« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

Norman Ornstein to the Press Corps: Stop Covering the GOP Fairly to Stop Their Success

Nothing says marginal extremism like holding the US House, most statehouses, most governorships, and a plurality of national party ID.

“It is a soft form of the liberal fascism about which I’ve been warning. The GOP must be painted as extremist by the press, their point of view must be painted as fringe, and they must be shut up because they are too damn successful.

Norman Ornstein is the in house pet liberal at the American Enterprise Institute who they let out of his cage once in a while to lament the free market, conservatives, and the like. I’m not sure why groups like the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute ever allow their supposed scholars to team up with the Brookings Institute, but whenever they do it results in intellectual underwear stains for both organizations.

In today’s quasi-bipartisan inane ramblings, Norman Ornstein of the American Enterprise Institute and Thomas Mann of the Brookings Institute want the Washington Press Corps to know the GOP is extremist, destroying the country, and they should all stop paying attention to the GOP or treating them with balance.

Nothing says marginal extremism like holding the US House, most statehouses, most governorships, and a plurality of national party ID.

Now, we know their target audience is the press corps because they write

Our advice to the press: Don’t seek professional safety through the even-handed, unfiltered presentation of opposing views. Which politician is telling the truth? Who is taking hostages, at what risks and to what ends?

This is a growing trend among left-wingers. They have not won the arguments. In fact, Ornstein and Mann take 1,998 words to make sure we know the left has been wholly unsuccessful in its agenda. So what Ornstein and Mann resort to in response is

The GOP has become an insurgent outlier in American politics. It is ideologically extreme; scornful of compromise; unmoved by conventional understanding of facts, evidence and science; and dismissive of the legitimacy of its political opposition.

It’s kind of like how they refused to compromise on their healthcare plan and insisted on parliamentary gimmicks to ram it through Congress, cooked the books to make it look like it would cut the deficit, chose to ignore facts not in dispute since Adam Smith wrote Wealth of Nations back in the 1700′s, and tried to paint their opposition as wanting to put women back in kitchens, blacks back in chains, and old people in the grave.

Oh wait . . . that’d be the Democrats who did that when they controlled Congress and the White House at or near filibuster proof levels for two years and did nothing to fix the economy, but chose instead to wreck private healthcare in America.

Ornstein and Mann are all upset at Allen West for comparing the Progressive Caucus in the House to the Communist Party — an accurate comparison considering how the groups are so closely aligned in their publicly stated agenda.

For 1,998 words, Ornstein and Mann chronicle Republican successes since 1994 and view it all as bad. The drive to reduce government is viewed as bad government. Republican ideas are viewed as unworthy of consideration or fair treatment by the press.

This, in fact, is the point to pay attention to in it all.

The American Press Corps leans left and does so objectively. Consider, in the past few years, the number of journalists who went to work for Barack Obama. Consider, in the past few years, the number of journalists who have moved from left-wing organizations into the mainstream or who have spouses who work for left-wing groups. I can think, offhand, of a number of very prominent journalists in Washington who are married to pro-abortion advocates, DNC and left-wing political operatives, etc. The press does lean left.

The way the press has tried to get around its biases is to state both positions as fairly as possible. Now, even so the press fails miserably often intentionally putting a female pro-abortion activist against a male pro-life activist even though there is a ready supply of female pro-life advocates ready to go on TV.

But the press takes the approach they ridicule Fox News for taking — being fair and balanced. Left-winger says X and cites these facts. Right-winger says Y and cites these facts. You decide. They’ll reveal their biases in who they use for those facts and how they give treatment to them.

Consequently, left-wingers are upset. Their ideas have been rather unsuccessful since around Ronald Reagan’s election and have been declining ever since. Now we’re starting to see a new trend in journalism.

First is the belief Ornstein and Mann peddle:

The GOP has become an insurgent outlier in American politics. It is ideologically extreme; scornful of compromise; unmoved by conventional understanding of facts, evidence and science; and dismissive of the legitimacy of its political opposition.

They cite a liberal’s research that conservatives think differently from liberals and make the blanket determination that the liberals’ “facts” are the real facts.

