« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Navy Names Ship ‘Cesar Chavez’ As Cali Strips Farmworkers of Secret Ballot

In a San Diego shipyard on Wednesday, Navy Secretary Ray Mabus told a largely Latino workforce gathered for a ceremony that it was an honor to name a Lewis and Clark class cargo ship after United Farm Workers co-founder Cesar Chavez.

According to the Associated Press, Democrat Senators Boxer and Reid, as well as several others sent a letter praising the Secretary of the Navy’s choice, stating:

“It is clear that Cesar Chavez is a fitting namesake for this fourteenth and final ship,” said the letter, which was provided to The Associated Press by Boxer’s office. “Any comments to the contrary reflect a total disregard for Cesar Chavez, who deserves our respect and gratitude for the lifetime he spent promoting the fair treatment of workers and equal rights and justice for all Americans.”

While Chavez did serve in the Navy in the late 1940s, it is no small irony that the naming of a ship after him comes the same week the California legislature passed a bill stripping farmworkers of their right to a secret-ballot election:

The Assembly approved SB104 on a 51-25, party-line vote Monday. It would allow field laborers to organize by submitting a petition to the state instead of holding a secret-ballot election.

Workers would sign and turn in state-issued representation cards. If the state determined the cards had been signed by a majority of workers, the union would be certified without holding an election.

The legislation was passed previously in the Senate and now goes to Gov. Jerry Brown.

As was noted just over a month ago, California’s SB104 also imposes harsh $20,000 penalties against employers who engage in unfair labor practices, while ignoring unions entirely.

The bill also provides fines of $10,000 for each day an employer does not furnish the union and California’s Agricultural Labor Relations Board employee information.

Meanwhile, back at the ship-naming ceremony, Cesar Chavez’s son, Paul, acknowledged the honor of having his father’s work in “making sure the nation kept it’s promise as a ‘beacon of equality and freedom.’”

And, of course, the underlying issue behind it all—political pandering.

[Attendee Martin Sanchez] acknowledged that politics probably played into the Navy’s decision and that it will likely help President Barack Obama in getting support from the Latino community. But he said that’s not a bad thing.

“At this point, he made a lot of Hispanic[s] happy,” he said. “It’s going to go a long way.”

It’s somewhat mystifying that a lot of Hispanics will be happy at having a ship named after a man that most never knew, while ignoring the fact that many of the farmworkers that Cesar Chavez fought so hard for are about to lose one of the most important rights he fought to win…the right to vote.

_________________

“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.” Thomas Paine, December 23, 1776

X-posted.

Follow laborunionrpt on Twitter

COMMENTS

  • banzaibob

    Naming a ship does not pay the bills or put food on the table, unless your a corrupt politician.

  • blooch

    Huh. I did not know.

    Oh, and Freedom, too.

    Coincidentally, the Statue of Equality is nearing completion, too:

    http://www.constructionphotographs.com/preview.asp?photo=concrete_pour_form_rebar_002.jpg

  • streiff

    he did as much for America as Chavez.

  • bannor

    so a state facing financial ruin. that has been controlled completely by liberals forever is unionizing the mostly illegal alien farm worker labor force against its will. so now the Dems get campaign donations and establish that permanent underclass that they have always wanted. i don’t know about any one else but i’m going to enjoy watching California go screaming into the financial abyss.

  • acat

    He makes an interesting icon for the La Raza Dems, therefore, and shows just how far the goal posts can be moved.

    The labor movement has nowhere to go but down – within 10-20 years, we’ll be hearing (though likely not from the Mostly Stupid Media) about how bad the union leaders are, the abuses by the shop stewards, etc. etc.

    Mew

    • blooch

      were the worst two years of his life. I hope this doesn’t tick off the ghost of Cesar…but it’s too late now, because it’s bad luck to change a ship’s name.

