« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Orlando Sentinel reporter Scott Powers stuffed in closet at Bill Nelson shindig.

This is all very symbolic: Orlando Sentinel reporter Scott Powers was assigned to cover a fundraiser for Senator Bill Nelson (D, FL) that was being thrown by local real estate bigwig Alan Ginsburg.  The fundraiser featured Vice President Joe Biden (D), whose staff promptly tossed Powers into a closet and refused to let him out except for the actual speeches [themselves].  This… is problematical, particularly since Biden’s been beating the transparency drum lately; well, more accurately the words on the paper in front of him are telling Biden to beat the transparency drum, and that’s just what Joe Biden is going to do, yes indeed.  Fortunately for Biden, Nelson, & Ginsburg, neither Powers nor the Orlando Sentinel seem inclined to see whether all of this qualifies as ‘kidnapping’ under Florida law.

I know that people will find this story funny on first read, and superficially it is.  But there’s a problem here, and it exists on a somewhat deeper level than the assault on the dignity of a member of the Fourth Estate.  You see, who told Biden’s staff that they had the right to sequester a reporter in another man’s home? It certainly wasn’t Alan Ginsburg who signed off on it: as the article linked to above reports, Ginsburg fell all over himself to apologize to Powers once the former heard what had happened to the latter.  As well he should have: Alan Ginsburg’s intent with this fundraiser was to maintain good relations with a sitting US Senator and generally build links, not get swept up into a dispute that threatens to sour his existing relationship with a local paper, at absolute best.  Ginsburg is thanking God right now that the Orlando Sentinel isn’t threatening a lawsuit; and I’m not a lawyer, but it looks like there would have been at least a civil case there.   In other words, Ginsburg mostly dodged the bullet that Biden fired.

But that is an unimportant detail for VP Biden’s staff, who – like the rest of this administration, honestly – is generally slapdash and heedless about the effects of their actions on others.  Time and again we’ve seen an institutional arrogance from these people: one that may have been… well, not justifiable.  But certainly unsurprising when the President is enjoying an average 63% approval rating; but at 48%?  Not so much.  But the administration’s worker drones are still not particularly interested in learning better, either – as one particular detail about the situation shows.  You see, when Ginsburg found out about the mess he called the reporter to personally apologize and admit his embarrassment.  Because that’s what you do.

Unless you work in Biden’s office: in that case, you just send an email.

Moe Lane (crosspost)

COMMENTS

  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

    false imprisonment, which carries a penalty of 10 yrs to life.

  • renny

    The left would censor and proscribe anything that doesn’t meet with their narrow and restricted view of politics, forget history or any academics, and would easily name the NYT “Pravda.”

  • http://www.dirkworld.com dirkbelig

    What does the Obama Regime have to do to get their slobbering sycophants in the JournoList media to stop loving it so hard? It seems like every week there’s another story about the press being excluded from normal events that would’ve prompted howls of censorship against Dubya, but now they’re stuffing reporters in closets and no one wants to say a thing about it? Perhaps they’re too busy reading MMA’s site for the latest anti-Koch talking points?

  • http://pocketchangeproductions.net/ anotherindyfilmguy

    1. The D.A. for Florida very likely has the discretion to pursue charges despite the victim not seeming to want to. In my Opinion the D.A. for Florida should pursue charges and find out both who made the decision and who carried it out and put them all in jail.

    2. The press laughs it off? Really? The Press, of all people, should be demanding someone go to jail over this. If this were a Republican VP’s staff doing this it would be 24/7 until either someone goes to jail or it’s impeachment time if not both…

    3. This administration has been nearly the textbook definition of everything they falsely accuse the Republicans of and yet everyone yawns at this? To me this seems to bring out the real divide in our country, it’s not D vs. R so much as it is right versus wrong/good vs an incredibly banal evil.