An example would be taxes. To the simple minded liberal, raising taxes increases revenue to the federal government in an amount capable of solving our debt problem. They ignore that cutting taxes can generate enough economic growth to generate new revenue into the treasury as we saw during the Reagan years. Liberals view the Reagan deficits as proof tax cuts don’t work and ignore the excess growth in government defense spending during the time.

Another example would be global warming. Conservatives and the American public at large have failed to buy into politically correct notions of global warming and the left views this as a terrible thing.

The list is pretty extensive and those are just two examples. Because conservatives have been so successful, Ornstein and Mann first must label them out of touch with facts and science and then do what the left has been trying since Barack Obama took office — silence dissent.

We understand the values of mainstream journalists, including the effort to report both sides of a story. But a balanced treatment of an unbalanced phenomenon distorts reality. If the political dynamics of Washington are unlikely to change anytime soon, at least we should change the way that reality is portrayed to the public.

Our advice to the press: Don’t seek professional safety through the even-handed, unfiltered presentation of opposing views. Which politician is telling the truth? Who is taking hostages, at what risks and to what ends?

Also, stop lending legitimacy to Senate filibusters by treating a 60-vote hurdle as routine. The framers certainly didn’t intend it to be. Report individual senators’ abusive use of holds and identify every time the minority party uses a filibuster to kill a bill or nomination with majority support.

Look ahead to the likely consequences of voters’ choices in the November elections. How would the candidates govern? What could they accomplish? What differences can people expect from a unified Republican or Democratic government, or one divided between the parties?

It is a soft form of the liberal fascism about which I’ve been warning. The GOP must be painted as extremist by the press, their point of view must be painted as fringe, and they must be shut up because they are too damn successful.

The sad thing is, there are a number of Republican Leaders in Washington who agree and wish conservatives would just send them money, but otherwise shut up.

COMMENTS

  • APA Guy

    When Democrats bleat about “fair” treatment of Republicans in the media, you know something great is about to happen.

    But I concur with your warning to the GOP establishment, Erick. Don’t run from us, Beltway boys. The country is dying for conservative solutions to this socialist quagmire, but it will turn from you if you don’t choose the same path that gave us historic victories in the 2010 midterms. We need only hold true to the traditions, principles and values that made American great to take her back again.

  • gwalt

    Like I have said many times, let’s go after the media. Call them out in ads and by name and face. This is our chance to level the playing field. The Liberal Fascists account for 17% or so of the country but are controlling the narrative. Let’s expose the morning “news” anchors then the evening ones then on to 60 Minutes ( of lies). What are they going to do, attack us?
    They already are.

  • spinoneone

    something akin to calling out the Brown shirts back in the day. I wonder what else 0 has up his sleve. How many Executive Orders could be issued under one of the 20,000+ criminal statutes that already exist that would aim to stifle freedom of press and freedom of speech? What happens under NDAA 1021 et seq if 0 declares the “Tea Party” a terrorist organization?

  • uncmike

    Eric, I totally agree with this statement: “I?m not sure why groups like the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute ever allow their supposed scholars to team up with the Brookings Institute, but whenever they do it results in intellectual underwear stains for both organizations.”

    Why anyone would team up with the usual shills like Ornstein and Mann, and their “think” tanks is a mystery to me. It only gives cover to those who have no intellectually honest arguments in favor of their political positions. As this piece, and other posters have noticed, Ornstein and Mann have it ass-backwards when it comes to press fairness. The fact that they are hawking this line suggests that, indeed, the left is scared. And that goes for too many “Republicans” in the House and Senate as well–who fear the “Tea Party.”

  • jdbird

    . . . interviewed on NPR this morning. I was yelling at the radio. It was unhinged and offensive. As Moe Lane is fond of saying, these guys would like to see us all die in a fire.

  • jomo2009

    This should also include doing some “oppo research” on a number of reporters and commentators. Let’s take a look and see what happens to be in their closets.

  • http://patriotpowerplay.blogspot.com/ mirac777

    The GOP has become an insurgent outlier in American politics. It is ideologically extreme; scornful of compromise; unmoved by conventional understanding of facts….. let’s change the last 3 words there to reflect the truth. The GOP is unmoved by..the liberal twisting of the truth and the rewriting of history. Period.

