« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Hey, I have a request for the USFWS.

That being the US Fish and Wildlife Service. Anyway, I have a request: can you let us know the name of the idiot who decided to fine an 11 year old Virginia girl $535 for saving a baby woodpecker? Particularly since said idiot decided that she couldn’t bear to confront such a potentially violent criminal without a Virginia state trooper in tow*? And after you release the name, can you guys fire that person? – I kid, I kid: like you’d not protect one of your own. Heck, scaring a kid probably got the aforementioned idiot extra points.

This one is going around: Mark Steyn (via Ace of Spades Headlines) is using it in relation to the not-really-related, but reasonable-enough-point that Barack Obama is an elitist, wasteful snob who loves the comfortable lifestyle associated with his job more than European royal families love the lifestyle associated with theirs. But the original story is quite bad enough on its own terms. What particularly bugs me about it? The girl was clearly trying to do what she was taught to do by her culture and her teachers: that is, be a steward to the environment, help out endangered species, repair the ‘damage’ done by Man’s encroachment on Nature, all that feel-good ecological stuff. And some of that is not, in fact, a bad thing for you to do.

Apparently, you just can’t do it where Fish & Wildlife can see.

Moe Lane (crosspost)

PS: “…according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, “The citation was processed unintentionally,” and the agency apologized for “the clerical error.”" Note: the apology was not for “Geez, but our staffer totally flew off of the handle, exercised poor judgement, misappropriated resources, and generally made the rest of us look like a cross between Smokey the Bear and the East German Stasi.” Raise your hand if you’re surprised…

*This footnote is addressed to any random officials from the Commonwealth of Virginia who might be reading this post – or to their staff: there’s nothing stopping you fine folks from checking into this story on your own. After all, the USFWS dragged one of your people into this mess in the first place.

COMMENTS

  • vamoose

    If Ms. Butinski of USFWS was a law enforcement officer, why did she need VSP to accompany her? If not, why didn’t she have a USFWS law enforcement officer accompany her rather than VSP? There are legitimate reasons for USFWS and state police to work together, but this isn’t one of them.

  • earlgrey

    People. Common sense and decency SHOULD matter. This official needs to be revealed and/or fired.

  • lineholder

    commented on this?

  • fbks

    by National Park Service “law” enforcement for boat registration infractions.
    On the previous handcuffing incident, the man’s name is Tim Henry. He was working on his boat which was on the Yukon River bank and he was with his wife and child. As many here in Alaska, he simply does not like the NPS and refused to talk to them. That means silence, ignoring, no name calling or profanity, nothing. In the same manner many Norwegians dealt with the German occupation forces.
    He was cuffed in front of his family and left that way for HOURS, while the same rangers involved in the Wilde incident attempted to verify his identity. He was never charged or suspected for any crime or regulatory infraction.
    Keep in mind the entire population of Eagle is approximately 150, Circle about 120 and they are about 150 river miles apart. Tim’s incident occurred about 60 miles downriver from Eagle. There are no other communities in between, and everyone KNOWS everyone.
    The Wilde story is more dramatic. Jim’s wife was close to him in the boat, and by using a shotgun the ranger endangered her life as well as Jim’s. Although an LEO “law enforcement officer”, the ranger did not know what type (buck shot or slugs) of shells were in the shotgun. Consider the NPS boat was rolling in the water created by the disturbance from the two boats motion causing unsure footing for the ranger.
    The Yukon is a very wide, fast and powerful river. The water is full of silt, and when overboard the tendency is for your clothes to fill with silt and drag you under. Fighting the current is impossible, and once under the surface it is impossible to see anything (logs, debris, human bodies, whatever).
    Jim’s wife is a European Holocaust survivor, and when on the stand testified she dealt with the same type of mental trauma as during the Nazi occupation of her native country. Jim, who is elderly, was thrown to the muddy bank upon reaching the shore before being cuffed. He was hauled off to Circle, and his elderly wife and family friend were left at the Slaven’s Cabin for days with no boat or means to leave.
    On the way to Circle, Jim had to navigate the NPS boat as the “rangers” were unfamiliar with the multitude of sloughs and backwaters that commence downriver as the Yukon enters the Yukon Flats region. They passed a boat on the bank and did not stop to aid the people who requested by waving at them. Apparently escorting their 71 year old “criminal” was too important than lending aid to boaters.
    Another interesting fact is that the NPS boat jet unit equipped outboard exceeded the manufacturer?s recommendations. There is simply too much power for the frame and the NPS boat would not pass a Coast Guard inspection.
    In Alaska the offense of an expired or lack of a boat registration is commonly around a $100 citation. The citation could simply have been dropped in the mail. I understand our Governor would rather the Alaska State Troopers deal with these types of infractions.
    The fact that the NPS rangers were in Canada raises an interesting issue. NPS “LEOs” carry loaded sidearms, which is a serious criminal act upon entering Canada. They were not on official business, responding to a call for aid from Canadian authorities. This was an extracurricular tax payer money buying the fuel trip. Dawson City is about 105 river miles above Eagle, the Canadian Border about 12 miles upriver from Eagle.
    At least the USFWS in Virginia did not cuff and arrest Skylar’s Mom. Now that would have taught the family a lesson in wantonly violating federal law.

