« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Things That Threaten Our Children

True Equality Is Only Found At Absolute Zero

Daffyd over at The Big Lizards Blog begins an excellent post on some of the problems of Modern Leftism with a timely reprint of the opening paragraph of the Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. short story Harrison Bergeron.

THE YEAR WAS 2081, and everybody was finally equal. They weren’t only equal before God and the law. They were equal every which way. Nobody was smarter than anybody else. Nobody was better looking than anybody else. Nobody was stronger or quicker than anybody else. All this equality was due to the 211th, 212th, and 213th Amendments to the Constitution, and to the unceasing vigilance of agents of the United States Handicapper General.

Daffyd cites this as a framework to discuss voter fraud. The story provides an even better departure point to discuss the problems that both Liberals and Conservatives have noticed afflicting younger Americans. Perspicacious observers on both ends of the political spectrum have noticed the blindingly obvious. Children graduating from our schools now are frequently less well educated than the cohorts of Americans that have grown up in the previous 40 years.

The Left does what it always does and assumes that all problems under the sun are caused by the Iniquitous GOP and their fleet of black helicopters flying missions from a Death Star equipped with E-Coli Rays. It’s always a case where the Konservatives just won’t let government spend money because they want the rich to keep it all buried in Mason jars in Sheldon Anderson’s backyard. The fact that government spending has been almost constantly skyrocketing since 1960 (over the same period of time that young Americans have suffered a tragic reversal of fortunes) is flushed down some Orwellian memory hole.

A more compelling look at what ails American Youth would examine what happens when a society allows its standards of excellence and conduct to die in a bonfire. Heather MacDonald describes the impact of this death of standards by examining the experiences of one teacher in Minneapolis/St. Paul. The teacher, Mr. Benner, taught fifth graders and describes the following set of policies and activities initiated by his school district.

Like districts across the county, the St. Paul public school system has been on a mission to lower the black suspension rate, following complaints by local activists and black parents. A highly regarded principal lost his job because his school had “too many” suspensions of black second- and fourth-graders. The school system has sent its staff to $350,000 worth of “cultural-proficiency” training, where they learned to “examine the presence and role of ‘Whiteness.’ ” The district spent another $2 million or so to implement an anti-suspension behavioral-modification program embraced by the Obama administration.

Benner despises the impact this policy has had on his students. He describes his concerns over the impact youths have suffered from George W. Bush once termed “the soft bigotry of low expectations.”

Benner sees the consequences of this anti-discipline push nearly every day in the worsening behavior of students. He overheard a fifth-grade boy tell a girl: “B****, I’ll f*** you and s*** you.” (“I wanted to throw him against the locker,” Benner recalls.) The boy’s teacher told Benner that she felt powerless to punish the misbehavior.

The students being patronized quickly realize the cowardice of modern authority. They smell blood and go for the kill. When teachers feel powerless to enforce discipline, school becomes nothing more than a jail to keep children out of other people’s hair for a few hours every day.

Allen Zollman, a middle school remedial teacher in Pennsylvania, told an eighth-grade girl who would not stop talking over him: “You have two choices: either stop talking, or I will have you removed.” Her response: “I’m going to torture you. I’m doing this because I can’t be removed.”

The end result of these policies is the very equality that liberals quest for. Nobody is any better than anyone else. Attempting to learn in a classroom where bored young boys can walk up to any girl in the class an announce “B****, I’ll f*** you and s*** you.” is obviously impossible.

The modern American School becomes a place where the absolute worst people in the room can say “I’m going to torture you. I’m doing this because I can’t be removed.” And nothing will ever happen to them. At that point, the children are incarcerated instead of educated. The experience becomes a worthless exercise in wasting the youth of America’s children at the expense of their families via local taxation. But that’s just fine with the American Left because true equality can only occur at absolute zero.

COMMENTS

  • lineholder

    But are you sure his name is Sheldon Anderson?

    The situation in our schools is almost as dangerous to our nation’s future than the fiscal track leading us off the cliff is viewed as being. Students can’t even do the basics, much less to engage in comprehensive problem-solving and trouble-shooting.

    And the Liberals support the status quo because they feel like any changes to the system will threaten their chances of ultimately succeeding in their political and socio-economic goals.

