« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

J Street apologist miscounts Israeli options.

Of course he does.

This is amusing, in a darkly humorous sort of way:

More recently, Daniel Levy, director of the Middle East Task Force at the New America Foundation and a member of J Street, said in an interview: “America has three choices. Either say, it’s politically too hot a potato to touch, and just pay the consequences in the rest of the world. Or try to force through a peace deal between Israelis and Palestinians, so that the Palestinian grievance issue is no longer a driving force or problem.” The third choice, he said, “is for America to say, we can’t solve it, but we can’t pay the consequences, so we will distance ourselves from Israel. That way America would no longer be seen, as it has been this week, as the enabler of excesses of Israeli misbehavior.”

Via Hot Air. It’s darkly humorous because there are five options here, not three – which Daniel Levy knows full well.

Option Four is the simple, straightforward, and by the way moral one: the United States of America continues to support the Republic of Israel in its reasonable, proportionate, and responsible efforts to prevent terrorist attacks on its country and citizens. Option Five is the one that the ‘peace movement’ embraces: the world should stop trying the half measures of Options One, Two, and Three and get on with driving all the Jews into the Mediterranean Sea. That’s where the actual battle-line is being drawn these days: it’s either support our ally from world attempts to brutalize it, or join in the brutalization.  This will be disputed, of course; and let me personally note that I bask in the disapproval of people who like to publicly show their support for the movement that murdered Shiri Negari.

I honestly hesitate to suggest that Daniel Levy espouses Option Five personally: he claims to be an Option Two supporter, and I have no evidence otherwise.  But I am not even remotely surprised that a J Street professional apologist forgets to even mention Option Four.

Moe Lane

Crossposted to Moe Lane.

COMMENTS

  • Doc Holliday

    They don’t like Netanyahu, so they will always side against his government. Of course they don’t like Israel because we support it, the facts, history, and reality don’t come into play.

    I am probably to the right of you on this Moe. I think the only problem with the raid is that the Israelis botched it. They need to get their military mojo back and quick. No more paint ball guns, no more troops thrown overboard.

    I know this is off topic but I have wanted to say this for some time. I think Hot Air has become quite odd and less important since Malkin sold it. I was not always on Malkin’s side, but I am less in line with the views of Hot Air now. It is too bad because the site structure is great and important. It is too bad consistent conservatives do not run the place.

  • mikerazar

    Option 6: aka the right choice.

    State unambiguously, that we support Israel’s claim to its eternal, undivided capital, Jerusalem and to its ancestral lands of Judea, Samaria, and Golan.

    Personally, I would go with Option 7, but i doubt any US government would dare even hear it. Add to option 6 that we support the return of Israel to the borders of David and Solomon; the Nile on the West and the Euphrates on the East, with the land from there to the gulf thrown in as reparations.

    It isn’t so much that I expect much of that to happen, but both sides should have to give something up. Right?

    As to J-Street. They are traitors to the Jewish People. May they choke on their own evil bile.

    I guess I’m even further right than you, Doc!

    But seriously,

  • gmscan

    Levy writes –
    “Or try to force through a peace deal between Israelis and Palestinians, so that the Palestinian grievance issue is no longer a driving force or problem.?

    This is absurd. The Arab states don’t care about the “Palestinian problem.” In fact they all use it to distract their people from their incompetent governance. It is similar to how the Southern power structure in the U.S. used race hatred to remain in power — “You may be poor but at least you ain’t a n—–.”

    If Israel disappeared tomorrow they would invent a new scapegoat — Western imperialism, American capitalism, or some brand new excuse.

    Greg Scandlen

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    Israel needs a secure interior and defensible borders.

    The hostile populations in the areas you suggest expanding Israel to would make the extra territory useless.

  • DirtyDave

    Our one and only option is to support Israel. Period.

    It have a lively, thriving democratic government and vibrant capitalistic, free market economy. The collective nutcases in the world don’t like this country.

    What is not to support?

  • Doc Holliday

    borders should have a purpose, and strategic defense should be number one. The Poles are as tough as they come, but they have a nation with poor strategic borders, and that is why the Nazi’s took it so quickly.

  • Doc Holliday

    distract and disorganize

  • wennejunk

    …which is we resume initial philosophy of the war on terror – that of pursuing terrorists wherever they hide – and throw our lot in with Israel.

    It will never, ever happen, but it would involve an active approach to resolving the terror issue by sorting the sheep from the goats in Gaza and the West Bank.

    So, there’s lot of options.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    Every time I think about it, it burns me up that the USSR kept all its ill gotten gains from that.

