« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Repealing the ban on the common light bulb

By Reps. Joe Barton, Marsha Blackburn and Michael Burgess

On this page two weeks ago, Erick lamented the fact that American factory workers are losing jobs to China as a result of the de facto ban on the incandescent light bulb. Light bulbs seem to be a pretty simple part of our lives today. It gets dark, you flip a switch and presto – light happens. But a law passed by Democrats in 2007 – the Pelosi non-energy energy bill – banned nearly all use of the incandescent light bulb by 2014.

A recent Washington Post reported GE is shuttering a plant in Winchester, Va., killing 200 jobs in the process.

“‘Everybody’s jumping on the green bandwagon,’ said Pat Doyle, 54, who has worked at the plant for 26 years. But ‘we’ve been sold out. First sold out by the government. Then sold out by GE.’”

Turns out the compact florescent light bulb, or CFLs as they are commonly known, can’t be produced cheaply enough in America so we’ve turned to China, where virtually every CFL is produced.

Even the AFL-CIO isn’t happy about the move to CFLs. The labor union’s Web site, Screw That Bulb, makes the valid point that there are many ways to save electricity without shifting to the mercury-filled compact florescent bulb from China, or anywhere.

Fortunately, we were already working on legislation to repeal the ban. Today we’ve introduced H.R. 6144, the Better Use of Light Bulbs Act, which repeals the ban on the incandescent bulb that has been turning back the night ever since Thomas Edison ended the era of a world lit only by fire in 1879. It’s as simple as that, though technically it repeals Subtitle B of Title III of the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007.

The unanticipated consequence of the ’07 act – Washington-mandated layoffs in the middle of a desperate recession – is one of many examples of what happens when politicians and activists think they know better than consumers and workers. From the health insurance you’re allowed to have, to the car you can drive, to the light bulbs you can buy, Washington is making too many decisions that are better left to people who work for their own paychecks and earn their own living.

We believe that the consumer, not Washington, is capable of deciding which light bulb works best. Democrats, however, believe that you just can’t be trusted to make the right decision. If Democrats want to show the folks back home that they understand the pent-up frustration in this country, they’ll start by supporting our bill.

COMMENTS

  • dpddj

    I, too, bought several cases of various wattage incandescent bulbs and have enough to last until 2050 or so.

    • mark1957

      And I saved a ton of money by buying in bulk. A case was the price of 4-four packs at the grocery store price. I also found long life incandescents that last for 12,500 hrs. for $1.99 each. I’m mercury free.

      • Thomas_Hauber

        I’m curious where did you buy them in bulk from? Amazon.com?

        • davesinsanantonio

          I tried Sam’s yesterday and only found CFLs and grossly overpriced LEDs. Fortunately, my local grocery chain still sells the traditional bulbs for the time being. But, I would like a bulk seller if there is one in my city.

          • sbo6220

            You can get the 10,000 hr incandescents in various wattages and clear or frosted for $1.25 each in any quantity. Frankly I own a small business and could use extra sales these days. lightsources@earthlink.net if you’re interested.

          • JSobieski

            Can I store them for a couple of years and still enjoy a full lifespan of use?

          • sbo6220

            No problem. I have old movie projector bulbs in stock that have pictures of “June Cleaver” on the box! Same technology, just a different application of an incandescent.

  • justfedup

    We initially jumped on the CFL bandwagon, but logic circuits kicked in. How long will it be before we hear about mercury contamination in landfills & the need for the “government to do something”. We too, have been stockpiling light bulbs. At about a quarter each, it’s a good deal.

    • gekster

      Are there earthquakes, hurricanes, or tornadoes in your area?
      The average cost of cleaning up one broken CFL is between $1.000 to $2.000.

      Even a small house, let alone an average house, has at least ten to fifteen bulbs in them.

      God forbid, if one of the three things happens to your house, and it gets destroyed, how much will the clean up cost be, let alone having to throw away all of your possesions that will be contaminated by the mercury on them.

      And on a side note, remember when they called W evil and uncareing because he risisted changing the allowable mercury content in water from .004 ppb to .003 ppb. (parts per billion)
      And then they force this on us?

  • blooch

    You mean this one?

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5DJEDdvujF8

    Sorry…I love the tune.