  • http://pocketchangeproductions.net/ anotherindyfilmguy

    “Oh mighty O – We’re soooo sorry your staff was caught throwing our reporter off a bridge, we really try to teach them the right questions to ask before we send them out – really – no harm, no foul, it was only a reporter…”

  • http://www.sunshinestatesarah.com sunshinestatesarah

    Ah yes, the latest “Only in Florida” example.

    I do have to point out that the Daily Mail made a number of laughable errors…the party was in Winter Park. I don’t think there is a place called “Winter Falls” in Florida. And that photograph is definitely NOT Senator Bill Nelson. It’s Ginsburg.

    And just to clear up the legal issue…this wasn’t kidnapping or false imprisonment. The reporter was given the choice to wait in the closet to listen to the speeches, or to leave. See that last part…”or to leave.” Because he had the choice and could have left at any point if he wanted to, there’s no crime.

    There’s a lot of stupidity, and an appalling lack of etiquette, but there’s no crime.

  • http://www.theprecinctproject.wordpress.com ColdWarrior

    The Orlando Sentinel reporter was not “kidnapped” in any sense of the word, I’ll bet. Rather, he was simply told that if he wanted to stay on the premises he had to abide by their rules. And he went right along with the indignities — because, probably, his editors at the paper are Dem sycophants. As he probably is. He wouldn’t want to write anything bad about the vaunted Vice President or the vaunted Sen. Bill Nelson. No way, no how. Because they are all on the same side.

    The Democrat Media is just that — Democrat Media.

    The “political children” in the Democrat Media are treated by the “grown ups” — the Democrat officeholders — like the kids at the family Thanksgiving gathering who are sent to the basement to eat at the card tables with the folding chairs. And they put up with this treatment because, in the end, they are all part of the same family, pushing the same socialist/progresive/communist/democrat (pick one or more) agenda.

    Read here how Fox News reported it and follow the link to the Orland Sentinal’s “reporting” of what happened to their very own “reporter.” You’ll see no outrage. No blaring headlines deploring the treatment of their “reporter.” Nope, it really was no big deal. But we thought we’d mention it. Because we’re “journalists.” Ahem. (Some good comments, too.)

    http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2011/03/27/reporter-confined-storage-closet-fundraiser-biden-newspaper-claims/

    Good piece by Moe!

    Thank you.

    ColdWarrior

  • jmimac351

    it’s about arrogant goons from Washington doing as they please because they can get away with it.

  • Tbone

    Not from being held captive by the Democrats, which they are, but being held captive by their own stupidity from which they have reconciled themselves to there being no escape. As evidenced in this story, they have chosen to embrace it.

  • uselogic

    “The Democrat Media is just that ? Democrat Media.”

    And our local rag, the Orlando Slantinel, has dropped all pretense of being unbiased…. even more so since Gov. Scott’s election. Typical slanted news stories, all-lib letters to the editor, zero conservative columnists. They even edit AP articles to suit the liberal line. No surprise they didn’t and will not express outrage over the Dem staffers’ actions. Now, if it were a Republican or Tea Party function….

  • blooch

    because they knew that any reporter who still has the same haircut he had in 1975 wouldn’t make a big stink about it. That, and the editor probably would have fired this Bernie Woodstein for leaving the building instead of getting quotes for the puff piece he had promised to deliver.

    And sunshinestatesarah sounds a bit like James Carville discussing Paula Jones.

  • smagar

    Imagine if Sarah Palin’s team had done this…

  • smagar

    Again, if Cheney or Powell had done this, or if it had happened at the house of one of the Koch brothers…

    What, does Joe Biden or David Brock have compromising pictures of the Sentinel’s leadership? Why else would the head shed at Powell’s paper have such a “oh heck” attitude about all of this.

  • Ann_W

    But I’m sure we’ll hear about it over and over and over like we heard about that one…. NOT.

  • tulsajack

    Innocent cocktail party conversation, but closed to the press? Who are they kidding? Whenever D-rats in office sidle up to their money-bags, we know they are hatching some corrupt conspiracy against the public interest. What is it this time?

