« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

The Texas record.

We’re pleased to bring you this commentary on the Texas economic record from Bill Peacock, Vice President for Research at the Texas Public Policy Foundation.

Texas has been the home of the last two Republican presidents. With Governor Rick Perry now in the fray, we’re fixin’ to find out if Texas can make it three in a row.

When examining what makes Texas the benchmark conservative state, the best place to start is the size of its government. Back in 1987, total state and local expenditures in Texas were about 18 percent of private gross domestic product (GDP), versus a national average of just over 19 percent. In 2008, Texas was still at about 18 percent, while the national average had risen to over 22 percent. Spending in California, our biggest competitor, grew during that period from about 19 percent to more than 25 percent of private GDP.

Stats about where Texas ranks in taxes and spending tell the same story. The Tax Foundation says that Texas ranks 45th in state and local tax burden. StateHealthFacts.org ranks Texas 47th in total state spending. And the latest data from the U.S. Census Bureau has Texas 42nd in education spending.

Of course, these figures are used by liberals to pillory some state officials — including Governor Perry — as uncaring. Texas conservatives, though, are quick to point out the connection between low spending and taxes and what Texas is providing Americans that no other state in the country can match: jobs.

Texas is the country’s leading job creator and has been for more than a decade. Between June 2006 and June 2011, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that Texas added 537,500 non-farm jobs — almost more than 10 times that of the next state, Louisiana.

Additionally, five Texas cities are in the top six nationally of newgeography.com’s 2011 Best Cities for Job Growth. Ten Texas cities are in the top 20, and only one falls outside the top half of the rankings.

At a time of anemic economic growth nationally, Texas is keeping Americans employed.

Texas’ job creation performance over the last decade is truly amazing and would have surely gathered much more prominence were it not so inconvenient to the proponents of big government.

In fact, our economic record has become such an inconvenient truth that people try almost anything to undermine it. One critic tried this approach: “Take a tech-oriented region like Greater Boston or the Bay Area, subtract out a housing collapse and add in an energy boom, and I suspect you’ve covered most of the discrepancy in performance” between Texas and other states.

Perhaps it is true that if Texas’ housing and energy markets had collapsed, our economy might look a lot like Massachusetts’ or California’s. But they didn’t. And it doesn’t.

Other critics point to Texas’ 8.2 percent unemployment rate — 26th in the country and slightly higher than New York’s — as evidence that Texas is not doing so well. But they overlook the fact that Texas’ unemployment rate stands at 8.2 percent after a net inflow of 1.78 million job seekers and their families in the last 10 years. New York, on the other hand, lost 847,000 people during the same period.

Of course, Texas still has some room for improvement. As the greenest state in the country when it comes to wind energy, we are spending billions of dollars subsidizing renewable energy. And though the Texas Legislature balanced its budget this year without new taxes, it accomplished some of that with accounting gimmicks that will have to be paid for in 2013.

Additionally, the Obama administration is doing its best to hamstring the Texas economy through air quality regulations, endangered species listings, and restrictions on oil and gas production.

Despite its opponents and blemishes, though, Texas is the one big state that has proven that free-market policies work for everybody — not just the rich. And that provides quite a platform for Texans moving out into the national stage.

Should this platform prove to be a boon for Perry, one of his first acts in office may have to be reining in his anti-trust lawyers at the Justice Department, who will be sorely tempted to investigate Texas’ recent preeminence in presidential contests. One can easily imagine their proposed remedy to dissolve Texas’ monopoly: imposing new taxes and spending to take Texas down off of its high economic horse.

Bill Peacock is the Vice President for Research and Director for the Center for Economic Freedom with the Texas Public Policy Foundation, a non-profit, free-market research institute based in Austin. He may be reached at bpeacock@texaspolicy.com.

COMMENTS

  • rick554

    You dont mess with Texas OR Texans!

    • msjallen

      you got that right. I would move back to Texas in a NY minute if I had the money.

  • Locked and Loaded

    ?Take a tech-oriented region like Greater Boston or the Bay Area, subtract out a housing collapse and add in an energy boom, and I suspect you?ve covered most of the discrepancy in performance.?

    He deserves a Nobel prize.

  • fortcollins

    Can we borrow a few Texans to fix Colorado?????

    We are exporting jobs. We are exporting graduates. We are exporting family businesses. We are importing federal subsidies. We are suffocating in taxes. we have so many layers of mindless regulations that even the regulators can’t keep them straight. We are wallowing in welfare spending. We are drowning in a sea of Democrats. Here’s the kicker: our elected officials can’t figure out what is wrong.