    We have CFL’s almost everywhere. As the incandescents die, I replace them with CFL bulbs. The most annoying thing about them, other than their toxicity, is how they start of so dim when I turn them on, and they take a minute or two getting to full throttle. On the other hand, they’re a good way to ease into the light at 5:00AM.

    • Richard Mullins

      and I love to have Cool White CFL’s that aren’t all that bad on my eyes. It has saved me a lot of money, but I’m worried a light switch in one of the bathrooms in my apartment. The fixture has all Cool White CFLs on it and it seems to having a bit of a problem turning on. Other than that, no problems with them, but LED’s aren’t coming down to replaceable price levels yet. Any chance to use Cheech and Chong is great.

      • blooch

        once they get warmed up the light is good…much better than I thought it would be before I tried them. One other thing…I have a couple of CFL’s in a fixture with a dimmer switch, and they make an annoying hum which varies in pitch depending on where the dimmer is set. I can play “Flight of the Bumblebee” with it, though.

        • Richard Mullins

          and there is Dimmer switch friendly CFL’s out there. The lowest cost I can find for LED’S is $39 at cyberguys.com and the best LED light for the cost is a Phillips bulb at $49. The best is a CC Crane LED Light bulb. I have small lamps in my bedroom and when they are both on, it gives good light.

      • bettered

        Somebody needs to get a clue. There is no question that climate change hysteria was a scam to get gov’t funding for questionable projects. We now know that weather is unaffected by human behavior. So what are we to do to stop hurricanes? or ocean currents. What a farce.

      • shadowmane

        The ones in my bathroom have stopped working completely. They are supposed to have a life of a few years, yet these lights only lasted a few months before they stopped working altogether. We have incandescent bulbs in there now.

        I might look into LED’s. Even though they are probably expensive, they will last almost a decade before they begin to dim. They won’t blow, they’ll just get dimmer and dimmer until I replace them.

        • acat

          They are more expensive, especially if you want the “warm white” ones, but they throw light just like traditional bulbs. Well .. almost. For some applications, there are multiple LEDs inside an enclosure and that means it’s not a uniform light from a single source, so for spotlights the shadows thrown aren’t as crisp. That’s the only real issue.

          One other nice part about LEDs is that the under-cabinet strips are pretty cheap, and very versatile. I stuck strips of them across the garage ceiling and light up the whole space, no shadows in the corners, and no Gore bulb hanging down to get broken, and no broken glass from fluorescents. (the garage is also my workshop and .. stuff happens)

          Mew

  • Menlo

    For those interested though, there is ONE American manufacturer of those mercury twirls.

    I’d be surprised if no one was able to put out an alternative to the ugly poisonous twirls that meets Jane Harman’s criteria. I expect to see more than one variety when I look on the store shelves, but I guess that’s not the case in Communist regimes. Anyway, I have recently seen reduced-wattage versions of regular bulbs on store shelves.

    Of course it’s always possible they won’t. In that case, I’ll be using candles for ALL of my lighting. And I do mean that quite seriously. I don’t buy ANYTHING made in China (and often buy used or do without a lot), and I would not buy one of those twirls to save my life no matter where it was made.

    • acat

      Much more expensive than Gorebulbs but at least some should still be made here…

      Mew

  • Praying

    NOT because I’m green, but b/c I’m cheap. I figured they cost more initially but they last so much longer than the old bulbs… except that they DON’T!! Maybe I got a bum batch of CFL bulbs, but they don’t seem to last a day longer than the old faithful incandescent bulb. And they give me a headache – thousands of tiny “flickers” a second – it bothers some people, and I am one. So I’m back to stockpiling the incandescent bulbs. Plus you don’t have to don CERCLA superfund gear if you accidentally drop and break one.

    • deano64

      retail store type applications. You turn them on and they stay on all day long. But, once they are applied to a typical home situation their life decreases greatly. What decreases the life is turning them on and off and on again etc. Typical home situation right? You go into a room turn on the light, you leave the room and turn out the light. Also they don’t work with dimmer swithes and can actually be dangerous if you do use them in those situations. Let me keep my incandescents!

  • gazill

    because it is cheaper, or are there significant regulations by the EPA, maybe because of the mercury content, that are also prohibitive? I for one, cannot stand the CFL. They do not last long (perhaps because of the on/off nature of a residence), and the light they put out is far inferior.

