« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Tech at Night: Google, Wireless Internet

Tech at Night

Good evening. Even as Google tonight wins some recognition from conservatives for its observing Veterans day on the search homepage, the firm is still under fire. As Machiavelli warned, become the big guy and everyone turns on you. Now it’s the big television networks going after Google. Specifically, they’re blocking Google TV from watching streams of their shows. Fox has since joined the blockade I believe.

This strikes me as a scared overreaction, and a poorly thought out one at that. As soon as Google TV’s User Agent is changed to match a desktop browser, the blockade is history and there’s nothing the networks can do about that.

Not all criticisms of Google are looking particularly interesting, though. When I see Halliburton invoked without irony, I seriously just stop reading. I’m sure Darrell Issa’s Oversight Committee will be plenty busy looking into the White House’s connections anyway, though. It’s not like he can’t print more subpoenas.

DIAGF, TSA. There’s a good metaphor for government in there somewhere, that any program ends with a bureaucrat’s hand where the sun doesn’t shine.

Oh, and just another little side note to remember when Net Neutrality advocates pretend that there’s no real competition among ISPs: wireless providers are rapidly becoming ISPs first and voice providers second. And it’ll only get more obvious once the newer wireless technologies come online.

COMMENTS

  • Raven

    “As soon as Google TV?s User Agent is changed to match a desktop browser”

    Translation for the merely end-user barely literate?

    I don’t read this feature often because I can’t track what is being said. Could you provide translations of the technical phrases and terms?

  • usastandup

    Twisted answer: A Benz pulls up to the entrance and a man gets out and runs to open the door. Out steps an aged but refined model known as MS IE8. She’s obviously due anytime and rumor has it the tradition will carry on and she will be named MS IE9. Behind the piece of work is several generations of mothers. MS IE5, MS IE6, and MS IE7 are all there. Makes a Mother proud. They walk to the theater entrance and tell the doorman their name and are escorted straight in. Next, A big Lincoln Navigator rolls up and a big woman known as Opera climbs out and rolls up to the doorman and announces herself. She too is escorted right in. Next a Ford pickup screeches to a halt an out comes a burly fellow named Mozilla with a very beautiful item beside him known as Firefoxy. They prance up and tell the doorman their names and are escorted in. Finally, a Jeep pulls up and out steps a refined man that walks to the doorman and says “Hello, My name is Ibe Google, IV”. The doorman says, “I’m sorry sir, but your name is not
    on the list.I can’t let you in.” Disappointed but determined to attend the event, Ibe steps back and watches a few lesser known attendees allowed in. This gets him to thinking about his cousin Im Chrome who is welcome everywhere. He gets back into his Jeep and pulls around the corner, takes off his coat, reverses it, and puts it back on. He walks back around the corner and up to the doorman. He says “Hello, my name is Im Chrome.” The doorman says “Welcome Sir. Come right this way.” The moral of the story is it’s not who you are but who you can say you are.

    Simple answer: All brands of internet browsers applications (User Agent) identify themselves (in a string of characters sent) to the service providers (Web Servers, etc.) during communications.
    A handshake so to speak. this allows the service to make accommodations to the services provided as needed, such as to disallow use of that service. Google TV could easily can try to first identify itself in the User Agent string as “Google TV” and if services were disallowed, it could repeat the attempt with a User Agent string of “Google Chrome” and then be allowed access. Same application but masquerading as a Google Chrome browser application (User Agent).

    My morning coffee must have been spiked……

  • Finrod

    Here’s another TSA horror story:

    http://wewontfly.com/question-tsa-risk

  • quesoviejo

    What I’ve read is that the blocking is not based on browser user agent. It is based on an identifier sent by the flash player on the client machine, which is harder to fake since this is not standard HTTP.

    Translation: Harder to fake than changing one simple setting

    source: http://www.engadget.com/2010/11/10/fox-com-joins-nbc-abc-and-cbs-by-blocking-google-tv/