  • blooch
  • conservativecrusade

    very enlightening! But I fear that the anti-Israel sentiment is becoming the norm in this country and it will come back to haunt us. The above quoted guy is just another spokesperson for the leftist scum in this country. Hope we start putting a stop to them this November.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    That was postwar punishment of Germany.

    I’m talking about what’s south of that, former Polish territory on the USSR side of the Molotov-Ribbentrop line.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    Now part of Ukraine and Belarus I guess.

  • Flagstaff

    “are defined not by our borders”?

    Borders have no purpose other than to keep friends and families separated.

    Peace, love, and hare krishna.

  • http://www.dcworksforus.com Kenny Solomon

    Designed, built and now being used by ‘my people’, Teh Eeeeevil Jooooooooooos.

    http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/137908

    The Air Force put its new UAVs (unmanned aerial vehicles) to the test last week opposite the coast of Gaza. UAV operators had their first chance to work with the new vehicles, the IAF’s most advanced.

    The new UAV, dubbed ?Eitan? (English name: Heron TP) has a wingspan almost as long as a Boeing 737, can stay in the air for over 36 hours, and is capable of reaching as far as Iran. It officially joined the IAF’s fleet in February.

    — — — — —

    GIT-R-DONE.

    To my people in IAF……. Now go do that voodoo that you do so well !

  • happyblackmale

    [Be a real shame if you didn't save a copy of that, retread. - Moe Lane]

  • redneck_hippie

    Apt.

    I sure would like to think that the furor over Helen Thomas’ remarks would shine a light on the connections between the Israelphobes, J Street, Obama apologists, terrorist regimes and the current foreign policy of The One (termer).

  • Doc Holliday

    I will agree and allow it.

  • Michael Dugas

    becoming the norm in this country. The problem is that that view is all you hear about. No one in the media, the MSM, speaks out for Israel or its citizens because the leftist media is on the Palestinian side. Proof is how quickly they all jumped on Israel over the raid before even knowing what happened. Once the video showing what really happened came out it was a war of semantics and spin to try and still
    keep Israel as the bad guy.
    The internet has become a huge tool for the truth and transparency and I believe that the majority of Americans are becoming tired with the Palestinians and their never ending drama.
    Something that I find to be darkly humorous is that I think Obama has lost his belief that he, through his power of the One, can resolve the Palestinian issue and I am beginning to think he blames it ON the people calling themselves Palestinians. I can only hope.

  • mikerazar

    which is at least 6 times more often than I or anyone else in this thread. Shall we permit murder just because the O.T. prohibits it?

    Yes. Anyone who denies Israel’s right to self defense is an anti-semite. End of story.

    I don’t have the patience to refute or correct all his lies and mis-statements, but perhaps someone else does. A fair reading of international law unambiguously supports option 6.

  • mikerazar

    How do you say GIT-R-DONE in Hebrew?

  • mikerazar

    nt

  • http://www.dcworksforus.com Kenny Solomon

    You’re not gonna believe this, but check the March issue of Popular Mechanics. Some data is there.

    ———

    Git-R-Done…….. I’ve got it, but I don’t think the Hebrew characters will transition here, but just in case…… ???? r ?????

    In Norwegian, it’s “F?-r-gjort”

  • SteveLA

    mikerazar

    Can you please use the two blocks in the comment form? One is for a title and one is for the comment.

    It’s so simple even a Gamecock eventually figured it out….LOL.

  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

    haven’t “figured” out protocol – don’t tell him its by des….aw, never mind…

  • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

    We’ve got to get it right the first time. But in a few hours, depending on traffic, it’ll drop off the page and your won’t have to be embarrassed any longer.

    However, I think you currently hold the title for the longest RedState comment title line, having dethroned gamecock, who seems to be reforming his ways in recent weeks.

    I would strongly suspect that you cut and pasted from a word processing program. That’s a good way to find spelling errors, but always remember 1) save to a text file first and then cut & paste that, 2) check to make sure you copy into the body field, not the title field.

  • JoeG

    Did anyone include the one where Israel realizes that most of the world is against them no matter what, so they start fighting a war like a war.

    Pound Gaza until Hamas declares a cease fire. Once they have a cease fire, tell them that they will receive a widely disproportionate response if the cease fire is broken.

  • http://www.scragged.com petrarch

    “I am beginning to think he blames it ON the people calling themselves Palestinians.”

    No, see, that would require him to blame the people that are, in fact, the cause of the problem. Which is anathema to liberals.

  • mikerazar

    Even at risk of keeping my mistake on display a bit longer, thanks for the advice.

    As to the title, I hope I can be excused for leaving it off my resume.

    To the big bosses: You do a great job BUT

    (Snark) Is the lack of editing functionality a bug or a feature?

    (Snarkier) Would it be too much trouble to put SOME limit on the length of comment titles?