    • Menlo

      Lots of other countries have cheap labor and less regulatory oversight, so there has to be more to it.

      • JSobieski

        No other market in the world is at large except for the US in terms of GDP. Even with the 51% domestic partner, there is lots of money to be made.

        If Mexico was smart, they would adopt Chinese policies and within 10 years they would be a very wealth country.

  • nalora

    Please also see this report by the CBC about the effects on health of these bulbs.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-3YrEMlmE9E

  • desertguy

    There is a potential FIRE danger when a CFL is installed in the lighting circuit with a DIMMER control. Almost all dimmers are for incandescent bulbs ONLY! This ban is another case on progressives thinking they know better and want to control everyone else!

  • tlhanger

    Got one and like someone else stated, it flickers when the fan is on. Hate them and who the hell bans light bulbs and for what reason? Think about it. I never minded buying the old bulbs and they make the light better. If a Republicans had wanted it, the papers would of been full of MERCURY CONTAMINATION TOUTED BY REPUBLICANS.
    If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!

  • indyjohn

    that CFL’s have an integral ballast that loses its efficiency as the temperature decreases? When the temperature drops toward freezing, CFL’s begin to dim, and if the temperature drops below about 25F, they stop producing light entirely. Here in the Hoosier State, where nighttime temperatures average well below freezing for the three winter months, CFL’s make zero sense for outdoor applications. Without incandescents, what are we supposed to do? Did the geniuses in D. C. stop to consider this problem?

    • acat

      The answer to your question, though, is LEDs for light and the transformers to convert 110vac to 12vdc that the LEDs require for heat.

      Mew

      • indyjohn

        I can get a 40W incandescent at Wal-Mart for about $0.27. If it lasts for 2,000 hours, I have four bulb changes a year. My total expense is $1.08 + the cost of electricity. A set of LED’s and a transformer? LED’s have a life of what? 20,000 hours? I would like to know the economics involved.

        • acat

          To start with, LEDs are definitely more expensive. No question. If the Dems hadn’t interfered in the marketplace, we wouldn’t even be having this discussion. That said, if the proposed bill to repeal the ban on incandescent bulbs fails to pass, given that incandescents do have a shelf life, i.e. an amount of time they can sit on a shelf and retain sufficient vacuum. Glass is slightly porous, eh?

          Manufacturers are currently claiming 45,000 hours for an LED before it gets below 60% of initial light. (LEDs slowly go dim) That’s over 5 years, although depending on application, you may want to change earlier. That’d be 20 incandescent bulbs, or 5 bucks. Not bad.

          LEDs cost a lot more, though. Amazon says I can pay over $100 for a single bulb to replace a floodlight bulb I’d pay $12 for today. For a straight 60-watt thing, it’s around $50. In theory, this will come down in time, but ..

          What I’m looking at, though, aren’t straight bulbs but LED strips. A 16 foot strip of LEDs is about $60, and can be split into 16 1-foot lengths, or $3.50 per foot, plus transformer.

          As far as transformers go, a simple 12v dc transformer is enough to kick this strip over, and for only a foot, it doesn’t take much wattage. Chances are there’s an old “wall wart” transformer around somewhere that can be re-purposed.

          Mew

  • phred

    I just bought a bathroom exhaust fan that had GU-24 bayonet-type pin connections for the two 13-watt pig-tail bulbs required. This feature was a stealth item and it was only after I destroyed the packaging did I realize the trap that had been laid for me.

    As time passes, the new replacement for the time tested and universally used Edison-base socketed bulb will permeate the market until it will be necessary to buy replacement fixtures to overcome the lack of Edison-based bulbs.

    Stock up if you can my friends, I am, but the govt plan will eventually neuter our end run through stockpiling the incandescents. Just as refrigerant charge points on air conditioning equipment was changed to a weird configuration, God’s own standard for electric light bulbs is being monkeyed with and will eventually thwart the efforts of even the most industrious among us.

    One more step toward the nanny state. The west must conform to this silly crap while the third world uses western-banned refrigerant to degrease parts and makes children’s toys out of asbestos.

  • capeconservative

    that you do NOT put a CFL in a stairway ENCLOSED light fixture!