    All this PC “cultural diversity” mumbo-jumbo isn’t helping young Americans get the basic fundamentals that they would need to survive. I’d almost bet this was a program promoted by the 81 duplicate agencies in the federal government pertaining to Teacher Quality, right?

    • andrewjs

      It’s Sheldon Adelson, not Anderson.

      An article about the problems with education does itself no favors when this elementary bit of information is incorrect.

  • renny

    If it isn’t the race hustlers and the ed pscho nuts (every one needs to be happy-la la), it’s the ed. “professionals” with PhD’s in kindergarten group theory who have done away with learning skills of any kind, memorizing anything, repeating any information, having discussions based on facts instead of feelings, and continuing the Western tradition of real liberal arts in favor of nitwit categories of racism, class, and gender that for the most part are meaningless and worthless.

    Home school students, send them to private religious schools, and look for small private Southern colleges using the Classical curriculum for any kind of real “1950s” education.

  • msctex

    Now what we really need to do is apply these values and standards to Health Care.

    • kopen

      That there are no standards .. everything is acceptable if it feels good ..
      welcome to the end of Anerica as we have known it !

  • kentucky

    during my middle and high school years. One of the teachers learned to deal with this student very effectively. At the beginning of every class the teacher would unlock the supply closet/storage room, and say “All right, get in there.” The student would sit in the supply closet with the door closed and copy the textbook word for word.

    Getting the disruptive students out of the classroom is an easy fix. The hard part is educating the disruptive students, because they spend most of their time with families that don’t care what they do or see no value in education when you can make a living out of crime.

    • wintermute

      who dealt with a continuously troublesome student by placing his desk against the back wall, facing backwards. Not sure how that worked, but it did. I feel like many teachers could be good if they were allowed to be. I can’t imagine being a kid and trying to learn when things like “B****, I?ll f*** you and s*** you.” are being thrown around without consequence.

      Some parents are truly miserable human beings.

      • clamdigger53

        the teachers dont have the guts to stand up and STRIKE for education!

        • kopen

          The only thing they will strike for is more money and benefits for them selves
          the students are only a means to get these goodies ..
          Get government out of school administration .. Cut the number of administrators
          along with all the red tape ..
          I can remember when “School” was a place of learning, now it is more a place to indoctrinate our kids to be liberals and sexual perverts ..

    • avgjo

      When the American school system worked, parents took the side of the teachers unless something was really amiss. Now, the parent is even more violent than the kid. Add to that ‘activists’ and ‘community leaders’ that use agitation techniques to bring law and media to bear on those who want to do the right thing, and all the ingredients for a nice big batch of disaster are there.

      I believe it is this that sort of thing Franklin had in mind with his comment

      As nations become corrupt and vicious, they have more need of masters.

      People like this are perfect wards of big government – slaves by nature. They live by emotion, such that even their perverse ‘values’ are little more than a set of prejudices, anger over perceived and real injustices from the past and passions and lusts translated into rules of action. As long as these passions and appetites are satisfied (or seemingly so), they have no care about things like freedom or right and wrong. A statist can take perfect advantage of this, as history bears out. In the end, these useful idiots have even the pittance they traded their freedom for taken from them.

      I said the solution for this specific problem is to bring problem parents to heel. This will not, in any likelihood, happen. These lowlives have a ‘voice’, a vote. They have ‘advocates’, agitators that wrap themselves in the Constitution whose hypocrisy and wrong-doing is hidden by a corrupt media. Our ‘leaders’, reflective of the society that puts them into office, are too self-interested to deal with these problems in the right way. And so the process will continue, the wound will fester, until the body is corrupted to death.

      • clamdigger53

        i dont think spreading your legs for a bigger check is exactly being a Parent.

        • avgjo

          If you’re referring to Franklin, you’re 100% WRONG.

          April 17, 1787, to Abbes Chalut and Arnaud

          Go to google books and look up ‘Memoirs of Benjamin Franklin, Vol. 1′ P. 604 and read the above-referenced letter.

          As for your comment about parents, cute. I’m talking in the biological sense.

          I’m still trying to determine the purpose of your post…

          • clamdigger53

            Sorry for crossing wires!

