« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Gas Pains

A roundup of the natural gas news of the week.

1. Despite a natural gas drilling moratorium in New York, that state’s Chemung and Broome Counties are feeling the economic lift from drilling next door in Pennsylvania. But to the New York Times, the ex-pat workers, largely from Texas, Oklahoma and Louisiana, have awfully low-brow tastes, don’t you know. (NYT link below the fold.)

2a & 2b. The Daily Beast seems to have turned over reporting on energy issues to complete idiots. They should stick with things they do best, like candid upskirt photos of the Kardashian sisters. (Two DB links below the fold.)

3. Betty Sutliff is a member of the Upper Wayne County Property Owners Alliance. Her northeastern Pennsylvania county is prospective for Marcellus gas development, but a board called the Delaware River Basin Commission (representing New York, Delaware, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and the U.S. government) has blocked development. In addition an influx of well-heeled interlopers who own second homes in NE PA are vocal in their anti-gas rhetoric, although they have almost no skin in the game.

There exists a minority of those who vehemently oppose natural gas development. They would oppose it if it were 200% safe. For this group it really isn’t a question of safety. Instead, it is a new ideology aimed against anything fossil. Simplistically, these folks look at any fossil fuel development as an addiction that should be conquered “cold turkey.”

Most of these individuals own very little land and think (mistakenly, as UGI [retail natural gas price cut] demonstrates) they have nothing to gain economically from natural gas exploration and production. They also are typically residents who do not reside here full-time or have moved to the area after living elsewhere. They don’t want their peace and serenity, not to mention their viewscape, tampered with at all for any reason.

However well-funded, well organized, and vocal they may be, they do not speak for the majority of residents here who have called this area home for generations. This is noticeable by the landslide victories of pro gas candidates in local elections which show the majority of people in favor of moving forward with exploration and production of natural gas.

Well said, Ms. Sutliff. The loudest voices in the debate are the ones with the least knowledge and the least stake in the game. And they would be the first one to cry “Conspiracy!” if the cost to heat their home doubled, or if there were no gas available at all.

These elitists portray natural gas as bad for the environment (a very tenuous position), but in reality they know that cheap gas is the #1 enemy of their Mother Gaia-approved alternatives.

1. NY Times:
With Gas Drilling Next Door, County in New York Gets an Economic Lift

HORSEHEADS, N.Y. — At the Glamour and Glow boutique in the local mall here, crystal necklaces and fake fur vests have been hot-ticket items the last year.

When the drilling workers head home between long stretches of work in this gas-rich region, explained Christy Spreng, the shop’s owner, they need gifts for their wives and girlfriends. “They know what they want,” she said. “They’ll say: ‘Looks good. Wrap it up.’ ”

2a. The Daily Beast:
Gas Drilling Likely Caused Ohio Quake

A seismologist investigating a series of minor earthquakes in Ohio says they were almost certainly caused by a well used to dispose of wastewater from oil and gas drilling.

Nice headline; too bad it is a blatant lie. Gas drilling doesn’t cause quakes; disposal of waste products in a well situated near a fault zone may have caused some slippage in the fault, so the well is being shut down to check it out. I blogged it here; even the Washington Post got it right in the article the DB links.

2b. The Daily Beast:
Youngstown Rocks: Is Fracking Causing Earthquakes in Ohio? by Jon Avlon

My wife and I were in town visiting my 96-year-old grandmother and felt the mid-afternoon rattle shake the roof for five to 10 seconds.

What makes the minor rumble newsworthy is that until 2011, Youngstown had never had a recorded earthquake.

What changed? Fracking. …

In response to a Christmas Eve earthquake—the 10th in nine months—the Ohio Department of Natural Resources ordered D&L Energy Inc. to stop its operations at a brine-injection well in the heart of downtown Youngstown.

The epicenter of the New Year’s Day quake was within half mile of the 9,000-foot-deep well. All of the earthquakes emanated from within five miles of local drilling, and in some cases as close as a few thousand feet. The Ohio Department of Natural Resources is careful to state that there is no proven link between the drilling and the quakes, but the cause and effect seems clear to citizens.

This is one of the stupidest things I’ve ever read. Mr. Avlon clearly doesn’t know the difference between a “drilling”, “fracking” and an “injection well”, and I suspect he could not care less. I set a very low bar of expectation for technical comprehension by journalists, and Mr. Avlon has tunneled under it.

Cross-posted at stevemaley.com.

COMMENTS

  • spinoneone

    are usually drilled vertically and go down anywhere from 2000 to 10000 feet. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers drilled a series of them in Denver in the 1960s and ’70s to dispose of waste from the Rocky Mountain Arsenal. Some of those wells either intersected one or more faults or discharged high pressure liquid into the near vicinity of those faults. The result was occasional slippage of those faults, with minor earthquakes resulting. When the pumping stopped, slippage stopped, and the earthquakes stopped. Is this situation being duplicated in Youngstown? Maybe. Is the cause “fracking”? No. However, will the acolytes of the National Socialist Democratic Action Party use any possible excuse to stop fracking? Yes.

    • http://stevemaley.com Steve Maley

      There are 550 Class I deep injection wells in the U.S. All kinds of toxic stuff is injected in them — heavy metals, all kinds of chemical and industrial waste — and the public at large is blissfully unaware. Some of the stuff in these wells could cause detrimental effects on contact, but we do it because it’s the best, safest way to get rid of this nasty stuff.

      By comparison, oilfield waste, including frack water, is relatively benign.

  • renl57

    “they know that cheap gas is the #1 enemy of their Mother Gaia-approved alternatives.”

    Actually, the only alternatives they approve of are the ones we aren’t using. Because when we do try them on a large scale for the first time:

    Environmentalists have lobbied politicians and courts to stop the building of solar power installations in the CA desert (where else but deserts does the Sun shine nearly all the time?).

    http://e360.yale.edu/content/feature.msp?id=2236

    In VT, environmentalists are trying to stop construction of windmill farms in the VT mountains (where else except mountains does the wind blow nearly all the time?).

    http://www.wcax.com/story/16448144/controversy-swirls-over-wind-farm-on-public-land

    If we add up all the objections that environmentalists have, we can’t build any power plants of any type anywhere. And sure enough, the GreenPeace vision is of a future where we all live on small family farms, each growing its own food and each with its own windmill or solar panels on the roof of the barn.

    Back to the future.

  • NeoKong

    “At the Glamour and Glow boutique in the local mall here, crystal necklaces and fake fur vests have been hot-ticket items the last year.”


    “And give me a quart of that there purty smellin’ toilet water. My Fi Fi just loves that stuff…Oo la la.”

    It seem that Mireya Navarro could be the new Miss Jane.

  • tailfins1959

    “A report commissioned this year by the State Department of Environmental Conservation, for example, predicts local housing shortages and a rise in rents as workers migrate to New York to take jobs in well construction and production that cannot initially be filled with local labor. ”

    If the workers come from Laredo or El Paso, that’s a problem. If they come from two miles further down the road in Nuevo Laredo or Juarez, that’s diversity. What nimrods!

  • wsg57

    The Eco-Socialists have had for decades the clear intent to stop all energy development as ren157 points out. It is not energy they oppose, it is individual freedom and Free Market (including the entire concept of private property) which they intend to destroy. These diversions of “supporting” “green” energy are only mechanisms to reduce energy consumption by making energy costs rise exponentially. Ultimately they view humans as a cancer on Mother Earth and it is humans the despise.