Eagle Publishing

  • MONEY & INVESTING
    • Eagle Daily Investor
    • Mark Skousen
    • Doug Fabian
    • Nicholas Vardy
    • Chris Versace
  • HEALTH
    • Newport Natural Health
  • REGNERY BOOKS
    • Regnery Books
    • Little Patriot Press
  • POLITICS
    • RedState
    • Human Events
    • RedState Morning Briefing
    • Daily Events
    • Guns & Patriots
    • Ann Coulter Letter
    • Advertise

RedStateThursday, May 23, 2013

Login Register | GATHERING Jobs Subscribe Contribute

  • ERICK ERICKSON
  • FRONT PAGE WRITERS
  • FEATURES
    • ENERGY ANALYSIS
    • LABOR UNION REPORT
    • TARGET RACES
    • TECH AT NIGHT
    • TOBYTOONS
  • E-LETTERS
    • REDSTATE MORNING BRIEFING
    • GUNS & PATRIOTS
  • COFFEE & MARKETS
  • REDSTATE EVENTS
    • REDSTATE GATHERING 2013
  • FRIENDS
Fracking

    Debunking the War on Fracking

    By: Brad Jackson (Diary)  |  April 9th at 10:00 AM  | 

    On today’s edition of Coffee and Markets, Brad Jackson is joined by David Holt to discuss incorrect myths about fracking, the importance of natural gas in our economy and the latest on the Keystone XL Pipeline.

    Read More »
    Tags: Coffee and Markets, Consumer Energy Alliance, David Holt, Fracking, Global Warming, Natural Gas

    Fracking: Drilling Past The Myths

    By: Breeanne Howe (Diary)  |  February 28th at 05:30 PM  | 

    It’s probably safe to say that most Americans are unaware of what the term “fracking” means.  If you’ve heard of it, the details can be hard to pin down due to the controversy surrounding the method of gas extraction.  With mainstream movies like Gasland and The Promised Land on their side, those opposing fracking have easily buried the truth below layers of myths.  Fortunately, as | Read More »

    Tags: Fracking, FrackNation, Gasland, Natural Gas, The Promised Land

    Just the Fracks, Ma’am

    By: Steve Maley (Diary)  |  February 24th at 05:14 PM  | 

    Natural gas is a cheap, abundant American resource, and cleaner than all of its viable alternatives to boot. It would be hard for a reasonable person not to favor natural gas as a component of our national energy mix, but then anti-frackers like Josh Fox, Yoko Ono and their ilk put little value on being reasonable people. They are the neo-Luddites resisting a modern energy revolution, standing between the people and the prosperity promised by affordable domestic energy.

    Read More »
    Tags: Fracking, FrackNation, Gasland, Hydraulic Fracturing, Josh Fox, Yoko is a Supreme Intellectual, Yoko Ono

    Fact-Checking Matt Damon’s ‘Promised Land’

    By: Steve Maley (Diary)  |  January 8th at 04:00 PM  | 

    “Promised Land”, Matt Damon’s anti-fracking propaganda flick, is short on science, short on industry knowledge, and geographically confused.

    Read More »
    Tags: Alligators, environment, Fracking, Hollywood

    Will Obama Tap Strategic Petroleum Reserve to Lower Gas Prices Before the Election?

    By: Brad Jackson (Diary)  |  September 6th at 09:00 AM  | 

    On today’s edition of Coffee and Markets, Brad Jackson and Ben Domenech are joined by David Holt to discuss Obama’s plans to release oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve before the election, the risk we would face with a depleted reserve should Israel attack Iran, and why fracking has an image problem. We’re brought to you by Stephen Clouse and Associates and The Heritage Foundation’s | Read More »

    Tags: Coffee and Markets, David Holt, Fracking, Iran, Natural Gas, Oil, Strategic Petroleum Reserve

    Shale Fracking: If it Keeps Moving, Regulate it

    By: Daniel Horowitz (Diary)  |  June 26th at 08:43 PM  | 

    Shale technology coupled with horizontal drilling has created the biggest oil and natural gas boom in recent years.  Fracking could become the most auspicious innovation of the past decade.  It has already created thousands of jobs, and has the potential to drive down the cost of energy and reinvigorate our economy.  Unfortunately, the more successful the private innovation, the more Obama’s regulatory regime will ensure | Read More »