          • clamdigger53

            I was referring to what these kids are going home to.

  • Viet71

    I live in a wooded Connecticut town populated by professionals and landed gentry. The public schools here are very good, though they suffered from NCLB heavy-handedness.

    Hartford, Connecticut schools, on the other hand, just plain suck (not for lack of money or computers, BTW).

    The real question is, what expectations do the child’s parents and society have for the child’s education? If the answer is zero, the outcome will be zero.

  • jakee308

    of how teachers maintained control: That can’t happen anymore.

    Those of you who think you’re schools are immune due to where they are and the community around them? Think again.

    If obama is reelected they plan to enact an eductational reform known as “regional schools” No not the regions you’re thinking of.

    Your nice cozy and well off school district will be paired with a city or urban school that is not and YOUR taxes (property, income whatever) that now funds YOUR school will now be divided between YOUR school and the other school(s) in your REGION.

    You won’t have the control or the money to fund your school like you do now.

    They intend to recover all the money that the whites took with them to the suburbs.

    For some reason they think that money is what makes a school excellent. For some reason they refuse to account for the students homelife, neighborhood and “community” as having any influence on why certain children do not learn or if they learn, they do not behave.

    There will be riots over this. count on it.

    • checkmate2012

      Luckily it was overturned as there was outrage from the “richer” districts. But it lasted several years until it was overturned.

      I know, not the best source, but it gives an overview anyway:
      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robin_Hood_plan

      I’m with Viet71, if a parent doesn’t invest their time in their child’s education, the outcome will be zero regardless of the money spent.

      The outcome of the problems pointed out in this diary, is teaching to the lowest denominator, thus collapsing the system for average students, let alone bright kids.

      • jakee308

        They haven’t been put off because of one time being rejected or overturned or whatever.

        They’re at this again. They’re trying to do it in Connecticut around Hartford (this is 6 yrs ago) using a civil rights suit (I don’t know the status lately) to force the suburban schools to share their money with Hartford schools.

        Incrementalism. The left never gives up while the right goes back to business after they think they’ve won.

        It’s why we’re where we are now.

        They’ve taken over entertainment, education, the newspapers and the courts, the only thing left is Congress and they’re a weak reed against all that jabber.

        If one nation could be pointed to as the cause of all this, we’d have gone to WAR.

  • macbookben

    …making more suckers to be taken advantage of.

  • clamdigger53

    If thats the case close down the schools,an internet education would obviously be preferable! Dark clouds were suddenly dominating the skies when Hitler took over educating.

  • johnhiggins1990

    As a former public school teacher, this article gets to the heart of the problem. There can be no discipline in the public schools, and therefore schools become, at best, daycare facilities and at worse, jails. If parents don’t value education, then their children shouldn’t be allowed to disrupt the learning process for others; this can’t happen in a public school. The only option is to get your kids out of the public schools.

    • Repair_Man_Jack

      Absent a concerted effort to discipline children, anyone who values their children’s future will either district shop or put their kids in private school so that they never come into contact with some of the people mentioned in the post above. It will become a class and cultural divide in the US when that process accelerates.

  • airandlight

    There are many people out there who believe that “equality” is a good thing but they are only partly right. It is equality of opportunity that is a very good thing, but equality itself simply does not exist in any form that is good either for the individual or the group.

    Of course the absolute, most equal that people can be to each other is DEAD. All dead people are absolutely and perfectly equal. As you rise up slightly above the level of death you find apathy of the kind that pervades the Bowery bum’s men’s shelter, but if you’ve ever noticed some male or female sitting or lying on the sidewalk, filthy and ragged with his/her hand out there is still is still a marked “equality” between people at that stratum of society.

    As you rise up further away from death, inequality begins to show up in the form of different abilities with different degrees of ability coming into view and so the further an individual or group rises above death a greater degree of inequality comes into play.

    So I believe it is safe to say that the more people in a society/civilization are equal to each other the closer that civilization is to death.

    • clamdigger53

      Drugs are a Big part of the problem,but our flaccid leaders through inaction and half measures are making things worse.I have it on the best of sources that all of the prisons are full and CANNOT take in anymore! This means the cities are all done.