  • http://patriotpowerplay.blogspot.com/ mirac777

    the TEA Party, due to their taking a stand for a limited government and reduced spending is already on the DHS domestic terrorist list. Only in Liberal America could that be called democracy.

  • Section9

    This is battlefield shaping by liberal analysts who don’t want Deviationism to develop in the news media and want it to reliably echo Democratic talking points.

    I wouldn’t be surprised if this came out of the White House.

  • celador2

    The media are mouthpieces for the DNC and they have a farm system that just keeps giving. Everyone goes to college nowaday and all reporters get higher degrees. By the time students graduate often with a Master’s degree in journalism they take jobs at papers owned by liberals like president AP and slant stories just as Ornstein calls for. Who, when, where and what can be altered for ponit of view reports. They start with a slant and work to be fair

    Point- of -view journalism and advocacy journalism are alive and kicking in schools of journalism. Rabid tone, PC, multicultural quotas, anti Christian themes run through its tendencies.

    Who ever said life was fair?
    Ah come on, as Pres Reagan would say.

    Our work is cut out for us whatever that may be, It has been made harder by these open calls to throw challenger conservatives on defensive and not to cover with scruitiny the status quo and incumbents.

    Silencing dissent is fascism and its not soft,

    cel

  • richsr7

    My opinion
    How do we tell/
    America is in a bad situation; our politics have come out into the open; and it looks evil!
    The Obama administration seems to have approved of the disparaging of conservative women in politics. Sarah Palin, Michelle Bachman, all conservative women in politics and most recently Anne Romney! Yet Mister Obama waited ?till just yesterday to come out against it! Yesterday he started speaking out against this practice! What took him so long?!
    Mr Obama seems to have been approving of this! America is getting sick and tired of this attitude.

    I think what America needs now is the other side of Politics; that?s right a Conservative point of view.
    We already have FOX news ?Fair and Balanced?, now we need a right side to balance it out.
    Who is the author of fair and balanced???

  • celador2

    A republic is best served with a press that holds the govrnment and those in power to scruitiny. US has had thousands of papers over time and most were dedicated to news coverage with the press as an outsider.

    Cetralization and consolidation of papers and TV stations , absemtee ownership have rendered point of view to close to 100 not just liberal but DNC. They are mouthpieces for Democrats.

    Today mainstream corporate media attack critics of DNC and Obama openly and without shame.

    Mainstream media are able to do what Soviet Union never could as well for one party government, support the government if Democrats. SU was a one party system that fell due to market forces.

    When a Republican is in office major media are so slanted and hyper-critical they never cover strong points and distort news for the public. The Katie Couric intervieiw with Sarah Palin is an example 2008. Palin wanted to discuss her history in energy, Couric played gottcha.

    Had Couric been fair and informed the large viewing public about Palin’s work in energy maybe Palin would be VP today.

    .

  • http://conservativemormonmom.blogspot.com ew88

    If we could get them to pass such a thing, of course. Term limits may do a world of good at getting the GOP leadership to agree with the populace! Democrat too, for that matter. Until then, we’ll have to vote ‘em out of office.

  • rightlane1111

    http://www.washingtontimes.com/blog/inside-politics/2012/apr/30/new-obama-slogan-has-long-ties-marxism-socialism/

    I’d try the html thing…but I have a problem with it. Please read

  • celador2

    There is much more media indignation, mostly NY and AP of NYPDs monitoring Muslims after 9/11 than any outrage over hostile tea party coverage.

    Media are critical of NYPD and Tea party.

    The 9/11 hyjackers fit the terror profile Ray Kelly followed. All were male, young, Muslim, educated and visa overstays. Police ComRay Kelly has kept NYC safe from terror threats from Times Square bombers to threat unknown since 9-11. Media mob went after him for monitoring Muslims as individuals and in communities..

    When DHS listed a profile of domestic terror threats not one major media outlet complained. DHS said domestiic terrorists were more dangerous than foreign. But they described limited government advocates not homegrown Islamists.

    The lawabiding, neat Teaparty is the number one challenge to big government liberals, and that limited low tax profile got a DHS terrorist watch list tag!

