Dahlia Lithwick Hates Medical Research


The utter fecklessness of Slate’s Dahlia Lithwick is becoming more apparent by the day. Last week she decided that a proposed Virginia law, one that the Republican governor has suddenly gone squishy on, is the equivalent of rape because it could conceivably require something be “inserted into the vagina, and then moved around.”

Since then we’ve discovered that not only did Lithwick simply lie about what the law required and we’ve found that Virginia Planned Parenthood requires two ultrasounds with each abortion. Presumably to insure they only kill half their patients.

To hear Lithwick tell it, a trans-vaginal ultrasound is a horror tool invented by rich, white, elderly Republicans to enslave and defile women who only want to be left in peace to dismember their unborn child. The truth is quite different, and in the context of this artificial kerfuffle, and quite ironic.

From LifeNews:

Abortion advocates in Virginia have come under heavy criticism for equating the ultrasound legislation there would allow women to see before an abortion to rape.  Yet, while abortion backers say having an ultrasound is like getting raped, a 2003 study shows 99% of Planned Parenthood abortion facilities do them beforehand.

Apparently, in 2003 the medical journal Contraception reported on a survey conducted of abortion providers in the United States (article hosted by LifeNews). The finding, 99% of abortion providers either always or frequently used vaginal ultrasound for surgical abortions. 92% of the sites providing mifepristone induced abortions did vaginal ultrasound.

Based on the evidence thus far, the worst that can be said of the proposed Virginia law is that is recognizes the standard practice used in 99% of abortion facilities. The best that can be said about Lithwick is that she’s a mendacious know-nothing.

 


RSS feed

4 Comments Leave a comment

Using Lithwick's logic...

scipio62 (Diary) Wednesday, February 22nd at 2:51PM EDT (link)

…Planned Parenthood already “rapes” women before performing abortions.

So why hasn’t there been outrageous outrage by Lithwick against Planned Parenthood? Does she somehow believe some “rapes” or ok while others aren’t?

Of course, these are rhetorical questions.

A just war leads to a just peace and freedom. An unjust peace leads to death.

Cross-posted at Scipio the Metalcon.

 

Rape ultrasound, nope

misty Wednesday, February 22nd at 5:07PM EDT (link)

Just got home from my daughters first visit to the doctor, she is 8 weeks preggers and it was the first ultrasound, it was done vaginally. It was neat seeing the little ‘tadpole’ and you could see the heart beat. Awesome. They did not have anything like that when I was preggers with my daughter. I asked my daughter if she felt like she was being raped while having the test. She said no.

By the way we live in Richmond, VA. I think it is important for women to see that a life is forming inside them before they decide to KILL it. How is killing a child in the womb considered women’s health??? Where is the lefts compassion for the life of the child. After all, when it comes to giving more money to education all they scream about is that it is ‘for the children”. But they don’t give a damn about children if they don’t get money in their coffers for it. By the way, did Michele Obama feel that she was punished to have Sasha and Malia? Obama says his daughters would feel punished if they became pregnant.

 

Examination called rape, maybe the initial intrusion

oralchef Thursday, February 23rd at 8:13AM EDT (link)

Not to crass but didn’t the woman need to have something inserted into her vagina and moved around in order to get in this condition. Maybe a little forethought before putting yourself in that position might have prevented it. It takes 2 to tango.

 

Doesn't the Act of Abortion itself...

Ketih W Thursday, February 23rd at 10:05PM EDT (link)

Require the inserting of some tool and moving it around as well?

Just my $0.02

Keith W of St Louis

Not Racist
Not Violent
Just No Longer Silent