  • vandalii

    My wife brought up an excellent point.

    Let’s say we come to our collective senses as a nation and recognize the need to return to Classical Education that skyrocketed the US to the top of the “I want to be educated there” list in the world. Let’s say we recognize the importance of understanding History, Science, English, Math and the Arts (yes, the Arts are a big part of true Classical Education aimed at equipping students to become well-rounded citizens).

    Let’s say we began to educate students appropriately — there will be those that need to know how to repair the Rocket Scientist’s car and air conditioning as well as those figuring out how to colonize Mars. We are not a one-size-fits-all society, so need to make education available for those doing the plumbing at my house as well as the plumbing in the Int’l Space Station. So we remember the good old days when there was Vo-Tech for the HS students headed in vocational directions and (actual) College Prep classes for students moving on to college and other post-HS education.

    Let’s say we really decide to do the right thing by our young people starting today.

    We don’t have any educators (in the public sector, anyway) that know the first thing about doing it. Most current teachers betweeen ages of 22 and 40 we educated during the educational decline in the 80′s and 90′s so never learned what is needed during their public schooling, then immediately got taught by meat-head social experimentors (remember “Open Space” classrooms? Geez!) foisting the latest theory on their students who, in turn, carry said social, psychological and educational theories out in the petri dish we call Public Education.

    Who would teach the teachers what they have no clue how to do?

    Yikes.

    • mollieb55

      I am in total agreement with all I have read above. I began teaching before the Federal Department of Ed. was created. I retired a couple of years ago because I could not take the system any more!

      There are teachers who do stand up and maintain discipline in the classroom. The parents then come in and complain to the principal who bring their wrath down upon the teacher without fail! Administration is only concerned about getting more money from the government. DON’T GIVE IT TO THEM! It goes to huge administrative offices, extra vice-principals, secretaries, large columns, huge lobbies.. It does NOT go to textbooks or a decent sized classroom or room to have research books and computers in the classroom. Schools have plenty of money and teacher salaries are fine! The rest of it is FAT!

      Get rid of NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND! It forces us to teach all children to lowest level possible.

      Devote the first 3 grades to reading, writing, and math.then add science and history. By 8th grade begin teaching logical thinking, teach them to recognize propaganda, persuasion, business, etc in speech and writing. Teach them how to research and how to recognize good sources! Bring back shop and home Ec.

      With these skills they can go on to college or vocational school or have the skills to apprentice in their interest.

      No more than 3 semester of “teaching techniques” in college! Introduce them. A teacher is born not made. There is an overabundance of “eduction” courses in college. Teach teachers their subject – make them experts in it! And make sure the principal assigns them to their field!

  • myron_j_poltroonian

    “Here here!”

  • aussiegothamite

    Full disclosure. I’m a lefty. Regular reader, extremely infrequent poster. American born living in Australia.

    I’m a chef studying part time to become a primary school teacher.

    I have to agree with some of what’s being said here. Where I live, per capita funding is assigned by the state, so there should be no difference between “poor” areas and more wealthy ones. There still is. The involvement and expectation of parents is still the thing that separates the schools rife with “at-risk” children from the schools doing well.

    I had trouble even submitting my application for inclusion in the teaching course, because I felt that my honest expectations of my future career would have to include the admission that some students were not going to do well, academically, for a variety of reasons. I know that despite my best efforts, there will be failures.

    I think teachers are pulled in a lot of different directions. It is simply not possible, mathematically or otherwise, for every child to be above average. That teachers feel they cannot be honest about this is a shame. The answer is that the requirements of teachers must be sensible and that the teachers must strive, individually and as a group, to make their jobs more professionally performed and accept accountability for both successes and failures.

    My goal is to be a professional teacher, in every sense of that word. The job, as I see it, is to provide children with the instruction and tools they need to learn the required skills, but also to guide them through the process of learning how to learn, which will serve them regardless of which profession they move into in the future. And also to require that they can demonstrate their proficiencies before moving on to the next level.

    Everybody loves fun and everybody loves praise, but that’s not the purpose of the education experience. As many here have said in different ways, a coach’s desire may be a team of perfect athletes, but some are going to be faster than others, and carrying somebody over the line doesn’t really help.

