« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Missouri redistricting hurts Russ Carnahan.

The below is being floated as a potential redistricting map for Missouri:

I’ll summarize the changes as follows: Missouri loses a district, thanks to the 2010 Census. On the Republican side, Vicki Hartzler is liking this map least: she had some R areas taken away from her and given to Emanuel Cleaver, and has been given some D areas from Luetkemeyer. On the other hand, on the Democratic side Cleaver’s district is now somewhat less urban. This is not necessarily a disaster for Cleaver: he’s that rarity, a Democratic African-American that white Democrats will vote for anyway. But the really nice news? Russ Carnahan‘s district was chopped up like a chicken for the stewpot: half of it went to Jo Ann Emerson (who didn’t break a sweat winning last year with 65% of the vote) and the rest looks like it’s in William Clay’s (majority-minority). Bottom line: I am not an expert on Missouri county vote totals, but it looks like Missouri’s going to go from 6R/3D to 6R/2D.

As it happens, both Russ Carnahan and his sister Robin (current Secretary of State) are technically up for reelection in 2012. I note “technically” because Russ doesn’t have anywhere to go except his boat, and Robin’s political future was recently and entertainingly tarnished by her inept loss in the 2010 Senate elections. It’s likely that she’ll have a tough reelection fight for Secretary of State; and while Senator Claire “SELL THE JET!” McCaskill and Governor Jay Nixon both look weaker than one might expect, knocking them off in a primary in 2012 might be a bit of a slog. Particularly since the Democratic Party of Missouri is going to be in full firewall mode at that point.

So, all in all: good times, good times. Russ Carnahan is on an old list of mine, you see: and with him gone the only ones left will be the race-baiter and the anti-Semite.

Moe Lane (crosspost)

COMMENTS

  • chipbennett

    …for me, at least, is it looks like (I can’t quite tell from the map) we might get moved from MO-1 (Clay), back into MO-2 (Akin). My fingers are crossed, anyway…

  • http://wadingacross.wordpress.com logus

    Following the election I did some number crunching and saw that Russ bled a lot of votes. Those votes didn’t necessarily go to Martin or any third party candidate… they stayed home.

    It was also pretty much concluded that Russ’s district would be the one to get chopped up – there was no way that the Missouri Republicans would be allowed to do away with Clay or Cleaver’s districts, especially considering how the federal congressional apportionment laws are written. And it wouldn’t make sense for Republicans to take away Hartzler’s newly won district.

    That said, Hartzler might be in for a fight in ’12 if the population of Columbia is enough to tip the margins in favor of a Democrat opponent. Cleaver might also have a harder time though – he wone well, but not by a tremendous landslide. Lacy Clay however will be solidly in his district unless he dies or some scandal or crime runs him out.

    I seem to recall hearing a rumor or theory that Russ would possibly just join Obama’s administration before ’12 instead of taking a defeat at the polls.

    The map as proposed above removes the 9th Congressional district which is currently held by Republican Blaine Luetkemeyer. That may have also been part of negotiations, a tit for a tat so to speak (since Cleaver and Clay were no doubt off the table)… If the 3rd is to be redrawn in such a way that it will become Republican, then for the Republican’s numerically it’s a wash while at the same time having a larger representative majority.

    Luetkemeyer will probably land on his feet with upward political mobility. Russ on the otherhand might find himself not just out of a Congressional job like Luetkemeyer, but out of a political job altogether… though to be sure there’s a lobbying job waiting for him somewhere – that seems to be where most retired politicians go.

  • http://wadingacross.wordpress.com logus

    Bites for me. I’m deep in Clay territory. Congressional races in MO1 are going to be absurd from here on out – they were a joke already with Clay easily winning around 70% or so every election.

    The St. Louis Tea Party and even the Republicans made zero effort to assist either Byrne (06) or Hamlin (10).

    At that point, why should any Republican waste their money trying to run against Clay?

    Maybe Missouri needs an O’Keefe who’ll go after Clay and Cleaver.

  • http://wadingacross.wordpress.com logus

    Here I compiled numbers for the state and various districts including MO3 going back 10 years.

