Back in June, we reported that California Congressman Brad Sherman (D) was circulating a letter to his fellow Democrats to introduce legislation to repeal “Right-to-Work” laws in 22 states. Now, with less than a month before the mid-term elections and five weeks before a lame-duck session in Congress, Sherman has introduced legislation to eliminate state Right to Work laws all across America.
Currently, there are 22 states in the U.S. that have laws where workers who are employed at companies that are unionized have a choice whether or not to join or pay the union. These states are known as Right-to-Work states.

On the other hand, in the 28 Non-Right-to-Work states (also called forced-dues states), it is legal for a union to negotiate a “union (income) security clause” that requires all workers covered by the union to pay the union dues or ‘agency fees’ as a condition of employment. If the workers refuse to pay the union, under a “union (income) security clause,” the union can have them fired from their jobs.
As background, in 1947, Congress amended the National Labor Relations Act with the Taft-Hartley Amendments which, among other things, gave states the right to establish “Right-to-Work” laws. Until the Taft-Hartley Amendments, from 1935 to 1947, private-sector workers in all 50 could be required to pay dues to a union or, if not, be fired from their jobs. The ability of states to have Right-to-Work laws is contained in a single paragraph within the National Labor Relations Act (Section 14 [b]), which states:
(b) [Agreements requiring union membership in violation of State law] Nothing in this Act [subchapter] shall be construed as authorizing the execution or application of agreements requiring membership in a labor organization as a condition of employment in any State or Territory in which such execution or application is prohibited by State or Territorial law.
As a result of this one section being inserted into the 1947 amendments, states (through their legislatures) could determine whether or not to be a Right-to-Work state, or a forced-dues state. Therefore, the removal of this one section would make all 50 states forced-dues states, giving unions the ability to have workers fired for not paying union dues or fees.
From Congressman Sherman’s website [emphasis added]:
Today, Congressman Brad Sherman announced the introduction of dramatic legislation that would eliminate so-called “right-to-work” laws, which was applauded by AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka. Sherman has a strong record of supporting working men and women and earned a 100% rating from the AFL-CIO.
Right-to-work laws require unions to represent non dues-paying employees, thereby undermining the basic premise and promise of union membership and creating free riders – people who are exempt from paying their fair share. Right-to-work laws create different standards for union membership in different states. This results not only in confusion over the regulation of union membership, but also places a higher cost on worker representation in labor rights states.
[snip]
“I do not believe that there should be a right to be treated unfairly or to endure unnecessary restrictions. Right-to-work laws strip unions of their legitimate ability to collect dues, even when the worker is covered by a union-negotiated collective bargaining agreement. This forces unions to use their time and members’ dues to provide benefits to free riders who are exempt from paying their fair share,” said Congressman Brad Sherman. “These laws are harmful to states like California, which allows labor unions to organize, because now we have to compete with the race to the bottom as our companies have to compete with those where the workers would like better wages, working conditions and benefits but are unable to organize to get them.”
“With the introduction of legislation banning so-called right-to-work, Congressman Sherman has once again demonstrated his strong commitment to working families,” said Richard Trumka, president of the AFL-CIO. “Right-to-work laws undermine the economy and weaken workers’ ability to bargain for better working conditions, which translates into lower pay and fewer benefits for everyone.”
While Brad Sherman’s statement about workers in Right-to-Work states not having the right to organize is patently false (the National Labor Relations Act does not discriminate on workers’ rights to organize in a Right to Work state), he is accurate that his state of California has been losing jobs. However, there are a multitude of factors that have contributed to California’s demise—many of which were, ironically, caused by the unions that Sherman has so endeared himself.
Although Congressman Sherman introduced this legislation back in 2008, it had little chance of succeeding. However, with the mid-term elections and a lame-duck Congress following, the chances that Democrats (who are taking hundreds of millions from unions), it is possible that Democrats could vote to end Right-to-Work states.
As a result, now is as good a time as any to get Democrats (in both Right-to-Work states and forced-union states) to state their positions on whether they support an end to workers’ right to work.
[hat-tip: Projections, Inc.]
__________________
“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.” Thomas Paine, December 23, 1776
Cross-posted on BigGovernment.com and LUR.
For more news and views on today’s unions, go to LaborUnionReport.com.

