« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Make room for the new guys, Newt.

It’s no secret that Newt Gingrich has had his eye on the White House for several Presidential cycles, and has been waiting his turn for the nomination. Thankfully, his recent flameout has pretty much eliminated his chances. However, it has been a long time coming, and it is time to remind America that Newt isn’t so much on our side.

Let’s start things off with his support for Medicare Part D. At the time, it was the biggest expansion of entitlements since the LBJ era (has since eclipsed by ObamaCare), and remains one of the largest Republican travesties in recent memory. Club For Growth has a great white paper that takes an extensive look at Newt’s record. On Medicare Part D:

“Gingrich also has a recurring impulse to insert the government into the private economy.  A particularly bad mark on his record came in 2003, when he urged “every conservative member of Congress” to support the Medicare drug benefit bill.  He called it the “most important reorganization of our nation’s healthcare system since the original Medicare Bill of 1965.”  The drug benefit now costs taxpayers over $60 billion a year and has almost $16 trillion in unfunded liabilities.

In addition, he’s long been a proponent, like Obama, of forcing us to buy health insurance with an unconstitutional individual mandate.

April 4, 2006:

…In his keynote speech during the Greater Detroit Area Health Council’s annual Health Trends Conference on Monday in Dearborn, Gingrich called for:

A free-market system that encourages Americans to take more responsibility for their health care. He would require Americans over a certain income level to buy health insurance or post a bond.

March 24, 2008:

Gingrich called it “fundamentally immoral” for a person who can afford insurance to save money by going without, then show up at an emergency room and demand free care. He said those who can afford insurance and choose not to buy it should be required to post bonds to pay for care they may someday need.

Just last weekend, he restated his love for the individual mandate, and in the process managed to take a shot at one of the most popular Republican Congressmen we have, at the same time giving Romney and RomneyCare a pass. It should be expected, considering his vocal support for the very policies that have been Romney’s albatross.

Policy failure aside, this expresses a new level of political tone-deafness. Health care should be a gimme for Republicans at this point. A piece of advice: When you are among the most unpopular Republicans in the 2012 field, you do not make yourself more popular by A) Taking shots at those that are more popular than you are or B) Aligning yourself with losing issues. For all of the talk of Newt’s brilliance, this was a boneheaded move.

Obviously, he has realized  this and has been furiously backpedaling, even calling Ryan to offer an apology. Too little, too late.

In the midst of his health care policy failures, Newt also found time to fail in regard to climate change legislation as well. All that really needs to be said about Newt and climate change is in this shocking video he filmed with Nancy Pelosi where they agree we “must take action to address climate change” :

And to be clear, this wasn’t just an embarrassing black mark for Gingrich, or a misguided attempt at populism that has now been rectified in light of better science. No, as recently as January he was standing by every word of it:

Yet Gingrich told us Friday: “I meant exactly what I said in that commercial.”

He added that though “nobody knows” every cause of every climate change — past, present and future — for sure, “What I said was, ‘As a matter of prudence, conservatism ought to involve caution.’ “

Watch the video. That’s not what he said.

Next, there was TARP, which motivated many Tea Party activists to take to the streets in the first place. The bailouts were the inspiration for Rick Santelli’s famous rant, and inspired the movement that became the political force it is today.

Enter the 2010 election cycle. At every turn, Newt managed to work against conservatives and undermine the efforts of the Tea Party insurgence. For example, in 2009′s NY-23 special election, he endorsed liberal Republican Dede Scozzafava, who wound up embarrassing her own party and those who endorsed her by pulling out of the race and supporting the Democrat over conservative Doug Hoffman. $900,000 went to Scozzafava from the RNC and NRCC, all for nothing.

Then came the Utah Senate primary. Big government Republican incumbent Bob Bennett was among the top Senate targets in the 2010 cycle for the Tea Party movement, and he was being primaried by both conservative and local tea party favorite Mike Lee and establishment Republican Tim Bridgewater. In the time leading up to the primary, Newt threw his support behind Bennett, undermining the efforts of Utahans and the sentiment of conservatives nationwide.

With all the statist policy proposals and boneheaded political moves under his belt, it isn’t even necessary to dig into his personal transgressions to make him irrelevant. He’s everything that Americans have been working against – a DC insider who is out of touch with what’s important, and who is more concerned with populist garbage than being, well, right.

It’s time for Newt to disappear into the background. His moment has passed, and this tailspin has been decades in the making.

Make room for the new guys, Newt.

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • sandbun

    “So let me say on the record, any ad which quotes what I said on Sunday is a falsehood.”
    http://politicalwire.com/archives/2011/05/18/quote_of_the_day.html

    Way to keep digging Newt. Maybe you can be the next Jon Kyl (of #NotIntendedToBeAFactualStatement fame) and get your own twitter hashtag which embarrasses the GOP.

  • jiminga

    Newt is the embodiment of the “I am entitled” mantra of Republicans past. He really doesn’t understand we have a much better informed electorate this time around and he can’t make stupid statements and later lie about saying them.

    It has been said an honest man doesn’t need a good memory, and Newt proves every day he’s not an honest man.

  • gawken

    He gave the media a tour of his new office. He had models of dinosaurs and stuffed plush moose. Now, he has a revolving charge account at the jewelers..

  • gmscan

    Your quote — “Gingrich called it

  • Samsara

    Here is a list of Republican who were still in Congress in 2009 and voted for Medicare part D… “the biggest expansion of entitlements since the LBJ era”. Most are still in Congress, they are called the leadership.

    All good conservatives to a Man / Woman.