    I know three families who threw in the towel on Colorado’s tax structure and small business regulatory nightmare and relocated to Texas. If I personally know three families who did this, how many others are out there who made that move? The liberals can yap about their spin, but Texas simply is a success magnet. What they are doing is working, and is attracting like-minded people who are willing to relocate to a promising future in a sound economy.

    • edintexas

      Every winter there are lots of Texans who go to Colorado for skiing.

      Sorry, couldn’t resist the opportunity which was beckoning.

      • rattlerjake

        Colorado won’t have any snow if Al Gore has his way, you Know GLOBAL WARMING? LOL!

      • msjallen

        Texans own ski resorts in Colorado too.

    • vandalii

      …still need to feed the family though. We had to leave our beloved Colorado when tech started tanking in the mid-90′s and the place I worked was purchased by a Silicon Valley company that closed our doors 18 mos. later, laying everyone off. Couldn’t land anything reasonable in Colo. so had to come to Texas to resume feeding the family and such.

      We just returned to TX from a blessed week of sub-100 degree weather visiting family in CO — sleeping with the windows open at night, room at 68 degrees in the morning. SIGH!

      We’ll come back as soon as there’s some place to work up there :-) We’re grateful for TX, but we love CO ;-)

      • pttx333

        progressives and Hollywood types have taken over to a great extent. They have taken a beautiful, wonderful place and are trying to drive it into the ground, just like they everywhere the go – it is a pernicious invasion that just takes over.

  • rightwingmom52

    One of my favorite southern expressions, along with “reckon.”

    Perry for President? From your blog to God’s ears.

    • pttx333

      difference between “goin’ to” and “a’fixin’ to” is: If you are “goin’ to” it means someday down the road while “a’fixin’ to” means “rat” now.

      Yep, “reckon” a mighty good word. And a favorite put-down is: “When your phone don’t ‘rang,’ you’ll know its just me.” There’s a boat load of such goofiness, and we love to pull it on others just for the shock factor! HAHA

      • rightwingmom52

        it’s just “fixin’ to” for everything, but I get what you’re saying. My husband laughs every time we go home to Tennessee to visit my folks (we’re in Alabama) because he says my use of the word “reckon” goes up exponentially. Just struck me that’s a fancy word to use in a comment about southern vernacular. Ha. There’s another one. I should have just said “a lot” and southern talk. LOL.

        • pttx333

          on those poor unsuspecting folks who don’t know us? I do say “fixin’ to” all the time and “reckon” just like you … it is just part of who I am. And for those who think we are just full of corn pone, stupid, dumb hillbillies that they can walk all over – well, my advice is “not so fast there, dude.” They are in for the ride of their lives! The only smoke we blow, Ms. rightwing, is in cutting up and acting the fool. And is it fun or what??? HA

          Lived out in West Texas for many years where in the winter we would get these cold fronts called “blue northers.” A big whopper was from an a grizzled old rancher I knew who, with a straight face, told this story:

          “Me and muh friends was a’goin’ to go bird huntin’ so we was down at the stock tank with our guns and there was a bunch a big ol’ bull frogs sittin’ around that there tank. Well, there we are, just a’waitin’ on the birds when we seen this big ol’ blue norther a’fixin’to blow in and we knew we’d better run for it. Well, afore we could get away, that ol’ norther hit, the water in that tank started to freeze, them frogs tried to jump in the water but froze right there – half in, half out. Amazin’ huh? So us guys we just went to town, got a bunch of lawn mowers, went back out to that tank and mowed us up 5 baskets of frog legs for supper that night instead them birds we planned on havin’.”

          That was many years ago and I still laugh when I hear about it. Now this old grizzled rancher was a Texas A&M grad (with honors) but preferred that others think he only got through grade school. It is just more fun that way, doncha know. HA

        • texasjohn

          …when they move to Texas. :D

          “Carry” is one of my favorite words.
          Me: “Truck’s broke. Can you carry me up to the store?”
          Them: “Isn’t it easier if I just drive you?”
          Me: “That’s what I said.”

          I love Texas.

          • rightwingmom52

            Just one of the extra benefits of being born in the South.

      • pttx333

        and I loved to pull on others was (imagine exaggerated drawl here):

        Boss to me: “Jeet yet?”
        Me: “Naw, ju?
        Boss: “Yont to?”
        Me: “Sure.”

        Then I would grab my purse and away we would go. Translation: “Did you eat yet?” “No, did you?” “You want to?” “Sure.”

        Oh, do we ever love to play on the lingo here!

        • rightwingmom52

          • pttx333

            and the silliness. Another one is that us southern ladies can get away with saying the most outrageous things using the old Perils of Pauline routine (you know, blink blink) if we use “bless his/her heart.”

            Example: “You know, Betty Lou just has the most terrible taste in clothes. Bless her heart.”