Jeff Emanuel
Because unemployment wasn't high enough?
tngal (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 7:16PM EDT (link)That must be the reason. Well, Tennessee won’t stand for this. Things are about to get nasty.
NJ lost its right to work law.
mirac777 (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 7:04AM EDT (link)Wonder if Christie is aware of that fact? Time to get out the executive order pen. ( or force the issue with the State leglislature)
Take a look at that map. The most financially troubled states are the ones stupid enough to let the Unions in with this scam! Cardcheck is the next piece of the Marxist puzzle these liberals will try to get done during the lameduck session too.
With the collapsing of the Auto Industry directly due to Unions demands, I would think that people would learn their lesson.Yet now America is letting the Unions into our Gov’t at a nasty pace. As if it wasnt incompetent enough as it was!
United we stand…. Divided we fall.. into the pits of Socialism.
Expect to get more of these "stick to the Americans"
throwback59 Monday, October 4th at 7:17PM EDT (link)vengeance bills from these low-lifes.
If you look closely at pictures of the bespectacled Sherman, you can see the puppet strings.
Is it just my imagination, or.......
maindependent Monday, October 4th at 7:17PM EDT (link)Most of the orange states on the map above don’t seem to have been as severely affected by the current economic malaise as the blue ones.
I am not a trained rocket scientist, but, perhaps there is a lesson buried somewhere in that map.
Noooooo!
Kayla Monday, October 4th at 7:23PM EDT (link)We don’t want Detroit brought to TX.
I'd get a rope
banzaibob (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:25PM EDT (link)But hanging is too good for that clown.
Prefiero morir de pie que vivir de rodillas
It’s better to die upon your feet than to live upon your knees!
Emiliano Zapata
but
pamela1631 (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 10:00PM EDT (link)gelding isn’t.
This republic was not established by cowards; and cowards will not preserve it. ~~Elmer Davis
I am stone forged from the fires of creation into flesh ~~Pamela1631
The greatest civilization is one where all citizens are equally armed and can only be persuaded, never forced.~~Maj. L. Caudill, USMC (Ret.)
I think somebody already beat you to it...
audax (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 3:03AM EDT (link)…LOL
Audeamus pro audere est facere
To be drawn and quartered
dmccracken Tuesday, October 5th at 1:35PM EDT (link)Is too good for them.
What I want to see is a government that will take these people to task for their traitorous conduct.
Tis of no surprise
Deskpilot (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 7:24PM EDT (link)that a union lap-dog Democrap could think of introducing this type of federal legislation designed to circumvent the 10th amendment of the Constitution which his is sworn to uphold. Looks like another D>R fip for the house. I’m sure that Sen. Harry Reid (D-NV, speaker of the unions) will find a way to fast track this while excluding legislation to freeze current tax rates for 5 years.
If you can read this, thank a teacher. If you can still read it in English, You’re Welcome
Deskpilot, AM(H)1 (AW), USN (Ret)
Join the RedState Strike Force
Brad Sherman = a zero with zero integrity
fpete13527 (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 7:30PM EDT (link)GOP needs to start opening their mouth and sound biting this to hell.
As LUR said, force the Dems to show that they are going to dictate to all workers that they must join the DemComm Socialist Union or they will not be allowed to work……..or exist.
Make the DemComm candidates go on record across the board starting with their plan to force any worker to join the DemComm Socialist Union.
A solid republican amendment
natlanthem (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 7:30PM EDT (link)would require all unions to have 4 year jubiliees … meaning every four years require a secret ballot election to see if workers still want the representation. In the event of less than 50% even participating in the election, the default would be to eliminate the union.
But then there would be no unions...
dmccracken Tuesday, October 5th at 1:37PM EDT (link)Think of all the money the dems would lose!
All states should be Right to Work
gypsy Monday, October 4th at 7:43PM EDT (link)I have always wondered how it can be legal to require a person to join a union and pay dues. Has this ever been challenged? It sounds like a violation of basic freedoms to me.
Easy. They already think they are part of the government.
momma Monday, October 4th at 8:04PM EDT (link)Unions (the leadership, that is) think they are a quasi-government agency now…they give $$ to election campaigns, they get support from incumbents, they write legislation like this at federal and state levels and work to get it passed, they write regulations and work to enforce them.
