« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Judge Maryann Sumi (D*) ‘fixes’ anti-reform restraining order. Again.

How many bites at the apple does this judge get, anyway?

Let’s recap what happened in Wisconsin (that link leads to a whole slew of links that track this epic foul-up by the Democratic party in Wisconsin over what should have been a simple enough demonstration of the principle that elections have consequences).

  • Wisconsin Democratic Senators run away rather than do their jobs.  This prevents a quorum for bills that are primarily financial in nature.
  • Wisconsin Republican Senators end up passing what they can, including a critical union reform bill.
  • Having returned from self-imposed Illinois exile, Wisconsin Democrats find a convenient judge (Maryann Sumi) to issue a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO), on what is frankly a misunderstanding of the law.
  • Judge Sumi makes a mistake in the TRO by only enjoining the Secretary of State (Democrat) from publishing the law.  For example, she did not enjoin the Legislative Research Bureau (LRB) from publishing the law, despite the fact that they are required to by law.
  • The LRB publishes the law, as per their statutory requirements; as the TRO did not cover that department, they have no choice.
  • On Monday, the Wisconsin Department of Justice (DoJ) points this detail out to the courts and asks them to vacate the order, given that the law is published.
  • On Tuesday, Judge Sumi reissues her TRO to prevent implementation of the law.
  • On Wednesday, the Wisconsin Department of Administration (DoA) points out that this ruling was flawed in that it: did not in fact indicate that the law is not in effect; explicitly declined to state that the law was not legally published; and since when did Judge Sumi get to presume to drag the DoA (a non-party in the original dispute) into this mess she made in the first place?
  • On Thursday, Judge Sumi has to fix her TRO again to rule that the law is not published, in a fashion that satisfies the DoA.
  • At some point in all of this Judge Sumi somewhat plaintively (if you’ll pardon the pun) wonders aloud why the legislative branch simply just doesn’t pass the law again.
  • To which Wisconsin Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald (R) effectively replies “Because we did it right the first time, and it’s not like I tell you how to run a courtroom.”  Left off is the unstated “Although I apparently should.”

I agree with Hot Air: the sooner the Wisconsin Supreme Court takes this away from Sumi, the better.  At this rate, I fully expect the next ruling to feature Bozo the Clown.  Come to think of it, if Bozo has space on his judicial docket…

Moe Lane (crosspost)

*I am assuming.

COMMENTS

  • Michael Dugas

    She should be recusing herself due to her sons Union affiliation and employment history.
    http://www.laborunionreport.com/portal/2011/03/wisconsin-judge-maryann-sumi-her-seiu-afl-cio-political-operative-son/

  • congressworksforus
  • bk
  • nvrepub

    if “process” is the judge’s hangup?

  • chipbennett

    This is a matter of principle: of rule of law, of separation of powers, and of the democratic process.

    The WI legislature did pass the law under legal, due process.

    Judge Sumi can go pound sand.

  • chipbennett

    This timeline clearly indicates a pattern of gross incompetence and willful judicial activism..

    Some of my more liberal friends are shocked – shocked! – at my mere suggestion that she should be impeached; and yet, she absolutely should be.

  • Marcus_Traianus

    One with Sumi and a Bozo nose.

    I know you guys have mad Photoshop skillz. What gives?

  • johnt

    True of both animals and Democrats. Another ugly example of the depths which these uncivilized things have sunk to. This fool knows she is making it up as she goes along, at least I think she does. It only matters that her party wins, if that’s the word.
    Things have become worse, leftists have not yet hit the nadir of their obscene corruption.
    It’s going to be a very interesting 2012, be prepared.

  • joepyne

    “At this rate, I fully expect the next ruling to feature Bozo the Clown. Come to think of it, if Bozo has space on his judicial docket?”

    he only did it because the unions told him to.

    I always favored Chucko the Clown … better birthday cakes and prizes.

    Besides, Hobo Kelly would be a better fit for Sumi anyway, don’t you think?

  • lineholder

    Now, Walker is saying his admin will adhere to amended TRO.

    http://host.madison.com/wsj/news/local/govt-and-politics/article_0abe773a-5ba2-11e0-a42c-001cc4c03286.html

    Pass it again, Walker!!! Just do it and get it done.

    I’m so glad I live in RTW state. I’ve been saying that over and over to myself every time I look at what’s going on in WI.

  • ArchTriumph

    For the record Sumi was appointed 1998 by Republican Governor Tommy Thompson. Elected in 1999 and reelected in 2005.

    That said, Reagan nominated O’Conner and Kennedy who have ruled anti-constitutionally.

    Her son is a union member and ardently opposed to Gov. Scott Walker – so that apple may not have fallen far from the tree…

  • chipbennett

    You see, Tommy Thompson was a Repulican only for a certain definition of Republican.

  • cja99

    I’m just wondering if Sumi has a conflict of interest with the Unions and should not even have a right to slap an injunction on this legislation.

  • cja99

    I’m just wondering if Sumi has a conflict of interest with the Unions and should not even have a right to slap an injunction on this legislation

  • carolina

    (wishing the legislature would just pass it again)
    She has put herself in this position. Now she will get to live with it. Serves her right.

  • powertothepeople

    her son worked for the union as a bog dog, lobbied for them, and now runs a political activist group that gets paid by them.

  • hunter10

    has it Sumi got her law degree from Sears & Roebuck. Also rumored Sears wants it back now.

  • carolina

    Former gov Pat Lucey has switched from co-chair of Prosser’s campaign to endorsing Kloppenberg. The heat is obviously really on. I hope WI folks can see through all of this.

  • melbedewy

    I’m beginning to think there’s a Trojan Horse in the Wisconsin Republican party.
    To not re- pass this with 24 hours notice is pure idiocy of the rankest sort.