    Tags: Energy, Fracking, Natural Gas, Oil, regulations

    Gasland’s Josh Fox Can’t Be Bothered with Facts

    By: Steve Maley (Diary)  |  June 23rd at 01:11 PM  | 

    Oscar®-nominated filmmaker Josh Fox, he of the burning water tap, loves to scare people with the provocative word “fracking” and misleading images and claims of its potential to damage the environment, specifically groundwater. To wit, this screenshot of a cute little animated .gif at Fox’s website gaslandthemovie.com. It clearly depicts fractures from a horizontal gas well invading a freshwater aquifer. Scary! Now, consider the detail | Read More »

    Tags: Fracking, Fracking Idiots, Gasland, Hysteria, Josh Fox, Lies and the Fracking Liars Who Tell Them, Marcellus Shale, Son of GasLand

    Fracking is Blamed for … Well, Everything, Really.

    By: Steve Maley (Diary)  |  April 7th at 11:00 AM  | 

    Blaming natural phenomena on fracking is this year’s fad, reminiscent of the mood ring, the pet rock or Anthropogenic Global Warming. Item 1. Vice-President of the United States Joe Biden may not know what hydrofracking is, but he does know that it sounds plenty scary. “… There’s a thing called fracking. They’ve got to go crack the rock in order to get [oil and gas] | Read More »

    Tags: Boom goes the dynamite, Booms, Clintonville, Fracking, Fracking Idiots, Hair Club for VPs

    President Obama, Dr. Chu and Their Fracking Whopper

    By: Steve Maley (Diary)  |  February 11th at 04:16 PM  | 

    …[It] was public research dollars, over the course of thirty years, that helped develop the technologies to extract all this natural gas out of shale rock – reminding us that Government support is critical in helping businesses get new energy ideas off the ground. – Barack Obama’s 2012 State of the Union Address On Thursday, Energy Secretary Dr. Steven Chu visited the National Energy Technology | Read More »

    Tags: Fracking, GRI, Halliburton, Hydraulic Fracturing, Lies and the Fracking Liars Who Tell Them, Mitchell Energy, Slick Water, Steven Chu, UPR

    Coming Soon: FrackNation

    By: Steve Maley (Diary)  |  February 7th at 09:00 AM  | 

    Phelim McAleer and his wife Ann McElhinney are journalists and documentary filmmakers. You may remember Not Evil Just Wrong (2009), their takedown of Al Gore and Global Warming hysteria. Now they want to tell the truth about natural gas development and hydraulic fracturing in a full-length documentary titled FrackNation. McAleer says: FrackNation will skeptically examine some of the scarier claims made by anti-fracking activists and | Read More »

    Tags: Fracking, FrackNation, Gasland, Hydraulic Fracturing, Josh Fox, Lies and the Fracking Liars Who Tell Them, Phelim McAleer

    Twitter’s Uneasy Relationship with Free Speech and North Dakota’s Oil Boom

    By: Brad Jackson (Diary)  |  January 30th at 10:00 AM  | 

    Download Podcast | iTunes | Podcast Feed On today’s edition of Coffee and Markets, Brad Jackson and Ben Domenech are joined by Francis Cianfrocca to discuss Twitter’s decision to sensor tweets, North Dakota’s oil boom and the challenges their rapidly growing economy faces. We’re brought to you as always by BigGovernment and Stephen Clouse and Associates. If you’d like to email us, you can do | Read More »

    Tags: Fracking, free speech, Keystone XL Pipeline, North Dakota, Twitter

    Gas Pains

    By: Steve Maley (Diary)  |  January 7th at 08:00 AM  | 

    1. Despite a natural gas drilling moratorium in New York, that state’s Chemung and Broome Counties are feeling the economic lift from drilling next door in Pennsylvania. But to the New York Times, the ex-pat workers, largely from Texas, Oklahoma and Louisiana, have awfully low-brow tastes, don’t you know. (NYT link below the fold.) 2a & 2b. The Daily Beast seems to have turned over | Read More »

    Tags: Energy, Fracking, Lies and the Fracking Liars Who Tell Them, Natural Gas

    The New York Times and Its Anti-Fracking Cargo Cult

    By: Steve Maley (Diary)  |  December 13th at 07:00 PM  | 

    Another day, another distorted and fear-mongering attack from the Old Grey Lady on America’s natural gas industry. Headline: Add Quakes to Rumblings Over Gas Rush (originally published under the headline “Some Blame Hydraulic Fracturing For Earthquake Epidemic”; link may require subscription/signup) Nine quakes in eight months in a seismically inactive area is unusual. But Ohio seismologists found another surprise when they plotted the quakes’ epicenters: | Read More »

    Tags: Energy, Fracking, Halliburton, Horizontal Drilling, Hydraulic Fracturing, Lies and the Fracking Liars Who Tell Them, New York Times, Some Say...