I’m sure they’d love to be on the legitimate government payroll, as well as the underground one…oh, wait…
It's the same logic that would mandate the purchase of health insurance under Obamacare...nt
ddstrain (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 10:28AM EDT (link)China must be supporting these democrats
izoneguy (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 7:52PM EDT (link)Why else would the socialists keep pushing jobs overseas?
We won’t have any money left tp pay China back.
Maybe they will take our socialists in trade?
I would love to see Barack & Michelle working in a sweat shop over in Bejing for 3 bucks a day.
Those who had once simpered: “I don’t want to destroy the rich, I only want to seize a little of their surplus to help the poor, just a little, they’ll never miss it!” – then, later, had snapped: “The tycoons can stand being squeezed; they’ve amassed enough to last them for three generations” – then, later, had yelled: “Why should the people suffer while businessmen have reserves to last a year?” – now were screaming: “Why should we starve while some people have reserves to last a week?” – Atlas Shrugged
This is an opportunity
Change Jar Conservative (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 7:58PM EDT (link)Get Democrats on the record over this and get those pictures into commercials.
********
Formerly know as “Oz” in these parts
I ran the numbers
mustango (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:06PM EDT (link)Just doing a quick and dirty spreadsheeting of the most recent state-by-state unemployment figures, I found the right-to-work states have an aggregate unemployment rate of about 9.15%, while the rest of the country has an unemployment rate of nearly 9.9%. And that’s with the worst state, Nevada, falling on the right-to-work side of the numbers.
“I just miss — I miss being anonymous.” — Barack Obama
I fully sympathize, Mr. President. I miss you being anonymous too.
With the coming Governor elections
Scope (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:12PM EDT (link)and the Republicans looking to win the majority of states, this will never happen at the state level. Couple that with the Union Rally in support of the Communists this weekend, the now educated population of how the Unions are bankrupting every state, the fact that Union Workers, at least at the Federal Government level, are paid something like twice what the private sector workers are earning, and, you have a bill that is more than dead. If the Progressives pass this abomination in a lame duck, it will survive about as long as it takes to seat the new Republicans in DC in January. If that doesn’t work, in DC, the majority of Republican states will take care of it, just as they are fighting Ocare, and, the EPA Endangerment Finding, which is about to get worse. This is a no go.
Scope, I agree...Governors matter.
lineholder (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:04PM EDT (link)The Feds could take all these various programs to the hilt, but if we get the right Governors in place, this could make a huge amount of difference.
I’d love to see them implement watchdog and productivity/efficiency groups on the state level to oversee fed activities in the state. Keep federal activity limited. Slow them down a bit.
Anything along those lines that might limit federal power and control…I’d say go for it.
for sure lineholder
Scope (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:49PM EDT (link)our relatively new VA Atty. General has been on top of the fed takeover of Ocare and the EPA. The Governors can take matters into their own hands with fighting the feds, as was seen in AZ with Brewer, even if the Atty’s Gen. refuse to do it.
Cucinelli? He's the "Chris Christie" of Atty Gen's. [nt]
lineholder (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:55PM EDT (link)Yup- Cuccinelli doesn't back down
Scope (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 10:03PM EDT (link)n/t
Consider yourself blessed on that one, Scope.
lineholder (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 10:09PM EDT (link)I live just south of you in NC and our situation here is horrriiiibbbblleee!! I’m in Watts’ district. This district is as gerrymandered as they come.
We are seeing some bright spots on the horizon in my state, like Pantano and Elmers, etc.
Looking forward to Nov. 2nd
The I-85 corridor has been hit especially hard...
rbdwiggins (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 12:03AM EDT (link)Too much reliance on the textile industry in the past, and on commercial construction in the present.
I’m lucky. It was easier for the Northwest Piedmont to transition away from tobacco and dairy farming, and Virginia Foxx is about as conservative as they come.
“Well, the trouble with our liberal friends is not that they are ignorant, but that they know so much that isn’t so.” – Ronald Reagan
Your facts are dead on the money.
lineholder (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 12:09AM EDT (link)I will say that in the immediate area where I live, the demographics are changing drastically and have been for the past two years. I don’t know what kind of difference this might make the next time district elections take place, but I’m hopeful all the same.
The Free Rider Argument - a Question
Locke (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:16PM EDT (link)“Right-to-work laws require unions to represent non dues-paying employees”
What prevents an employer and a union from contracting with regard only to the union members, with one or more other contracts for the non-union employees?