    Again, I’m a lefty, so I don’t find myself agreeing with a majority of what’s said on this site, but sometimes. Thank you for your hospitality

    Mike F

  • Pingback: Charles Wish

  • Pingback: electronic cigarette

  • Pingback: Welcome to My Blog

  • Pingback: Auto Forum

  • Pingback: ropa para bebes adidas

  • Pingback: zakopane noclegi

  • Pingback: Egal Gabbay CA

  • Pingback: skype pobierz

  • Pingback: Randki internetowe

  • Pingback: Mining

  • Pingback: ropa para bebes recien nacidos peru

  • Pingback: wzór cv

  • Pingback: backyard activities

  • Pingback: แทงบอล

  • Pingback: musica cristiana rojo

  • Pingback: resources

  • Pingback: Mining

  • Pingback: Links Eintragen

  • Pingback: descargar musica gratis 80 mp3

  • Pingback: check this

  • Pingback: borderlands

  • Pingback: bankruptcy

  • Pingback: kozmetika

  • Pingback: Payday Loans Online

  • Pingback: Koi

  • Pingback: diet yogurt

  • Pingback: home distilleries

  • Pingback: dieta proteinas para adelgazar rapido

  • Pingback: Pool Shop

  • Pingback: informe oficial

  • Pingback: dallas finish repair

  • Pingback: randki internetowe

  • Pingback: killer offer

  • Pingback: znajdz milosc

  • Pingback: rewelacyjny portla randkowy

  • Pingback: florida no fault auto insurance

  • Pingback: serwis randkowy

  • Pingback: aquarium filter

  • Pingback: super randka

  • Pingback: umow sie na randke

  • Pingback: znajdz milosc

  • Pingback: Doctors

  • Pingback: alcocklaw.com

  • Pingback: http://www.creditjusticeservices.com/cjsblog/trackback.php/1022/www.kirads.com/

  • Pingback: miami real estate listings

  • Pingback: survey research associates

  • Pingback: Exploretalent.net Reviews

  • Pingback: sewing machine repair singer

  • Pingback: master cleanse diet 40 days

  • Pingback: to do list for kids

  • Pingback: homes retirement

  • Pingback: fresh healthy vending new york

  • Pingback: umow sie na randke

  • Pingback: computer repairs belfast

  • Pingback: Ian Kanahele

  • Pingback: super randka

  • Pingback: Arkadaslik

  • Pingback: najlepsza randka

  • Pingback: strona z randkami

  • Pingback: management

  • Pingback: rzeszow randki

  • Pingback: conversational strengthen

  • Pingback: get beats

  • Pingback: easy payday loans

  • Pingback: Investment Opportunities

  • Pingback: SEO Services Australia

  • Pingback: Kathleen Burch

  • Pingback: dry cleaner

  • Pingback: listen to podcast

  • Pingback: learn to create wealth online

  • Pingback: wedding planner toscana

  • Pingback: profits noob

  • Pingback: ipl laser hair removal mascot

  • Pingback: Free Money

  • Pingback: Bellamy

  • Pingback: Post Free Classifieds

  • Pingback: Delmar

  • Pingback: pumpkin pie

  • Pingback: regarding Bing

  • Pingback: spectrum investment advisors

  • Pingback: Rayna Milosevic

  • Pingback: Minerva Stagnitto

  • Pingback: alfileres de novia

  • Pingback: Diseño web barato

  • Pingback: Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Player's Guide

  • Pingback: Clint Lamberton

  • Pingback: Angla Dallam

  • Pingback: my latest post

  • Pingback: sofy rozkładane

  • Pingback: green coffee pure extract

  • Pingback: แทงบอล

  • Pingback: John Markin

  • Pingback: Data Entry Jobs From Home

  • Pingback: anywho reverse phone lookup

  • Pingback: ecommerce software development in delhi

  • Pingback: Teichfolie

  • Pingback: service PLC mitsubishi

  • Pingback: Car Forum

  • Pingback: honda 599

  • Pingback: 60 minute payday loan reviews

  • Pingback: ketosis diet

  • Pingback: Welcome to My Blog

  • Pingback: najlepsza randka