    Thankfully there was no fire, but the entire fixture burned/melted/stunk up the house – you can be assured there is a normal light bulb in place now.

    I admit it…I failed to read the directions that said no enclosed fixtures, but what about all the manufacturers of enclosed fixtures once there are only CFL bulbs available? Are they already working on new designs? I did put a low-wattage CFL in the enclosed shower light and so far, because it on for such short periods of time, it’s done okay.

    There is NO reason why we should all be subjected to the whims of the idiotGore!

    Thanks, Congressman Barton…I wish you SUCCESS in your attempt to remove the government from our light bulb choices!!!!!

    Let’s see now…what kind of car to drive, what kind of food to eat or drink, whether or not one can choose to smoke, removing parental rights to inform their own children about sexuality, where to bank, where to get a loan for college, RESPONSIBLE Americans watching their hard-earned tax dollars go to bailout those IRRESPONSIBLE homeowners who failed to consider whether they could afford to be a homeowner or not, coming soon will be the government advising us whether we can go to a doctor or not…the list goes on and on and on and on…America, the land of the once free – REMEMBER IN NOVEMBER!!!!

  • astrojohn8

    Let’s look at this mercury non-issue logically. Fluorescent tubes have been around for decades and also contain minute amounts of mercury. Where was the hew (or is it hue?) and cry all those years? Why does CFL mercury “require” these ridiculous cleanup processes while broken fluorescent tubes do not (or have they been ignored all these years)?

    • JSobieski

      Since they are the SAME PEOPLE who are pushing the “ridiculous cleanup processes”.

      If

    • blooch

      Nannystate is coming to spoil the fun for all the forklift jockeys in the warehouse who throw tube javelins at the dumpster after 3:00 break.

  • Death_of_the_Donkey

    I actually use CFL’s almost everywhere in my house, but need the heat generated by a normal bulb for my turtle. Also, here is an interesting fact, part of the law that banned the normal light bulb also mandated that ceiling fan light kits come with a regulator to prevent a total wattage above some threshold from working (maybe to stop fires, who knows), but the funny thing is that this regulator interferes with CFL’s, causing them to flicker like a strobe light and thus you have to use the less energy efficient normal bulbs even if you didn’t want to (or at least one of them to stop the circuit). This is all probably moot anyways, as once LED’s get down in price no one is going to want anything else (except turtle owners like me).

  • Death_of_the_Donkey

    Please add to your bill the removal of the wattage regulator for ceiling fan light kits too.

  • sbo6220

    As a tech rep in the lighting industry for over 25 years, I am disgusted with the CFL’s no matter where or how they’re made. They may save energy (which is a pittance compared to a stove, refrigerator, hair dryer, or closthes dryer, and many other things used in a home) but they pollute our landfills and water table with mercury. If the progressives thought everyone that uses the CFLs would take their burned out ones to hazardous waste sites for disposal, they’re as crazy as I figure they are. One more sign of their incompetence and another “unintended consequence” which is worse for our environment the staying with “energy efficient” versions of incandescent and halogen lamps.

    Did you know that if you use an incandescent bulb rated to withstand 130 volts instead of 120 volts, you will lose 22% of the light output, reduce wattage use by 12%, but gain 2.5 to 3 times the normal life at 120 volts? Need more light output? Get a 100W 130V bulb instead of a 75W one.

    LEDs need more than price reduction. Their “throw” needs greatly improved.
    Although you can shine one quite a distance (as in a flashlight), they do not illuminate an area well without combining a large amount of them. Nor do many of them have a wide angle. They are very efficient for some uses, but in a home, they are currently more decorative than direct replacements for standard incandescents.

  • Dan McLaughlin

    My wife and I have been stockpiling bulbs in the basement after having bad experiences with CFLs. This needs to happen.

  • audax
  • myoda176

    When it’s time to dispose of your CFL’s just send them to your congressman instead of following the 87 step disposal plan. When he/she complains that you have sent them a hazardous material in the mail, ask them why they are requiring you to have it in your home.

  • BA Cyclone

    There are but a handful of perfect examples of the Federal government over-reaching its Constitutional limits, and this is certainly one.

    I am fine with adopting new technologies where they make sense for application and budget – at my discretion.

