« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

Saxby Chambliss’s Office Says I’m Lying

I read from an email from the Republican Communications Director for the Senate Budget Committee. A listener to my show this morning called Saxby’s Washington Office and they said I was lying.

Well, read for yourself what the Republicans on the Senate Budget Committee say about Saxby Chambliss‘s proposal:

It seems the G6 plan does not balance elimination of deductions with reductions of rates in a way that would prevent a net increase in taxes and that, in fact, a substantially higher net tax burden would likely be imposed.

As a result of such an imbalance, Americans would lose more of their money to the government through losing deductions than they will gain from lower rates. This is common sense to any American. At the end of the year, when an individual is filling out his or her tax return it will be of little consolation to that taxpayer if he or she is paying taxes at a lower statutory tax rate, if their overall amount of taxes goes up.

Specific tax hikes that Americans could face under this approach:

Tax increases that hit American families:

  • Eliminating 2/3 of the home mortgage interest deduction.
  • Eliminating 2/3 of the deduction for charitable contributions.
  • Phasing in a $1,250 average tax increase on health insurance.

Tax increases that make businesses less competitive:

  • Tax rates on capital gains and dividends would nearly double from 15 to 28 percent.
  • Small businesses that create two-thirds of our new jobs would lose the ability to immediately write off their purchases of capital equipment, hurting their ability to expand.
  • Companies that invest in research and development would no longer receive a tax credit.
  • Tax incentives that promote energy production would be eliminated.
  • Eliminates the employer wage credit for activated military reservists.

That’s not me coming up with this stuff. That’s Saxby Chambliss’s Senate Republican colleagues.

COMMENTS

  • Death_of_the_Donkey

    for the free market, as deductions (and other subsidies) distort the market and are nothing more than government picking winners and losers in the economy. Having said that, we should be using the bulk of the savings from the elimination of said deductions to lowering the overall rates and let the broadening of the base and increased economic activity from letting the free market work generate the additional revenues.

  • JSobieski

    nt

  • bigredone

    Nothing passes except Cut, Cap, and Balance which must be done before any other issue.

    Where are you guys coming from? Are you so afraid of the lies of Obama, the Dems, McConnell, et al, that you are willing to throw away everything for “compromise” which to me is capitulation.

    Come on! HOLD THE LINE!

  • Bill S

    It’s making me ill how many out and out cowards we have on “our side”.

    Chambliss, McConnell, Boehner and a bunch of the commenters here need to split off and form the Neville Chamberlain Party, where no capitulation is too much and they always trust the other side. The GOP is turning into a bunch of gutless pansies.

  • jeffreywturner

    Its ridiculous that over 1/3 (actually nearly 1/2) of all workers nothing or receive a check from the government as a result of the deductions and credits in the code.

    While I would tinker with the numbers a bit (for instance eliminate ALL of the mortgage interest deduction and NONE of the charitable giving deduction), the overall goal of broadening the base while lowering rates is a good one. Unfortunately you KNOW we aren’t going to eliminate the real BS credits like the Earned Income Credit and the Child Tax Credit, which are the ones that make out tax code into an entitlement system.

    All that said, as begredone mentions above, the tax reform, as good or bad as it is, needs to be done AFTER a real, meaningful plan for controlling spending (like Cut, Cap and Balance) is enacted.

  • jeffreywturner

    n/t

  • rickdeckard

    It’s a tax hike that let’s politicians claim they cut taxes come election time.

    I can almost hear Chambliss now,”Freakin’ internet…”

  • http://UnitedConservativesofVirginia Cargosquid

    They’re Republicans!

    Just ask the Democrats.

  • carolina

    The reason Clinton and W got economic growth was because both of them cut cap gains taxes. Personal income tax rate changes are not as important for ecconomic growth as the cap gains tax.
    Anyone who raises the cap gains tax will be very sorry.
    The cap gains tax should be zero.

  • http://nerds4cain.com Brookhaven

    I attended the Fair Tax rally where Boortz and Huckabee urged us to vote for Chambliss in the runoff, because othewise the Democrats would have super-majority in the Senate. What difference has having Chambliss in that seat instead of a Democrat made? None. Worse, Chambliss didn’t learn any lesson from almost losing his seat, as he is right back to his old ways.

    The tax code is approximatly 70,000 pages long (nobody knows for sure, it’s so big and complicated). Most of those 70,000 pages involve tax breaks and favors for various industries and special interest groups. So, with 70,000 pages of tax breaks to choose from, which ones does Chambliss suggest we cut? The home mortgage deduction and child tax credits–the two most poplular ones.

    This is the oldest political trick in the book. When faced with tax shortfall, threaten to eliminate the most popular programs as a way to gin up support for tax increases.

    Instead of focusing on the two pages in the tax code that contain the home mortgage deduction and the child tax credit, how about focusing on the other 68,998 pages of tax deductions and loopholes politicians have create over the years for their contributors and special interest groups?

  • jout99

    Time to get someone to take his place here in Georgia. Since he won’t hold the line and support the ones who are doing the heavy lifting and standing up to the liberals. It’s time to say Bye, Bye!

  • jout99

    the rat from Illinois, Dick Durbin. I grew up in Illinois and have seen Durbin in action. Not Pretty. Is Chambliss stupid enough to think he can compromise with him and have it come out well for the American People?