      • acat

        Right of workers to determine how they want to organize, right of ballot privacy, right to deny work to illegals …

        Mew

    • Duke

      I can tell you that naming a ship “Barack Hussien Obama” is the epitome of “bad luck” as far as ship names go.

      • blooch

        I wonder if hope still floats.

        http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/20/american-activists-plan-gaza-flotilla-ship-named-for-obama-book/

  • http://rhymeswithright.mu.nu Rhymes With Right

    Not his politics or his race, but his pacifism. Naming this ship after him is like calling it the Martin Luther King, Jr or the Dorothy Day. It flies in the face of who he was. http://rhymeswithright.mu.nu/archives/316369.php

    • Duke

      While I’m not a fan of naming any ship after Chavez, this particular ship is not a commissioned warship. It’s a USNS ship that is crewed by civilians, and a part of the Military Sealift Command. It’s basically a cargo ship that’s owned by the U.S. government.

      Here’s an idea: If the CA legislature wants to have the ship named after a certain person, how about they cough-up the money for naming rights?

      Hmmmm…, what would it cost to name a USNS ship “Da Sperminator?”

      • http://rhymeswithright.mu.nu Rhymes With Right

        But I’d still argue that it is the wrong thing to do unless they were naming a hospital ship after him (or either of the other two examples I suggested). After all, the Sealift Command ship will still be delivering ammunition — something that seems to contradict the ethos that Chavez adopted. My position is one of respect for Chavez and his beliefs.

  • sundaycombo

    It’s not the politically brightest idea to disparage the man who (rightly or wrongly) is the Hispanic equivalent of Martin Luther King.

    While the GOP has been spectacularly unsuccessful in chipping away black voters from the Democrats, the Hispanic vote has been shown to be amenable to GOP candidates. Kerry only got 58% of the Latino vote in 2004 nationally for example.

    As the second largest ethnic group (and growing) in America we will never be successful in our ultimate goal without convincing all Americans of the need for smaller government and the abolition of special interest money in politics without getting a good number of them on board with us.

    • blooch
      • sundaycombo

        Well…..there would be the matter of comparing him to Trotsky. Unless of course the poster in question thought highly of Trotsky and meant it as a compliment. (which I assume doe does not and did not)

        I was making the point that swing states like Nevada, Florida, New Mexico and others have sizable Hispanic populations and our goal should be ways to get them thinking about conservative positions that they can embrace. There is nothing to be gained in that regard by debating Chavez having his name on a cargo ship. Heck, its not they named an attack sub after him.

        • blooch

          His name is all over dozens of buildings throughout the US—to be sure, most of them in California, including one at Berkeley–so putting a Public School Pantheon member’s name on the ship is not unexpected. What remains unknown is whether or not this will really “make a lot of Hispanics happy”. My guess is they’ve got a pretty good idea when they’re being patronized.

          Cesar Chavez, despite intense, sustained promotion by the government, is really more of a localized phenomenon, and any political benefit to the Federal Dems for getting a ship named after him is minimal and confined mostly to California. Meanwhile Dems in California are busily screwing over the same people to whom Chavez devoted his work. If we get them thinking about the ramifications of the Dem’s Pander/Punch combo, they might start thinking about conservative positions.

    • streiff

      I don’t particularly go for identity politics and race baiting, so I see right away we won’t agree. If you believe the success of our ideas depend upon the virtual deification of a fairly inconsequential union organizer then we are already doomed.

      As most Latinos don’t aspire to be field hands and as Chavez did little but try to aggrandize power to his own union I think a more accurate description is that Chavez is a guilty liberal Anglo’s version of a Latino Martin Luther King, Jr.

  • sundaycombo

    I believe the success of our goals IS dependent on getting as many folks as possible to embrace them. Indeed one of the biggest media criticisms of the Tea Party is it’s an old white man’s club. And that meme has unfortunately stuck. You can call it “identity politics” if you choose but much smarter people than me have come to the same conclusion.

    I respect your views but can’t agree that naming a cargo ship after this guy amounts to “deification”.