« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Response to President Calderon

.

House Chamber, Washington, D.C. May 20, 2010. M. Speaker:

I rise to take strong exception to the speech of the President of Mexico while in this chamber today.

The Mexican government has made it very clear for many years that it holds American sovereignty in contempt and President Calderon’s behavior as a guest of the Congress confirms and underscores this attitude.

It is highly inappropriate for the President of Mexico to lecture Americans on American immigration policy, just as it would be for Americans to lecture Mexico on its laws.

It is obvious that President Calderon does not understand the nature of America or the purpose of our immigration law.

Unlike Mexico’s immigration law — which is brutally exclusionary — the purpose of America’s law is not to keep people out. It is to assure that as people come to the United States, they do so with the intention of becoming Americans and of raising their children as Americans.

Unlike Mexico, our nation embraces immigration and what makes that possible is assimilation.

A century ago President Teddy Roosevelt put it this way. He said:

“In the first place, we should insist that if the immigrant who comes here in good faith becomes an American and assimilates himself to us, he shall be treated on an exact equality with everyone else, for it is an outrage to discriminate against any such man because of creed, or birthplace, or origin. But this is predicated upon the person’s becoming in every facet an American, and nothing but an American…There can be no divided allegiance here. Any man who says he is an American, but something else also, isn’t an American at all. We have room for but one flag, the American flag… We have room for but one language here, and that is the English language … and we have room for but one sole loyalty and that is a loyalty to the American people.”

That is how we have built one great nation from the people of all the nations of the world.

The largest group of immigrants now comes from Mexico. A recent RAND study discovered that during most of the 20th Century, while our immigration laws were actually enforced, assimilation worked and made possible the swift attainment of the American dream for millions of immigrants seeking to escape conditions in Mexico.

That is the broader meaning of our nation’s motto, “E Pluribus Unum” – from many people, one people, the American people.

But there is now an element in our political structure that seeks to undermine that concept of “E Pluribus Unum.” It seeks to hyphenate Americans, to develop linguistic divisions, to assign rights and preferences based on race and ethnicity, and to elevate devotion to foreign ideologies and traditions, while at the same time denigrating American culture, American values and American founding principles.

In order to do so, they know that they have to stop the process of assimilation. In order to do that, they must undermine our immigration laws.

It is an outrage that a foreign head of state would appear in this chamber and actively seek to do so. And it is a disgrace that he would be cheered on from the left wing of the White House and by many Democrats in this Congress.

Arizona has not adopted a new immigration law. All it has done is to enforce existing law that President Obama refuses to enforce. It is hardly a radical policy to suggest that if an officer on a routine traffic stop encounters a driver with no driver’s license, no passport, and who doesn’t speak English, that maybe that individual might be here illegally.

And to those who say we must reform our immigration laws – I reply that we don’t need to reform them – we need to enforce them. Just as every other government does. Just as Mexico does.

Above all, this is a debate of, by and for the American people. If President Calderon wishes to participate in that debate, I invite him to obey our immigration laws, apply for citizenship, do what 600,000 LEGAL immigrants to our nation are doing right now, learn our history and our customs, and become an American. And then he will have every right to participate in that debate.

Until then, I would politely invite him to have the courtesy while a guest of this Congress to abide by the fundamental rules of diplomacy between civilized nations not to meddle in each other’s domestic debates.

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • Fla Mom

    for saying what so many of are thinking.

    Fla Mom

    • http://erickbrockway.wordpress.com/ Erick Brockway

      Not that schmuck we ended up with.

    • viejoken

      AZ SB1070. It occurs to me that as frequent visitors to Mexico my wife and I are always asked if we are U.S. citizens by ICE not once but again as we get closer to Phoenix. Now we are geezers in flowered print shirts. Are we being profiled? I think the illegals should be given the opportunity to answer that question.
      Ken, Phx

  • constitutionalconservative

    Only to find that Rep. McClintock was a step ahead of me.

    Anyone who reads this will understand why so many Californians think that Tom McClintock is the gold standard when it comes to conservatism,

    Thank you for your wise words. It says a lot about the state of our country right now that Rand Paul’s echoing the views of Bill Buckley, Barry Goldwater and Ronald Reagan was seen as a scandal today. Yet President Calderon’s insulting to America in our own Congress was met with applause by most Democratic members of the U.S. Congress.

  • TxCon

    Love the Teddy Roosevelt quote. It should be engrained into the mind of every immigrant to comes to this country.

    • mustango

      The only thing missing — and I’m sure you were loathe to assert this without cast-iron proof — was that Calderon was clearly invited and requested to make the remarks he made by President Obama himself. That’s really the only way to explain Calderon’s comfort in making what it every other respect is a massive breach of protocol.

