« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

The fix is in on NY *state* redistricting?

I dunno. They’re certainly scurrying around like… things that scurry… in Albany tonight. This report suggests that the fix is in for the state legislature, and that Governor Cuomo is going to cave on his promise to support reform today, in exchange for promises of reform tomorrow; but it also suggests that the NY legislature has decided to let the courts design the Congressional maps, after all.

Which means… OK. Current breakdown is 21 Democrats, 8 Republicans. After this election, we’re looking at… OK, Hinchey is retiring and Turner is running for Senate, and their districts were erased. 20 Democrats, 7 Republicans. Assume that Hochul and Buerkle cancel each other out*. Still 20/7. Of the remaining Members of Congress, the two most vulnerable are Bishop and Owens, and I think that at least one of them is going to be tossed. So it’s reasonable to think that a 19/8 D/R result is very possible… and that even an 18/9 D/R one is not outside the realm of possibility. Which is to say, one where the NY Republican delegation somehow increases in size in the face of a two-seat CD loss, or at least stands pat.

:pause:

I’m flabbergasted. Both at this scenario, and at the thought that state Democrats would sign off on it. Or, more accurately, just let it happen because it was getting in the way of protecting their own seats.

Moe Lane (crosspost)

*Ann Marie Buerkle has no intention of tamely waiting for the axe to fall, of course. And her upset of the incumbent in 2010 was noteworthy even in an election cycle that had many, many noteworthy moments. So her situation is not exactly like that of Kathy Horchul, who is probably even now being advised not to sign up for any multi-year gym memberships.

COMMENTS

  • On_the_Right

    Buerkle is in a tough spot, yes. Her district went for Obama by 14.2% in ’08. I don’t think she can run 14.3% ahead of the presidential ticket, but I do thikn she can run (say) 9-10% ahead.

    Unless the GOP nominates Paladino in NY-27, Hochul is simply done.

    Bishop and Owens won’t be pushovers. They can be beaten, but it would take the right candidate and a partisan environment that is at least semi-decent (say, 2002-ish). Doesn’t have to be like 2010, but it can’t be like 06-08, either.

  • RSSS

    maybe there’s hope for other state delegations that are totally or overwhelming dominated by D’s – i.e. MA,CA,MD, etc.

  • On_the_Right

    Maryland is giong to be 7-1 as long as the current lines are in place.

    No incumbent D is going to lose to an R under the current lines in Massachusetts. The open race this year in MA-04 is not *Totally* off the radar, but it will take a near-perfect candidate running a near-perfect race. I wouldn’t count on that.

  • freemanja1991

  • freemanja1991

    We can get more then 9. Slaughter might retire in the Monroe County district yet. The Monroe County Exec is a republican. Steve Israel, and Carolyn McCarthy are in reach with good candidates. Lowey could be beat if we get Deneen Borelli to run. How bad is Engle hurting if we get a former Republican Mayor of Yonkers to run? And what did Burke go to, she was D+3 now what D+5?

  • http://californiateapartypolitics.blogspot.com/ smokedaddy

    the Dem controlled sham commission did leave a number of Dem districts with a fairly small cushion in their desire to add 3-5 new House members. So, if, as I think eminently possible, there is a backlash to the complete Dem control which now exists, then some of these Dem +5 districts may actually go the other way, and there are a lot of them.

  • On_the_Right

    But I’ll believe it when I see the GOP candidate get 44-45% there

  • http://www.thehayride.com MacAoidh

    Ackerman’s Leaving? So Long, Sweetie

  • freemanja1991

    It’s dummy mandered, we will pick up several left leaning seats in Cali