    Frankly, it should never be the business of any government what light bulb I purchase to use on my property.

    Please keep up your work to serve us and protect our liberty!

  • graciegirl

    Previous diary mentioned that some teachers no longer use them because the flickering causes learning disabilities (Autism?) They also exacerbate migraine headaches and will be miserable for those of us who love to read for hours.

    It is unconsicionable that the government control us like this! Thank you for doing this and please don’t give up!

  • proudmarinemom

    and the first one I took out of the package broke into pieces in my hand as I attempted to screw it into a recessed light fixture. I threw it in the regular trash, completely unaware that it contained mercury.

    The second bul, which gave off a greenish, sickly light, burned out in 3 days.

    The other two are still in the package. I’ll send them to Ed Begley, I guess. I don’t want these things in my house.

  • dnha14

    I’m gathering a closet full of incandescent bulbs. The CFL’s are useful in some situations, but when direct light is needed for actually seeing something, like my reading lamp, they’re not happening. Why don’t we just learn to turn lights off when they are not in use?

  • davesinsanantonio

    If these idiots who love to boss other people around so much really cared about it, they should get busy and invent an acceptable alternative, then the problem would take care of itself without any government coercion. If the government has to force you to buy a “better light bulb”, it isn’t better! I mean, if you build a better mousetrap, the government will force people to beat a path to your door?

  • dudette

    whatever—I want a CHOICE! Hands off my bulbs! I have stockpiled icandescent because i detest the anemic lighting of CFL and I detest being prodded to buy what the govt wants. Whatever the govt tells me to do i want to do the opposite. They are too bossy and I bet a lot of those senators and congressmen use regular lights at home. BTW I worked in health and safety and you do NOT want mercury spilling around on the floors. Very bad.

  • edintexas

    At least not to my Congresscritter. Jeb Hensarling (TX-5th) doesn’t deserve that sort of abuse. But there are others…

    Oh, wait – I don’t have any of the danged things. If the government wants to force me to buy them, there has to be something wrong with them – or at least the very act of trying to mandate my purchase is enough reason to ignore the government’s order.

  • Jack_Savage

    I put an LED fixture in my closet and it now feels like a freaking tanning salon – the heat is incredible.

    Anyway, keep up the commentary. We need you.

  • Achance

    on them. I don’t use them at home. I have LEDs for my cockpit lights and anchor light on the boat because LEDs use little electricity and the cockpit lights and anchor light are on for long periods of time and, especially the anchor light, often when I’m on battery power only.

  • mramerica

    Someone once said, “Since trifles make the sum of human things, and half our misery from our foibles springs”.We should all understand the trivial, yet extreme lengths, democrats will go to achieve their liberal agenda. They seek to control every aspect of American life, from the mundane to the excessive .

  • timchgo9

    bulbs… but, the girlfirend is “concerned” about the “state of the environment” so, we have them damned CFL’s all over the house. They flicker, put out lame light, don’t last very long, and are pretty fragile. They are not dimmer friendly, and they don’t last anywhere near as long as regular bulbs. However, in the one lamp I use for reading, I have a 100W incandescent in there. Makes reading easier.

  • lighthouse

    On the one hand,
    the ideology that reflects a belief in regulations and subsidy schemes,
    not just in relation to consumer products,
    but also more widely in regulating and subsidizing the supply and use of energy,
    that add upfront costs for questionable savings down the line,
    and limit the freedom of businesses and consumers to do what they want.
    If this ideology seems attractive, then taxation is better on every
    count along the energy usage chain.
    Applied to products, the comparatively easier and more adaptable
    taxation on cheap products
    that in turn can cover subsidy costs in equilibrating markets of for
    example light bulbs, while retaining choice.

    On the other hand,
    the ideology of market based competition to deliver desired products
    and services,
    pushing profit-seeking businesses to do market research of what people
    want, including energy saving products,
    keeping down their cost, creating real jobs sustained by market demand,
    while at the same time promoting the efficient use of energy
    throughout the energy usage chain, from generation to distribution to
    consumption,
    and keeping freedom of choice for businesses and consumers.

    Why all energy efficiency regulations are wrong,
    and how they affect buildings, cars, washing machines etc,
    with a focus on light bulbs
    http://ceolas.net
    .