  • Xasteius

    But I’ve lived there and become a bit jaded and cynical, so there’s always possibilities….

  • freemanja1991

    4 doesn’t look like it will end up being all that liberal, just slightly more competitive. Currently 5 is only a D+10 and Cleaver only won by 10 points in 2010, that district looks as if it could be more competitive possibly on D+3 or 4. I think this could end up being 7 R 1D. On the Topic of Russ, he might run for LT Gov, it would be an open seat since Kinder will be running for governor. It would be good to see Robin lose too, I love see Democrat Dynasties end. But Missoura should be ripe for Republicans in 12. With potential for 2 house seats a lame duck in the Senate (I Think Claire is done already) the governor’s Mansion, the SOS and attorney general. We would need to find a quality LT Gov Candidate encase Russ pulls what I think (How about the State Senator that Sponsored the Heath Care Ballot initiative?).

  • proudgop

    I hope we can get a lot more posts on redistricting ( NJ, LA, and IA are coming out this week too with proposals)

    my question more resides with does this make any of the other Republican districts more solid for GOP or weaken any?

  • freemanja1991

    will benefit Republicans at the State Senate and House Level. The fastest growing districts in the state are some of the most solid republican districts. Most rural districts will get bigger, and this will hurt the few rural dems still out there. Many barely won in 2010. Congressional elections will be ugly. But Steve King and Tom Latham will probably be safe. But not sure we will gain a seat out of it.

    Below are several variations that may come up.

    http://theiowarepublican.com/home/2011/02/17/redistricting/

  • hunter10

    McCaskill was polling poorly before the airplane/tax issue broadsided her. Time for her to go. The Carnahans have been feeding at the public trough too long. Time to send them back to the farm. I do like Nixon though. Wish he would switch parties though.

  • alwaysfiredup

    Cleaver beat Turk 53-44. Hardly 2 to 1.

    Jacob Turk and just about everybody else in KC wants all of Jackson County in the same district. Missouri Republicans, please listen!!!

  • alwaysfiredup

    For some reason the opinions of KC residents are not being counted in Jefferson City with respect to MO-5. We don’t want a gerrymandered 5th congressional district. We want Jackson County to be kept together, with whatever bit of Clay or Cass or Lafayette county that will bring the district up to the necessary population number.

    This is good both for Jackson County Republicans (it’d be a more Republican district than we have currently) and for people who believe in non-gerrymandered districts. Stand with us!

  • freemanja1991

    Have you drawn a plan that does this? and what do you your idea would do number wise, like how close would elections become, in MO 5? I’d also like to know what parts of the counties you listed are Republican leaning/ Dem leaning. Because I drew up something similar to what your saying (I think) and it still gave us at least 6R-2D and probably a swing district in MO 5.

  • chipbennett

    MO-01 is one of those districts that I can see not dumping any money into. For example: every dollar spent on Hamlin was one dollar less that could have been spent on Ed Martin.

    Missouri is about to become a 6-2 R-D caucus. Given that the state has two liberal strongholds in St. Louis and Kansas City, that’s not bad.

  • proudgop

    The commission came out with first map today and it lumps King and Latham together and then lumps Braley and Loesback together and makes Boswell (D) a percentage point more GOP friendly.

    Arkansas passed controversial plan today which makes 4th district held by Ross more Dem friendly. can’t find out what it does to 1st and 2nd though?

  • freemanja1991

    is trending to the right its a matter of time, and if and when Ross leaves (they want him to run for Gov in 14) it will be highly competitive. And if the RNCC, through a bunch of money at him he’d be done.

  • freemanja1991

    That one will not pass, in Iowa, not with who is pitted against each other just in the state house.

  • Xasteius

    Wikipedia didn’t give the latest election results. I don’t live in MO anymore, but I am glad that things could turn around.

  • jeffreywturner

    to get those extra couple of votes in order to override the veto, however, it is still not the best scenario for the GOP, at least as far as the 5th district is concerned. That could be a winnable district for the GOP.

    Anytime you have a district in a southern or border state that is more than 20% black but less than 50%, that is a waste. Every majority black district in such states should be at least 60% black, preferably closer to 70%.