    Links to a couple of pertinent articles.

    http://www.alaskadispatch.com/article/feds-defend-aiming-shotgun-elderly-alaskans-yukon-river

    http://www.alaskadispatch.com/article/park-service-tries-tame-wilde-arrest-blowback

  • snowshooze

    I can’t find it. It is a howl… Don chastized NPS for patrolling a navigable waterway, and asked oif the Coast Guard had ceded their authority of inland waterways, he chewed them to pieces.
    Now to see they were invading Canada and assaulting private parties with firearms… ( Canada is a gun control country… not sure but I think these ” Rangers” should be in a Canaidian prison )
    Those articles cited just don’t carry the full flavor of the level of stupidity and arrogance shown.
    And the Rangers were patrolling a heavy traffic area…yeah…what… two boats go by in a WEEK is rush hour.
    Thanks for the links. Yep, I am still mad too.

  • fbks

    although emotional rhetoric “feels” good, I would like to see in addition:
    1) Meaningful legal action against both “rogue” rangers and their supervisors.
    2) Alaska Region specified budget cuts to in fact reduce the amount of resources available to the NPS and minimize it’s opportunities for mischief.
    3) Meaningful prosecution of the RS 2477Public Access rights of way across federal lands in Alaska.
    The use of deadly force, as defined by Alaska Law, as used against the Wilde party occurred about 80 miles below Eagle within Alaska. The NPS trespass into Canada occurred previously, as recorded by their gps unit. The Canadian Fisheries maintains a fish camp to monitor salmon returns about 8 miles upriver from the border. The folks there are friendly, and they often hire local fur trappers for off season employment.
    Another issue with the Yukon Charley unit of the park system is their interference with Alaska predator control programs. Moose and caribou populations are enhanced by reducing wolf numbers by helicopter harvest and trapping and snaring, and reducing bear populations by liberal harvest seasons.
    All wildlife belongs to the state of Alaska. It is in our interest to enhance ungulate populations for the use of subsistence, general and sport hunters. Predator control is very effective. In fact the major role of the USFWS in Alaska used to be predation control of a variety of species during the 1940 to 1960s. Subsequent to their efforts, Alaska became known for large populations of all wildlife, including predators due to the increase in the entire biomass of wildlife.
    The NPS concentrates on wolf “management”. I have seen their data charts showing the ideal number of wolves to inhabit what is known as the Yukon Charley (YUCH). The problem is that the NPS has no idea of overall moose densities or calf survival rates within the YUCH. Of course the YUCH spans several drainages and portions of drainages on both banks of the Yukon, with a variety of habitat, some more suitable for moose browse than other portions.
    Aside from moose, the Fortymile caribou herd seasonally moves through portions of the YUCH which must be factored in for wolf sustenance. Some wolf packs concentrate on moose predation and others on caribou. These packs range widely across the artificial boundaries of the YUCH. When they are on adjacent state or private lands, they become fair game for predator control teams, and they belong to the state of Alaska.
    When the caribou move and the resident moose population (there is seasonal migration for moose, mostly restricted to the bulls moving into the higher willow belts during the summer and winter and moving down to the river drainages during the rut. Cows and calves tend to summer in the bottoms near water for escape terrain, and then into the hills during the winter months) is depressed, wolves tend to move and combined with this is inter pack violence and often cannibalism.
    By not allowing predator control on federal lands, these park units become predator pits, either devoid of, or with limited moose populations. These same wolves now move onto the richer state lands and help themselves.
    Although details can be argued by preservationists, these are facts. For the NPS to create hard numbers for what a “healthy” wolf population in a given geographical area should be, without examining the quantity and quality of food resources available to them is nonsense.
    Federal land policy should not be designed to thwart state policies on adjacent lands. And in any case, data submitted by federal agencies and deemed scientific, should in fact be scientific.