      Of course Calderon may well soon find himself under the same bus Obama has thrown so many other people that are no longer of use to him, but that’s his problem.

    • azred

      I have received a copy of news reports from an Atlanta news station detailing some very disturbing information relating to identities of some of the hundreds of thousands of attempts at illegal entry to our country. These individuals are from 12 terrorist friendly countries including Iran, Afghanistan, Sudan, Somalia, Pakistan. My gut told me this was happening. But what is maddening is the fact it is lost in the tirades from the WH, Calderon, and the left in general. WHERE IS THE DHS IN THIS PROCESS?

      As an AZ resident, this is beyond a failure of the DHS and the media in general. It is not a matter of if, but when the next 9-11 happens.

      The WSBTV in Atlanta reports linked below.

      Video 1 http://www.wsbtv.com/video/23438021/index.html

      Video 2 http://www.wsbtv.com/video/23438712/index.html

      • ladyimpactohio

        according to Holder in this grilling by Rep. Ted Poe (TX).

        http://www.redstate.com/ladyimpactohio/2010/05/19/texas-rep-grills-holder-over-his-failure-to-read-az-immigration-law/

        Start at about the 2:40 mark. Actually, the whole segment is pretty entertaining.

        • azred
  • http://www.thehayride.com MacAoidh

    …and I only have a little more to add to it.

    http://thehayride.com/2010/05/scathing/

  • http://www.scragged.com petrarch

    I agree with your statement 100%. But I must respectfully ask, why did you and the rest of the Republicans present not walk out in response to Calderon’s blatant slap in the face of America? The time for showing courtesy to those who are not worthy of it is past. America is tired of being slapped in the face by our enemies – and, yes, any nation that is permitting if not aiding and abetting an armed invasion of the United States is an enemy – while our leaders just sit there and take it.

    • pirate55

      ….would serve as the strongest message Conservative America can send, and while we’re at it, maybe the UN can move its headquarters to Mexico City.

    • http://www.thehayride.com MacAoidh

      …to voice a sentiment or two.

      • joayn

        Fighting times demand action. Should’ve walked out. Republicans have to stop being so nice and obedient all the damn time. Some rebellion is mandatory to take back this country, gentlemen.

        Man, I sure felt the impotence of the GOP while watching Calderon’s speech and the ovation. Depressing.

        • Achance
    • irishgirl

      Thank you sir for standing up. That was brilliant, might I add.

  • johnt

    to give us a lecture on morals and law, a routine practice for the thieves who visit us from that kleptocracy. Good thing we had a true blue American President there to correct him,[ OK, I can dream.}
    Thanks Congressman, we need more of this in the public debate.

    • http://theminorityreportblog.com Repair_Man_Jack

      When in the kfuc are Mexican leaders ever going to be expected to do something useful w/ Mexico? It’s been well neigh 150 years since we’ve seriously messed with them. That whole Collossus of the North BS is totally out of date. Their excuse is over.

  • Raven

    Keep it up and watch your back.

  • Alberta
  • http://www.ArchitecturalShots.com mdyou

    …a disgusting sh**hole of a country whose people and culture have deteriorated by generations of failed leadership. And in Calderone, the failure continues.

    • http://www.suvstrategery.blogspot.com SoFiMil

      It’s especially gratifying to see this response came the same day as President Calderone’s comments, and not 24 hours later.

      • jamo

        Include the story about the rapist in Washington State. The leadership of our country aid and abet the drug traffic and human slavery that comes from Mexico.

        They give comfort to and support our enemies. They should be tried for treason and, if convicted, they should receive the punishment George Washington would have met out.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    What’s your position on human cloning?

    Because we need someone like you in CD45!

    Thank you!

  • SeriousLaff

    While the voters of Washington State were learning that a recent rape suspect had been deported 4 times their representatives were giving a standing ovation to the Mexican President who was compainig about efforts to enforce immigtation law. Was Patty Murray one of them?

    We need to match names with faces and run ads in every district in the country. They have shown their true colors and they aren’t red, white and blue.

    Both Murray and Wyden are vulnerable with this issue. Extremely high unemployment in the Northwest yet they both support every effort to import more foreign workers and make it easier for illegals to get into the country. Banks are running ads in Oregon encouraging Metricula cards. The voters here are getting fed up.

    This issue could turn both safe blue states red, if republicans mention it.

  • jwinston

    …that the Congressmen like Tom McClintock realize how many of us he’s speaking for. The left is skilled at using ad-hominems to shame people on immigration. He gives me more conviction to speak out. Congressman McClintock has my full support.

  • mkozikowski

    I would suggest, as absurd as it sounds,
    that we formally request the same of our President.

    For he is not debating the issue.
    He is dictating the destruction of our immigration tools.

    What a shame that we should be required to discuss this at all.