« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

DSCC inadvertently reveals its 2012 battleground?

Not that, if they did, they intended to do that, mind you: they were probably just intending to scare their donors into giving them money (link via @MattCover) by screaming about how us awful, awful Republicans are so insistent that you should show have to show a picture ID when you vote.  Well, they’re Democrats.  Screaming about Republicans is what they do – besides, these days they don’t precisely have a plethora of other options that are what you’d call viable when it comes to winning elections.

But that’s not what interests me.  No, what interests me is this sentence:

More than 5 million voters could be affected in states including Ohio, Florida, Wisconsin, Nevada, Virginia and California…

Hmm. Let’s look at those states.  Assessments of each one is based on the latest Cook ratings for the Electoral College and the Senate.

  • Ohio.  Democratic-held.  Sherrod Brown is popular, and normally favored to hold the seat; Ohio is increasingly hostile territory for Obama, and cannot be relied to stay Democratic in the Presidential election.
  • Florida.  Democratic-held. See Ohio, except that Ben [Bill, sorry] Nelson is not as popular.
  • Wisconsin. Democratic-held. Open seat: both the Senate and the Presidential election may flip.
  • Nevada. Republican-held.  Incumbent Dean Heller is one of only two GOP Senators who can be considered at this point to be at any real risk of losing his seat, and that’s only because he was appointed after the incumbent resigned.  The state itself may flip in the Presidential election.
  • Virginia. Democratic-held.  Open seat: like Wisconsin, both the Senate and the Presidential election may flip.
  • California. Democratic-held.  …Generally considered a safe Democratic haven, on both the Senate and Presidential level.

Gee.  One of these things is not like the other.  You have six states, five of which are considered to be battleground states in 2012 (and all five were won by Obama in the first place); of those five states, four are held by Democrats, and all four are considered at least competitive.  The five million number undoubtedly comes from this report by the Brennan Center for Justice, by the way.  Please note that these ‘restrictions’ consist of: photo ID requirements (Wisconsin); reform of voter registration drives (Florida); reform of early voting (Ohio, Florida); reform of felon voting (Florida).

Please note that the DSCC just read the executive summary and not the full report; if they had, they would have noticed that Nevada and California have voter-related bills, not laws, in play.  For that matter, if the DSCC had been thinking then they might have considered that there is not a chance in Hell that the Republicans could currently pass anything in California – and, in fact, what’s waiting for Brown’s signature right now is a bill that would make it easier for people to register to vote by taking the process online.  I bring this up because, really, there’s no reason for California to be on that list: it’s not part of any sort of supposed nefarious Republican plot; it’s not particularly reforming its election fraud prevention process; and it’s not realistically a state in play on either the Senate or Presidential level.

Unless, of course, those rumors about Dianne Feinstein being in trouble and considering retirement are actually true.  It turns out that her erstwhile treasurer may have stolen over four million dollars from Feinstein’s campaign fund (bringing down the Senators cash-on-hand from 5.2 million to 662 thousand); that’s a lot of money to lose at a critical moment, even in California and even for a powerful Senator like Feinstein.  Which may be why the DSCC slipped California into the mix…

Moe Lane (crosspost)

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • Repair_Man_Jack

    I’m required to show a photo ID to get on base every morning and go to work. AM I ever effected? Only when I suffer a stupid attack and forget my ID.

  • earlgrey

    they have never to my knowledge had a problem. We have even had some people show passports.

  • circlegranch

    He also signed a law that ensures deployed active duty military members get ballots and that they votes are counted.

  • lookingforward

    We must not again fall into the trap that California is a battleground state. We wasted tens of millions of dollars that could have helped elect Republicans in Colorado and other winnable races in 2010. If extremely well-funded, moderate Republicans could not win in an extremely anti-democrat year, it is not going to happen. We need to accept that California is lost and focus on winnable races (such as WI, OH, VA and others).

  • blooch

    and, awwwwwwwww…..”:

    “The Los Angeles County Democratic Party passed around a donations basket at a meeting and laid off one employee this week, unsure they’d be able to make payroll. Fifty-one college students can’t get access to scholarships issued by the Legislative Black Caucus Policy Institute. That’s all thanks to the arrest of prominent California treasurer Kinde Durkee, accused of making personal use of her clients’ funds.”

    http://tpmmuckraker.talkingpointsmemo.com/kinde_durkee/

    Warning: Pics NSFE

  • freemanja1991

    Why don’t they try to do it by ballot incentive? Since Republican and Independents support it by a wide margin it could pass.

  • gawken

    Look, she’s 78, so if she does in fact run, it will most likely be her last term. She’d have go go on a fund raising blitz, and for what? Consider:

    GOP will likely control the Senate, and in 2014 may well have a filibuster proof majority.
    Dem Senate caucus in 2012 will be smaller, and much more hard liberal left…with Schumer as likely minority leader.
    At age 80+..those weekly trips back and forth to the coast take a toll

    So she may well decide..why..I don’t need it, and retire..

  • gawken

    Look, she’s 78, so if she does in fact run, it will most likely be her last term. She’d have go go on a fund raising blitz, and for what? Consider:

    GOP will likely control the Senate, and in 2014 may well have a filibuster proof majority.
    Dem Senate caucus in 2012 will be smaller, and much more hard liberal left…with Schumer as likely minority leader.
    At age 80+..those weekly trips back and forth to the coast take a toll

    So she may well decide..why..I don’t need it, and retire..

  • earlgrey

    so that it would make a bigger splash. What would the number be if they took CA out of the states that supposedly risk voter disenfranchisement?

  • ThePoliticalHat

    …if he were the Democratic nominee.

  • carolina

    The 5 million number is totally bogus anyway. dems are such good whiners.

  • http://moelane.com/ Moe Lane

    About Wisconsin.

    Moe Lane

    PS: Ohio, too. Virginia in 2009.

  • toothpick

    Problem is, it costs $1-2M to get something on a statewide ballot in CA, then another bunch of cash to beat back the inevitable Union-led attacks. In principle, voter ID is a good idea, the question is whether that’s the best way to spend the money.

  • johnt

    and is plainly racist besides, as everything else is it seems.

  • earlgrey

    republican.

  • lookingforward

    Ohio and Virginia have always been swing states. Even Wisconsin (outside of Madison) remains a fairly conservative midwestern state. CA is nuts. The reality is that it takes an enormous amount of money to run a race in California, and if Carly and Meg couldn’t get CA voters to choose them over an unpopular former governor and an unpopular sitting senator, despite being moderate and spending unfathomable amounts of money, I think our resources are better spent elsewhere. If we would have given half the help to Ken Buck we gave to Carly, he would be the junior senator from CO today.

  • acat

    Is Cali winnable by the GOP? If so, what kind of candidate would it take?

    Do we need Zombie Reagan?

    Mew

  • westcoastpatriette

    I’m tired of hearing Cali is hopelessly blue forever. But I’d like to hear some ideas from others.

    Personally, the Republican slate was weak in 2010, in my opinion. I also think there is massive voter fraud skewing the wins way out of proportion. It will take a major Tea Party type uprising –and finding new blood to run against the old to win right now.

  • freemanja1991

    pass easy by 5 points, make it simple.
    Voters must show a form of photo ID that has the voters DOB, and expires, to cast a vote in California.
    Simple hard to argue against.
    Make another part allowing for “poor” to be protected. Even some dems will vote for it.