  • fbks

    do you have any thoughts on the feasibility of replacing him with a fiscal conservative during the primary? During the next election the only thing Alaska can contribute is to make sure our three electoral votes go to the final Republican candidate, and if possible, “upgrade” our Representative.

  • snowshooze

    It isn’t the peoples house seat… it’s Don’s!
    He slaughtered the last guy who took him on. Sheldon Fisher only wound up with 25% Cox 6% and Don took the rest in the primary.
    He is cranky, mean and old. Pretty much entrenched.
    And probably filthy too. Is he still in the ethics investigation, or did they finish that?
    Honestly, I have enough great concerns over Murkowski and Begich and consider them both unfit for office.
    I voted Miller even though I knew he was damaged goods. The recount was pitiful…
    With all the headaches they generate, Don is safely off my radar. I never asked him for a favor, and don’t know him.
    Don at least is an outdoorsman.. so there’s that.

  • fbks

    subject incase I have missed something. I cannot think of hardly any conservative politicians in Alaska, much less sufficiently popular and savvy to win statewide.
    Don is reliable on certain issues, and I can state from experience that he takes issues like the NPS seriously and his office will help constituents. The lack of longlasting effects is more a systemic problem with the federal agencies, and until their size and power is reduced by national pressure, we will probably have to grin and bear it.
    I remained loyal to Miller and there is no doubt in my mind that the write in campaign for Lisa had fraudulent elements to the extent that I know what happened in several villages. Even if the Division of Elections had performed legitimate audits and monitored rural polling, I am not sure a sufficient number of ballots would have been disqualified to make up for the mass support Lisa enjoyed from urban Democrats and liberal/leftist Independents.
    In the end, I think Lisa holds her office in a legitimate manner because the left mobilized its’ support for her, and through mistakes made by Miller and the media frenzy, a sufficient number of “moderate” Republicans voted for Lisa.
    As much as I look forward to working to replace her, I cannot wait to work to replace Begich.

  • snowshooze

    Yeah, predators are a serious problem. Fighting the Federal government over Game management should never be even so much as an issue.
    It’s all uphilll these days. We are Californicated.
    Wolf control via helicopter? Yep, we got it.
    I do not understand the law that prevents us from incorporating the old bounty system instead of having $3500.00 per hour helicopters full of government employees flying around having a great time .
    Bounties only pay for real results.
    It has been many years since I was able to get my last moose.
    And yet they tell me they are at an all time high.
    I hunt from the pickup, Usually I don’t have any time to do my research, and only get a weekend or two. I hike in…and the motored competition is hard to get around. 4 wheelers, snowmobiles, airplanes, horses too… and me afoot. So maybe there are a bunch of moose piled up somewhere’s where they been chased off to.
    That moose hole I got the last one out of is currently overrun with brownies. It’s too darned tough to even get a horse into, so it was good for me. The 2 miles of hiking from the truck was bad but carrying a moose out of there was a nightmare. 2 guys, 3 trips, every pack over 100#… record pack…135#
    Brown bears eat moose. They ate my moose, and I don’t like bear meat at all. That stuff is evil. I’d like to just go in there and do a nice little cleanup. The magpies would vote for it.
    Anyway… if our game management has become some kind of political football, our fish management is a joke. Commercial fishing interests out of Seattle have that. ( I once was a commercial fisherman, but I see both sides..)
    I guess… I do not believe there is a place for federal or national interfereance in such matters at all. We have enough troubles fighting our own around here.

