« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Jonathan Chait Hears A Dog Whistle

and that is really hard to do with your head in your watch pocket

We’ve been told now for over four years that any criticism of Obama is not based on his ineptness, incompetence, corruption, or moral cowardice but rather on our own racism.

If you want to know why Obama’s “you didn’t build that” statement resonates, it has nothing to do with Obama’s dislike for America or his rejection of hard work and exceptionalism as American values. Rather it is because you are racist. Don’t trust me, Jonathan Chait at New York Magazine, offers this as proof:

Mitt Romney’s plan of blatantly lying about President Obama’s “you didn’t build that” speech is clearly drawing blood. But what makes the attack work so well is not so much the lie itself but the broader subtext of it. [...]

The key thing is that Obama is angry, and he’s talking not in his normal voice but in a “black dialect.” This strikes at the core of Obama’s entire political identity: a soft-spoken, reasonable African-American with a Kansas accent. From the moment he stepped onto the national stage, Obama’s deepest political fear was being seen as a “traditional” black politician, one who was demanding redistribution from white America on behalf of his fellow African-Americans.

The entire key to the rise of the Republican Party from the mid-sixties through the nineties was that white Americans came to see the Democrats as taking money from the hard-working white middle class and giving it to a lazy black underclass. Reactivating that frame is still the most mortal threat to the Democrats and to Obama. That is why Obama is reacting so urgently to reestablish himself.

Got that. No one noticed Obama was in black in 2008 which allowed him to get elected. At some point this year people started saying to themselves, “hey, isn’t that a black guy in the White House?” And from that point on it has been down hill. Nothing to do with 15% actual unemployment, skyrocketing debt, rapacious government regulation, the administration of justice based on whim, billions given to Obama cronies, or key countries being handed over to islamic terrorists while representatives of those terrorist organization actually help make our security policy. Nope. Suddenly everyone discovered there was a black guy in the White House. And they only did it because Obama slipped up and sounded like an angry black guy.

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • http://www.neoavatara.com/blog neoavatara

    You just don’t get it. Simply by being a conservative, you are a racist. I say we accept it, behold it, bask in its glory, and move on.

    Pretty sad that liberals have destroyed the true meaning of the word, when racism, real racism, does still exist in the world.

    • renl57

      When Obama switches his “black dialect” on and off like a light bulb, depending on whether his audience is mostly black or mostly white.

      • zachv

        Just curious because, for example, when I’m in Germany I try to speak in German (or I learn how to say, “I cannot speak (language), do you mind if we speaking in English?)”. Or when foreign politicians are in America, they try to speak English. It shows that you are respectful of the audience.

        Never mind that it’s Obama who’s doing this, but if a politician wanted to be respectful of his audience, why then would he not choose to speak the dialect of his audience (assuming that he could manage it)?

        Not implying one thing or another any way, I’m just curious.

        • ceili_dancer

        • funwithknives

          Barry is using an “inflection” that he never was born with.
          { Southern Black Dialects in Indonesia? Or Hawaii? Hah-vahdd or Columbia? A Kenyan sub- dialect?}

          It’s an act and not a very convincing one.
          Bad theatre is just that and no more.

          But he’s talkin’ to de folks who think
          “… the Gubmints gots money…”, and all else is blurred.

          That about got it?

  • DerKrieger

    …believe that Obama does seek to punish whites as a form of overdue reparations but my opposition to him is purely because he’s an anti-capitalist, anti-American, socialist. I’d oppose any Democrat that had his beliefs and operated as he does.

  • irishgirl

    what this moron at New York whatever wrote, the last paragraph by streiff is simply priceless and made my afternoon.
    And really, these willfully blind idiots will never acknowledge the truth, so why chuckle when we can?
    Enjoyed the diary.

    • irishgirl

      n/t

  • aesthete

    “…but when I do, I prefer soft-spoken, reasonable African-Americans with Kansas accents.”

    -The Most Interesting Conservative in the World [Who Lives in Jonathan Chait's Head]

    • tnfriendofcoal101368

      nt

    • http://www.plumbbobblog.com Plumb_Bob

      …say PRECISELY that?

      OMFG!!! Chait is PROJECTING!!!

  • ctredstater

    I have not seen this covered anywhere, but I am convinced that one of the reasons that CJ Roberts put down his judicial robes and became a “legislator” in the Obamacare case was his vision of a nation torn apart by an unapologetic demoagogue whipping up class and racial fury to win an election.