    Drilling in New Jersey? No Fracking Way!

    By: Steve Maley (Diary)  |  August 25th at 11:30 PM  | 

    New Jersey Governor Chris Christie issued a conditional veto on a measure that would have imposed a permanent ban on hydraulic fracturing — a/k/a “fracking” — in the Garden State. Instead, Christie has suggested a year-long moratorium on the practice. The debate over fracking in New Jersey is mostly symbolic. New Jersey has exactly zero oil and gas wells. It is, however, the nation’s #7 | Read More »

    Tags: Chris Christie, Energy, Fracking, Hydraulic Fracturing, Lies and the Fracking Liars Who Tell Them, luddites, Natural Gas, New Jersey, Utica Shale

    Tech at Night: Schumer’s bad idea, Victory over Fairness Doctrine, Chinese attacks on our networks

    By: Neil Stevens (Diary)  |  August 22nd at 10:00 PM  | 

    What would be a Monday without Democrats wanting to expand government by passing new laws and regulations? Some people aren’t careful with their things and/or their data, so Chuckie Schumer thinks there oughta be a law. I like CTIA’s response to that: CTIA understands that when consumers have their mobile devices lost or stolen, it is an unfortunate situation as they often contain a lot | Read More »

    Tags: Barack Obama, BART, China, Chuck Schumer, CTIA, Cybersecurity, Dearborn, elections have consequences, Facebook, fairness doctrine, FCC, Fracking, Privacy, Regulation, spam, Terrorism, Wikileaks, youtube