Under current law, because the union is the...
LaborUnionReport (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 11:45PM EDT (link)“exclusive bargaining agent” over the entire bargaining unit — members and non-members alike. Per the National Labor Relations Board:
http://www.nlrb.gov/nlrb/shared_files/brochures/basicguide.pdf
“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.” Thomas Paine December 23, 1776
In any compromise between food and poison, it is only death that can win. In any compromise between good and evil, it is only evil that can profit.-Ayn Rand
LaborUnionReport.com
The Most Comprehensive Source for
News & Views on Today’s Labor Unions.
Follow @laborunionrpt
Thanks.
Locke (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 7:09AM EDT (link)So those who are concerned about free riders ought to support changing that, which is the real source of the “problem”.
Nay, for them the problem is that they are not lemmings
BA Cyclone (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 10:41AM EDT (link)‘Why aren’t YOU a lemming and following the union lead’ is what it looks like to me.
Here they have a sheet posted on the union communications board with the names of every hourly employee not paying dues. “Freerider list”
And some people wear T-shirts with a particular dated list of said employees on the back, with the words GET OFF MY BACK at the top.
Classy.
“If Congress can do whatever in their discretion can be done by money, and will promote the General Welfare, the Government is no longer a limited one, possessing enumerated powers, but an indefinite one, subject to particular exceptions.” — James Madison
“Electing Republicans who don’t have the courage of their convictions may be easier in some circumstances, but it won’t save our country.” — Jim DeMint
BA Cyclone’s blog
BA Cyclone on Twitter
They are hypocrites, complaining about a problem they have created
Locke (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 1:23PM EDT (link)And the “freerider list”, etc., sounds to me like an unfair labor practice.
Dear scumbag congressman
texasproud (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:20PM EDT (link)Dear Brad Sherman, get the hell away from the rest of the country that has a clue on what a functioning economy looks like. California screwed up on their own, don’t export your misery because the rest of us are not stupid enough to buy your garbage. Texas likes to have jobs, and not be forced to do that slimeball Trumka, who belongs in prison not in front of a microphone, bidding. Go back to the whole you came from, and hopefully your neighbor will move a boulder over it so you don’t ever surface again
$1.6 Trillion deficit, $800 million to Hamas to rebuild West Bank, kowtowing to the whims and demands of Hugo Chavez, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, and Raul Castro, and bowing before a Saudi Prince. I guess that’s ‘Change we can believe in’
http://practicalgopvoter.blogspot.com/
California's sinking like a lead weight...
LaborUnionReport (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:29PM EDT (link)This could actually be a separate post, but if Mr. Sherman thinks Right to Work states are his problem, he needs to look at the unions inside his state first:
Watch the latest video at video.foxbusiness.com
“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.” Thomas Paine December 23, 1776
In any compromise between food and poison, it is only death that can win. In any compromise between good and evil, it is only evil that can profit.-Ayn Rand
LaborUnionReport.com
The Most Comprehensive Source for
News & Views on Today’s Labor Unions.
Follow @laborunionrpt
Nvmd. The video didn't embed. Sorry. nt.
LaborUnionReport (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:30PM EDT (link)“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.” Thomas Paine December 23, 1776
In any compromise between food and poison, it is only death that can win. In any compromise between good and evil, it is only evil that can profit.-Ayn Rand
LaborUnionReport.com
The Most Comprehensive Source for
News & Views on Today’s Labor Unions.
Follow @laborunionrpt
Hey, LUR, the laugh may be on Sherman and his union buddies this time.
lineholder (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:59PM EDT (link)CA high court unanimously approved Schwarzie’s furloughs today.
Gotta’ love those Californians…solid as a rock aren’t they?
Here it is...California Rasputins...
LaborUnionReport (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:37PM EDT (link)“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.” Thomas Paine December 23, 1776
In any compromise between food and poison, it is only death that can win. In any compromise between good and evil, it is only evil that can profit.-Ayn Rand
LaborUnionReport.com
The Most Comprehensive Source for
News & Views on Today’s Labor Unions.
Follow @laborunionrpt
Love the video, LUR!
lineholder (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:46PM EDT (link)Solid proof of how top-down misuse/abuse of authority has a destructive influence on private sector business economy.
If it somehow makes it through...
anotherindyfilmguy (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:31PM EDT (link)The courts will throw it out as overstepping their bounds and trampling on those things left to the states.
