Over a year ago, the president of the United Auto Workers, Bob King, announced a campaign to ‘shame’ foreign automakers with plants here in the U.S. into allowing his union to unionize them–the details of which would be released at a later point in time.
Earlier this year, when King finally released his new manifesto on what he expected the automakers to agree to, it was met with well-deserved derision.

The union was silent, though, when in June Bloomberg ran this headline: Hyundai Teaches UAW Best Factory Job Doesn’t Need a Union.
However, in early August, knowing that his union’s future is looking bleak, King stated that the union was in “confidential” talks with the foreign automakers.
“The vast majority of the assemblers here in the United States have at least agreed to confidential discussions,” UAW President Bob King said at an industry conference in Traverse City, Michigan. “We’ve had productive discussions. The last thing we want is confrontation.”
This seemed to confirm the buzz that was created in July when it was reported that the UAW was talking to the Volkswagen AG’s works council and the German union IG Metal to launch an attempt at unionizing the employees at VW’s new Tennessee plant.
Unfortunately for Bob King and his ambitions, the UAW got some bad news on Friday. It appears the German unions have decided against helping the UAW unionize the VW plant in Tennessee.
A key German labor leader says he won’t promote United Auto Workers’ efforts to organize Volkswagen’s Chattanooga plant.
Bernd Osterloh, who represents labor on the German carmaker’s supervisory board, said he is keen on union representation for employees at the plant, but he would not actively promote UAW efforts to broaden its membership at VW, Reuters reported Thursday.
An auto analyst said Osterloh’s remarks “aren’t terribly surprising.”
“He’s trying to protect his own jobs,” said Michelle Krebs, senior analyst at Edmunds.com.
Krebs said German labor leaders are nervous about plant production in that country. At the same time, the United States has become much more competitive in manufacturing autos.
“Each one wants to protect their own,” she said.
This comes as a double-whammy following VW-owned Audi’s decision to locate a new manufacturing plant in Mexico instead of the U.S. in what appears to be a desire not to put itself in the UAW’s (and NLRB’s) sights.
To make matters worse for King and his cronies at the Solidarity House, just a few weeks after UAW members rejected a final offer at an American Axle plant in Cheektowaga, New York, the company has decided to close the plant, eliminating 300 jobs.
This closure follows the UAW’s rejection of a contract at American Axle’s Detroit facility two months ago, which prompted the company to announce the closure of the Detroit facility as well.
In June, [Chris Son, director of corporate and investor relations] told Crain’s that American Axle, a former General Motors Co. unit, continued to seek a competitive labor contract with the UAW that was much like a pact in place at the supplier’s Three Rivers plant in southwest Michigan.
Axle wanted to reduce compensation to $30 an hour from $45 at its Detroit plant, which is likely what the supplier was seeking in New York.
“It’s a matter of being market-competitive and achieving an appropriate cost structure,” Son said.
Between the UAW’s inability to save jobs in the North, its failures to unionize plants in the South, the chasing of Audi to Mexico, and the rejection by the German union, there is a bright side for Bob King: At least none of his members were caught by news cameras smoking pot this week.
Of course, there’s always next week.
________________
“I bring reason to your ears, and, in language as plain as ABC, hold up truth to your eyes.” Thomas Paine, December 23, 1776
Cross-posted at LaborUnionReport.com
Jeff Emanuel
Great post...
smitch61 Saturday, August 20th at 9:21AM EDT (link)I enjoy reading ALL of your work, fantastic job. You truly have a great boots on the ground knowledge and put print to paper in a way that really captures the reader.
As a Michigander, I find all of your work informational to me and my family. I have two brother in laws still hanging on in the car companies, lucky for them, at FORD. They are fantastic men that work hard and have no use for the union.
We've had GM and UAW cars
peg_c (Diary) Saturday, August 20th at 9:48AM EDT (link)Never again on either. This post serves as a decent explanation why I boycott the latter. The former is self-explanatory…
Government cannot be the solution when government is the problem.
As long as there are places capital can move to
johnt Saturday, August 20th at 10:49AM EDT (link)the unions will lack the strangle hold they crave. Union members will lose jobs, dues will suffer, and no lessons will be learned. It would help if the nation had an honest NLRB, and not one like Obama and the Democrats, at war against America.
“a man’s admiration for absolute government is proportinate to the contempt he feels for those around him”. Tocqueville
I'd like to buy a Ford
DerKrieger (Diary) Saturday, August 20th at 11:08AM EDT (link)There is no way I will buy a GM or Chrysler product because of Obama and the UAW but I’m torn about Ford. I really want one of their trucks when I’m ready for my next vehicle and it would be good to reward the company with my business for not taking “Obama money” but I still loathe to support the UAW. Is there any way to communicate to Ford or Ford’s employees that their sales suffer due to the UAW presence?