    Senate
    Lamar Alexander, Bob Bennett, Kit Bond, Sam Brownback, Jim Bunning, Saxby Chambliss, Thad Cochran, Susan Collins, John Cornyn, Mike Crapo, Mike Enzi, Chuck Grassley, Orrin Hatch, Kay Bailey Hutchison, Jim Inhofe, Jon Kyl, Richard Lugar, Mitch McConnell, Lisa Murkowski, Pat Roberts, Jeff Sessions, Richard Shelby, Olympia Snowe, and George Voinovich.

    House
    Robert Aderholt, Spencer Bachus, Roscoe Bartlett, Joe Barton, Judy Biggert, Gus Bilirakis, Rob Bishop, Marsha Blackburn, Roy Blunt, John Boehner, Jo Bonner, Mary Bono, John Boozman, Kevin Brady, Henry Brown, Virginia Brown-Waite, Michael Burgess, Steve Buyer, Ken Calvert, Dave Camp, Eric Cantor, Shelley Capito, John Carter, Michael Castle, Howard Coble, Tom Cole, Ander Crenshaw, Nathan Deal, Lincoln Diaz-Balart, Mario Diaz-Balart, David Dreier, John Duncan, Vernon Ehlers, J. Randy Forbes, Trent Franks, Rodney Frelinghuysen, Elton Gallegly, Jim Gerlach, Phil Gingrey, Bob Goodlatte, Kay Granger, Sam Graves, Jeb Hensarling, Wally Herger, Pete Hoekstra, Duncan Hunter, Darrell Issa, Lynn Jenkins, Sam Johnson, Timothy Johnson, Pete King, Steve King, Jack Kingston, Mark Kirk, John Kline, Tom Latham, Steven LaTourette, Jerry Lewis, John Linder, Frank LoBiondo, Frank Lucas, Donald Manzullo, Thaddeus McCotter, John McHugh, Buck McKeon, John Mica, Candice Miller, Gary Miller, Tim Murphy, Sue Myrick, Randy Neugebauer, Devin Nunes, Thomas Petri, Joseph Pitts, Todd Platts, Adam Putnam, George Radanovich, Dennis Rehberg, Harold Rogers, Mike Rogers (AL), Mike Rogers (MI), Dana Rohrabacher, Heana Ros-Lehitnen, Ed Royce, Paul Ryan, Aaron Schock, F. James Sensenbrenner, Pete Sessions, John Shimkus, Bill Shuster, Mike Simpson, Chris Smith, Lamar Smith, Mark Souder, Cliff Stearns, John Sullivan, Lee Terry, Mac Thornberry, Todd Tiahrt, Pat Tiberi, Michael Turner, Fred Upton, Greg Walden, Ed Whitfield, Joe Wilson, Frank Wolf, C.W. Bill Young, and Don Young.

  • Finrod

    But I just don’t see him as top-of-the-ticket material any more.

    • http://908StraightSt.wordpress.com/ mbecker908

      He’s spending too much time in the swamp.

  • earlgrey

    not be a true conservative. His policy changed with the political winds. Savage comes on pretty storng so I took it with a huge grain of salt, but he was right.

    I just think Newt had his chance in the 90s. I mean even in a visual sense his time has passed. There is nothing new about him, and if you are like me and would like to see the R party reinvent itself, than you don’t start with a long time political hack.

  • chihank

    For the month of April, the media beat up on poor Donald. With Trump out, is it Newt’s turn to be beaten up on.

  • http://www.FranBaker.com frankieb

    We could call it Hoot and Toot. Or vice versa.

  • earlgrey

    http://pawatercooler.com/?p=22555

  • PubliusII

    Give credit where due: in the 80s and 90s he had some good ideas. But he has several huge defects:

    1. Incontinence of the mouth. He talks too much, and is undisciplined in what he says.

    2. He shoots his own soldiers. Criticizing Ryan was inexcusable, even if Ryans’ budget is not popular (as the MSM are claiming). You can be loyal to your own side even when you disagree with them.

    3. He lacks the strategic and tactical instinct to win in actual governance. When Gingrich as Speaker went toe-to-toe with Clinton, Clinton out-maneuvered Newt every time. Granted, Clinton is very formidable, but Gingrich could have done better. The Republicans seemed sluggish, reactive and clumsy next to Clinton’s dexterity. Don’t get me wrong, I wish we had done better against Clinton. But Newt’s performance then showed that Clinton out-classed him in political skill.

    4. He is old, and looks old. I am pretty old myself, but we have to get somebody younger than 68 or 70 as our candidate.

    5. He is tainted with the Washington mess. Newt is an “establishment” man, as is Romney. He helped create the mess we have now and won’t reform it. We need an outsider unsullied by Washington.

  • roguebeaver

    RPed from HotAir: http://hotair.com/archives/2011/05/18/gingrich-spokesman-the-beltway-literati-elite-are-trying-to-destroy-him/

    Press release from Gingrich’s press secretary Rick Tyler to HuffPo

  • wilgolden

    and Newt is at the ragged end of his alotment. He is a genuinely nice guy, has great ideas, but way to prone to foot-in-mouth desease.
    Should he be SOME part of a Republican Administration? Chief of Staff, Secretary of this or that? Probably a case can be made. Top of the ticket? Not a chance.

  • averagevoterdotcom

    Jealous of Ryan.
    Solutions not principles.
    3rd wife.
    Arrogant.
    Egomaniac.
    Smug.
    Traitorus.
    President?
    Think not.

  • cam1

    finally and irrevocably shot himself in the foot. He’ll never talk himself out of his gaffe on the Today Show. Good riddance at last.