Page: 12Older Entries
ADVERTISEMENT
REDSTATE COMMUNITY

ALL

COMMENTS

POPULAR

#RSRH

  • My fondest wish: Ted Cruz comes out and announces he will filabuster the Gang of 8 Senate immigration bill
    By: RealQuiet (Diary)  
  • Doctors of Death
    By: ronbayjr (Diary)  
  • An Open Letter to DOJ Attorneys
    By: patrickmillsaps (Diary)  
  • Why Jindal is Right To Reject Medicaid Expansion
    By: jefflandry (Diary)  
  • 2008 Campaign Flashback: Obama is the ‘Biggest Celebrity In The World, But Is He Ready To Lead?’
    By: Myra Adams (Diary)  
  • Why Ricky Gervais is Wrong About Prayer
    By: MiamiDave (Diary)  
  • Is God For America?
    By: tomjeffersonsghost (Diary)  
  • Leftists, Socialists, Communists: Lend Me Your Liberals!
    By: Ausonius (Diary)  
  • PowerTalk – The Fiscal Cliff, Debt Ceiling, The Economy & The Mood On The Floor of the NYSE
    By: Chris Versace (Diary)  
  • White House Chief of Staff Knew About IRS Targeting Last Month
    By: Matt Vespa (Diary)  
  • Prayer and Daniel in Obama’s Democrat IRS Lions Den
    By: Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary)  
  • Tweets from the bench in South Florida
    By: William E. Lewis Jr. (Diary)  
  • The IRS Scandal: There is No Smoking Gun
    By: davenj1 (Diary)  
  • The IRS Weaponized
    By: garygrw (Diary)  
  • Prayer Request for Oklahoma
    By: vangoghssister (Diary)  
  • 2014: When will the Federal Government dump Federal Employee’s into Obamacare?
    By: JimmyGee (Diary)  
  • Lois Lerner Attorney: Purpose Of Hearing Is Just “To Embarrass Or Burden Her”
    By: Dana Loesch (Diary)  
  • Kentucky Governor Steve Beshear shows America why he doesn’t belong to Mensa
    By: davidadamsinky (Diary)  
  • WHITE HOUSE or “There’s No They’re There”
    By: jamesmpratt (Diary)  
  • Mitch McConnell Supports Schumer’s Amnesty/Immigration Deform Bill
    By: Daniel Horowitz (Diary)  
  • Immigration and Immigration Reform with former Secretary of Commerce Carlos Gutierrez
    By: Chris Versace (Diary)  
  • We must ensure this never happens again
    By: Bob Goodlatte (Diary)  
  • The Faces Of Big Government Scandals
    By: plumely (Diary)  
  • does impeachment wait until 2014 or after?
    By: cheesycon (Diary)  
  • A rabbit hole that began with a wrestler
    By: Joe Cunningham (Diary)  
  • Let’s Take The Long View
    By: Dominic Moore (Diary)  
  • Concern Over EW Jackson
    By: johng405 (Diary)  
  • Other Scandals we have forgotten
    By: Michael Harrington (Diary)  
  • Will big government be felled by big government overreach, arrogance and overconfidence?
    By: imperfectamerica (Diary)  
  • Milan Simonich, media operative for New Mexico Democrats?
    By: Politix Fireball (Diary)  
  • An open letter to George Will: Time to save your reputation, and possibly your soul, and quit “This Week”
    By: gawken (Diary)  
  • The Left – Feeble Arguments, Weak Shots, Conspiracy Theories and Zero Debate
    By: Seton Motley (Diary)  
  • The Heckler and the Commentators
    By: Paul Dragu (Diary)  
  • Save the Utah Neighborhood Caucus and Convention Process
    By: fredccox (Diary)  
  • Scars and Stripes: The Boston Bombing Unfurled
    By: alaskanangle (Diary)  
  • Abuse of Power. Dereliction of Duty. If the shoe fits, wear it, Mr. President
    By: politicalwoman (Diary)  
  • Economics is Too Focused on Math
    By: huizingadanny (Diary)  
  • OBAMA BENEFITTED FROM LIES AND DECEPTION
    By: longtimeconservative (Diary)  
  • The Company You Keep. Common Sense Choices for Those Who Lawfully Carry a Gun.
    By: cmndr45 (Diary)  
  • The Collapse of a narrative?
    By: SteveM (Diary)  
  • Obama’s Travesty of Leadership: The News Media Share Culpability
    By: lakeworthcane (Diary)  
  • Time to start talking about a Flat Tax
    By: montani (Diary)  
  • The Great Wall of Obama
    By: kybo (Diary)  
  • Is the HHS Director Illegally Campaigning … Again?
    By: Loren Heal (Diary)  
  • November 22, 1963
    By: Viet71 (Diary)  
  • WWDD
    By: frang8c (Diary)  
  • Democrat Senator Baucus: More to come on IRS-gate
    By: ConservativeWanderer (Diary)  