If not it’s time for rebooting the federals…
Razz Etc!
“Best Poker book written ever!!!” – Author’s unbiased opinion…
Hmmm...sounds like what John Galt was up against, doesn't it? [nt]
lineholder (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:34PM EDT (link)This guy has no integrity
The_Rebel (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:36PM EDT (link)“I do not believe that there should be a right to be treated unfairly or to endure unnecessary restrictions…”
What about the rights of dues paying union members who have seen their dues restricted to Democrat political causes, with no voice in how those funds should be spent. How is that treating union members fairly?
In the state of Massachusetts, there is a ballot initiative which would lower the state sales tax from 6.25% to 3%, after Governor Patrick raised it from 5%. All of the unions, private and government, have just come out against this ballot question. Their members have no say in how their millions will be spent in the next 4 weeks trying to kill this measure.
It will be a close vote, and the last I heard was that the proponents were leading by a few percentage points.
Gotta love the unions.
kchand Monday, October 4th at 8:42PM EDT (link)In AZ we have a union effort (well hidden) that opposes ALL ballot propositions … Just Say No … blah blah blah. Their real aim is the proposition that would not allow a ‘card check’ law at the state level. They know voters would not KNOWINGLY vote against a ballot measure that PRESERVES their right to always have their votes be private.
——————–
The ‘N’ word is November! Nov 6, 2012 will be the next cleansing.
It may be well hidden,
The_Rebel (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:48PM EDT (link)but the voters are a lot smarter now, and these under-the-radar tactics won’t fly.
It only makes sense.
kchand Monday, October 4th at 8:37PM EDT (link)The Detroit auto companies and their unions are poster children for the great successes they’ve had. Why not destroy every industry in this country?
I wonder if this election has any importance?!?
——————–
The ‘N’ word is November! Nov 6, 2012 will be the next cleansing.
Would love for Ford to ....
ddstrain (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 10:35AM EDT (link)leave Detroit and re-headquarter and move assembly lines to Virginia or Tennessee or Alabama. I’m sure some of these RTW states would be quite happy to assist the move.
Isn’t there a shuttered Saturn assembly line somewhere in Tennessee???
This is breath-taking, even for Democrats
E Pluribus Unum (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 8:45PM EDT (link)I don’t even know where to start with the rage thing. Good way to cause states to seal the deal on that 10th Amendment thing.
As in …Congress, try to enforce it in Texas.
Kill the Terrorists
Protect the Borders
Punch the Hippies h/t IMAO
I thought they went home to save their skins by campaigning
renny (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:00PM EDT (link)Who is going to be around to vote this abomination?
The Republicans should respond to this
romeg Monday, October 4th at 9:10PM EDT (link)with a bill to repeal the NLRA in its entirety. Far from protecting workers’ rights, Unions destroy jobs. Witness The Rust Belt. Wherever the palsied hand of Big Labor touches, first business, then industries followed by communities and those by entire cities wither and die. Unions are a blight on modern society.
“Of all tyrannies a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victim may be the most oppressive. It may be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron’s cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated, but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.” – C. S. Lewis
This close to the election and he releases this?
acat (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:23PM EDT (link)Time for Repubs to just stand back, out of the way, and let the endangered Dems take this doofus out behind the woodshed.
Mew
——

Caveat Suffragator
He must be feeling bold
Scope (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 10:20PM EDT (link)and brave considering the 10/2 rally this weekend. You are so correct- stand back and let them do themselves in.
In his twisted mind, he must think it is going to help get people to the polls...
LaborUnionReport (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 11:47PM EDT (link)OR, maybe he just is placating a big (union) donor…
“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.” Thomas Paine December 23, 1776
In any compromise between food and poison, it is only death that can win. In any compromise between good and evil, it is only evil that can profit.-Ayn Rand
LaborUnionReport.com
The Most Comprehensive Source for
News & Views on Today’s Labor Unions.
Follow @laborunionrpt
Oh, it'll get people to the polls...
acat (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 10:59AM EDT (link)if his Repub opponent can get enough ads out…. and has the testicular fortitude to do so.
And if I were a big labor donor, I think I’d have him whacked for being this stupid.