    Ray Kelly looks like a good shot for mayor NY on GOP ticket 2013 except for the rain cloud by liberal media on his monitoring Muslims. In their hearts they appreciate his work to keep them safe in terror target number one NYC,

    But Ray Kelly may run as a Republian SO IS IN LINE FOR SPECIAL SCORN.

    The media may have overplayed their advocacy for Democrats on this one.

    .

  • johnt

    Beneath a too thin layer of self control, of the strain of seeming civilized, is the cry for repression, the single voice, opinion, and policy. Utterly totalitarian in it’s barbaric impulse and until The One only to be guessed at, but now, and not just with the fanatic Ornstein, out of it’s slime and in the open. Normal People, take note and be warned.

  • annie54

    “I would remind you that extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice. And let me remind you also that moderation in the pursuit of justice is no virtue.”

    Barry Goldwater during the Republican National Convention in 1964 in his acceptance speech for nomination.

    The establishment did a number on him, also. Even then – 48 years ago.

  • funwithknives

    Is this not the most telling incident to come down the pike in recent history? All it needs is a 1/4 profile of Barry {doing his Mussolini thing} with Lenin in the backround, applauding.

    Did Barry ignore his advisors, on this one too?

    Let’s get the blowback started, boys and girls…..
    {you know you want to}

  • cwfoster

    The GOP establishment turned their backs on us before the votes were full counted in 2010! I’ll hold my nose and vote for Mittens, but afterwards how about following the British example and forming a CONSERVATIVE Party?

  • APA Guy

    nt

  • acat

    fighting against each other while the Liberals ruled the roost.

    Mew

  • olliek

    This has the potential of being a great article based on its subject, however, there are so many disturbing errors and such sloppy writing, the impact is completely lost. Sorry, but you need some editors to polish these up. I realize time is short, and publication is virtually instantaneous, and at the risk of sounding like a writing coach, you need to critically reread what gets posted here and read by hundreds of thousands or millions (hopefully) of people. You lost me at the paragraph about the Laffer Curve that you never mentioned regarding increased tax revenues with lower marginal tax rates. Please.

  • tnguy

    We’re losing as well, Cat. I don’t just mean the party, but the country as well. It should be obvious by now that continuing to do things just as we have simply will not work.

    Perhaps others simply don’t see the situation as dire as I do.

  • acat

    when there’s a historical gem of a fixer-upper for sale on the lot next door?

    Take the party indoors!

    http://theprecinctproject.wordpress.com/

    Get involved, take the GOP out of the hands of the establishment. At the risk of misinterpreting what is evidently your holy book – bloom where you’re planted.

    Mew

  • powertothepeople

    no one here needs your critique, Erick does not need your writing style opinion, and Erick already reaches more people than you ever will.

    By the way, he is the head editor of the site and is in no need of any of your editing. When you have written your first diary and millions read it, hell, when you have made more than two comments, maybe, just maybe someone will give a damn about what you think.

    Moron.

  • christiandystopian

    The GOP is extremist. The Patriot Act, passed with overwhelming Democrat support effectively ended the United States of America & turned the Nation into “The Homeand Once Known As America.”
    The NDAA of 2012, passed with overwhelming GOP support solidified & defined what had already been set in motion.
    The influential members of both parties are a wholly owned subsidiary of Corporate Facism. The less important ones, like the President are just rented for awhile.

  • gekster

    Who is owned by what.

  • gekster

    Will you answer?

  • Common_Cents

    They are getting bolder and bolder in their bias by the day. The GOP better have a serious discussion on formulating a strategy to counter this immediately.

    Why does the GOP continually bail the biased media boat rather than start talking about a way to plug the damn hole?

  • ww2nd95

    Honestly I think it’s up to us to vote these people out of office. If we’re willing to continue to vote them in over and over, it’s on us. My problem with term limits is, it would take experienced politicians, and even though career politicians can be corrupt, experience matters, so when you replace that experience over and over.. I think it would lead to bad law after bad law.

    I understand the sentiment of having term limits, I just don’t think it’s feasible.

  • gwbramhall

    I made a similar comment the other day. It seems EE needs
    another set of eyes to read his posts before he hits the send
    key. In this era of instant communications, it is too easy to
    get sloppy. I wish they had spell check on these sites. It
    would help me a lot.