our Tea Party hell raisers?
    They have a real opportunity, they only need the testicles.

  • ihateliberals

    Mitt is nothing more tan a toned down Obama. He is not a conservative he is a social Republican. he wants to get rid of Obamacare so he can implement Romneycare. The problem is that the people do not want the government involved in our healthcare system at all. Romeny is soft on most conservative policies that will need to be put into place to revive the economy. I’m really thinking that it is just too early to make hard predictions. I think tht once the campaigns really get going around or just after Christmas that the real candidate will be discovered and i don’t think it will be Romney. Romney is McCain 2.0. We are going to need a strong conservative one that isn’t afraid to say the right things because we are going to be up against the biggest Liar this country has ever seen. The classes of 2008 on have been taught nothing but Liberalism in schools. They still think that Obama is the Messiah the salvation of the country. Obama has no intention of leaving office. He wil say and do whatever it takes to win and some of the things he will do might not even be legal but he wil let the courts argue over that. Possession is 9/10ths of the law!

  • sundaycombo

    It seems that one of the best ways to get what you want from many of these folks (especially Boehner) is to provide free golf trips at very high end courses. Maybe the Tea Party groups can organize an outing at Doral or Pinehurst and invite the GOP “leadership”.

    Chances are it will get them a lot more mileage than another rally in DC.

  • Remington_Steele

    of your points are correct. Yet, I’m finding the ‘Romney to implement Romneycare’ a bit silly. What exactly is he going to implement nationally from Romneycare? The mandated coverage? How many state legislatures in this political climate are going to do that?

  • acat

    Unions are a way of life, once you go behind the cheddar curtain, in a way that they just .. aren’t .. outside of the rust belt and some of the decaying urban cores.

    I do think the Unions overplayed their hand this time, the loss of the state supreme court was a major blow. The question is whether they can mount an effective challenge in the recalls .. so far, they seem to be just blowing smoke and hot air, not actually doing anything. I suspect they’re looking to back down without losing any more face than necessary.

    Mew

  • ibelieveinfreedom

    Mitt Romney is not the man for the job of a conservative president. Sure, he looks good, speaks well, can raise money, and probably get the economy going a little bit. But, what else does he have? A lot of liberal “green” ideas like global warming. We don’t need that kind of nonsense. We need to get it right and use those bold colors with a true conservative. Exactly who that will be, I am not sure but it definitely will not be Romney. A better bet maybe Bachmann, whoever it is must be able to stand their ground and not be bullied by the progressives. We can only win when the choice is clear more of the same “in your face” government or a hands off government that respects our freedom and liberty given us by our Creator.

  • http://www4.webng.com/rickbull/lostlucky/ rickbull

    the Republicans are backing a bunch of “fake Democrats” in the recall elections in WI. I sent a screen shot of it to a liberal friend along with a “bwwwaaaahhhhaaaaaaaaaaaa!”

    Reminded me of the Democrat turned Tea Party candidate who skewed the election results in NY-26.

  • http://www4.webng.com/rickbull/lostlucky/ rickbull

    And President John McCain proved that you can be a milquetoast and a wimp and still get elected.

  • sccrenny

    There is a growing movement to convince Jim DeMint to enter the race. Gravitas. Experience. The prototype for the 2010 Tea Party candidates. I dream of a DeMint/Cain ticket!

    conservatives4demint.com