“In questions of power, let no more be heard of confidence in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the Constitution.” – Thomas Jefferson
“I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents.” – James Madison
Whenever the legislators endeavor to take away and destroy the property of the people, or to reduce them to slavery under arbitrary power, they put themselves into a state of war with the people, who are thereupon absolved from any further obedience.” — John Locke, 1690
That's just ridiculous.
dirkbelig Saturday, August 20th at 12:40PM EDT (link)The Big Three have ALWAYS been UAW outfits and the odds of Ford throwing the union out in order to get your sale are waaaaaaaay longer than those of Angelina Jolie deciding to dump Brad and the kids in order to move in with me.
The employees didn’t have a choice whether to join the union since they’ve been at Ford since 1941, but in your zeal to deny the UAW money, you’re hurting the last non-government-owned American car company and the workers. If everyone refused to buy Ford cars because of the UAW, eventually the workers would be let go.
The UAW is a parasite, like a tapeworm; but your “cure” would be to shoot the host in the head. If you want to screw the UAW, your options are all foreign. I’m not one of those “REAL AMERICANS BUY AMERICAN!” types, but to deny yourself a quality Ford product because of something that can’t and will never change is just being stupid.
“This would be a great job if it weren’t for the ****ing customers.” – Randal Graves, “Clerks”
I Will Never Buy A Car From The Big 3
wonkish1 (Diary) Saturday, August 20th at 1:58PM EDT (link)Besides the “foreign cars” are actually increasingly more American today then the “domestic cars” anyway.
We established a long time ago in economics that it doesn’t matter what country a company originated in or what capital market the company is originally native to, but instead where it employs people and where it sells to.
And the fact that these “foreign automakers” are more American today then most “American companies” should get a lot of people off the notion of buying only the big 3.
“First you win the argument, then you win the vote.” Margaret Thatcher
Conservative Innovations I Want To See Succeed
http://rightnetwork.com/ –New conservative TV network
http://actright.com/ –Fundraising hub for all things conservative
http://connect.freedomworks.org/ — Connecting Tea Partiers around the country
http://procinct.net/ –GOTV walk/call lists
http://www.citizensunited.org/ –Their documentary arm
I couldn't agree more!
soljerblue Monday, August 22nd at 2:15PM EDT (link)In Alabama — where Alabamians work for Mercedes, Honda, Toyota, Hyundai, and their assorted second tier suppliers — buying a so-called “foreign” car keeps employment numbers respectable, and wages very competitive. Not to mention the quality of the vehicles turned out. I have a 12 year old Toyota 4-Runner with 175K on it that’s run longer, better, at less overall maintenance/repair cost than all the Fords and Chevys I’ve had in my life, and I’ve been driving since 1954.
I’d really like to have a Chevy Silverado — love the look, and read good things about the truck itself. BUT — and y’all can fill in the rest of it.
May I also add...
soljerblue Monday, August 22nd at 2:17PM EDT (link)The UAW has been trying since the mid-90s to unionize Mercedes, and has come up short each time. Tango Sierra, Mr. King — you’re Sierra Oscar Lima
Like Fords too
50scars Monday, August 22nd at 6:57PM EDT (link)I now drive a 2004 Explorer with 315,000 miles on it. Except for consumables like tires, brake pads, belts, hoses, battery, it is pretty much as the factory built it. Same A/C compressor, same alternator, same starter, same brake booster, same calipers, etc. It was a company car until I retired–they told me to take it with me, they didn’t want to try to get rid of it. I have properely maintained it,–it was an expense account item– and as a result, my mechanic told me that the engine is such that if he was installing it as a rebuilt, he’d deliver it. The last time I had it into the dealer for the transmission service, the technician told me that he has sent rebuilt transmissions out the door that were not as good as that one. I pull a car trailer with it, so it is not all light duty highway miles. I had 4 Crown Victoria’s with the 4.6 L engine that all were past 200,000 miles when I gave them to a teen as their first car. When the kid decided that he wanted something different, they were all sold as operable functional cars. Prior to the 92 Crown Victoria, all of the Fords I had driven truely earned the acronym Found On Road, DEAD!! They were all brand new cars when I got them, and they all recieved the same maintenece as the Crown Vics got. By 50,000 miles, the prior cars were limping, if not actually refugees from the junkyard. The company kept them on the road because of tax laws, but they paid the price anyway. Ford learned something by the time they put out the 92 Crown Victoria because the cars they made after 1992 were pretty darned good. Even the Focus is a pretty good long lived car. I have been a life long GM product fan. I never had a Ford in my name until I started giving teens cars. (when you choose to send them to a high school 15 miles away from home with no bus service, either you drive them to and from school, or you give them a car. Believe me, giving them a car, and threatening them with a penalty worse than death–becomming a pedestrian–or a cyclist is a really great idea).
My Dad Does Love His Silverado
wonkish1 (Diary) Tuesday, August 23rd at 5:01PM EDT (link)But even he’s pretty sure he wont touch a Gov Motors car from now on.
I’m working on getting him to switch over to completely “foreign cars” from now on. He is thinking of buying his first Ford and I’m trying to talk him out of that.