Mew
——

Caveat Suffragator
First question on all Congressional Bills:
GregInFla (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:26PM EDT (link)Where is this authorized under the U.S. Constitution? Someone please tell me where?
Also, is anyone in the Union states proposing initiatives to change them to right-to-work? The statistics given by commenters above are compelling.
– A true evolutionist would let endangered species die off. Think about it.
– The sign outside the courthouse said no signs allowed. So I took it down.
– Atlas Shrugged is now on the non-fiction aisle at Amazon.
Yes, becoming to Right to Work
kestrel (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 10:36PM EDT (link)is a serious debate in Michigan that has been gathering momentum for a couple of years. The worsening economy made it an issue in our primary elections this year (in August). The following article from July 9, 2010 gives a good sense of the thinking and progress on it.
Here’s the lead: “Two Republicans joined a united Democrat caucus in the Michigan House to oppose a recent vote on whether local governments in Michigan should be permitted to create “right-to-work zones.”
http://www.michigancapitolconfidential.com/13143
That's why I am so frustrated with Snyder...
glorybee Tuesday, October 5th at 9:24AM EDT (link)Oh, he’s still the best guy for the Gov job (Bernero is a nasty little man). But why do squishy Republicans give away a great issue right out of the gate? Snyder said he won’t address right-to-work issues because “now isn’t the right time”. Excuse me? The state has been dead last for a decade! I could just scream sometimes – makes it a lot harder to give up time, money, etc. But I will – hey I’m a precint delegate & I take it seriously – gonna poll watch all day on election day. (Aside: the unions got the state to declare Election Day a state holiday, but it’s those of us who are conservatives who actually GOTV!)
In the unlikely event that this happens
aesthete (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:34PM EDT (link)expect civil disobedience from the several Right to Work states whose industry is based on lower aggregate wages (due to lower cost of living) and the lack of significant union interference: pretty much all of the Southern states, Texas, and AZ. Heck, I think you could throw in a sizeable chunck of voters in non-Right to Work states, like AK, CO, and several of the Midwestern states.
“It is a popular delusion that the government wastes vast amounts of money through inefficiency and sloth. Enormous effort and elaborate planning are required to waste this much money.”
-P.J. O’Rourke
I would think that the higher cost of living ...
ddstrain (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 10:48AM EDT (link)in the heavily unionized states would come down as the hyper-inflated compensation packages come into parity with the RTW states. Of course that would presume that the heavily unionized states would lower their tax rates as well.
To some extent, certainly
aesthete (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 12:23PM EDT (link)especially as sales taxes are lowered. However, there are some other reasons why COL is higher in progressive states, as well: greater urbanization (more expensive property/housing), historically low wages and development in Southern states, and some other factors exogenous to conditions imposed by government. That said, a big reason that the South (and more specifically, Texas) are doing so well is because their governments have done a decent job of attracting business. For example, the movement of engineering companies and startups to the red states is something of an underreported trend.
“It is a popular delusion that the government wastes vast amounts of money through inefficiency and sloth. Enormous effort and elaborate planning are required to waste this much money.”
-P.J. O’Rourke
Compare growth rates over the past 63 years
thomasburkby Monday, October 4th at 9:38PM EDT (link)between “right to work” states and those where workers are enslaved to the union bosses. You’ll see a huge difference. The South began the last half of the 20th century far behind the north by most economic measures, but gained ground consistently as businesses and skilled labor moved south in search of greater freedom (and warmer winters). The warm winter part doesn’t apply to ND, SD, Wyoming, Idaho or Utah, but even in those places growth rates have generally exceeded the national average as they are friendlier to business.
Admittedly, in some right to work states people are in more serious trouble than others just now. That’s generally the result of the collapse in construction. An economy like that of Las Vegas, which was largely built on growth itself, takes a tremendous hit when the growth stops. That’s why one has to look at the long term and the big picture in order to evaluate the effect of worker freedom properly.
In short, right to work is a big part of the relative success of the red states. That of course is the reason why blue-staters like Sherman want the rest of us to be miserable like MIchigan, California and New York.
Re-apportionment also favors the right-to-work states...
rbdwiggins (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 9:50PM EDT (link)over the more heavily unionized states.
One true indicator of growth.