            But my personal favorite that I have used on occasion, due to being a “little old lady” now: “Oh, pleae forgive me for not remembering to do ____, but I suffer from CRS.” The person to whom I’m speaking usually just gets their sympathetic look on his/her face and says “Bless your heart.” To which I reply: “Thank you so much.”

            Isn’t it fun?

          • http://moelane.com/ Moe Lane

            …that I’ve blatantly stole it. It’s just too useful.

            As is “all y’all,” which honestly plugs the second-person plural hole in Standard English quite nicely.

          • pttx333

            We are more than pleased for you to “steal” our silliness. And that is one reason why all voters should be aware that Rick Perry is Texan, born and bred, and can appear “dumb” at times (when it is expedient to do so) just before he lowers the boom. Just as Texas females have their Perils of Pauline routines down pat, the males have a similar Perils of Paul.

            As for “all y’all” you need to add the possessive “all y’all’s” to the mix.

            Welcome to the silliness.

  • pttx333

    While working for many years at an internationally-known law firm, I observed many baby lawyers with acceptable credentials hired in from Ivy League schools and other well-known universities. The support staff used to discuss the odds of those who would last and those who wouldn’t – we were always right. The ones who didn’t last for long were the ones who were snobbish, condescending elitists who were determined that they were going to run the show, while the ones who lasted were the ones who behaved like a normal person and treated others with respect. It was interesting to watch the evolution of those coming to Texas from other very different cultures to fitting in comfortably as a Texan – they are the ones who remained and are still there today. No one forced or asked them to adapt, they just became comfortable with the culture and adopted iit as their own. I don’t know what it is, but the majority in this culture (with the exception of Austin, now full of CA transplants) are hard-working, take no prisoners, funny, God-fearing folks who welcome everyone to come join in. Rick Perry is a perfect example of this culture. Even those who don’t like him DO respect him.

    I say this as one born in Oklahoma who wouldn’t leave Texas for anything – even with its warts. And as one whose late husband was an Economist from NY and became a Texan overnight, proudly wearing his boots and hat back to NY to visit – he so loved it here.

    • bk

      People from New York move to places like New Hampshire and try to ruin them by turning them into another New York. But when they move to Texas they eventually become Texans and realize how different it is.

      Snobby liberals like the Obamas haven’t a clue what flyover country is like, including Texas. Flying into El Paso with an armed escort and saying the border is safe is a joke. Riding a limousine/bus into a small town and stopping at the local diner to give a speech to a few local folks and having some staffer tell you what local delicacy you’re supposed to pretend to eat for 15 seconds of photos doesn’t mean you understand anything about how those people feel.

      If you think about it, it’s the same way liberals treat minorities – “We know better than you do what you need, so I don’t really need to listen to you. You need to just shut up, vote for the D, and let us take care of everything.”

      • TxTess

        When I lived in the barracks many years ago you could tell who was a Texan. We would always have our state flag displayed. I still have mine.

        • pttx333

          state flag that can be flown at the same height as the American flag because it was the only state who was a country before being a part of the US. Someone correct me if I’m wrong, but I’ve always been told that as the truth.

      • pttx333

        Texans as a rule don’t like elitist snobs – they pretty much get pushed to the curb not long after they open their mouths. Not that they are treated rudely, they’re just ignored while we say a little “bless his/her heart.” I’m sure that most of fly-over country is essentially the same – it boils down to having the ability to think logically and use a whole lot of our God-given common sense. And that counts for a boat load more than grades. If you are the smartest person in the room but have no common sense, then you just lost the argument, any argument.

        Wow, I’ve just described the progressive mindset! And I’m convinced they will eventually lose simply because they have no common sense and lack the ability to sort things out logically. And I think we are on the right road to that end as we speak.

    • davesinsanantonio

      is one of my favorite Texasisms It is amazing how strong the culture is and how some just cherish it as it they had been here all their lives.

      • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

        He said, he never asks a man where he is from because if he is from Texas he will tell you. And if he isn’t then it’s no use rubbing it in.

        • pttx333

          coach of the old Houston Oilers? One time I was watching him being interviewed before a big game where the reporter asked if his wife traveled with him when there was an out-of-town game. Bum replied: “She sure does cuz she’s too ugly to kiss goodbye.” Everyone was howling with laughter about that one. In other parts of the country, the NOW females would be all up in arms but not in Texas. He didn’t mean a single word of it – that was just his Texas humor and NOT a put-down of his lovely wife, not in the least.

          Bless their hearts.

      • pttx333

        Yes, it is a strong culture because it is made up of God-fearing, decent, common sense folks (for the most part) that overrides any other fad, trend or other such nonsense. And the ones who buy into said nonsense aren’t considered to be Texan. It doesn’t matter where you come from, you can still be a Texan.