  • Embryonic Stem Cells From Skin
    By: Doug Payton (Diary)  
  • OBAMA DOESN’T TRUST “THEM”… BUT WHO TRUSTS HIM?
    By: Chris Wilson (Diary)  
  • White House: All Americans Can Opt-Out Of ObamaCare
    By: @toddeherman (Diary)  
  • “A nickel isn’t worth a dime today” 
    By: drrobertowens (Diary)  
  • What will Seal the Deal against Common Core Standards in GA?
    By: Cee Marie Hinkle (Diary)  
  • Keeping the Constitutions
    By: Danielle Davis (ocleverone) (Diary)  
  • Finally, A Bi-Partisan Solution on Term Limits
    By: Jim Bridenstine (Diary)  
  • Can Obama pardon Kermit Gosnell?
    By: stridentconservative (Diary)  
  • The Thrill is Gone…and the Wheels Have Come Off (Important Updates)
    By: checkmate2012 (Diary)  
  • Current Scandals in Perspective
    By: RightinSanFrancisco (Diary)  
  • Yes, We Are Doomed… But Why?
    By: dalders (Diary)  
  • The Obama Scandals Aren’t About Bad Government, but Big Government
    By: Senator Mike Lee (Diary)  
  • University Commencement Speakers Lean Left
    By: toddstarnes (Diary)  
  • Why the IRS will never be brought to heel
    By: DerKrieger (Diary)  
  • PHOTO: F-35A Weapons Separation Test
    By: F35.com (Diary)  
  • Proposed Changes at the Boy Scouts of America Places a Gag Order on Faith-Based Organizations [Updated Response]
    By: kipling (Diary)  
  • The Globalization of The RedState Gathering
    By: Hammer2008 (Diary)  
  • Who Gave the Order to Stand-Down and Denied Aid to Benghazi?
    By: ajshea (Diary)  
  • 10 Questions for Obama’s Thursday Press Conference
    By: gyakuzuki (Diary)  
  • Broke Illinois Looking To Tax Deliveries
    By: Ulysses Arn (Diary)  
  • NAACP Julian Bond Once Again Blames Another Organization for his Organization’s failings and shortcomings
    By: newsninja2012 (Diary)  
  • President Elsworth Toohey
    By: pweldon (Diary)  
  • Obama Administration turns on media
    By: Griffin@griffinelection (Diary)  
  • IRS Conducts Inquisition Against Tea Party Activists
    By: FMeekins (Diary)  
  • A Flurry of Hearings, Probes & Litigation Awaits the IRS
    By: Candice Lanier (Diary)  
  • The Barack H Obama Foundation Got Tax Exempt Status in Just One Month, Back in 2011.
    By: alanjoelny (Diary)  
  • Does Dr. Gosnell Deserve Death Penalty for Baby Abortion Murders
    By: kfobbs (Diary)  
  • Great Education Colorado Lines Employees’ Pockets While Pushing for Higher Taxes
    By: Kyle Forti (Diary)  
  • Let’s all gather as we watch NOTHING happen.
    By: erinmist (Diary)  
  • I’m #ProLife And Support The #DeathPenalty. Why Do You Ask?
    By: BigGator5 (Diary)  
  • Fair Tax – Abolish the IRS
    By: digitalboss (Diary)  
  • ‘Reject These Voices’ That Warn of Big Government an Tyranny
    By: quill67 (Diary)  
  • A Christmas Carol
    By: GreyCloak (Diary)  
  • Are You Ready for Some Politically Correct Football?
    By: chrisshugart (Diary)  
  • Shocked, Shocked!
    By: mlgoodell (Diary)  
  • The IRS targeted Laurens County Tea Party (SC)
    By: karenmartin (Diary)  
  • Breaking News: Justice Served, Gosnell Guilty of 1st Degree Murder – OPEN THREAD
    By: scipio62 (Diary)  
  • A Verdict Doesn’t End the Gosnell Story
    By: Chairman Reince Priebus (Diary)  
  • Keeping them Focused on Benghazi
    By: RottDawg (Diary)  
  • Benghazi and Reddit
    By: firstchevalier (Diary)  
  • Personhood Issue: Aggravated Murders vs Abortions
    By: Cheetah772 (Diary)  
  • IRS Apology Misleading
    By: Steven Willis (Diary)  
  • Confessions of a Racist
    By: ratio (Diary)  
  • In Memorium: Dallas Willard (1935-2013)
    By: runner12 (Diary)  
  • Anthony Kennedy on Adolf Hitler
    By: AndrewHyman (Diary)  
  • Adventures into the Alcohol Nanny State
    By: freedomworks (Diary)  
  • Pollsters embarrassed by Sanford win, Cockstradamus ends retirement
    By: gsandlapper1 (Diary)  
  • The Most Frightening News of the Day
    By: mjdaniels (Diary)  
  • Let’s Talk Gay Marriage, Part 1
    By: S. Wyatt Young (Diary)  
  • Congressman Paul Broun testifies on NDAA
    By: freedomrepublican (Diary)  
  • Conservatism And Small Business
    By: Chris Myers (Diary)  