“First you win the argument, then you win the vote.” Margaret Thatcher
Conservative Innovations I Want To See Succeed
http://rightnetwork.com/ –New conservative TV network
http://actright.com/ –Fundraising hub for all things conservative
http://connect.freedomworks.org/ — Connecting Tea Partiers around the country
http://procinct.net/ –GOTV walk/call lists
http://www.citizensunited.org/ –Their documentary arm
Excellent Post
mike_rundle Monday, August 22nd at 7:57PM EDT (link)I have driven ford pickups for many years..I simply like them..last fall when looking for a new truck, I considered a GM product, which is a good vehicle also..I loathe the UAW..Ford got the nod due to not taking government money. The clowns in ALL union management are bullies and thugs, lacking brains..workers gung-ho about the union generally are too dim to understand that if their interests are served, it is only by coincidence. I am aware that rank and file workers have little choice in the matter..
Unions recently tried to organize student exchange workers at Hershey PA recently...
anotherindyfilmguy (Diary) Saturday, August 20th at 1:30PM EDT (link)http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2011/08/foreign_guestworkers_union_off.html
One of the many complaints heard on the local news was that the “students” were “upset” that the union workers were making about $10/hr more than they were getting… (among a litany of complaints, a few of which end up in the pennlive article)
Razz Etc!
“Best Poker book written ever!!!” – Author’s unbiased opinion…
A recent attempt here in Michigan,
funwithknives Tuesday, August 23rd at 1:44PM EDT (link)was made to Unionize Graduate Student researchers,by calling same Employees. A majority of U of Mich. trustees (6 for/ 2 against) voted for this action even though a similar action had previously been adjudicated as not legal.
We get a Column here in S/E Mich. once a week called: “Labor Voices”, in The Detroit News. AFL-CIO/Mark Gaffney,UAW/Bob King, President of the Det. Fed. of Teachers, and James Hoffa/TeamSters are the usual suspects. How 4 different people can write such similar “Opinions”, isn’t surprising at this house. But where in The Lord’s Creation is “The Diversity”? Do they all get the same weekly script? Maybe they just tap-in,and use Charlie Schumer’s Phone Instructions.
At some point in time,
popster Monday, August 22nd at 7:17AM EDT (link)even the die-hard union employees will realize that they are not being represented, only duped!
Unions have become
brojohn2 Monday, August 22nd at 10:46AM EDT (link)big business, 6 figure salaries to the top tier, and nothing much for the guy on the floor. Unions were a good thing back in the days of child labor, sweat shops and worker abuses. Today, I have worked for non-union and union shops, give me the non-union shop any day.
If you want to see socialism at it’s best work in a union shop, everybody takes a break, no matter what you are involved in at the time, your break is sacrosanct. Salary and benefits are way out of sight at many plants, and so there are fewer workers and more robots doing the work, the robots only need lube and oil, the workers get $$$$ and Benefits. If they cut some of that out, then more people would be working, but of course the union bosses want their benefits to continue to increase on the backs of the folks who do the actual work.
“What spectacle can be more edifying or more seasonable, than that of Liberty and Learning, each leaning on the other for their mutual & surest support?” –James Madison, letter to W.T. Barry, 1822
“Every man who loves peace, every man who loves his country, every man who loves liberty ought to have it ever before his eyes that he may cherish in his heart a due attachment to the Union of America and be able to set a due value on the means of preserving it.” –James Madison, Federalist No. 41
Unions never were all that, brojohn2. It's a myth.
acat (Diary) Monday, August 22nd at 11:10AM EDT (link)One might say a lie.
Look up the history of unions and anarchists in Chicago. There’s significant cross-over. The working stiffs were always stooges for guys who sought to bend their strong backs and weak minds to other non-labor-related motives.
Compare how a modern farm family operates – show me a farm kid who hasn’t been driving a truck or tractor around the farm for years before he or she gets a license to drive on the streets, who doesn’t start working the truck patch as soon as he or she can walk, or gathering eggs, or raising livestock for 4-H – to how families were trying to operate in the cities. Kids working. No-brainer.
I’m not arguing that ending child labor was a bad thing, factories and farms are quite different, but .. I’m not crediting the unions with anything other than protecting their own.
Mew
——

Caveat Suffragator
Farm work didn't do me any harm
jout99 (Diary) Monday, August 22nd at 1:15PM EDT (link)12 yrs old, being drug out of bed at 6 in the morning. Learned a lot of things that most people have no idea about. Especially how to rely on yourself. Had a lot of fun driving tractors and trucks too, plus hunting and fishing too.
Later on worked for a union, where the old timers bullied me into a corner and told me to slow down as I was making them look bad. The union was worthless to do anything for us, except take our money. Didn’t stay there long.
The UAW and Obama took a chunk of my Grandmother’s saving (GM Bonds) so no way will I ever again own a Gov’t Motors or Chrysler product.
The UAW is getting their just deserts. They have been taking the American people to the cleaners long enough.
We have a new Kia plant that is helping the local economy out. No unions thank goodness. And you wouldn’t believe how much water it takes to build a car. Keeps us water plant operators busy as we have to bring in extra operators to keep up with them.
So to the UAW and the Prez, they can stay out of our lives, I think we’ll be just fine.
you are working an assemble line
mmm21 Monday, August 22nd at 4:56PM EDT (link)making $45 an hour???? Seriously???? And they put out that crap????