    • texasjohn

      I got here late to the party myself. I don’t want to be anywhere else.

      I’ve lived in tons of places (a former voc-tech classmate described me as “havin’ ramblin’ in my shoes”), but I haven’t felt like I really belonged anywhere til I got to Texas. I did come to Fort Worth in the 80′s for a short time, but that darn ramblin’ acted up. Now I’m here for good. I don’t think I’ve ever been anywhere that so closely reflected my values and beliefs as the people of the great Lone Star state. Unfortunately, I may have to leave again next year due to family duties, but I have specifically stated in my will that I’m to be buried in Texas.

      • msjallen

        you can take the gal out of Texas but you can’t take Texas out of the gal.

        • pttx333

          know us can’t possibly understand. It is something in the blood and hard to describe, but you know it if you have it.

      • pttx333

        and came here is what matters. (Still laughing at your “havin’ ramblin’ in my shoes’ comment.) I do hate that you may have to leave soon, but understand that family duties come first. I can guarantee that you will miss us.

        I have a long-time friend who is came late to the party from Alabama, moving to Houston. When her oldest daughter started college in Alpine, she of course drove her there to settle in. Well, when she came back she was telling me that something must be wrong with her car and was going to take it to the shop because everyone on the road out there kept waving at her. She would stop, get out and go all around the car checking the tires, open the hood to check under it, and just never understood what was going on. I died laughing and solved her mystery right away. Having lived in West Texas for many years where everyone waves at everyone else even though they maybe waved at them 10 minutes before, I was pleased to tell her that they weren’t warning her of anything – they were just being Texas friendly.

        Yes, it is quite a special place – you will miss it. But at least you will end up here for all eternity – hope you can make it back before then, though.

  • lisamiller

    We have to factor out rising energy prices as not every State has these natural resources as a cushion and as President, he’ll have to be proactive in deeply cutting government.

    There will be no crutch for Rick Perry.

    • edintexas

      Assuming we get Perry as President (or any Conservative Republican – that lets Huntsman out), he’ll need to keep a majority in the House, and pick up a lot of seats in the Senate in order to keep the Dems from filibustering everything. Unlike Republicans, Democrats are more than willing to gum up the works to prevent bills from getting to the President’s desk.

  • http://www.reddit.com/user/pi_over_three/ Pi Over Three

    will make a great President when he wins next November.

  • carolynr

    Just think back when Obama became President. Look at the states that he went after and look at what political party they belonged to. You have to hand it to Perry…he has hung in there the best of all of them, given what Obama thuggery has dished out. Let’ see…sued Arizona. Went after Palin with lawsuits that cost the state plenty…not to mention the moratorium. Bobby Jindalh had his hat handed to him when Obama refused to allow help with keeping the oil out of dangerous wildlife habitats. He wasn’t too kind to Mississippi or Alabama either. Governor of Virginia had his offshore oil exploration stopped. Christie didn’t have his staff fill out paper work correctly with a very minor mistake, thus the state did not get education aid. Obama has gone after Perry in a big way…can’t drill on land in certain areas because of a lizard…WAIT…THAT SHOULDN’T COUNT…HE LET LOUISIANA WETLANDS GO DOWN THE TUBE)…but I digress. Scott Walker…had the State smothered with SEIU people to demonstrate. South Carolina….NLRB against Boeing and Job Creation. Let’s also not forget Fast & Furious where guns were walked across the border and given to drug cartels to try to diss the 2nd Amendment.

    Get my point people….Obama and HIS federal government are against the States that have Republican Govenors…and I bet I don’t know the half of it. Vote this anti-American (Obama) out of office in 2012. Perry/Rubio with Rudy as AG

    • westcoastpatriette

      .

      • westcoastpatriette

        Never mind. You did mention it. My bad (for reading too fast.)

    • msjallen

      not our country. Presidents are to be for ALL the people but that little O hates our country and takes vengeance out on those he dislikes because as he said: White people haven’t suffered enough.

  • cbartlett

    Anybody But Obama – please! I’m not sure Perry is the one to take this country in the right direction but we HAVE to do something – and quick! As a lifelong, very proud Texan who has somewhat reluctantly voted for Perry in the past, he does seem like more of a true conservative as compared to the rest of the field right now. For you Texans, and any others who are interested in getting educated, this website has excellent, well-documented information about Perry. http://peskytruth.wordpress.com/2011/07/19/rick-perrys-negatives This guy does an great job of defending many of the liberal media lies and distortions floating around. Do yourself a favor and get educated. I’ve been voting Republican in this great state for more than 30 years and I learned a lot from this.

  • williamjameson

    I’ll pass this via email and post online with a link back to RS