  • Ann_W

    That question would have kept Chris Matthews going for a month if it had been a Republican fundraiser.

  • acat
  • SoFiMil

    Jill Stanek, fortunately, showed the precious infant some dignity, and held it until it took it’s last breath.

  • edwyrd

    The more outrageous and prejudiced the media, the less relevant it becomes.
    And the more americans with ANY common sense will seek out another source of information. I.E. Redstate

  • throwback59

    “out of the closet” in support of the democrats.
    Powers may have been shoved in the closet because he wasn’t officially out of it.

  • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

    But we are clinging to the constitution and rule of law, you know, those inconvenient and old fashioned things.

  • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

    But we are clinging to the constitution and rule of law, you know, those inconvenient and old fashioned things.

  • 1trinity

    SunshineStateSarah and all:

    “The reporter was given the choice to wait in the closet to listen to the speeches, or to leave.”

    Are you kidding me? Does this sound right? This is how we treat another human being–VP’s people tell someone to wait in a closet? Are you kidding? Why wouldn’t he be allowed to stay? This whole thing sounds fishy…I bet there’s more to this story….wish we could ALL find out.

    If this behavior took place under Cheney…whew…can you imagine?!

    Maybe, we should start a new ‘CAUSE’….’SAVE THE REPORTERS’!

  • acat

    Bitter has a subtext of “resigned to whatever fate has in store” and .. especially here at Red State, it just ain’t so.

    Are we mad as {hades} and not going to take any more? Yes.

    Are we distrustful of anyone who wants to run for office *because* they want to run for office? Sure.

    Bitter? I don’t want to speak for everyone but .. I ain’t got time for bitter.

    Mew

  • sheryl

    As a senior citizen i’m more and more disturbed about the behavior displayed
    such as what happened to that reporter. The reporter should have been
    escorted to another room, and instructed to wait until it was time for the speeches to begin.
    I have worked with people who wear the latest fashions and show potential
    in their chozen field. Then after talking with them for several minutes their
    outward appearance is tarnished with poor grammar. Whenever i heard , i
    seen , instead of i have seen i no longer wanted to talk with them. In my
    mind i continued to correct the poor grammar each time i heard them speak.
    I come from a middle class background. My father was a blue collar worker,
    and a Republican. I was taught a person showed class by the way they,
    lived and treated their fellow citizens.
    The news stories talk about how more people have moved up into the
    high middle class. A good example would be the unions. I wouldn’t have
    any self respect to behave the way they do. I’m appalled our teachers, nurses, and elective officials behave as if they were never taught anything.
    When someone won’t try to learn proper speaking grammar, will not be
    diligent in other areas.

  • http://www.thejoyofreason.com Greg Garrison

    http://theweek.com/article/index/213614/the-biden-staffer-who-locked-a-reporter-in-the-closet

    Just in case you hadn’t seen it, Moe.

  • http://www.thejoyofreason.com Greg Garrison

    http://theweek.com/article/index/213614/the-biden-staffer-who-locked-a-reporter-in-the-closet

    Just in case you hadn’t seen it, Moe.

  • http://www.sunshinestatesarah.com sunshinestatesarah

    Did you read my entire comment?

    I was merely trying to point out that the whole reporter-in-a-closet thing wasn’t a crime. I was NOT defending it. It was stupid and colossally rude.

  • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

    Does your head look like Skeletor?

  • blooch

    But in retrospect, I sound more like Carville than you. At least your were arguing the legal merits. We both know Carville would never do that.

    I, on the other hand, was trashing the guy for getting what he deserved. Now that, Carville would definitely do. I should have stopped at the first paragraph.

    Bygones?

    And Kyle, I never said she *looked* like ol’ snakehead ; )

  • http://www.sunshinestatesarah.com sunshinestatesarah

    haha thanks – for the record, I am not bald. :)

    The staffer who shut the reporter in the closet = rude idiot. The staffer who sent the “apology” = should have tried harder. The reporter = a weenie for putting up with that mistreatment.