“Well, the trouble with our liberal friends is not that they are ignorant, but that they know so much that isn’t so.” – Ronald Reagan
Work moved to Right-to-Work states
GregInFla (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 11:08PM EDT (link)Many people think that we don’t manufacture anything in the USA anymore. The truth is that we do. We just don’t make as many things in the big union-dominant cities anymore. Factories are now in right-to-work states away from the unionized cities and states. The USA still out-manufactures China.
– A true evolutionist would let endangered species die off. Think about it.
– The sign outside the courthouse said no signs allowed. So I took it down.
– Atlas Shrugged is now on the non-fiction aisle at Amazon.
The greener grass
BA Cyclone (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 10:56AM EDT (link)The work can’t escape the forced-dues states to greener pastures (literally) if they spray Roundup everywhere outside their fences.
They’ll legislate us into prosperity, if they can just pass enough laws….
“If Congress can do whatever in their discretion can be done by money, and will promote the General Welfare, the Government is no longer a limited one, possessing enumerated powers, but an indefinite one, subject to particular exceptions.” — James Madison
“Electing Republicans who don’t have the courage of their convictions may be easier in some circumstances, but it won’t save our country.” — Jim DeMint
BA Cyclone’s blog
BA Cyclone on Twitter
With all the union stuff in the news,
susanwalkin Monday, October 4th at 10:24PM EDT (link)I was wondering when this was going to come up.
It has to be stopped now.
I am from Texas-we will not put up with this!!!!!
Susan Walkin
“You may all go to hell, and I will go to Texas!”-Davy Crockett
Christine O'Donnell
popdaddy Monday, October 4th at 10:59PM EDT (link)If non-communists need a reason to vote in Delaware November 2,
Christine O’Donnell will move directly into the Senate to vote during the Socialist Democrat lame duck session. Her vote could not be more appropriate than to win this battle
Lame Duck would have other new Senators
GregInFla (Diary) Monday, October 4th at 11:15PM EDT (link)Illinois (Kirk), Colorado (Buck), and West Virginia (Raese) winners are replacing appointees and the winners should get seated the first week of November. Anyone know differently? I’d prefer Rubio to get seated then, since his seat was Martinez’, who retired and was replaced by appointee LeMieux.
– A true evolutionist would let endangered species die off. Think about it.
– The sign outside the courthouse said no signs allowed. So I took it down.
– Atlas Shrugged is now on the non-fiction aisle at Amazon.
Union shop laws are legalized racketeering
Adjoran (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 12:10AM EDT (link)But Obama owes his thugs a lot.
No offense to LaborUnionReport
theBlur (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 1:50AM EDT (link)But this ain’t gonna happen. Makes for nice “fire-em-up” for the left, but this bill will go absolutely nowhere.
And believe me, when I heard about this on the radio I thought first “oh (*&” but then thought, “wait – they don’t have 60 in the Senate. . .”
What is the difference between a labor union and a corporate enterprise?
The labor union promotes based on seniority, the corporate enterprise promotes based on ability. . .
Take a look at a map...
LaborUnionReport (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 2:08PM EDT (link)As long as there is partisanship, and Brown, Collins and Snow (who are all from NON-right-to-work states) don’t fall for the drivel…or any other R from a NRTW state.
[Brown, by the way, got elected because of union members' support--not the unions, but the members. Union members view RTW states with antipathy.]
“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.” Thomas Paine December 23, 1776
In any compromise between food and poison, it is only death that can win. In any compromise between good and evil, it is only evil that can profit.-Ayn Rand
LaborUnionReport.com
The Most Comprehensive Source for
News & Views on Today’s Labor Unions.
Follow @laborunionrpt
LUR, don't forget Graham
lineholder (Diary) Tuesday, October 5th at 8:32PM EDT (link)SC may be a right to work state, but I can’t see that little fact stopping Graham from supporting the unions if he gains from it in the long run.
Is there anyone...
soljerblue Tuesday, October 5th at 10:54AM EDT (link)dumb enough to buy this horse hockey?
I know, I know. The (current) House majority in hock to the SEIU and similar members of the thug-ocracy
Outlaw Public Sector Unions!
dambama Tuesday, October 5th at 6:00PM EDT (link)Government employees already enjoy civil service protection. They can rarely be fired. What do they need unions for?
I would also outlaw civil service protection since so many government workers should be fired, right now. Either because they are paper pushing do nothing incompetents, or the federal agency they work for is unconstitutional.
Either way guaranteed lifetime government employment is a really stupid policy.