    The vision of Obama campaigning against the Five White Guys in Robes – who “stole the 2000 election – but they won’t steal this one” – the damage it could have done to the nation at such a pivotal historic moment – the consequences – win or lose – of that type of campaign – were so negative that he decided to take a “lifetime mulligan” – and make this decision.

    I will forever be convinced that in Roberts mind he was putting the issue back in the hands of the electorate – who would render final judgmnent in November. I disagree completely with what he did – but all I have to do is look at stuff like this to think that this is part of what Roberts was looking at when he made his historic switch.

    • streiff

      I’m cranky because it is Friday pm and my morning was ruined by Dewhurst candibots.

      • ctredstater

        no bad intentions – I actually felt I was writing to the point. I am not as sophisticated re: the Red State etiquette.

        I am really pulling for Cruz – so thanks for your support of Cruz, who gave a truly wonderful speech at FreePac.

      • westcoastpatriette

        I’m kinda disgusted with myself for losing my cool. But, coming here making accusations against Erick with absolutely no evidence just pushed me over the edge.

  • eddiethegeek

    and while Black Americans tend to vote Democrat, they voted in 2008 for Obama more heavily than for a white Democrat.

    Now, you tell me – who is racist? The racist is the person who votes for or against someone simply because of the color of their skin.

    Nobody in the media is pointing out this blatant racism. Why not write about this, Mr. Chait?

    • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

      they got no power, except the presidency, but, well, uh, well Just because!

    • fightnright

      before you know it, such honesty might lead him to admit that most in the DNC would never have been so enthusiastic about promoting the candidacy of a man with such a lightweight political resume (and an even slimmer list of legislative accomplishments) if not for the color of his skin, and likely to motivate a previously unreliable, but historically 95% Democrat voting bloc to get to the polls.

      The years of grooming in hard leftism Obama had were a big plus, but those extra few demographic percentage points were what Dems counted on to put them over the top in 2008.

    • teaforme2012

      in this brilliant NAACP spot. In the way it was edited it appears here that blacks are reasonable and willing to accept a white leader like Mitt Romney, which is probably more reality-based than all the liberal reports of them booing. http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=HyDsZ-OtaOI

      Why aren’t blacks more open to the views of Clarence Thomas and others like him? Thomas is one of their own, and while he still may take a minority viewpoint to what most of them believe, shouldn’t blacks, of all people, be more sensitive toward respecting the voices of minorities? It seems hypocritical to judge Mitt Romney only by the color of his skin. I wouldn’t use the word racist, though, as they have certainly had their share of inconveniences directed at them based solely on race in the past.

      • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

        The NAACP crowd, and all the rubes who follow them are not what we would call self made people. They are products, for the most part of either affirmative action, or the Academic/Government/Social NGO complex.

        They literally loath everything Thomas stands for and to them he is a lowly uncle Tom.

  • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

    so what else is new?

  • fredflintlock

    A few of Obama’s more “reasonable”, “soft-spoken” offerings:

    ?They Bring a Knife?We Bring a Gun?
    ?I don?t want to quell anger. I think people are right to be angry! I?m angry!?
    ?Get in Their Faces!?
    ?Punish your enemies.?
    ?We talk to these folks? so I know whose ass to kick.?

    Let’s not forget about:
    “fat cat bankers”
    “tea baggers”
    “tea bag people”
    “the enemy”
    “terrorists” – okay, “Plugs” Biden, but still on O’s watch

    Honorable mention for “subtext”:
    “typical white woman”

    This Chaitt guy is really on top of things, eh?

    • fightnright

      n/t

      • fredflintlock

        And don’t forget this this old chestnut from the magnanimous one,”I won, we’ll write the laws”.

        Yep, our problem is obvious and our criticisms are groundless…
        “this is racism, straight up”.
        That one never gets old!

        • fightnright

          giving the finger to Hillary Clinton as he speaks

          his ‘photo op’ in which Air Force One buzzed the WTC site

          ending missile shield plans in Eastern Europe on the anniversary of Russia’s invasion of Poland

          releasing one official press photo of phoning Israeli PM Netanyahu with Obama’s feet on his desk, with his shoe soles face out (greatly disrespectful in the Middle East)

          his lackeys letting the Dalai Lama out the back door by the trash

          shipping the bust of Winston Churchill back to England and giving the Queen a chintzy useless present

          making a public joke about the Special Olympics

          even sneeringly calling a senior Senator like McCain ‘John’, while being addressed by McCain as ‘Mr President’ is indicative of his juvenile, nasty personality. The list goes on and on, as our White House gets painted red and goes low rent.