  • KU law professor Stephen Ware interviewed on Wichita TV about Kansas’ unaccountable judiciary
    By: Benjamin Hodge (Diary)  
  • moelane: #rsrh Quick poll of the readership: should Scott Walker run in '16?: http://t.co/vCY3KEfZ9F
  • moelane: #rsrh At-risk Senate seats, 05/22/2013 assessment.: http://t.co/ofhRc29HvH
  • moelane: #rsrh FBI agent shoots, kills person 'of interest' wrt Boston Marathon bomber Tamerlan Tsarnaev.: http://t.co/oJTfsoQisj
  • RMConservative: Some say Schumer was upset when Reid won reelection. Nah..He got a better job. He's now GOP leader #rsrh
  • RMConservative: It is stupefying that Republicans would grant Obama the biggest victory of his presidency while he is embroiled in scandal #rsrh
  • moelane: #rsrh The Nation calls out the Center for American Progress for *selling* out to corporations.: http://t.co/NHa5LRMtDu
  • moelane: #rsrh For the record: I think the WH is telling the Journolisters that Eric Holder is resigning.: http://t.co/o7NyxRRJtA
  • moelane: #rsrh Lois Lerner to take the Fifth tomorrow on role in IRS attacks on Tea Party.: http://t.co/610sGda1XD
  • moelane: #rsrh The New York Times sub rosa declares for the Obama administration in DoJ/AP dispute.: http://t.co/CBkkG5VPVc
  • RMConservative: Dems just voted against an amdt to block the refundable portion of child tax credit for *future* illegals #rsrh
  • moelane: #rsrh Eugene Robinson... points out troublesome behavior from Obama towards the press.: http://t.co/5M215jxCPT
  • baseballcrank: IRS scandal should remind us why campaign finance 'reform' is so pernicious: it lets govt regulate politics. #rsrh
  • RMConservative: Democrats just rejected an amendment to ban gang members from receiving amnesty. You can't make this stuff up #rsrh
  • moelane: #rsrh Oh wow this is not good news for the Obama administration.: http://t.co/z1DFaFLMJt
  • RMConservative: Dems opposing amdt to block asylum status for those who return to their country just like the Boston bomber's parents #rsrh
  • cayankee: Obama met with IRS union cheif the day before they targeted the TEA Party http://t.co/wDfiFPf4PR http://t.co/4XcOEk7N4J #RSRH
  • cayankee: Former Georgia Secretary of State Karen Handel launches campaign for U.S. Senate. http://goo.glXlqik A fresh voice. #GAsen #RSRH
  • cayankee: Unions representing 20,000 federal immigration enforcement agents oppose Senate immigration bill. http://t.co/O772pQ4faJ #cir #RSRH
  • moelane: #rsrh QotD, The Thing About #Benghazi Is That It Was Sadly Predictable edition.: http://t.co/WYhI1KqYZb
  • moelane: #rsrh Why Dan Pfeiffer called the law 'irrelevant.' (Spoiler: so people won't go to jail.): http://t.co/FIUsVs2hcS
  • moelane: #rsrh Tweet of the Day, Moo Hoo Bwah Hah edition.: http://t.co/JOmEr67pqx
  • moelane: #rsrh This would be EW Jackson http://t.co/uvAr803kta This is suddenly going to be a MUCH more entertaining VA-LTGOV race. (via @JohnG405)
  • moelane: #rsrh Of *course* Ed Markey is hiding from Massachusetts voters.: http://t.co/kzUef1Pq2O
  • moelane: #rsrh Hastily-retiring Max Baucus suggests more IRS revelations.: http://t.co/ElYCPYsZ4k
  • moelane: #rsrh Oh, just this *once*: 44[*].: http://t.co/QWpy8SXGkt
  • moelane: #rsrh Let me just be honest here about 'Watergate.': http://t.co/WLu6UrRQ0F
  • VladimirRS: Well, you learn something every day. #eggonmyface #rsrh http://t.co/5jK2SUHwee
  • VladimirRS: How does burning 6 lbs of gasoline generate almost 20 lbs of CO2? #junkscience #conservationofmass #rsrh http://t.co/5B19gPSB7p
  • VladimirRS: Happy Endangered Species Day! Happy Nat'l Cherry Cobbler Day! Happy Nat'l Bike to Work Day! #rsrh http://t.co/2RVVcPXMZp
  • moelane: #rsrh "Was western meadowlark the official state bird of the entire Louisiana Purchase..." : http://t.co/flfLaSpsr0
REDSTATE LOCAL

PICK YOUR STATE & GET LOCAL

ADVERTISEMENT

BACK TO TOP

[RS]

Home | About Us | Contribute | Advertise | Contact | RSS

© 2013 EAGLE PUBLISHING, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. | LEGAL, COPYRIGHT, & TERMS OF SERVICE. | Eagle Publishing | Human Events | Regnery Books

POWERFUL CONSERVATIVE VOICES

Sign Up Now
Lost your password?