« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

As Debt Commission Plan Fails, Unions Have a Solution: Spend MORE money!

AFTER DECADES OF KILLING JOBS, WHAT PART OF BANKRUPT DON'T THEY GET YET?

It’s official: Obama’s debt reduction commission has failed. Not surprisingly, former SEIU boss Andy Stern was among those who voted against the plan.

The closely-followed US debt commission failed to pass its deficit reduction plan Friday, once more pushing back hard choices about America’s ballooning national debt.

Only 11 of the group’s 18 members backed the plan, three short of the 14 required to send it to the House of Representatives and Senate for a vote.

[snip]

Even those who voted against it had strong words for the deficit.

“This is the issue of our time that must be solved,” said labor leader Andy Stern, who nonetheless voted “no” because he favored fewer spending cuts and more tax increases.

When the commission’s co-chairmen issued their proposal [in PDF] on November 10th, its recommendations were roundly criticized by conservatives (like RedState’s Erick Erickson and Congressman Paul Ryan), as well as labor’s leftists—but for much different reasons. Through their opposition to making substantive cuts to the deficits that are quickly driving America into bankruptcy, union bosses seem intent on steering future generations of Americans into poverty.

When the debt commission’s report was released, the nation’s union bosses began bellowing their opposition in the strongest terms possible.  In fact, AFL-CIO boss Richard Trumka belched out a statement:

“The chairmen of the deficit commission just told working Americans to ‘Drop Dead,’” Trumka said. “Especially in these tough economic times, it is unconscionable to be proposing cuts to the critical economic lifelines for working people, Social Security and Medicare.”

In the face of the debt commission’s austerity proposals, and as leftists so often do, union bosses quickly assembled its own “commission” (read ‘shadow group‘) called the Citizens’ Commission on Jobs, Deficits and America’s Economic Future to come up with its own Keynesian solution to the debt.

The unions’ commission speedily released its own set of union solutions on Tuesday and, unsurprisingly, the union solution was not to cut runaway government spending, but to spend even more money.

The Citizens’ Commission on Jobs, Deficits and America’s Economic Future, a grassroots coalition of labor leaders and economists, on Tuesday released its own recommendations for cutting the deficit.

In a press conference call, the Citizens’ Commission recommended spending $1 trillion over the next two years to stimulate the economy and deferring budget cuts until after unemployment has dropped to 5.5 percent.

As opposed to reigning in deficit spending, the unions bosses’ delusional solution is to simply saddle more America with more unsustainable debt.  This leads one to wonder, after bankrupting so many companies and crippling so many industries, have they not yet learned that their style of economics does nothing but make people poorer?

We can’t spend our way to prosperity, and we can’t recover from a recession by creating a depression. It’s too bad union bosses don’t get these simple facts.

__________________

“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.”  Thomas Paine, December 23, 1776

X-posted.

For more news & views on today’s unions, go to LaborUnionReport.com

Follow laborunionrpt on Twitter

COMMENTS

  • General_Confusion

    Think about it. They killed their economic host. Got BILLIONS in tax payer money, now own the resurrected host and also have direct control over said host.

    For them it was a huge success. I

  • http://conservativemountaineer.blogspot.com/ conservativemountaineer

    paying *more* if you like.. nothing is stopping you.

  • californiagold

    As a fiscal conservative, there were certain areas of the commission report I opposed, but other areas of the report that were great ideas.

    First, the tax CUTS within the commission report.

    - Dramatic lowering of the marginal tax rates for all Americans.

    .
    - Impose tight “caps” on the agency budgets adopted by Congress each year, including a near-freeze on the Pentagon’s budget.

    – Eliminate congressional pet spending projects known as “earmarks.”

    – Reduce the corporate income tax rate to 28 percent from 35 percent and stop taxing the overseas profits of U.S.-based multinational corporations.

    – Overhaul individual income taxes and corporate taxes, giving Congress the choice of reducing the top rate to as low as 23 percent and no higher than 29 percent. The lower the rate, the fewer the tax credits and deductions that would be available to taxpayers.

    Unfortunately, republicans jumped all over the report in opposition because of the hike in gas taxes, but failed to mention the HUGE CUT in MARGINAL TAX RATES.

    The only conclusion I can come to is that neither party is serious about cutting the deficit…or cutting income taxes.

  • GreyCloak

    Neither The President nor Congress has any interest in balancing the budget. So they appointed a “committee” to study it.

    I am really disgusted with Congress in that they cannot do the jobs they were elected (and are paid for) to do. Whether deferring decisions to a “military decommissioning” committee, or this latest “debt reduction commission,” Congress abrogates its responsibilities.

    OF COURSE the Commision could not come up with a a plan that would require an up-or-down vote in Congress. They should return to The Public every cent of emmoluments (salaries and expenses) that they or their staffers received, and say to the Congress “We are incompetent and so are you. You were elected to do the task you deferred to us, so do it!”