  • jonnymadison

    like you said, no real accountability for an disgusting power trip.

    is using unjust power to punish a moral act worse than simply perfoming an immoral act? Seems like it is to me.

  • fbks

    system a few years ago, in certain areas in unit 20E adjacent to the YUCH. There is no legal barrier for non-profits such as SCI Chapters, Trappers Association, or even the creation of an association to purchase wolves at higher than market prices, creating a “bounty”. As long as private donors interested in enhancing wildlife populations rather than state funds are used.
    The problem pertains to the need to cover large geographic areas during small windows of ideal weather and snow conditions for anything to be close to effective. Land based trappers can work their areas, and private plane operators can jump around to hot spots, and depending on circumstances make small dents in the wolf population.
    An effective scientific based plan must remove set numbers of animals for a set amount of time. It is arguably one of the most effective uses of wildlife funds used by ADF&G. 80% of wildlife funds come from non-residents through the sharing of federal Robertson/Pittman funds and the sale of license and tags. Enhancing opportunity for all hunters is a direct result of predator control.
    We have a sordid history of Knowles era biologists who simply made excuses to continue no action for wildlife under pressure from animal rights/preservationists groups mostly based in the states. When the Board of Game removed the “buffer” zone around Denali NP, and the state got serious again (commencing under Palin and continuing with Parnell) to ignore the threatened boycotts and go ahead with predator control many areas have seen a rebound in ungulates and the animals rights groups were proved to be paper tigers.
    If you are hunting the road system you will have a hard time. It is telling that the moose density in Sweden, which is on the same latitude and similar to the Interior is many times higher than here.

  • Tbone

    resource related bureaucracy, has been taken over by eco-nazis. This is the type of behavior that one should expect when dealing with these agencies.

  • NRPax

    Is that the bad press made USFWS admit the error and cancel the fine. I have a feeling that the agent as well as the people that processed the citation probably had a Come To Jesus Meeting regarding the bad light that the agency has been cast in.

  • toadold

    People are getting really fed up with the Fed alphabets bureaucracies. They ignore the legislatures, the courts, local and state law enforcement. They are messing up the economy and endangering peoples lives. They may find themselves unemployed or in some desperate situation and no one will lift a hand to help them. The gravy train and tolerance for abuse is not forever.

  • snowshooze

    And they say 60% of the budget is SS and Military spending..
    I looked at the pie chart for the last budget…2010..
    An I realized… the whole pie was spending!!!
    Gosh. But them alpha bits are stuck around all over the place.
    Defense has their own, SS has theirs.. and piles more. Their percentages I think are severely polluted to pad themselves on ” Non-discretionary spending ”
    It isn’t any wonder that Obama referred the farmer to the USDA rather than the appropriate alphabet EPA agency.
    We could lose most of them, and the avaerge citizen wouldn’t even miss them .
    I figure if they were ALL on unemployment, we would SAVE money.
    Some would move to real jobs, some may be pretty much unfit for anything but brueaucracy. Anyway, unemployment being cheaper than salary & benefits. Plus as it is, they generate paperwork, regulations and debt. Subtract those out… and who cares???
    You may not believe it, but recently, a musician friend called me a redneck…

  • izoneguy

    You are correct – I would gladly pay all the Federal employees 26 weeks of unemployment. It won’t be 99 weeks anymore – we can’t afford it.
    Most federal employees make twice what the private sector salary would be for the same job. So hopefully they saved enough money to make the change.
    The gravy train will end soon and this is why the establishment is running
    around like chickens with their heads cut off.

  • izoneguy

    Heh, heh….I get called that and worse….thing is – I am a redneck.

    A friend of mine said I should start a blog and call it

    Redneck Report.


    (This is not me, I sent this to my friend)

  • snowshooze

    An I heard yer wife was a redneck.. an yer dog…redneck too.

  • izoneguy
  • pttx333

    Rednecks are mostly flag-waving patriots, and they ride motorcyles to the funerals of our warriors to not only honor the deceased but to block the evil ones who go there to protest.

    I’ve been called a West Texas hick and that compliment made me stand taller! Was brought up in West Texas so one would suppose that a W.T. hick is just like a redneck. If so, YEE HAW and thank ya!