« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

Nobodies Don’t Get Booed

One of my favorite groups in Washington is Heritage Action for America. A major indicator of their success is that the Washington GOP Establishment planted a story in Roll Call about their lack of influence.

The article was clearly planted by House Republican leadership staffers, the same staffers who planted a story about me in the Washington Post at the end of July about how I have no influence and nobody listens to me. Two weeks after these House leadership aides declared, anonymously, that I had no influence I introduced Rick Perry at the RedState Gathering where he declared his candidacy for President.

No influence. It is the same with Heritage Action for America. You know a conservative wields influence when House leadership staffers push out stories about the conservatives’ lack of influence, but are too chicken to go on record about it. Nobodies don’t get booed.

Kicking off the attack was Congressman Geoff Davis of Kentucky (HAFA Score: 63%) telling Ginni Thomas at the Daily Caller that “Heritage Action is a self-interested fundraising organization led by a former Giuliani staffer who is not taking counsel from real conservatives … It is a worthless organization to the conservative movement. I’ll be the first to say that.” Congressman Davis, who opposed social security reform, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac reform, and offshore drilling while supporting farm subsidies, cash for clunkers, green energy subsidies, the AFL-CIO, and NEA spending, was the only person willing to go on record attacking HAFA.

Heritage Action for America is so worthless in fact that House Republican Leadership staffers are forced to give anonymous quotes to Washington newspapers about how no one listens to HAFA. By the way, the sources are most likely from Eric Cantor’s Office (HAFA Score: 60%). I say this rather factually because the Politico was the first to drum up an anti-HAFA piece and a source at the Politico all but flat out told me it was Cantor’s office more than Boehner’s office pushing the line of attack. Same with the “Erickson and RedState have no influence” story at the Washington Post.

Not that Boehner’s office has clean hands, but his office doesn’t yet seem to be the driving force behind these stories. In fact, with the Politico story, which substantially changed from its original form, the key motivator was a feeling among some leadership staff that Heritage Action for America is staffed by people who went to Washington and decided it was more important to fight for conservative causes than to sell out for the “greater good” of the Republican Team.

Frankly, in my experience, conservatives who sell out their values are usually the most embittered, angry people in Washington — full of self-loathing every time they look in the mirror and realize, in the quiet of the night, what sell outs to their own values they’ve become. But unable to hate themselves, they hate those who haven’t sold out instead.

Outside of the psychology of these hit pieces, what is interesting is that while, like with me, leadership aides are unwilling to go on the record to smear HAFA, congressmen are willing to go on record to defend HAFA. Congressman Jim Jordan, leader of the conservatives in the House, (HAFA Score: 96%) took to their defense as did South Carolina Congressman Mick Mulvaney (HAFA Score: 95%), and my Congressman, Austin Scott of Georgia, (HAFA Score: 80%) has used Heritage Action For America’s support on legislation as a key selling point for why other members of Congress should sign on to legislation.

The latest “they’ve got no influence” story came after House leaders were able to get a highway bill through with a voice vote when Heritage Action had scored against it. The reaction by members of Congress and the backpedaling of leadership (and of Senators) on this legislation suggests that instead of having no influence, Republican Congressmen are scared to death of HAFA and fear not only being on record against them, but also being in opposition to them.

Like with RedState, these hit jobs from Republicans come because Republican Leaders in Washington, who campaigned throughout 2010 saying they’d learned the lessons of 2006, are being proven squishy and resent their conservative base holding them accountable for betraying the trust not just of the Republican base, but of the American people.

COMMENTS

  • http://moelane.com/ Moe Lane

    When the Democrats tried to re-segregate the DC school system a couple of years ago, Heritage was out there fighting them. Successfully, I might add.

    Moe Lane

    (Full disclosure: I have been known to have a glass of wine with various and sundry of their fellows, from time to time.)

  • YnotNOW

    Claiming HAFA is not influential is kind of like saying that the Sun gives light but no heat.

    The Heritage Foundation is one of the most influential think-tanks in politicial ideas. They created HAFA specifically to leverage that gravitas to apply pressure for specific actions – giving “heat” to the “light.” To claim that the influential position of Heritage Foundation does not lend influence to Heritage Action is absurd on its face.

    (full disclosure – I’m a proud member of HAFA)

  • YnotNOW

    Cantor has developed a rather schizophrenic reputaiton – conservative sometimes and “establishment sell-out” other times. And it seems that this may be due to the influence of various members of his staff – some of whom are conservative and some of whom are [redacted] not.

    But personnel is policy, so if Cantor hires and keeps them on staff, then he is responsible for those personnel he chose as a reflection of the policies he supports.

  • johnt

    Pretty much how it goes, commitment isn’t quite the word for it. Rather like deciding which itch to scratch first. A Democrat will suffocate you with a legislative horror in a year, a GOP moderate will take two or three years. They both share the same idea that they have an inbuilt superiority based on that mess known as the federal government, & their own place in Washington, where the Wise & Saintly tread.
    The rest of us wallow in a vast pigsty, not knowing the arcane mysteries of our priestly elite, some of whom deign to read the NY Times and the New Republic. We little folk should only be so graced.

  • Locked and Loaded

    The ACU gives Davis a 92 lifetime rating, and Cantor gets a 100.

    Kind of a glaring difference with HAFA’s 63 and 60, respectively.

    I guess the HAFA scores don’t set too well with these entrenched bureaucrats who have gotten used to a more cushy rating.

  • http://moelane.com/ Moe Lane

    :)

  • YnotNOW

    By the way, here is an article that agrees with you, me, EE, and the influence of HAFA:

    http://www.rollcall.com/news/gop_blows_past_heritage_key_vote-208678-1.html

  • YnotNOW

    Democrats believe in bigger government and control over your life. Republicans believe in smaller government and personal control over your own life.

    Just because the Repbulicans, as humans, are prone to compromise their beliefs in seeking personal power and aggrandizement, does not mean that they are the same as Democrats.

    With Republicans who go astray, we can appeal to their better conscience to bring them back into the fold (sometimes – other times we have to replace them). With Democrats we have no such option – we MUST vote them out!
    :)

  • edintexas

    “Republicans believe in smaller government and personal control over your own life.”

    As a generalization, that is correct. But it certainly doesn’t apply to all Republicans, as you obviously recognize “(sometimes ? other times we have to replace them)”. There’s even an occasional aberration on the Dem side, the proverbial exception which proves (i.e. tests as the meaning of proves) the rule.

  • YnotNOW

    not all Republicans actually believe in Conservative ideals and not all Democrats believe in liberal ideals. And fewer have the courage and integrity to hold to those ideals when facing temptation or pushback.

    But there is hope! :)

  • ihateliberals

    the in-fighting of Republicans is doing the destruction job for them. The Democrats don’t have to spend a penny attacking Republicans we are killing ourselves for them. If it isn’t Karl Rove it is some other RINO attacking the Tea Party or conservative Radio Host Rush Limbaugh, or Erick Erickson or any number of conservative organizations . If we don’t get our act together soon it isn’t going to matter who the nominee is because we wil already be beaten. It is time for Michele, Perry, Romney etc etc to stop talking down one another and tell me what they intend todo for America and the Economy and how they intend on Beating Obama. I don’t care if they don’t like each other but shut up about it I don’t care.