          • funwithknives

            Ray Romano’s mom (and dad) getting pitched out the Jersey retirement condos.

            “She seems to be giving you a compliment, when actually she’s being very nasty.”

            Here’s to ‘ninny removal’ on 11/7/2012.

  • Viet71

    And who are good at self-flagellation.

    These people are lost, clueless, and hopeless. They don’t even follow Dkos. And there are a bunch of them.

    • aesthete

      …this is what Jon Chait looks like.

      That, my friends, is the face of an authority on race relations in America.

      • Viet71

        Surely pays well. New York City. He gets to meet a lot of important persons.

        What more could one want out of life?

        BTW, money ain’t bad, nor is NYC on a good day.

        • aesthete

          Important people (especially in the context of politics, but also applicable to business, religion, and other newsworthy enterprises) are highly overrated, IMO.

          • Viet71

            They are important in their minds and in other minds.

            Speaking from professional experience.

  • renl57

    …in which he defended Obama’s original “You didn’t build that” remarks. He reviewed all the things he said government did over the years to facilitate the growth of industry:

    http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-07-26/we-did-build-that-and-our-government-helped.html

    So Mr. Alter says that Obama was absolutely right;

    Democrat politicians say that Obama didn’t really mean what he said; and

    Mr. Chait says that just to show Obama speaking verbatim is racist.

    Somebody should put all these three together into one diary or video. It would really make them look even more pathetic.

  • http://www.redstate.com/wp-admin/user/profile.php docfreeman

    I missed Obama?s black dialect. I heard him when he was speaking English with no dialect say that if you had a business you did not build that. This Jonathan Chait at New York Magazine, whoever he is must not have listened to the speech no matter how many times it has been rerun. Where Chait gets this back dialect is beyond me. I live in Realville while Chait lives in Obamaland I guess. I did not know I was racist if I disagree with Obama?s policies, his views, his running of the economy, his take on religion. Well I guess I am a racist because I think what Obama has done to our country and our economy is a crime and he needs to be removed from the office of President and get someone in their that loves our country and wants to help restore HER to her former Super Power Station where is where America is needed to be in this crazy world of ours. The Canada Free Press said it best, ?Because Without America There Is No Free World?.

  • avgjo

    You mean like…THIS?

    argue with your neighbor and ‘get in their face’

    ‘punch back twice as hard’?

    His infamous fits whenever a reporter actually does their job?

    his dressing down of the Supreme Court?

    his racial rhetoric?

    his class hate rhetoric?

  • Pingback: Gail Mulligan

  • Pingback: Desire Even

  • Pingback: aci Sarault

  • Pingback: Auto Forum

  • Pingback: Mining Technology

  • Pingback: Welcome to My Blog

  • Pingback: distillers

  • Pingback: randki rzeszow

  • Pingback: ανακαίνιση σπιτιού

  • Pingback: portal randkowy

  • Pingback: randka

  • Pingback: wielu ludzi w jednym miejscu

  • Pingback: steel strapping

  • Pingback: umow sie na randke

  • Pingback: charles david pumps

  • Pingback: wedding planner italy

  • Pingback: Media Streaming

  • Pingback: Hop Over To This Website

  • Pingback: Browse Around This Site

  • Pingback: see

  • Pingback: Look At These Guys

  • Pingback: web design barrow

  • Pingback: breastactives breast enhancement pills

  • Pingback: karos registraciya

  • Pingback: desain interior rumah

  • Pingback: madamlux

  • Pingback: jobs working from home uk

  • Pingback: biaya bangun rumah

  • Pingback: Wilfredo Longfield

  • Pingback: Ty Baudoin

  • Pingback: Ty Baudoin

  • Pingback: Flooring Installers

  • Pingback: Luanne Courtney

  • Pingback: cv

  • Pingback: cv wzór

  • Pingback: Sidney Chandsawangbh

  • Pingback: Dylan Vandresar

  • Pingback: Zella Asher

  • Pingback: brandy

  • Pingback: sofy rozkładane

  • Pingback: John Markin

  • Pingback: John Markin

  • Pingback: free reverse lookup phone

  • Pingback: Teichfolie

  • Pingback: Auto Forum

  • Pingback: Investment Opportunities

  • Pingback: กล้องวงจรปิด

  • Pingback: SEO Services Australia

  • Pingback: distilling equipment

  • Pingback: Scooters

  • Pingback: koi

  • Pingback: super randka